Jump to content

Abdelbaset al-Megrahi

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 163.1.156.219 (talk) at 08:37, 21 February 2011 (→‎Release). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Abdelbaset al-Megrahi
Born
(Arabic: عبد الباسط محمد علي المقرحي) Abdelbaset Mohmed Ali al-Megrahi

(1952-04-01) 1 April 1952 (age 72)
Tripoli, Libya
NationalityLibyan
Occupation(s)Libyan intelligence officer
Head of security for Libyan Arab Airlines
Director of the Centre for Strategic Studies in Tripoli, Libya
Criminal statusReleased on compassionate grounds, returned to Libya
SpouseAisha al-Megrahi
Children4 sons, 1 daughter
Criminal chargeMurder
Conspiracy to murder
Breach of the Aviation Security Act 1982
PenaltyLife imprisonment

Abdelbaset Mohmed Ali al-Megrahi (Arabic: عبد الباسط محمد علي المقرحي, `Abd al-Bāsaṭ Muḥammad ʿAlī al-Maqraḥī; born 1 April 1952) is a Libyan convicted mass-murderer, alleged former intelligence officer, former head of security for Libyan Arab Airlines and former director of the Centre for Strategic Studies in Tripoli, the capital of Libya.[1] On 31 January 2001, Megrahi was convicted, by a panel of three Scottish judges sitting in a special court at Camp Zeist in the Netherlands, of 270 counts of murder for the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland, on 21 December 1988 and was sentenced to life imprisonment. His co-accused, Lamin Khalifah Fhimah was found not guilty and was acquitted.[2]

Megrahi was freed on compassionate grounds by the Scottish Government on 20 August 2009 following doctors reporting on 10 August 2009 that he had terminal prostate cancer and was expected to have about three months to live, but could live longer.[3][4][5][6][7][8] Eighteen months later he is still currently living in west Tripoli in Libya. Some questions are still being raised into the reason for his release, and whether if he had appealed his conviction might have been quashed.[9] [10]

Background

Megrahi was born in Tripoli, and was educated in the United States and Cardiff in Wales. He was the head of security for Libyan Arab Airlines (LAA), and director of the Centre for Strategic Studies in Tripoli. It was also alleged by the FBI and the prosecution in the Lockerbie case that he was an officer of the Libyan intelligence service, Jamahiriya el-Mukhabarat.[11][12]

Indictment and arrest

In November 1991, Megrahi and Fhimah were indicted by the US Attorney General and the Scottish Lord Advocate for the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103. Libya refused to extradite the two accused, but held them under armed house arrest in Tripoli, offering to detain them for trial in Libya, as long as all the incriminating evidence was provided. The offer was unacceptable to the US and UK, and there was an impasse for the next three years.[citation needed]

On 23 March 1995, over six years after the 1988 attack, they were designated as United States fugitives from justice and added as the 441st and 442nd additions on the FBI Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list. This list offered a $4 million reward from the US Air Line Pilots Association, Air Transport Association, and United States Department of State, and $50,000 from the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), for information leading to their arrest.[citation needed]

The parties eventually agreed on a compromise and a trial was held in the Netherlands under Scots law. The trial format was engineered by legal academic Professor Robert Black of the University of Edinburgh and was given political impetus by the then foreign secretary, Robin Cook.[citation needed]

Protracted negotiations with the Libyan leader, Colonel Muammar al-Gaddafi, and the imposition of United Nations economic sanctions against Libya brought the two accused to trial in a neutral country. Over ten years after the bombing, Megrahi and Fhimah were placed under arrest at Camp Zeist in the Netherlands on 5 April 1999. During his seven-year house arrest awaiting deportation and trial, he lived on a Libyan Arab Airlines pension and worked as a teacher.[11]

Trial

Main article: Pan Am Flight 103 bombing trial

The Scottish High Court of Justiciary at Camp Zeist was presided over by three senior judges and an additional, non-voting, judge.[13] The two accused, Megrahi and Lamin Khalifah Fhimah, denied all charges against them. The full charges included the names of the murdered 259 passengers and crew of Pan Am Flight 103, and the eleven residents killed at Lockerbie in Scotland.[14]

Representing Megrahi were his solicitor, Alistair Duff, and advocates William Taylor QC, David Burns QC and John Beckett. Fhimah was represented by solicitor Eddie McKechnie, advocates Richard Keen QC, Jack Davidson QC and Murdo Macleod. Both defendants also had access to a Libyan defence lawyer, Mr. Maghour.

Court proceedings started on 3 May 2000. The crucial witness against Megrahi for the prosecution was Tony Gauci, a Maltese storekeeper, who testified that he had sold Megrahi the clothing later found in the remains of the suitcase bomb.[15] At the trial, Tony Gauci appeared uncertain about the exact date he sold the clothes in question, and was not entirely sure that it was Megrahi to whom they were sold. Nonetheless, Megrahi's appeal against conviction was rejected by the Scottish Court in the Netherlands in March 2002. Five years after the trial, former Lord Advocate, Lord Fraser of Carmyllie, publicly described Gauci as being "an apple short of a picnic" and "not quite the full shilling".[16]

During the trial, the defence showed that Megrahi's co-defendant, Fhimah, had an air-tight alibi, having been in Sweden at the time of the sabotage.

Verdict

Barlinnie Prison, where Megrahi was incarcerated from 2001–2005

The judges announced their verdict on 31 January 2001. They said of Megrahi: "There is nothing in the evidence which leaves us with any reasonable doubt as to the guilt of the first accused, and accordingly we find him guilty of the remaining charge in the indictment as amended."[17] Megrahi was sentenced to life imprisonment, with a recommendation that he should serve at least 20 years before being eligible for parole.

