Pacific Park, Brooklyn

The Atlantic Yards is a mixed-use commercial and residential development project of 16 buildings, currently proposed in the neighborhoods of Prospect Heights and Park Slope, adjacent to Downtown Brooklyn and Fort Greene in Brooklyn, New York City. A portion of the project is part of the Atlantic Terminal Urban Renewal Area (abbreviated as ATURA) and the rest located in a low-rise brownstone neighborhood.

The centerpiece of the development, according to the developers, would be the Barclays Center, which would serve as the new home of the New Jersey Nets. 8.4 acres of the 22 acre project would be built over a train yard that is utilized by the Long Island Rail Road, and a portion of the site was a part of the Atlantic Terminal Urban Renewal Area. The Atlantic Yards project is being developed and overseen by Forest City Ratner and designed by architect Frank Gehry.

Its derives its name from being the rail yard located on Atlantic Avenue. Officially the Long Island Rail Road yard is called the "Vanderbilt Yards" (named for Vanderbilt Avenue that crosses over on its way to the Brooklyn Navy Yard) but there are other Vanderbilt rail place names in New York City so the Atlantic Yards name has stuck. The specific stop for the LIRR is the Atlantic Terminal, the westernmost stop of the Atlantic Branch of the LIRR. Easy access by rapid transit and suburban rail, and the desirable brownstone housing stock nearby made it a target for speculative development.

The project is often considered the most controversial in New York. While the fierce opposition to the environmental effects has spurned several legal battles, the real threat to the completion of the project is the credit crisis and the weakening housing market. Despite the reliance on public subsidies for such a risky project, preparatory sitework in anticipation of construction has started as of February 20, 2007. On June 13, 2007, Forest City Ratner announced that the head of its Atlantic Yards development group, executive vice president James P. Stuckey, submitted his resignation, citing a desire to pursue new challenges.

When the project was announced at the end of 2003, the basketball arena was scheduled to open in the fall of 2006.

The Vanderbilt Railyards represents 8.4 acres of the 22 acre site (as seen in September 2006)

Elements of the Atlantic Yards Project

Barclays Center

The Barclays Center would serve as the new home of the National Basketball Association’s New Jersey Nets, which was purchased by a group led by principal developer Bruce Ratner with the intention of making it and the arena the centerpiece of the whole project. This would bring major league professional sports to Brooklyn for the first time since the Brooklyn Dodgers moved to Los Angeles, California after the 1957 season. (Ironically, the Atlantic Yards site was suggested by Dodgers' owner Walter O'Malley as a potential site for a baseball park before the Dodgers moved to Los Angeles. Robert Moses said that a sports arena here would create a "China Wall of traffic.") The arena’s design includes an ice skating rink and private park space on its roof. The arena represents about 10% of the Ratner proposal.

The naming rights to the arena were purchased by Barclays, the British bank, for a record-setting price of nearly $400 million over 20 years. This eclipsed the previous record for naming rights to an American indoor arena. The previous record, set by Royal Philips Electronics in 1999, was for $185 million over 20 years paid to name Philips Arena in Atlanta.

The proceeds of the naming rights will go to the developer, not to the state of New York, which would nominally own the land. The naming rights deal provoked additional controversy because Barclays has been accused of being associated with the South African apartheid regime, Robert Mugabe and Nazi financing.

Housing

The largest portion of the proposal is mixed-income residential housing. Of the 6,430 units, 1,930 will be market-rate condominiums. The remaining 4,500 will be rental units, half of which will be set aside for moderate , middle, and low income households. The project defines "moderate income" as families earning $49,600 to $131,600 per year^[1]. Some apartments will be available for those earning less than even $15,000 per year^[2]. The median median income for Brooklyn is $32,135^[3]

At the Manhattan average of 1.93 people per housing unit, Atlantic Yards would become home to about 12,410 people, while if the density is closer to the city-wide average of 2.63 people per housing unit, about 16,910 people can be expected to move in by completion of the project. Either way, since Atlantic Yards sits on 22 acres, it can be expected to become the most densely populated census tract in North America, with a density of 361,000 to 490,000 people per square mile, about twice the density of the current densest census tract in the United States, a block in Manhattan west of Broadway and between West 133rd and West 135th Streets, which as of the 2000 Census had a population density of 229,713 inhabitants per square mile [1]. By comparison, the most densely populated neighborhood in the world is Mongkok in Hong Kong, where density exceeds 410,000 inhabitants per square mile.

Commercial space

The remaining buildings in the Atlantic Yards would be used for office space and retail development.

Transportation

The development sits on the most congested intersection in Brooklyn. According to the Environmental Impact Statement, the addition of more than 15,000 new residents would not significantly impact vehicular traffic, a claim contested by the Council of Brooklyn Neighborhoods.

Subway station

The Atlantic Yards would be above the Atlantic Avenue–Pacific Street subway station, the largest train station in Brooklyn and the third largest transit hub in New York City, serving 11 different New York City Subway lines.

Long Island Railroad

The Atlantic Terminal serves the Atlantic Branch of the Long Island Railroad.

Buses

The site of the Atlantic Yards is currently served by five bus lines, B41, B45, B63, B65 and B67. However, bus routes change throughout the years, and may be changed to accommodate the Atlantic Yards project.

