Club Manitou of Harbor Springs

Comment: This needs a LOT of editing for tone. At best this reads like a personal article for a blog or newspaper, but at worst this reads like a fairly promotional version of the club's history. It's just far too casual and this will need a pretty thorough re-write in order to meet the NPOV standards.
I do see where another editor mentioned somethign about a cut/paste, so if this was taken from an official website then this makes it a copyright violation. Tokyogirl79 (｡◕‿◕｡) 10:14, 25 April 2015 (UTC)

Comment: Hello Submitter, it appears that your footnotes have been disrupted, possibly by copy-pasting text without actually copying the code. Please note how on footnotes 1 and 2 I have properly coded the footnotes rather than simply typing a "[1]". While this is not a mandatory fix at the moment, fixing this would help clean up the structure of the article for the next review. Note I have also included a simple 1-sentence introduction, which your article was lacking. Wikipedia articles need to start by getting right to the point, not "building a mood". I've done some basic format fixes, but am waiting on the next person to do a formal review. MatthewVanitas (talk) 18:41, 12 April 2015 (UTC)

1930's

Club Manitou is a summer resort and social club located in Michigan, United States that existed from 1929 until 1953.

Introduction

Northwest northern lower Michigan has been the mid-west's summer playground since the times of the Gilded Age. The Swift's, the Armour's, the Wrigley's, Gambles (Proctor & Gamble), Ford's and Wilson's (GM) all called Harbor Springs-Petoskey their summer resort homes. The 1930's era of northwest lower Michigan was particularly a time of gala summer resort tourism despite the United States being in the throes of a deepening Great Depression. Besides Mackinac Island, the top summer resort town in the area, known as the "Tip of the Mitt," was small village located on Little Traverse Bay, Harbor Springs. Little Traverse Bay in Lake Michigan was a sail boater's paradise. Petoskey, Michigan, located across the bay from Harbor Springs, was the first small northern Lake Michigan town to draw a summer clientele interested in relief from the city heat. Harbor Springs, Michigan soon followed. Mid-western city dwellers also came north for the freedom from the suffering of hay fever and other allergies.[1]

The Manitou

From the late 1870's into the 20th Century's early years, the wealthy mid-westerners from Chicago, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Detroit and St. Louis came north every summer via the many summer railroad passenger trains to Charlevoix, Petoskey, Mackinaw City (Mackinac Island) and Harbor Springs. They also came north via the Great Lakes on passenger steamships such as the "Manitou." The passenger cruise steamer was the source of Harbor Springs, Michigan's famous Club Manitou, which opened July 4th week-end in 1929. It was the dream of Abe Bernstein of Detroit, Michigan. Bernstein was the head of the infamous Purple Gang of southeastern Michigan. He and his operatives controlled the import of illegal whiskey from Canada across the Detroit River into Michigan. From there it went to other mid-western cities such as Cleveland, Chicago, and St. Louis. Bernstein loved to spend his summers in Petoskey and Harbor Springs. While there he saw the tremendous wealth of the summer resorters who loved to drink and loved to gamble.(2)

Naples of the North

By the late 1920's, Harbor Springs was being referred to as, the "Naples of the North." Wealthy mid-westerns would spend their summers at their Harbor Springs-Petoskey cottages, resorts, and hotels. In the winter, the same group would gather in places like Naples, Florida. Many of the wealthy cottages had summer homes in the Harbor Point Association, the Roaring Brook Association, the Wequetonsing Association, the Roaring Brook Association, and other private residential summer enclaves. All had grown up along the Harbor Springs' area's vast Little Traverse Bay-Lake Michigan shoreline. These affluent summer people came north for the July 4 through Labor Day "Summer Season," and they dined and drank first at the Harbor Point Casino, then the Roaring Brook Casino,and after July 4, 1929, the new Club Manitou. The Club built with Abe Bernstein's Purple Gang profits and manages by his one time driver and bodyguard, William "Slim" Al Gerhart.(3)