The judges unanimously found the second accused, Lamin Khalifah Fhimah, not guilty of the murder charge.[18] Fhimah was freed and returned to his home at Souk al-Juma in Libya on 1 February 2001.

Megrahi was sent to Barlinnie Prison. In February 2005 he was transferred to Greenock Prison.[19]

Greenock Prison, where Megrahi was incarcerated from 2005–2009

Appeals

Megrahi's appeal against his conviction in January 2001 was refused on 14 March 2002 by a panel of five Scottish judges at Camp Zeist in the Netherlands.[20] According to a report by the BBC,[21] Dr Hans Köchler, one of the UN observers at the trial, expressed serious doubts about the fairness of the proceedings and spoke of a "spectacular miscarriage of justice".[22]

On 24 November 2003 Megrahi appeared at the High Court in Glasgow, in front of the three Judges who originally sentenced him at Camp Zeist, to learn that he would have to serve at least 27 years in jail – back-dated to April 1999 when he was extradited from Libya – before he could be considered for parole. This court hearing was the result of the incorporation into Scots law of the European Convention on Human Rights in 2001, nine months after Megrahi's sentence was imposed, which required him to be told the extent of the "punishment part" of his life term. On 31 May 2004 he was granted leave to appeal against his 27-year sentence.[23] The appeal against sentence was scheduled to be heard in Edinburgh by a panel of five Judges on 11 July 2006. However, the Scottish Court of Criminal Appeal decided to postpone the July hearing to allow consideration of whether the appeal against sentence ought to be heard at Camp Zeist rather than in Edinburgh.[24]

Review

On 23 September 2003 lawyers acting for Megrahi applied to the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission (SCCRC) for a review of the case (both sentence and conviction), arguing that there had been a miscarriage of justice. On 1 November 2006 Megrahi was reported to have dropped his demand for the new appeal to be held at Camp Zeist.[25] In an interview with The Scotsman newspaper of 31 January 2006, retired Scottish Judge Lord MacLean – one of the three who convicted Megrahi in 2001 – said he believed the SCCRC would return the case for a further appeal against conviction:

"They can't be working for two years without producing something with which to go to the court."

MacLean added that any new appeal would indicate the flexibility of Scots law, rather than a weakness:

"It might even be the strength of the system – it is capable of looking at itself subsequently and determining a ground for appeal."

In January 2007, the SCCRC announced that it would issue its decision on Megrahi's case by the end of June 2007.[26] On 9 June 2007 rumours of a possible prisoner swap deal involving Megrahi were strenuously denied by prime minister Tony Blair.[27] Later in June, The Observer confirmed the imminence of the SCCRC ruling and reported:

"Abdelbaset al-Megrahi never wavered in his denial of causing the Lockerbie disaster: now some Scottish legal experts say they believe him."[28]

Second appeal

On 28 June 2007 the SCCRC concluded its four-year review and, having uncovered evidence that a miscarriage of justice could have occurred, the Commission granted Megrahi leave to appeal against his Lockerbie bombing conviction for a second time.[29] The second appeal to the Court of Criminal Appeal was abandoned in August 2009, as an impediment to the legal power to release him to Libya under the Prisoner Transfer Scheme then operating in the United Kingdom. Ultimately, he was not released under this scheme, rather, on compassionate grounds due to his ill health. There was in the event, no requirement to drop his appeal against conviction.

New information casting fresh doubts about Megrahi's conviction was examined at a procedural hearing at the Judicial Appeal Court (Court of Session building) in Edinburgh on 11 October 2007:

  1. His lawyers claimed that vital documents, which emanated from the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and related to the Mebo timer that allegedly detonated the Lockerbie bomb, were withheld from the trial defence team.[30]
  2. Tony Gauci, chief prosecution witness at the trial, was alleged to have been paid $2 million for testifying against Megrahi.[31][32]
  3. Mebo's owner, Edwin Bollier, claimed that in 1991 the FBI offered him $4 million to testify that the timer fragment found near the scene of the crash was part of a Mebo MST-13 timer supplied to Libya.[33]
  4. Former employee of Mebo, Ulrich Lumpert, swore an affidavit in July 2007 that he had stolen a prototype MST-13 timer in 1989, and had handed it over to "a person officially investigating the Lockerbie case".[34]

On 1 November 2007 Megrahi invited Professor Robert Black QC to visit him at Her Majesty's Prison, Greenock. After a 2-hour meeting, Black stated "that not only was there a wrongful conviction, but the victim of it was an innocent man. Lawyers, and I hope others, will appreciate this distinction."[35]

Prior to Megrahi's second appeal, another four procedural hearings took place at the High Court of Appeal in Edinburgh between December 2007 and June 2008.[36][37]

In the June 2008 edition of the Scottish lawyers' magazine The Firm, the UN Observer at the Lockerbie trial, Professor Hans Köchler, referred to the 'totalitarian' nature of Megrahi's second appeal process saying it "bears the hallmarks of an 'intelligence operation'."[38][39] Pointing out an error on the Foreign and Commonwealth Office's website (FCO) and accusing the British government of "delaying tactics" in relation to Megrahi's second Lockerbie appeal, UN Observer at the Lockerbie trial Dr Hans Köchler wrote to Foreign Secretary David Miliband on 21 July 2008 saying:[40]

As international observer, appointed by the United Nations, at the Scottish Court in the Netherlands I am also concerned about the Public Interest Immunity (PII) certificate which has been issued by you in connection with the new Appeal of the convicted Libyan national. Withholding of evidence from the Defence was one of the reasons why the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission has referred Mr. Al-Megrahi's case back to the High Court of Justiciary. The Appeal cannot go ahead if the Government of the United Kingdom, through the PII certificate issued by you, denies the Defence the right (also guaranteed under the European Convention on Human Rights) to have access to a document which is in the possession of the Prosecution. How can there be equality of arms in such a situation? How can the independence of the judiciary be upheld if the executive power interferes into the appeal process in such a way?