Financing

The development would be paid in part by private financing and in part by public subsidies. New York State has committed to $100 million of taxpayer money and New York City is giving $205 million in direct contributions. In addition, there are approved tax breaks and subsidies to pay for the project, bringing the total known public money to be used in the project to approximately $1.929 billion. The tax subsidies include:

$360 million - 30 Year Full Property Tax Exemption (if the lease for its full term of 99 years, the abatement would exceed $1 billion)
$77 million - Mortgage Recording Tax Exemption
$610 million - 9,100,000 square feet (850,000 m²) of Development Rights (A $910 million value for which Ratner pays approximately $300 million, including a discounted, closed-door price for the Rail Yards, without genuine competitive bidding; Vanderbilt Rail Yards appraised value: $214.5 million, Ratner bid $100, Extell bid $150 million)
$555.3 million - Tax-Exempt and Taxed Bonding for the Arena
$101 million - Housing Construction Subsidies
$26 million - Forest City Pays $1.00 for a 99 year lease for all the land under the Arena, its garages and access ways, including City street, a total of 6.5 acres

In addition to the known subsidies, the unknown subsidies include:

Unspecified (and unlimited) additional funds for "extraordinary infrastructure costs"
Government subsidies and/or tax credits to provide for "affordable housing"
Credit for any costs which Ratner incurs in relocating and installing public utility infrastructure
Guaranties from the City, the Empire State Development Corporation and the EDC that they will "use their best efforts" to obtain energy cost savings for the Arena for an unspecified period of time
Arena construction materials and fixtures sales tax exemption
Credit under the Brownfield Program if Forest City has to spend more than $20 million in remediation of environmental hazards

As of January 29, 2008, several challenges remain for the project to be finalized:

Ratner does not own the rail yard. The developer and the MTA have an agreement over the sale price of the yards (the low bid of $100 million was accepted) but the transfer agreement has not been signed and the MTA has not collected the money;
The city, state and Ratner have not reached financial agreements on the arena bond;
The city, state and Ratner have not reached financial agreements on the Payments in Lieu of Taxes (PILOT);
The city, state and Ratner have not reached financial agreements on the "affordable" housing subsidies, credits and bonds;
The city has not transferred all of its $205 million in direct cash taxpayer subsidy to Ratner;
Ratner does not own the property he needs to build the arena and superblocks.

According to the NY Post, this does not matter because "Bruce Ratner can pull out of his $4 billion Atlantic Yards project for Brooklyn without penalty.... That's because the developer never signed binding contracts for the controversial state-approved project or drew on hundreds of millions in government subsidies, officials confirmed yesterday."

Land to be used

The proposed development rests at one of the most desirable neighborhoods in New York City. Prospect Heights has seen remarkable explosion of real estate values, pushing out many of the less affluent residents. Critics charge that the few unused buildings are "developer's blight," that is to say, buildings bought by Forest City Ratner and then left vacant.

The bulk of the 22 acre project site is a mixture of public streets, private homes and small businesses. Forest City Ratner has bought much of this private property, but does not own the public streets and intends to use eminent domain to seize the remaining property from private homeowners and businesses. The Public Authorities Control Board, which effectively ended the West Side Stadium plan, approved the Atlantic Yards plan and use of eminent domain. [2] However, the plan still faces lawsuits from residents.

Controversy

The main controversy concerning the development of the Atlantic Yards is the use of eminent domain which would destroy a low-density neighborhood containing an undisclosed number of multi-million dollar townhouses and pre-war apartment buildings subject to rent stabilization regulations. Forest City Ratner offer the condo owners in 636 Pacific St. $850/sq. foot, the condo owners at 24 Sixth Ave (Spalding Buildings) $650/sq. foot and undisclosed amounts to renters. Sellers of condos signed a non disclosure agreement.

Another controversial aspect of the development is that the rail yard was valued at $214 million in 2005, and is in contract with the favored developer for $100 Million, despite another bid for $150 million. Even though this property was appraised at $214 in 2004, the MTA decided to negotiate exclusively with Forest City Ratner, which originally bid $50 Million. Extell Corporation bid $150 Million, and FCR eventually boosted its bid up to $100 million. The Extell bid, however, was contingent on a contract for the company to provide energy to the city from a power plant that would have been constructed in the location. Professional appraisers are quick to point out that there has been no prior transaction anywhere in the country that has approached the complexity, scale, and cost of the rail yard. This inherently limited the accuracy of any appraisal.

An important community concern is that Forest City Ratner submitted an environmental impact plan that many experts have deemed inadequate. Forest City Ratner's lead developer James L. Stuckey recently resigned citing a desire to "pursue new challenges."

Public opinion

Supporters

The project is endorsed by the MTA and Mayor Michael Bloomberg, has been strongly supported by Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz, who sees this project as the opportunity to finally produce the business district in Brooklyn that was intended with the construction of the Williamsburg Savings Bank but was halted by the Great Depression. Governor Pataki, U.S. Senator Charles Schumer, Congressman Edolphus Towns, Congressman Gregory W. Meeks, Congressman Anthony Weiner, and Comptroller William C. Thompson, Jr. have also supported the project as necessary for the economic development of Brooklyn and New York City.

[3] Borough President Markowitz in 12/30/06 Brooklyn Papers interview rails against media coverage and project opponents

Opponents

The most vocal opposition group is a nonprofit named Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn. Three of the four local elected representatives in the neighborhood also oppose the project, especially New York City Council member Letitia James. Other organizations that are opposed to or seek to scale back the project include: 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement, Boerum Hill Association (BHA), Central Brooklyn Independent Democrats (CBID), Committee For Environmentally Sound Development, Creative Industries Coalition (80 local businesses, galleries and collectives), Democracy for New York City (DFNYC).

References

External links

Official website
Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn
noLandGrab, an anti-project advocacy site
BrooklynSpeaks, an alliance of community groups critical of the project and not allied with DDDb
BUILD, advocates of the project

Template:Mapit-US-cityscale

[1] ttp://www.atlanticyards.com/downloads/housing_chart_july06.pdf

[2] ttp://www.atlanticyards.com/downloads/housing_chart_july06.pdf

[3] ttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooklyn

[1]

[2]

[3]