Jump to content

Brian Day

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by PeaBrainC (talk | contribs) at 22:18, 26 March 2021 (→Cambie Surgeries Corporation v. British Columbia (Medical Services Commission): Rearranged and removed obsolete information now trial completed). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

For the English swimmer, see Brian Day (swimmer).
Brian Day
Dr. Brian Day speaking as president of the CMA in 2008.
Born(1947-01-29)January 29, 1947
Liverpool, England
NationalityEnglish-Canadian
EducationUniversity of Manchester
University of British Columbia
Medical career
ProfessionSurgeon
FieldOrthopedics
InstitutionsCambie Surgery Centre
UBC Hospital
AwardsEdouard Samson Award

Brian Day MRCP (UK), FRCS (Eng), FRCS (C), (born January 29, 1947) is an orthopedic surgeon and health researcher in Canada, a past president of the Canadian Medical Association, and a prominent sometimes controversial advocate[1] for patient access to a hybrid of Canada's health system.

As the founder and medical director of a private clinic Cambie Surgery Centre and Specialist Referral Clinic[2] in Vancouver, British Columbia, Day is a spokesperson for a high-profile, multi-year and ongoing lawsuit against the provincial government, Cambie Surgeries Corporation v. British Columbia (Medical Services Commission).[3] that is sometimes cited publicly as 'The Day Case'.[4]

Early life and education

Day was raised in Toxteth, a working-class area of post-war Liverpool, England. He was the eldest of four children in a family with strong Labour views. Both his mother and father were socialists.[1] Day credited his personal shift from the political left to the political center-right by his disenchantment with the British labour movement's jurisdictional inertia and contributions to inefficiency in health care.[5]

Day attended the Liverpool Institute, the same high school attended by Paul McCartney and George Harrison.[1] His family's neighbourhood could be tough. Day has a permanent scar on a finger from a knife fight when he was 10 years old.[1][6] His father, a pharmacist, was killed in 1981 by hooligans looking for drugs during riots in the neighbourhood.[1] The possible contribution of misdiagnosis by British doctors for the death of Day's mother in 1986 is cited as his dissatisfaction with the British health system.[7][8]

Day entered medical school at age 18 at the University of Manchester, where he graduated in 1970. After an initial interest in general surgery, which he pursued as a postgraduate in Manchester and at the Hammersmith Hospital in London, he focused on orthopaedics.[1] He obtained his medical degrees, MB ChB from the University of Manchester, and post-graduate qualifications in both internal medicine and general surgery. In July 1973, Day moved to Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.[1] In 1978, Day completed his training and a M.Sc. degree at the University of British Columbia (UBC).

Medical career

In 1979, Day received the Canadian Orthopaedic Association's Edouard Samson Award, for outstanding orthopaedic research in Canada. Following a fellowship in traumatology, in Basel, Switzerland, Oxford, and Los Angeles, he began practice at the Vancouver General Hospital. After starting in trauma, he developed an interest and expertise in orthopaedic sports medicine and arthroscopy.

As an orthopedic surgeon, he earned an international reputation for performing arthroscopic surgery on hips, knees, shoulders and elbows. Day is regarded as being instrumental in the introduction of arthroscopic joint surgery in Canada.[5]

From 1970 to 2014, Day wrote more than 150 scientific articles or book chapters, in areas of orthopaedics and arthroscopic surgery / sports medicine, and on the topic of health policy.[citation needed]

Medical association leadership (Canada and North America)

Day is a founding member and was 2004 president of the Arthroscopy Association of North America, being the second Canadian elected to that position.