The FCO corrected the error on its website and wrote to Köchler on 27 August 2008:[41]

"Ultimately, it will be for the Court to decide whether the material should be disclosed, not the Foreign Secretary."

On 15 October 2008, five Scottish judges decided unanimously to reject a submission by the Crown Office to the effect that the scope of Megrahi's second appeal should be limited to the specific grounds of appeal that were identified by the SCCRC in June 2007.[42]

In January 2009, it was reported that, although Megrahi's second appeal against conviction was scheduled to begin on 27 April 2009, the hearing could last as long as 12 months because of the complexity of the case and volume of material to be examined.[43] At a preliminary High Court hearing in Edinburgh on 20 February 2009, Megrahi's Counsel, Maggie Scott QC, was informed that a delegation from the Crown Office was due to travel to Malta to "actively seek the consent for disclosure" of sensitive documents that could determine the outcome of the second appeal.[44]

Scottish ministers denied in April 2009 they had clandestinely agreed to the repatriation of Megrahi before the start of his second appeal on 28 April.[45]

Call for Megrahi's release

The first official call for the release of Megrahi was made by Moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland the Rt Rev Professor Iain Torrance. In July 2003 he petitioned British Prime Minster Tony Blair to consider his release in view of the widespread unease in Scotland concerning the safety of the verdict. The year before, the Kirk’s leading scientist, Dr John Cameron, had written a report criticising the technical evidence presented at the trial in The Hague. Nelson Mandela had also asked for the intervention of the Western Christian churches in what he described as a clear miscarriage of justice.

On 14 September 2008, the Arab League Ministerial Council passed a resolution calling for the 'political hostage' Megrahi to be released from prison in Scotland. The resolution demanded that the UK government should hand to Megrahi's lawyers the documents which the SCCRC had identified, adding that Britain's refusal to do so represented a 'miscarriage of justice'. The Arab League also endorsed Libya's right to compensation for the damage done to its economy by UN sanctions which were in force from 1991 until 1999.[46]

On 6 November 2008, three Criminal Appeal Court judges reserved judgment on an application by defence counsel Maggie Scott for Megrahi to be released on bail pending his second appeal against conviction which was expected to be heard in 2009.[47] A week later, Megrahi's bail application was refused.[48]

On the Lockerbie bombing's 20th anniversary, The Independent newspaper published an opinion piece by award-winning journalist and author, Hugh Miles, repeating questions around Megrahi's guilt, writing in part,

Since the Crown never had much of a case against Megrahi, it was no surprise when the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission (SCCRC) found prima facie evidence in June 2007 that Megrahi had suffered a miscarriage of justice and recommended that he be granted a second appeal. If Megrahi didn't do it, who did? Some time ago suspicion fell on a gang headed by a convicted Palestinian terrorist named Abu Talb and a Jordanian triple agent named Marwan Abdel Razzaq Khreesat. Both were Iranian agents; Khreesat was also on the CIA payroll. Abu Talb was given lifelong immunity from prosecution in exchange for his evidence at the Lockerbie trial; Marwan Khreesat was released for lack of evidence by German police even though a barometric timer of the type used to detonate the bomb on Pan Am Flight 103 was found in his car when he was arrested.[49]

On 14 August 2009, Megrahi withdrew his appeal. South of Scotland SNP MSP Christine Grahame said, "There are a number of vested interests who have been deeply opposed to this appeal continuing as they know it would go a considerable way towards exposing the truth behind Lockerbie.... In the next days, weeks and months new information will be placed in the public domain that will make it clear that Mr Megrahi had nothing to do with the bombing of Pan Am 103."[50] Tam Dalyell, the former Labour MP for West Lothian has long believed Megrahi is the victim of a catastrophic miscarriage of justice, and has publicly stated that Megrahi is merely a scapegoat.[51] Dalyell was supported by Nelson Mandela,[52][53] the Church of Scotland, the Catholic Church, the law faculties of the Scottish universities, the representatives of British relatives and the UN's official observer at the notorious trial in The Hague.[citation needed]

Family and health

Megrahi has been married to Aisha since the 1980s. They have five children: four sons and one married daughter.[54]

On 19 September 2008, armed police escorted Megrahi from prison in Greenock to Inverclyde Royal Hospital, where he was expected to undergo medical treatment.[55] On 23 September 2008, Megrahi was diagnosed with advanced prostate cancer, prompting calls for his second appeal to be heard promptly.[56]

On 4 December 2008, Megrahi's family joined others protesting against alleged miscarriages of justice within the Scottish justice system.[57]

An online petition to the Scottish Ministers seeking Megrahi's compassionate release was raised on 19 December 2008. It stated that he was terminally ill and would benefit physically and psychologically from compassionate release to his temporary home in Glasgow while he awaited the outcome of the appeal granted to him by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission in June 2007. Since it was likely to be many months before such an appeal was finally decided, the Petition asked that Megrahi be allowed to spend his "very limited" remaining time in Scotland with his family and loved ones.[58][59]

Wikinews has related news:

Release

Main article: Release of Abdelbaset al-Megrahi

On 4 August 2009, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice in Scotland, Kenny MacAskill, visited Greenock Prison to hear Megrahi's request for a prisoner transfer to Libya.[60][61] The following week it was reported that Megrahi was likely to be released within a few days on compassionate grounds due to terminal prostate cancer, although the Scottish Government dismissed this as "complete speculation".[62] Furthermore, a United States official said that the US had no information suggesting Megrahi would be released and that he should serve out his sentence.[63] MacAskill faced international pressure from politicians in the United Kingdom and United States, US victims’ groups and Syracuse University (which lost 25 students in the Lockerbie bombing), all urging him not to release Megrahi.[64]

