Brodnici: Difference between revisions
→Documentary evidence: correct insertion |
Rescuing 1 sources and tagging 0 as dead. #IABot (v1.2.7) |
||
Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
Attempts have been made to associate them to better known neighbouring populations, different authors classifying them as [[Romanians]],<ref>G. Popa Lisseanu, Brodnicii, vol. XII, Tipografia Bucovina, Bucuresti, 1938</ref>{{better source|date=May 2016}}<ref>A. Boldur, Istoria Basarabiei, Editura Victor Frunza, Bucuresti 1992</ref> [[Iranian peoples|Iranian]], or a mixed ethnic stock (Romanian-[[Jassic people|Jassic]];<ref>O. B. Bubenok, Iasy i brodniki v stepiakh Vostochnoi Evropy (VI-nachalo XIII v.), Kiev, 1997.</ref> Romanian-Slavic,<ref name=spinei/> or [[Turkic peoples|Turko]]-Slavic).<ref>[[Lev Gumilev]]'s opinion; e.g., in his "Discovery of Khazaria"</ref> |
Attempts have been made to associate them to better known neighbouring populations, different authors classifying them as [[Romanians]],<ref>G. Popa Lisseanu, Brodnicii, vol. XII, Tipografia Bucovina, Bucuresti, 1938</ref>{{better source|date=May 2016}}<ref>A. Boldur, Istoria Basarabiei, Editura Victor Frunza, Bucuresti 1992</ref> [[Iranian peoples|Iranian]], or a mixed ethnic stock (Romanian-[[Jassic people|Jassic]];<ref>O. B. Bubenok, Iasy i brodniki v stepiakh Vostochnoi Evropy (VI-nachalo XIII v.), Kiev, 1997.</ref> Romanian-Slavic,<ref name=spinei/> or [[Turkic peoples|Turko]]-Slavic).<ref>[[Lev Gumilev]]'s opinion; e.g., in his "Discovery of Khazaria"</ref> |
||
Some authors have identified them with the "Bordinians" mentioned by Byzantine chronicler [[Niketas Choniates]] as a branch of "Tauroscythians,"<ref>cf. "[[Taurida]]" and "[[Scythians]]"</ref> a term apparently applying to the [[Rus people]] in order to distinguish them from the [[Cumans]]/[[Polovtsians]] and from [[Vlachs]].<ref name=Knyasky>I.O. Knyazky, "Rus and the Steppe", Князький И.О. Русь и степь. - Moscow: Российский научный фонд, 1996., [http://www.auditorium.ru/books/242/gl5.pdf Ch. 5, Polovtsians] {{Ru icon}}</ref> |
Some authors have identified them with the "Bordinians" mentioned by Byzantine chronicler [[Niketas Choniates]] as a branch of "Tauroscythians,"<ref>cf. "[[Taurida]]" and "[[Scythians]]"</ref> a term apparently applying to the [[Rus people]] in order to distinguish them from the [[Cumans]]/[[Polovtsians]] and from [[Vlachs]].<ref name=Knyasky>I.O. Knyazky, "Rus and the Steppe", Князький И.О. Русь и степь. - Moscow: Российский научный фонд, 1996., [http://www.auditorium.ru/books/242/gl5.pdf Ch. 5, Polovtsians] {{wayback|url=http://www.auditorium.ru/books/242/gl5.pdf |date=20070929203924 }} {{Ru icon}}</ref> |
||
==Documentary evidence== |
==Documentary evidence== |
Revision as of 05:18, 9 November 2016
The Brodnici (Russian: Бродники, Brodniki) were a tribe of uncertain origin.