In August 2006, Day was elected president of the Canadian Medical Association (CMA) for the 2007/08 term, despite a challenge at the convention floor by another British Columbian physician (whom Day had beaten in the nomination process) regarding Day's views about for-profit health care.[1] He was the first orthopaedic surgeon in the 148-year history of the CMA to be elected president.[9] Day states that his advocacy as president of CMA was for a hybrid public-private system, not a full replacement by private hospitals.[10] The CMA policy drafted in 2007 was "When access to timely care cannot be provided in the publicly funded system, Canadians should be able to use private health insurance to reimburse the cost of care obtained in the private sector."[3]

Doctors of BC

In 2015, Day was temporarily announced as the president-elect for Doctors of BC, the provincial medical association in British Columbia, because of a win by a single vote difference. The election was then rescinded because of an error found in properly categorizing one ballot. Day then lost the subsequent run-off election in June 2015 to Alan Ruddiman by 603 votes after the publicity about the single-vote win escalated participation to the highest turnout by physician members of the association.[11] In May 2016, Day was defeated 1,896 to 1,674 votes by Trina Larsen Soles in the election for the 2017–18 Doctors of BC presidency.[12]

Day is a member of the editorial board for the BC Medical Journal.[2]

Advocacy for access to private care

In 2003, Maclean's Magazine named Day one its top 50 Canadians "to watch", describing him as "an iconoclast, whose time is now."[13] He is referred to as "Dr. Profit" by opponents who believe his legal challenges will threaten Canada's publicly funded medicare system, and Prophet by supporters for his advocacy of a role for patient choice and the right to obtain private insurance in the face of long government wait lists for care.[5]

Day has argued many Canadians are being hypocritical towards private healthcare, because 70 per cent of Canadians buy healthcare insurance. Many with such insurance themselves claim to oppose private healthcare, while embracing it for themselves. The other 30 per cent of Canadians who cannot afford the extra healthcare insurance receive poorer access to care.[14]

Day cites the Canada Health Act of 1984 being responsible for rationing of care that has resulted in over a million Canadians suffering on wait lists, and to more than 5 million without a doctor. In the 2005 Chaoulli v Quebec (AG) decision, the Supreme Court of Canada struck down prohibitions on private insurance in that province because it was an infringement of the Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms; the decision did not extend to the rest of Canada, but constitutional experts opined that it would certainly have major impact on similar cases brought to court elsewhere. Day also supports the end of block funding for hospitals and a change to "Patient Focused Funding" where revenue follows the patient. He advocates a patient-centered system with a greater role for competition in Canadian healthcare as a means to reduce waiting times and save government money by treating people before their condition worsens.[1] He is a frequent spokesman for the topic with news media and submits position papers with government. For instance, his submission to Roy Romanow's Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada made 10 recommendations:

  1. De-politicize the debate
  2. Repeal the Canada Health Act
  3. Eliminate global budgets and reward productivity
  4. Incorporate business methods
  5. Increase privatization and contracting out
  6. Introduce competition, choice and accountability
  7. Massively reduce bureaucracy
  8. Reduce influence of public sector health unions
  9. Accept economic reality, and introduce user fees
  10. Rank "core services" and de-insure unnecessary services[15]

US 'Conservatives For Patient Rights' commercial controversy

In May 2009, Day drew criticism after he was shown in a series of television ads for a US lobby group called Conservatives for Patients' Rights that opposed President Obama's health care reforms. Day appeared on the television program BNN on May 11, 2009, to clarify that he issued a letter distancing himself from the ad. He also pointed out that Obamacare was based on private insurance and private delivery, the opposite of what many Canadians believe in.[16]

In 1995, Day founded Cambie Surgery Centre, a for-profit Vancouver clinic. Day is the facility's medical director, and one of its 40-plus shareholders. The Cambie Surgery Centre has 50 full- and part-time nurses and 125 doctors performing operations and other procedures for up to 5,000 patients a year which may be the busiest private hospital in Canada.[17]

Day has said he decided to set up the Cambie Surgical Centre, which is non-union, after government funding decreased in the mid-90s cut his operating time at UBC from 17 hours a week to about six. The start-up was during the province's premiership of Michael Harcourt.[8] To demolish an old nursing home and build a surgery centre on the site, Day needed to raise about $5 million.[8] He succeeded in convincing notable Vancouverites such as the late Milan Ilich and Jack Poole, as well as Kip Woodward (chair of Providence Health Care and future chair of Vancouver Coastal Health), and 19 others including Jim Wyse and Hugh Magee,[8] to commit $100,000 each with the remainder financed by the Royal Bank of Canada.