On 14 August, lawyers representing Megrahi announced that he had applied to the High Court in Edinburgh two days previously to withdraw his second appeal, and that his condition had "taken a significant turn for the worse".[65] On 19 August 2009, it was divulged that MacAskill had reached a decision on the bomber's fate to be announced the following day.[66] The following day, MacAskill granted his release on compassionate grounds, stating that Megrahi was in the final stages of terminal prostate cancer and expected to die within three months.[67] Speaking of the Scottish tradition of justice with compassion and mercy, MacAskill said he was "bound by Scottish values to release him", and allow him to die in his home country of Libya.[68]

Immediately following the announcement, Megrahi, who had served just over 8½ years of his life sentence,[68] was escorted by Strathclyde Police to Glasgow Airport where he boarded a specially chartered Afriqiyah Airways Airbus for Tripoli.[69] Megrahi arrived back in time to join celebrations to mark 40 years since the country's revolution.[70]

Megrahi landed in Libya to national celebrations and acclaim.[71] As he left the plane, a crowd of several hundred young people were gathered at Tripoli Airport to welcome him, some waving Libyan or Scottish flags, others throwing flower petals. Many had been ushered away by Libyan officials in an attempt to play down the arrival in accordance with British and US wishes.[72] Megrahi was accompanied by Saif al-Islam al-Gaddafi, son of Libyan leader Muammar al-Gaddafi, who was dressed in a traditional white robe and golden embroidered vest. It was he who had pledged in 2008 to bring al-Megrahi home, and so he raised his arm in victorious salute to the crowd.[73] Megrahi was then joined on the aircraft steps by Lamin Khalifah Fhimah, dressed smartly in a white boubou with a tan waistcoat and waving a small Libyan flag at the gathered crowd. This was the first time the pair had met since they had stood side by side during their eight-month trial at Camp Zeist, in the Netherlands 8½ years earlier.[74]

After he left the aircraft, Megrahi was driven away in convoy for a long-awaited meeting with his 86-year-old mother, Hajja Fatma Ali al-Araibi, who a few days earlier had pled emotionally with Scottish Ministers to release her son. Hajja had not been told of her son's terminal cancer for fear that the shock would be too much for her.[75]

Megrahi also met Libyan leader Muammar al-Gaddafi. The reception was shown afterwards on Libyan state television.[76][77]

In an interview the following day with The Times, Megrahi vowed to present new evidence before he died which would exonerate him of any involvement in the 1988 Lockerbie bombing. He stated, "If there is justice in the UK I would be acquitted or the verdict would be quashed because it was unsafe. There was a miscarriage of justice ... my message to the British and Scottish communities is that I will put out the evidence and ask them to be the jury".[78] Megrahi was taken to a hospital in Tripoli because of his terminal cancer, and a video of him in the hospital showed him using an oxygen mask to breathe. On 2 September 2009, it was reported that his terminal cancer worsened, and that he had been transferred to the Intensive Care Unit. Libyan Foreign Ministry spokesman Mohammed Seyala claimed that Megrahi had been moved to a special VIP wing of the hospital and was receiving full treatment from a team of doctors, and that his condition was not dangerous. Megrahi's family claimed that they had been informed that he had been taken to the Intensive Care Unit, but they were not allowed to visit him. The Foreign Ministry confirmed that his family was not allowed to visit him, but said that it was to ensure his safety.[79]

In May 2010, a sister of one of the victims expressed her desire to visit and forgive him, saying "I want to look him in the eye and make sure he knows our pain... God will judge him". She said the decision to release him was "more than we could ever expect from Libya if the tables were turned."[80]

Megrahi is now living with his family in the New Damascus district in west Tripoli, in a villa reportedly built or bought for him, shortly before his release, by the Libyan government.[81][82][83][84] Under police protection, he has secretly resumed hospital chemotherapy sessions in a top medical centre to which he is making regular trips.[84][85]

On 28 August 2009, The Herald published an interview conducted with Colonel Gaddafi's son, Saif al-Islam al-Qaddafi, in which he stated that Megrahi's release was not tied to any oil deals but was an entirely separate issue. Referring to the Prisoner Transfer Agreement (PTA), he continued, "People should not get angry because we were talking about commerce or oil. We signed an oil deal at the same time. The commerce and politics and deals were all with the PTA. This was one animal and the other was the compassionate release. They are two completely different animals."[86]

On 30 August an article published in the Sunday Times claimed ministers at Westminster had agreed not to specifically exclude al-Megrahi from an agreement concerning prisoner transfers in 2007 because of "overwhelming national interests".[87][88] In a letter dated 19 December 2007, Minister for Justice Jack Straw wrote to his Scottish counterpart, "I had previously accepted the importance of the al-Megrahi issue to Scotland and said I would try to get an exclusion for him on the face of the agreement. I have not been able to secure an explicit exclusion. The wider negotiations with the Libyans are reaching a critical stage and, in view of the overwhelming interests for the UK, I have agreed that in this instance the [PTA] should be in the standard form and not mention any individual."[89] Straw is quoted as stating that an application under the prisoner transfer agreement was turned down.[88] Mr Straw denied that the release was part of any deal, while Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond reiterated that the release had been granted on compassionate grounds and not as part of any deal struck by the British Government.[89]

