Talk:Liberty Games

Wikipedia should not be used as a directory and companies ought to be listed when they have created something notable or news worthy. A list of the products this company sells is not noteworthy nor does it warrant having a page.

I believe the article to be purely promotional. All it says it's that they are a leading retailer with no citations. They just list a load of things they sell as well as 2 products they supposedly are Official UK Distributors of which is factually incorrect. Novotable company has ceased trading http://www.novotable.com/ and the offside football table is not and exclusive product. http://www.trifledesign.co.uk/ It's sold in lots of different places, John Lewis about 10 other websites included so I don't see why this article has anything noteworthy or gives the reader anything apart from promoting the company and it's products? The last think wikipedia needs is spammy pages with no value. The articles was also created by the companies Technical Director. http://linkd.in/kHwimm therefore a conflict of interests.

Itsmee (talk) 21:46, 16 June 2011 (UTC)

This has been placed by a competitor of Liberty Games, and so the proposition that this page is not neutral is itself not neutral! The page is written in a matter of fact way and in no way promoted Liberty Games, and only states facts that have been backed up by reliable 3rd party sources. As with all wikipedia articles anyone may add to this page. The company responsible for the Novotable is still trading, and although the Offside Coffee Table is sold through other outlets distribution is controlled by Liberty Games.

stukerr (talk) 21:46, 1 July 2011 (UTC)

This article appears to be neutral, and is simply a description of the company, it's history, and the products it sells. It is absurd to describe something as promotional when there is nothing that is positive or negative about the article.

sbpat21 (talk) 11 July 2011 (UTC