Cambie Surgeries Corporation v. British Columbia (Medical Services Commission)

Main article: Cambie Surgeries Corporation v. British Columbia

In 2009, the Cambie Surgery Centre and patients filed a lawsuit versus the province's Medical Services Commission. Six of the eight plaintiffs are patients, two of whom died before the conclusion of the court case.[3] The trial which took place from 2016 to 2020, included over a hundred witnesses.[18][19][20][21][22][23][24]

In 2012, the British Columbia Medical Services Commission confirmed what the clinics had openly admitted to doing since 1996—namely allowing patients, in violation of the Medicare Protection Act, to spend their own funds to jump the queue and access the clinic.[25][26]

The Commission asked the Cambie Surgery Centre not to permit patients access to earlier treatment.[27] The plaintiffs pointed out the constitutional challenge had been brought before the courts 3 years earlier. In the Supreme Court of British Columbia, the plaintiffs are challenging the prohibition against patients being prohibited from using their own funds to access care, instead of receiving it in order based on medical priority. Specifically, they are challenging the ban on private health insurance to cover medically necessary care, and the ban preventing doctors from working in both the public and private health systems at the same time.

Proponents of publicly funded healthcare in Canada argue that this legal challenge against medicare could set a dangerous precedent. Proponents of for-profit care argue the opposite and that patients will be protected from the dangers of waiting for care. In the Chaoulli decision (2005) the Supreme Court of Canada declared it was a fact that Canadians were suffering and dying on wait lists. If the case is decided at trial in B.C., as is expected, either side may seek an appeal of the outcome at the Supreme Court of Canada. A decision at this level would mean the outcome would be binding in all provinces and territories across the country. Some legal experts have described this case as one of the most significant legal challenges in Canadian history.[28]

On September 10, 2020 Justice John J. Steeves, of the Supreme Court of British Columbia (BCSC), handed down his 880-page decision, in which he found that the "impugned provisions do not deprive the right to life or liberty of the patient plaintiffs or similarly situated individuals." He said that there was a "rational connection between the effects of the impugned provisions and the objectives of preserving...the universal health care system and ensuring access to necessary medical services is based on need and not the ability to pay."Justice Steeves ruled against legalizing private health care.

Recognition

  • 1993 to 2001: Associate Editor, Journal of Arthroscopic Surgery
  • 2001: 80th Annual Osler Lecturer, Vancouver Medical Association
  • 2004: President, Arthroscopy Association of North America (AANA)
  • 2004: Honorary Member, Cuban Orthopaedic Association
  • 2004: Member, Board of Trustees, Journal of Arthroscopy
  • 2005/06: President, Canadian Independent Medical Clinics Association (CIMCA)
  • 2012: jointly listed as #38 in the Power50 list for influencers in sport in Canada by The Globe and Mail[29]
  • 2014: Doctors of BC Don Rix Leadership Award