On 16 July 2010, four United States senators made public their concerns over the release, stating they believed that the oil company BP pushed for his release to secure a deal with Libya. BP confirmed that it did press for a Prisoner Transfer Agreement as it was aware that a delay might have "negative consequences" for UK commercial interests. However the firm said it was not involved in any discussions regarding Megrahi's release. A spokesmen for the Scottish Government insisted that they acted alone stating: "The Scottish government had no contact from BP in relation to Mr Al-Megrahi." Further hearings examining Megrahi's release due to be held at Capitol Hill on 29 July, were postponed when the US Dept of Justice and Scottish and British witnesses refused to attend and were rescheduled for September the same year, before the senatorial elections.[90]

US position on release

While Obama expressed surprise at the decision, stating "I think all of us here in the United States were surprised, disappointed and angry about the release",[91][92] the US government was aware that a release was possible. The deputy head of the US embassy in London, Frank LeBaron, wrote in a letter to the Scottish first minister Alex Salmond that the US believed al-Megrahi should remain in prison for his role in downing Pan Am flight 103 in 1988, and continued: "Nevertheless, if Scottish authorities come to the conclusion that Megrahi must be released from Scottish custody, the US position is that conditional release on compassionate grounds would be a far preferable alternative to prisoner transfer, which we strongly oppose."[93][94] This same letter stressed the importance to America of a 3-months prognosis, despite it not being a legal requirement in Scotland: "any such release should only come after the results of independent and comprehensive medical exams clearly establishing that Megrahi's life expectancy is less than three months".[95]

Medical condition

Following the release, doubts were expressed whether Megrahi was as ill as claimed by MacAskill in his statement to the Scottish Parliament. The guidance on compassionate release of a terminally ill prisoner under Scottish law specifies that death must be likely to occur "soon"; there is no fixed time limit but a life expectancy of three months is suggested as "appropriate".[96] The Labour MSP for Mid Scotland and Fife and a Minister in the previous Labour administration, Dr. Richard Simpson, accused the Scottish justice minister of failing to conduct sufficient checks before deciding to release Megrahi.[97] Dr. Simpson, a former member of the British Association of Urological Surgeons' prostate cancer working group who specialised in prostate disease research, expressed doubt that Megrahi would die within the next three months and claimed that Megrahi could live for eight months. He then went on to say that, "Kenny MacAskill released him apparently on the advice of just one doctor whose status is not clear and who is not named." He added that a second specialist opinion in palliative care should have been sought before the release.[98][99] A source close to the justice secretary called Simpson's comments "tasteless" and added: "I really don't think we should be speculating on the day somebody is going to die."[100]

On 27 August 2009, The Scotsman, quoting an anonymous Scottish Government source, reported that MacAskill ignored the advice of four specialists who were unwilling to speculate on Megrahi's anticipated lifespan.[101] In response, a spokesman for the Scottish Government stated, "The latest assessment of his condition was conducted by the Scottish Prison Service primary care physician treating Mr al-Megrahi, in close consultation with a highly experienced NHS consultant oncologist of many years experience - both of whom have dealt with Mr al-Megrahi's case since the earliest stages following the diagnosis of metastatic prostate cancer".[102]

Reviewing the case, members of Holyrood's justice committee stated that Scottish Prison Service guidelines were not followed in the decision to release Megrahi, that the medical evidence presented was flimsy, and that four cancer specialists had refused to back up the opinion of the prison doctor that Megrahi would be dead within 3 months.[103] However the prison doctors and numerous experts[who?] brought in had stated that al-Megrahi met the Scottish standards for release.[citation needed] The release of prisoners on compassionate grounds is up to the Minister of Justice and not to a committee.

Soon afterwards, Libyan media reported that Megrahi was able to talk to his mother by telephone from his hospital bed and The Times, at the beginning of November, suggested that his condition had not deteriorated significantly.[104]

In early April 2010 it was reported that his cancer was no longer responding to treatment. The cancer consultant Karol Sikora, who had originally supported the three months prognosis (although his evidence was not allowed to contribute to the release decision as he was paid by the Libyan authorities), reported that Megrahi was bed-bound and had probably no more than four weeks to live, with his earlier apparent recovery probably due to his being with his family. The Libyan Consul General in Glasgow also reported that his condition had rapidly deteriorated.[105][106] In July 2010 Dr Sikora told The Daily Telegraph, "There was always a chance he could live for 10 years, 20 years ... but that would be unusual". He also stated that "It was clear that three months was what they (the Libyan government) were aiming for" adding that "On the balance of probabilities, he felt he could sort of justify that."[106]

In a July 2010 interview with Scottish Television [107] he said that his statements were misquoted extensively by dropping his qualification that 10 years survival "would be unusual". He stated that the chances of such a long survival would be less than 1% but there was a 90% likelihood that he would be dead in a matter of weeks. UPI was still reporting the other version in August 2010.[108]

In June 2010, an attempt to have his medical condition made public was rejected by the Scottish Information Commissioner Kevin Dunion.[109] In response to a similar request from Scottish Tories in July, First Minister Alex Salmond was quoted as saying "You can only take a decision based on information at the time. It's not unheard of for people who have been released on compassionate grounds to live longer than the three months specified.".[110] He also compared him to one of Britain's most famous prisoners, Ronald Biggs[111] who was outliving al-Megrahi while on compassionate release.

