Too Big to Fail (film): Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 16:12, 21 July 2011

Please do not use {{Infobox television film}} directly. See the documentation for available templates. Too Big to Fail is a television drama film in the United States broadcast on HBO on May 23, 2011.^[1] It is based on the non-fiction book Too Big to Fail by Andrew Ross Sorkin and Scott B. Smith. The TV film was directed by Curtis Hanson.

Plot

Too Big to Fail chronicles the 2008 financial meltdown, focusing on the actions of then Secretary of the Treasury Henry Paulson (William Hurt) to contain the unfolding catastrophe. Specifically, it focuses on the period of August 2008 to October 3, 2008, during which the stock price of Lehman Brothers declined precipitously as the company's large exposure to toxic housing assets became more and more apparent. Dick Fuld (James Woods), CEO of Lehman Brothers, is seemingly in denial of Lehman's toxic assets and refuses several deals to potentially save the company, believing the housing market will recover. Paulson attempts to arrange a private solution to the Lehman problem, and both Bank of America and Barclays express interest in Lehman's "good" assets. However, they want federal government loans to finance potential losses from Lehman's housing investments. Paulson wishes to avoid another government-sponsored purchase like Bear Stearns, fearing the encouragement of "moral hazard", and refuses. Bank of America decides to buy Merrill Lynch on the cheap instead, as Merrill was in a marginally better situation than Lehman, yet still desperately needing capitalization. Barclays was still willing to purchase a selection of Lehman assets, but the Financial Services Authority (the British regulators) made it impossible to close the deal in time. Lehman Brothers, acting under the encouragement of Paulson and the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), prepared the declaration of bankruptcy on September 14, 2008.

Reaction to the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy was positive at first. The stock market as a whole barely nudged, and approving editorials were written of the federal government refusing to bail out corporate mistakes. However, ripples of Lehman's counterparty risk soon spread throughout the financial system, as many of these debts would now need to be written off. AIG — which was not even a bank — had provided insurance to nearly everyone on their housing assets, and had priced this insurance very cheaply under the assumption it was impossible for all of the housing market to go bad at once, thus massively underpricing risk. AIG was already losing money it couldn't cover, and the fall of Lehman Brothers hastened its demise, as its creditors refused to lend even more money to AIG's collapsing portfolio. A collapse of AIG would imperil the entire world banking system, as banks find their hedges against a decline in housing not honored by a bankrupt AIG, setting off a chain reaction of bankruptcies. Paulson moves to have the government guarantee AIG's bad insurance, but the global economy is still under threat. As banks reassess their balance sheets and realize their liabilities are much worse than they thought, they realize they have far less cash to lend out, creating a credit crunch that starts affecting "Main Street", normal companies who had nothing to do with financial services. Ben Bernanke (Paul Giamatti), Chairman of the Federal Reserve, believes that the only thing that might calm the economy is if the federal government had a gigantic pile of cash ready to smooth over any further disruptions and to get the credit markets moving again, but that such an act would require legitimacy - an act of the United States Congress. Paulson is skeptical of the prospects of passing such legislation a mere two months before an election, and worries that the worst case scenario is Congress explicitly voting down such a tool. Bernanke notes the dire circumstances, and says Congress will act if they are as scared as he is.

Paulson and his staff brainstorm over how best to use such money, should they get it. The plan is "cash for trash" - buy the "toxic" assets of questionable worth off the banks, which will allow the banks to stabilize at a known valuation. Direct capital injection is considered as well, but written off as a political non-starter - a bailout to Democrats, and nationalization to Republicans. Timothy Geithner (Billy Crudup), President of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, attempts to arrange mergers between "strong" banks and "weak" banks to stabilize the situation. Geithner also seeks to end "investment banks," a model which failed, by merging any investment bank with normal depositor banks, bringing them under the regulation of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). Bernanke and Paulson lobby Congress, with Bernanke emphasizing that a lack of credit helped make the 1929 stock crash into the Great Depression, and that if Congress fails to act "we may not have an economy on Monday." The legislation looks likely to pass, but turbulence happens when John McCain suspends his campaign for president to join the negotiations - potentially restarting them from square 1. The vote moves forward regardless, but fails to pass the House after too many Republicans vote "no", causing an immediate drop in the Dow of 600 points. After a wave of panic and personal haranguing from President George W. Bush, the legislation passes on a second attempt, and the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 is signed into law.

Paulson and his staff now have the money, but find that valuing the toxic assets to buy will take two months minimum, and may still not be reliable, as the banks all wish to claim face value for them. As a result, they decide that the only way to get credit flowing again is direct capital injections after all. Furthermore, capital injections to only the weakest banks would be counterproductive - it would declare to the world which exact banks were "weak" and by how much, which could potentially just create a run on these banks and require even more of a bailout. With the help of FDIC chair Sheila Bair and the threat of an FDIC audit, Paulson informs all the remaining banks that they will be receiving mandatory capital injections in the form of non-voting government owned stock, and that they were all to use this money to get credit moving again.