References

  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i Mason, Gary (August 1, 2007). "Brian Day: Day in Your Life". 'BC Business Magazine'. Vancouver. Retrieved August 1, 2014.
  2. ^ a b "Editorial Board". BC Medical Journal. Retrieved 2016-09-02.
  3. ^ a b c Fayerman, Pamela (2016-09-01). "B.C. trial over private health care could reshape Canadian medicare". The Vancouver Sun.
  4. ^ Peden, Alex. "Backgrounder: Court challenges to one-tier medicare". EvidenceNetwork.ca. University of Manitoba. Retrieved 2016-09-02.
  5. ^ a b c Ward, Doug (April 8, 2002). "A new Day for health care". Vancouver Sun. Retrieved 2 August 2014.
  6. ^ Mickleburgh, Rod (2010-11-05). "Part 1: Is this private clinic surgeon a crusader or criminal?". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 2016-09-02.
  7. ^ Mason, Gary (2016-09-02). "Changing Canada's health-care system is a life-long fight". The Globe and Mail.
  8. ^ a b c d Fayerman, Pamela (2015-02-24). "Dr. Brian Day #3: his dad's murder, mom's misdiagnosis, Beatles connection and the prominent families who were his investors". The Vancouver Sun. Retrieved 2016-09-03.
  9. ^ "First orthopedic surgeon voted CMA president-elect calls for health care reform". healio.com. Orthopedics Today 2006. Retrieved 2016-09-02.
  10. ^ Day, Brian (June 18, 2015). "Rebuttal from Brian Day: my prescription for Canada's health care". Opinion: National Observer. Retrieved 5 July 2015.
  11. ^ Canadian Press (June 19, 2015). "B.C. doctors elect new president; Dr. Brian Day loses by 600 votes". Global BC. Retrieved 5 July 2015.
  12. ^ Britten, Liam (2016-05-16). "Brian Day, private medical care advocate, loses Doctors of B.C. election". CBC News.
  13. ^ 50 Canadians to watch in 2003, Maclean's Magazine, January 20, 2003
  14. ^ Brian Day's diagnosis: The president of the Canadian Medical Association explains how to fix our health-care system - Full Comment Archived October 29, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
  15. ^ Dr. Brian Day - Submission to the Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada
  16. ^ Ward, Doug (October 10, 2009). "Canadian critics slam Obamacare in U.S." Vancouver Sun. Archived from the original on 9 August 2014. Retrieved 2 August 2014.
  17. ^ Fayerman, Pamela (2015-02-15). "Dr. Brian Day #1: Everything you need to know about him and his legal case against the government health care "monopoly"". The Vancouver Sun staff blog. Retrieved 2016-09-02.
  18. ^ "B.C. Supreme Court rules against legalizing private healthcare in landmark case". Global News. Retrieved 2020-09-10.
  19. ^ "Cambie Surgeries Corporation v. British Columbia – BC INJURY LAW". Retrieved 2020-09-10.
  20. ^ "Private health care battle draws to a close after a decade in B.C." British Columbia. 2020-02-28. Retrieved 2020-09-10.
  21. ^ Weisgarber, Maria (2020-09-10). "B.C. Supreme Court rules against legalizing private health care following decade-long battle". British Columbia. Retrieved 2020-09-10.
  22. ^ "B.C. Supreme Court rules against legalizing private health care following decade-long battle | CTV News". Retrieved 2020-09-10.
  23. ^ "Private Vancouver clinic loses constitutional challenge of public health-care rules | CBC News". Retrieved 2020-09-10.
  24. ^ "CHC » Cambie Case (ongoing)". Retrieved 2020-09-10.
  25. ^ Ministry of Health Billing Integrity Program (June 2012). Specialist Referral Clinic (Vancouver) Inc. and Cambie Surgeries Corporation: Audit Report (PDF).
  26. ^ Brend, Yvette. "Epic court battle over private health care rages in B.C. courts". cbc news.
  27. ^ "Medical Services Commission releases audit". gov.bc.ca.
  28. ^ Macleod, Andrew (17 April 2014). "For-Profit Clinic Lawsuit May Transform Health Care". TheTyee.ca. Retrieved 22 April 2014.
  29. ^ "The Globe's Power 50 list- 2012". Globe and Mail. Feb 6, 2012. Retrieved 2 August 2014.

Further reading

  • Brian Day: CMA's next president supports private health care, By Michael McCarthy, The Lancet, Oct 14, 2006, Vol 368, p. 1321
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Brian_Day&oldid=1014409950"