As of February 2011, almost two and a half years after the diagnosis of terminal prostate cancer was made in September 2008,[112] al-Megrahi still remains alive. The local Libyan media outlets have reported he has been released from the hospital and is living at his family's villa.[113][114]

Appeals dossier released

On 18 September 2009 Megrahi released a 300 page dossier of evidence that challenges the prosecution case against him, and that he believes would have secured his release on appeal.[115] The release of the evidence dossier was condemned by Lord Advocate Elish Angiolini, who said that Megrahi had abandoned his appeal before his release on compassionate grounds.[116]

Wikileaks on Megrahi

Main article: United States diplomatic cables leak

Cable 08LONDON2673 (dated 2008-10-24) from US Embassy London reports: MEGRAHI was first diagnosed on September 23 at Inverclyde Royal Hospital, both the FCO and the Scottish Crown office have told us; the second diagnosis was on October 10. The two diagnoses match: he has prostate cancer that has spread to his bones, the cancer has advanced rapidly, and it is inoperable and incurable. MEGRAHI could have as long as five years to live, but the average life expectancy of someone of his age with his condition is eighteen months to two years. [117]

Cable 09TRIPOLI65 (dated 2009-01-28) from US Embassy Tripoli reports: the case of convicted Pan Am 103 bomber Abdelbasset al-Megrahi is arguably the regime’s most sensitive political subject, in part because it involves a firm timeline in the form of the ailing el-Megrahi’s approaching death. Through remarks by senior officials suggesting that al-Megrahi is innocent and a steady diet of publicity about his case, the regime has limited its room for political maneuver. U.K. Embassy interlocutors here are planning for a scenario in which the U.K.-Libya Prisoner Transfer Agreement is ratified in early March and the GOL makes application shortly thereafter for al-Megrahi’s transfer to Libya. The U.K. Embassy expects a sharply negative GOL reaction if al-Megrahi dies in prison or if the Scottish Executive and/or FCO oppose his transfer.[118]

Another stated that the UK feared action by Libya against British interests if Megrahi died in jail. It also stated that the UK government fully supported his release by the Scots.[119]