Cast

Topher Grace as Jim Wilkinson
Paul Giamatti as Ben Bernanke
Billy Crudup as Timothy Geithner
William Hurt as Henry Paulson
James Woods as Dick Fuld
Bill Pullman as Jamie Dimon
Tony Shalhoub as John Mack
Matthew Modine as John Thain
Ajay Mehta as Vikram Pandit
Edward Asner as Warren Buffett
Cynthia Nixon as Michele Davis
Joey Slotnick as Dan Jester
Michael O'Keefe as Chris Flowers
Amy Carlson as Erin Callan
Peter Hermann as Christopher Cox
Dan Hedaya as Barney Frank
Kathy Baker as Wendy Paulson
Steve Tom as Chris Dodd
Evan Handler as Lloyd Blankfein
Ayad Akhtar as Neel Kashkari
Laila Robins as Christine Lagarde
Andrew Ross Sorkin - cameo as a business journalist

Reception

The AV Club gave it a B rating.^[2]

References

External links

[1] Too Big to Fail at IMDB

[2] ttp://www.avclub.com/articles/too-big-to-fail,56421/

[1]

[2]

@@ Line 6: / Line 6: @@
 | producer = [[Lauren Shuler Donner]]<br />Ezra Swerdlow<br />Michael P. Flannigan<br />Cary Granat<br />[[Lynn Harris]]<br />Lawrence Kasdan<br />Bruce Berman<br />[[Trevor Short]]<br />[[Avi Lerner]]<br />Michael Bostick<br />Gary Scott Thompson<br />[[Toby Emmerich]]<br />John Thompson<br />[[Richard Donner]]<br />George Furla<br />Bradley J. Fischer<br />Charles Okun<br />[[Michael De Luca]]<br />Arnold Rifkin<br />Randall Emmett<br />Danny Dimbort<br />[[Leonardo DiCaprio]]<br />[[Mike Medavoy]]<br />Arnold W. Messer<br />Martin Scorsese<br />{{small|'''Co-Executive Producers:'''}}<br />Chris Brigham<br />Peter Giuliano<br />Carol Fenelow<br />Jonathan Gordon<br />[[Grant Curtis]]<br />Joseph Reidy<br />{{small|'''Line Producers:'''}}<br />[[Andrew Scheinman]]<br />Graham Place<br />{{small|'''Co-Producers:'''}}<br />Paula Weinstein<br />Emma Tillinger<br />Matthew Stein<br />Amy Herman<br />{{small|'''Executive Producers:'''}}<br />[[Bob Weinstein]]<br />[[Harvey Weinstein]]<br />Curtis Hanson<br />[[Ridley Scott]]<br />{{small|'''Associate Producers:'''}}<br />[[Rick Schwartz]]<br />[[Donald De Line]]<br />[[Tony Scott]]
 | writer = {{small|'''Screenplay:'''}}<br />Curtis Hanson<br />[[Tony Gilroy]]<br />[[Lawrence Kasdan]]<br />[[Brad Silberling]]<br />[[Gary Scott Thompson]]<br />[[Martin Scorsese]]<br />Scott B. Smith<br />[[Michael Apted]]<br />[[William Goldman]]<br />[[Jim Thomas (screenwriter)|Jim Thomas]]<br />[[John Thomas (screenwriter)|John Thomas]]<br />[[Thomas Carter (film director)|Thomas Carter]]<br />[[Peter Gould]]<ref>[[Peter Gould (writer)|''Peter Gould'']]</ref><br />{{small|'''[[Too Big to Fail (book)|Book:]]'''}}<br />[[Andrew Ross Sorkin]]<br />[[Scott Smith (author)|Scott B. Smith]]
-| music = [[Marcelo Zarvos]]<br />[[Alexandre Desplat]]<br />[[John Debney]]<br />[[Elliot Goldenthal]]<br />[[James Horner]]<br />[[James Newton Howard]]<br />{{small|'''Songs:'''}}<br />[[Marc Streitenfeld]]<br />[[Alan Silvestri]]<br />Happy Walters<br />{{small|'''Lyrics:'''}}<br />[[Bruce Broughton]]<br />Gary Jones<br />[[Rolfe Kent]]<br />[[Danny Elfman]] />'{{small|''Score:'''}}<br />[[Theodore Shapiro]]<br />[[Hans Zimmer]]<br />[[Michael Kamen]]<br />[[Robbie Robertson]]<br />[[John Barry (composer)|John Barry]]
+| music = [[Marcelo Zarvos]]<br />[[Alexandre Desplat]]<br />[[John Debney]]<br />[[Elliot Goldenthal]]<br />[[James Horner]]<br />[[James Newton Howard]]<br />{{small|'''Songs:'''}}<br />[[Marc Streitenfeld]]<br />[[Alan Silvestri]]<br />Happy Walters<br />{{small|'''Lyrics:'''}}<br />[[Bruce Broughton]]<br />Gary Jones<br />[[Rolfe Kent]]<br />[[Danny Elfman]] />'{{small|'''Score:'''}}<br />[[Theodore Shapiro]]<br />[[Hans Zimmer]]<br />[[Michael Kamen]]<br />[[Robbie Robertson]]<br />[[John Barry (composer)|John Barry]]
 | cinematography = Kramer Morgenthau
 | editing = Jonathan Olive<br />Steven Mirkovich<br />[[Bob Murawski]]<br />[[Pietro Scalia]]<br />[[Malcolm Campbell]]<br />Rick Shaine<br />[[Carol Littleton]]<br />[[Peter E. Berger]]