Dorothy Tuttle

Dorothy Tuttle Nitch (born Dorothy Polk Tuttle; April 21, 1918-August 12, 1998) was an American dancer and performer, primarily working at Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer in film musicals of the 1940s.

Dorothy Tuttle in the 1940s.

A familiar face in popular MGM musicals, Tuttle showcased her talent and artistry in many classic films: playing a waitress in the Judy Garland musical The Harvey Girls; a trolley passenger whom Judy Garland sings to in the classic “Trolley Song” in Meet Me in St. Louis; and as Gene Kelly’s dance partner for the song “Niña” in The Pirate, in which Kelly famously grabs her lit cigarette from her lips, places in his mouth, turns it inward, and then kisses Tuttle with the lit cigarette still inside his mouth.

Born in Los Angeles to Walter and Estrella Tuttle, Dorothy was trained in ballet from a young age. To help supplement the household income, Tuttle sought work as a dancer. Tuttle was urged by a friend to audition for MGM studios in 1937 and was hired for the film Rosalie as a background dancer. She continued to work at MGM until the early 1950s.

She appeared as a dancer and background performer in dozens of MGM films, including Marie Antoinette (1938), the Technicolor fashion show segment of The Women (1939), Ziegfeld Girl (1941), Ship Ahoy (1942), Du Barry was a Lady (1943), Ziegfeld Follies (1945), Two Sisters from Boston (1946), Till the Clouds Roll By (1946), Madame Bovary (1949), On the Town (1949), Summer Stock (1950), Royal Wedding (1951), and Show Boat (1951).

She also worked for other studios during this time: 20th Century Fox, in Tin Pan Alley (1940), Call Me Mister (1951); Warner Bros, in Tea for Two (1950) and Lullaby of Broadway (1951); Columbia Pictures, where she danced with Marilyn Monroe in Ladies of the Chorus (1948).

Tuttle was one of the few supporting dancers who had an MGM contract. She was one of the Screen Actors Guild members who petitioned MGM in 1941 for a raise in weekly salary and were successful in their efforts.

“Tut,” a nickname Tuttle acquired while at MGM, was often seen alongside fellow dancer Dorothy Gilmore Raye in the musicals of the Arthur Freed Unit at MGM. They remained lifelong friends and later in life appeared together in two documentaries: MGM When the Lion Roars (1992) and Judy Garland: Beyond the Rainbow (1997).

Her final screen appearances were in An American in Paris (1951) and Love is Better than Ever (1952), in which she was in the early stages of pregnancy with her first son. Tuttle retired from film that same year to raise a family.

She married Gene La Tour in 1950 and had 3 sons: Mark, Kevin and Craig. She later became active in Santa Monica civic groups working to preserve historic sites, in the Santa Monica Republican Women’s Club, and in the Santa Monica Presbyterian Church, where she was volunteer wedding director.

Divorced La Tour in the early 1980s and then married Jim Nitch in 1984, who published The Mysterious Chronicles of Oz under the pen name Onyx Madden in 1985. After her marriage, she moved to Encino, CA and was a volunteer at the Encino Women’s Club, the Old Treasures Club and the National Charity League of Los Angeles. Tuttle was an active member of the Daughters of the American Revolution (DAR). She was also active with The International Wizard of Oz Club in the 1980s and 1990s, making numerous appearances at conventions and events.

Tuttle died on August 12, 1998 in Encino, CA of natural causes.