Etymology
In some opinions, the name, as used by foreign chronicles, means a person in charge of a ford (water crossing) in Slavic language (cf. Slavic brodŭ). The probable reason for the name is that the territory of the Brodniks constituted the link between the mountain passes in the Carpathians and the mouths of the Danube, having a major economical importance, assuring the access to the Genovese colonies.[1] According to other opinions, their name is related to Slavic бродить ("to wander"), probably referring to the nomadic way of life of this population.[2] Other opinions claim that the name came from the river Prut or from its purportedly old name Brutus [3]
Territory
The territory of Brodnici consisted of the southwestern part of today's Republic of Moldova, the southern part of today's Vrancea and Galaţi counties of Romania, the southern part of Ukraine Budjak and probably the coastline between the Dniester and the Dnieper.[2]
Ethnicity
Attempts have been made to associate them to better known neighbouring populations, different authors classifying them as Romanians,[4][better source needed][5] Iranian, or a mixed ethnic stock (Romanian-Jassic;[6] Romanian-Slavic,[2] or Turko-Slavic).[7]
Some authors have identified them with the "Bordinians" mentioned by Byzantine chronicler Niketas Choniates as a branch of "Tauroscythians,"[8] a term apparently applying to the Rus people in order to distinguish them from the Cumans/Polovtsians and from Vlachs.[9]
Documentary evidence
In 1216 they were in the service of the knyaz of Suzdal.[citation needed]
In 1222, the Hungarian king Andrew II gave the "Burzenland" to the Teutonic Knights, delimiting it by the land of the Brodnici. A Papal bull of Pope Honorius III confirmed the charter in the same year; however, in the copy approved by the Vatican, "Brodnicorum" was replaced by "Blacorum" (i.e., "Vlachs" in Latin). While some historians believe that this shows that the terms were equivalent, others claim that this was just an error.[2] The latter base their claim on the fact that the two terms were used together in several Hungarian documents, very unusual if referring to the same population.[citation needed]
The Novgorod First Chronicle says that in 1223 the Brodnici took part in the Battle of Kalka on the side of Mongols ("Tatars").[10]
When speaking about Brodniks, the Chronicle mentions voivode Ploskynya (the name of the voivode is sometimes rendered as Ploscânea in Romanian historiography)) who deceived knyaz Mstislav Romanovich and delivered him to "Tatars". Some researchers conclude that Ploskynya was the Brodniks commander. According to some researchers, the Chronicle should be interpreted as "And there Brodniks were with Tatars, and their Voivod Ploskyna [...]." However other disagree, considering that the source should be translated as "And there Brodniks were with Tatars, and Voivod Ploskyna, [...]." After this date, they disappeared from Russian sources.[citation needed]
In August 1227 Pope Gregory IX wrote a letter to the bishop of Esztergom instructing him to convert to Christianity "in Cumania et Bordinia terra illis vicina".[citation needed]
A November 11, 1250 letter of king Béla IV of Hungary to Pope Innocent IV says that Tatars imposed tribute onto the countries neighboring with his kingdom: "que ex parte Orientis cum regno nostro conterminantur, sicut Ruscia, Cumania, Brodnici, Bulgaria".[9]
Notes
- ^ Binder Pál: "Antecedente şi consecinţe sud-transilvănene ale formării voievodatului Munteniei (sec. XIII-XIV.) II.",
- ^ a b c d Victor Spinei, Moldavia in the 11th–14th centuries, Editura Academiei Republicii Socialiste România 1986.
- ^ A. Boldur, Istoria Basarabiei, Editura Victor Frunza, Bucuresti, 1992, p.101
- ^ G. Popa Lisseanu, Brodnicii, vol. XII, Tipografia Bucovina, Bucuresti, 1938
- ^ A. Boldur, Istoria Basarabiei, Editura Victor Frunza, Bucuresti 1992
- ^ O. B. Bubenok, Iasy i brodniki v stepiakh Vostochnoi Evropy (VI-nachalo XIII v.), Kiev, 1997.
- ^ Lev Gumilev's opinion; e.g., in his "Discovery of Khazaria"
- ^ cf. "Taurida" and "Scythians"
- ^ a b I.O. Knyazky, "Rus and the Steppe", Князький И.О. Русь и степь. - Moscow: Российский научный фонд, 1996., Ch. 5, Polovtsians Template:Wayback Template:Ru icon
- ^ Novgorod Chronice, years 1219-1232
References
- Ghyka, Matila, A Documented Chronology of Roumanian History, Oxford: B. H. Blackwell Ltd. 1941.