See also

{{{inline}}}

References

  1. ^ Jason Allardyce (20 September 2009). "Legal doubt over Megrahi's guilt". Sunday Times. London. Retrieved 21 September 2009.
  2. ^ "Pan Am 103 - Lockerbie verdict". Terrorismcentral.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  3. ^ "Progress record" (PDF). Times Online. London. Retrieved 27 January 2010. The clinical assessment, therefore, is that a 3 month prognosis is now a reasonable estimate for this patient.
  4. ^ Sonne, Paul (13 January 2010). "Lockerbie Release Is Defended". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 16 January 2010.
  5. ^ Barrett, David; Mendick, Robert (2 January 2010). "Relatives of Lockerbie victims begin new legal fight for public inquiry". London: The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 16 January 2010.
  6. ^ Adams, Lucy (22 December 2009). "Lockerbie families sign up leading lawyer in bid for public inquiry". The Herald. Retrieved 16 January 2010.
  7. ^ Ali Aujali (2 September 2009). "Why Libya Welcomed Megrahi". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 23 November 2009.
  8. ^ http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/politics/government-admits-megrahi-always-had-50-50-chance-of-living-past-three-months-1.1064925
  9. ^ http://www.kentnews.co.uk/p_12/Article/a_10530/MP_demands_inquiry_into_release_of_Lockerbie_bomber_al-Megrahi
  10. ^ Aitken, Mark (Jan 9 2011). "Birmingham Six campaigner questions guilt of Lockerbie bomber". Daily Record (Scotland). Retrieved 21 January 2011. {{cite news}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  11. ^ a b Cramb, Auslan (20 August 2009). "Lockerbie bomber: Abdelbaset al-Megrahi - a profile". London: Telegraph.co.uk. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  12. ^ "Profile: Abdel Basset al-Megrahi". English.aljazeera.net. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  13. ^ "Lockerbie trial Judges". Terrorismcentral.com. 31 January 2001. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  14. ^ "Full charges, and names of 270 victims". BBC News. 11 January 2001. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  15. ^ Carrell, Severin (3 October 2007). "Fresh doubts on Lockerbie conviction". London: The Guardian.
  16. ^ Pressure grows for explanation in Lockerbie witness dispute
  17. ^ "Lockerbie trial verdict" (PDF). Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  18. ^ "Fhimah was found "not guilty"". I-p-o.org. 31 January 2001. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  19. ^ Gunn, David. "Lockerbie bomber Al Megrahi treated for 'advanced cancer' - The Scotsman". Thescotsman.scotsman.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  20. ^ "Lockerbie Appeal Judgment". Terrorismcentral.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  21. ^ "UN monitor decries Lockerbie judgment". BBC News. 14 March 2002. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  22. ^ "Statement by Dr Hans Köchler, international observer at the Lockerbie trial". I-p-o.org. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  23. ^ Kirsty Scott (1 June 2004). "Leave to appeal against sentence". London: Guardian. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  24. ^ Robertson, John. "July 2006 hearing postponed". News.scotsman.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  25. ^ "Appeal can be held in Edinburgh". News.scotsman.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  26. ^ "SCCRC ruling by the end of June 2007". Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  27. ^ "PM says no deal over Megrahi". News.scotsman.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  28. ^ Mark Townsend and David Smith (25 June 2007). "Evidence that casts doubt on who brought down Flight 103". London: Observer.guardian.co.uk. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  29. ^ "SCCRC referral of Megrahi case". Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  30. ^ 'Secret' Lockerbie report claim BBC News 2 October 2007
  31. ^ Fresh doubts on Lockerbie conviction The Guardian 3 October 2007
  32. ^ US paid reward to Lockerbie witness, Abdelbaset al-Megrahi papers claim The Guardian 2 October 2009
  33. ^ "Lockerbie trial: an intelligence operation? New revelation about financial offer to key witness from Switzerland". I-p-o.org. 5 October 2007. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  34. ^ Alex Duval Smith, Europe correspondent (2 September 2007). "Vital Lockerbie evidence 'was tampered with'". London: Observer.guardian.co.uk. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  35. ^ "Robert Black meets Mr al-Megrahi in jail". Lockerbiecase.blogspot.com. 1 November 2007. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  36. ^ "Major appeal cases back in court". BBC News. 14 December 2007. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  37. ^ "Concern at Lockerbie lawyer claim". BBC News. 22 May 2008. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  38. ^ "UN Observer to the Lockerbie Trial says 'totalitarian' appeal process bears the hallmarks of an "intelligence operation"". Thefirmmagazine.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  39. ^ Lockerbie bomber hearing 'flawed'
  40. ^ ""Lockerbie Appeal : Making Haste Slowly", ''Mathaba Net News'', 23 July 2008". Mathaba.net. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  41. ^ "FCO reply dated 27 August 2008". Retrieved 2 September 2008.
  42. ^ "Judgment on the scope of Megrahi's second appeal". Scotcourts.gov.uk. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  43. ^ Lucy Adams (15 January 2009). "Secret talks on deal to return Megrahi to Libya". Glasgow Herald. Retrieved 15 January 2009. [dead link]
  44. ^ David Lindsay (23 February 2009). "Lockerbie investigators to travel to Malta to seek new evidence". The Malta Independent Online.
  45. ^ Hamish Macdonell (19 April 2009). "Ministers deny that Lockerbie bomber will be moved to Libya". Scotland on Sunday. Retrieved 20 April 2009.
  46. ^ "Arab League Ministerial Council Re New Call for Al Megrahi Release". The Tripoli Post. 14 September 2008. Retrieved 14 September 2008.
  47. ^ "Lockerbie bomber 'should go free'". BBC News. 6 November 2008. Retrieved 6 November 2008.
  48. ^ "Lockerbie bomber bail bid fails". BBC News. 14 November 2008. Retrieved 14 November 2008.
  49. ^ Hugh Miles (21 December 2008). "Lockerbie: was it Iran? Syria? All I know is, it wasn't the man in prison". The Independent. London. Retrieved 31 December 2008.
  50. ^ "Lockerbie bomber withdraws appeal". BBC News. 14 August 2009.
  51. ^ Tam Dalyell (31 October 2008). "The Megrahi I know". London: The Times.
  52. ^ "Mandela calls for Lockerbie bomber appeal". Daily Mail. Retrieved 6 November 2010.
  53. ^ "Mandela takes up bomber's case". BBC. 10 June 2002. Retrieved 6 November 2010.
  54. ^ "Megrahi's daughter: I want to be a lawyer to help people like my dad". The Glasgow Herald. 10 December 2008. Retrieved 15 December 2008.
  55. ^ "Operation Megrahi". The Scottish Sun. 19 September 2008. Retrieved 19 September 2008.
  56. ^ "Lockerbie bomber in cancer battle". BBC News. 21 October 2008. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  57. ^ "Aisha, Khaleb and Ghada on protest march in Edinburgh". En.wikinews.org. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  58. ^ "Online petition for Megrahi's compassionate release". The Firm. 19 December 2008. Retrieved 18 January 2009.
  59. ^ "Letter of Petition to the Scottish Ministers". Justice for Megrahi. Retrieved 20 December 2008.
  60. ^ Alderson, Reevel (4 August 2009). "Minister visits Lockerbie bomber". BBC News. Retrieved 13 August 2009.
  61. ^ "'Regrettable actions' over bomber". BBC News. 20 August 2009. Retrieved 20 August 2009.
  62. ^ "Lockerbie bomber 'to be released'". BBC News. 13 August 2009. Retrieved 13 August 2009.
  63. ^ "US stands against bomber release". BBC News. 13 August 2009. Retrieved 13 August 2009.
  64. ^ Hines, Nico (14 August 2009). "Bomber Al-Megrahi drops Lockerbie appeal as release moves closer". London: Times Online. Retrieved 14 August 2009.
  65. ^ "Lockerbie bomber withdraws appeal". BBC News. 14 August 2009. Retrieved 14 August 2009.
  66. ^ "Decision reached on bomber's fate". BBC News. 19 August 2009. Retrieved 19 August 2009.
  67. ^ "Lockerbie bomber Abdelbaset Al Megrahi released from jail on compassionate grounds". Retrieved 20 August 2009.
  68. ^ a b "AP Top News at 8:54 am EDT — Google News". Retrieved 20 August 2009.
  69. ^ "Megrahi walks up the steps to freedom". Retrieved 20 August 2009. [dead link]
  70. ^ "Lockerbie bomber's possible release offers new undercurrent to Libya's revolution celebration". KTLA. Retrieved 21 August 2009. [dead link]
  71. ^ Foreign, Our (20 August 2009). "Lockerbie bomber returns to hero's welcome and Scottish flag waving in Libya". London: Telegraph. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  72. ^ Associated Press, Tripoli (21 August 2009). "Libya plays down return of Lockerbie bomber". London: Guardian. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  73. ^ [1][dead link]
  74. ^ Barnes, Eddie. "The familiar man who helped Megrahi from the plane - Scotsman.com News". News.scotsman.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  75. ^ Gardner, Claire. "Megrahi's mother makes plea for release - Scotsman.com News". News.scotsman.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  76. ^ Logged in as click here to log out (22 August 2009). "Lockerbie fury grows as Gaddafi meets bomber Megrahi | UK news | guardian.co.uk". London: Guardian. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  77. ^ "Libya's Gaddafi meets Lockerbie bomber: TV footage". Chinadaily.com.cn. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  78. ^ Fletcher, Martin (21 August 2009). "At home with the Lockerbie bomber". The Times. London.
  79. ^ [2][dead link]
  80. ^ McFadyen, Siobham (2 May 2010). "I'll look at Lockerbie bomber and forgive him". News of the World.
  81. ^ Lee, Adrian (24 July 2010). "Charmed Life Of Lockerbie Killer". Express.co.uk. Retrieved 1 December 2010.
  82. ^ Alderson, Andrew (20 February 2010). "Lockerbie bomber Megrahi living in luxury villa six months after being at 'death's door'". The Telegraph. London. Retrieved 30 July 2010.
  83. ^ Abdulsattar Hatitah (26 August 2009). "Al-Megrahi's Father: If There Was Any Evidence I Would Have Killed Him Myself". Asharq Al-Awsat. Retrieved 16 August 2010.
  84. ^ a b Vivienne Walt (21 July 2010). "BP and the Lockerbie Bomber: Despite Denials, Signs of a Link?". Time. Retrieved 16 August 2010.
  85. ^ "Bomber freed to die is now being given 'miracle cure' drug". The Malta Independent. 14 August 2010. Retrieved 11 August 2010.
  86. ^ "'I think the Scottish Justice Secretary is a great man. Why be so angry about an innocent man who is dying?' - Herald Scotland | News | Home News". Herald Scotland. 28 August 2009. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  87. ^ UngoedThomas, Jon; Allardyce, Jason (30 August 2009). "Secret letters reveal Labour's Libyan deal". The Times. London. Retrieved 30 August 2009.
  88. ^ a b Siddique, Maroon (30 August 2009). "Straw: Megrahi inclusion in Libya prisoner deal was 'in UK interests'". The Observer. London. Retrieved 30 August 2009.
  89. ^ a b "Salmond denies Megrahi trade deal". BBC News. 30 August 2009. Retrieved 30 August 2009.
  90. ^ "US Senators believe BP was behind release". BBC News. 16 July 2010. Retrieved 16 July 2010.
  91. ^ "Surprised, disappointed and angry". Times Union. 21 July 2010. Retrieved 3 August 2010. [dead link]
  92. ^ Winnett, Robert (20 July 2010). "David Cameron orders release of secret Lockerbie bomber documents". London: Telegraph. Retrieved 3 August 2010.
  93. ^ Carrell, Severin (25 July 2010). "Barack Obama faces rising pressure to publish Lockerbie bomber release letter". London: The Guardian. Retrieved 25 July 2010.
  94. ^ "White House backed release of Lockerbie bomber Abdel Baset al-Megrahi". The Australian. 26 July 2010. Retrieved 3 August 2010.
  95. ^ "LeBaron letter". US government. 26 July 2010.
  96. ^ Angus Macleod (28 August 2009). "New row over 'non-expert' cancer diagnosis of Lockerbie bomber al-Megrahi". TIMESONLINE. London: Times Newspapers Ltd. Retrieved 28 August 2009. . . . Scottish Prison Service guidance says that compassionate release from prison "may be considered where a prisoner is suffering from a terminal illness and death is likely to occur soon. There are no fixed time limits but life expectancy of less than three months may be considered an appropriate period". {{cite news}}: Unknown parameter |coauthors= ignored (|author= suggested) (help)
  97. ^ "Lockerbie bomber may live for months yet". Itn.co.uk. 26 August 2009. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  98. ^ Johnson, Simon (25 August 2009). "Lockerbie bomber Megrahi 'may live for many more months'". London: Telegraph. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  99. ^ "Lockerbie bomber Megrahi may live longer, prognosis under cloud". Dailyindia.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  100. ^ Maddox, David. "Medical advice on Libyan bomber 'in doubt' - The Scotsman". Thescotsman.scotsman.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  101. ^ Maddox, David (27 August 2009). "Ordinary prison GP – not cancer expert – told MacAskill bomber had three months to live". The Scotsman. Retrieved 27 August 2009. {{cite news}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help)
  102. ^ Daniel Martin (28 August 2009). "Lockerbie bomber Al Megrahi sent home 'on the advice of just ONE GP' | Mail Online". London: Dailymail.co.uk. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  103. ^ Maddox, David. "Report to slate MacAskill over early release of Megrahi - Scotsman.com News". News.scotsman.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  104. ^ Sweeney, Charlene; Fletcher, Martin (11 November 2009). "Justice Secretary under fire as bomber defies threemonth prognosis". The Times. London.
  105. ^ Maddox, David, "Lockerbie bomber 'will die within a month'" The Scotsman, 5 April 2010
  106. ^ a b Daily Telegraph (4 July 2010) Interview with Karol Sikora
  107. ^ "Lockerbie doctor speaks out over Megrahi comments".
  108. ^ "Megrahi-illness-not-faked-doctors-say".
  109. ^ http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/2010/06/20/bid-to-have-lockerbie-bomber-s-medical-condition-revealed-is-rejected-86908-22346868/
  110. ^ Kilbride, Paul "Release Megrahi Medical Evidence, Tories Demand", Express.co.uk 22 July 2010 [3]
  111. ^ Spillius, Alex (21 July 2010). "David Cameron could still order inquiry into Lockerbie bomber release, say senators". Telegraph. London.
  112. ^ "No update on Lockerbie bomber's health - more than three months after his compassionate release from prison with terminal cancer". The Daily Record. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  113. ^ Yager, Jordy. "Sen. Schumer wants Lockerbie bomber back in Scottish prison". TheHill.com. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  114. ^ "Libya: Lockerbie bomber asked back to jail - The AfricaNews articles of KingsleyKobo". AfricaNews. 20 November 2009. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  115. ^ Sweeney, Charlene (19 September 2009). "Lockerbie bomber Abdul Baset Ali al-Megrahi releases appeal dossier". London: The Times.
  116. ^ "Law chief 'deplores' bomber claim". BBC News. 18 September 2009.
  117. ^ http://cablesearch.org/cable/view.php?id=08LONDON2673
  118. ^ http://cablesearch.org/cable/view.php?id=09TRIPOLI65
  119. ^ http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/dec/07/wikileaks-gaddafi-britain-lockerbie-bomber

Template:BritishTerrorism

Template:Persondata

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Abdelbaset_al-Megrahi&oldid=415098596"