Prohibition in Michigan's Northland

Michigan instituted a prohibition against the selling of alcoholic spirits in 1917, two years before National Prohibition. That meant that the Purple Gang of Detroit had a head start learning how to thwart the law. The gang, under the Bernstein brothers direction, and Abe Bernstein in particular, developed a network of illegal smuggling methods that kept Detroit, Michigan, Indiana, Ohio and Al Capone's Chicago supplied with illegal booze. When the mid-western wealthy summer resorters came to Harbor Springs for their summer seaason they brought with them their desire for top notch restaurant dining, top-shelf liquors and wines. Also came with them their desire to gamble, and that desire, along with fine dining, was filled by the Club Manitou. Not one advertisement was placed to announce the establishment's opening but, from word of mouth only, it was an instant success. Upstairs fine dining, and downstairs (in the fortified and protected basement)was the finest in "speakeasy" alcohol, slot machines, roulette tables, baccarat and poker tables, along with dancing and entertainment.[4]

Gambling at the Manitou

The Club Manitou, from late June of 1929, until Labor Day of 1953, was the northland's finest summer spot for dance-gaming-drinking and nightly musical entertainment. The all male professional wait staff and chefs were brought to northern Michigan from Club Vatel, New York City. The croupiers were imported from Ballard's Resort in French Lick, Indiana. The wines and liquors were bottlegged in from Windsor, Canada across the Detroit River into Michigan and then trucked north to Harbor Springs. Sometimes the wines and liquors arrived north by boat, via the Great Lakes in speedy motorized boats.[5]

Local authorities looked the other way at the illegal discretions being carried out at the Manitou. It employed several local northern Michigan people and the actual "locals" of the Harbor Springs-Petoskey area were not allowed inside. A strict policy by owner William Al Gerhart of Detroit and Harbor Springs was followed towards local exclusion. The Manitou was strictly for the summer wealthy resorters, and by keeping entrance to the Club restricted, the police authorities of the area stayed on the sidelines. Being on the sidelinie was also reported to be helped by occasional "under the table payments" to the local county sheriff and other legal authorities in the area.[6]

Clubbing in the Northland

The only competition that faced the Purple Gang's manager William Gerhart's (aka "Detroit Slim")for the summer wealthy's attention and money was the Ramona Park Hotel Casino. However, it was soon noticeable to the summer patrons of both places that the From the 1929 summer the Ramona Park Casino was old and out-dated. Besides the lack of the Ramona Park Casino's building physical attraction, the Club Manitou's imported French chefs, male professional waiters, and fine wines-crystal each summer from New York City's Club Vatel. The Manitou soon was the top dining and gambling spot in northern Michigan. However, in 1932, the Ramona Park Hotel sold its Ramona Park Casino building to Toledo, Ohio's Gerald "Jimmy" Hayes. Mr. Hayes was a master at providing fine dining and the types of gambling coveted by the wealthy. Beginning in the summer resort season of 1934, the new Ramona Park Casino was strongly competing for the summer resort trade of northern Michigan.[7]

Gentleman Jimmy Hayes

"Jimmy" Hayes was a well known Ohio gaming operator who had visited the Harbor Springs area on various summer vacations and decided he wanted part of the summer wealthy resorter's money. His newly purchased casino was renovated into the Ramona Club Casino in time for the summer season of 1934. The casino lasted longer than "Jimmy Hayes." On October 4, 1934, while in Detroit to reportedly watch a World Series game between the Chicago Cubs and the Detroit Tigers, Hayes body was found in an alley. He had been shot many times at close range. During the next two summer seasons his wife Lenora ran the Ramona Club but decided to sell to Club Manitou's now owner-manager, William "Slim" Gerhart, after the 1936 season. Gerhart tore down the building and used the lumber to help renovate his newly purchased Harbor Springs bar that was located on the waterfront. Gerhart renamed it "Al's Pier Bar" and it existed until sold to become today's Pier Restaurant in 1968.[8]

Demise of the Manitou

The Club Manitou did so well in the late 1930's and early 1940's that owner Gerhart and wife Jeanne decided to tripled its size in 1945.The new addition, built to the west of the original 1928 log cabin structure, opened in time for the July 4-Labor Day summer season of 1946.It was an immediate success. The dining and dancing portions of the nighclub had been moved into the new addition while the illegal gambling activities (such as roulette, poker, baccarat and chuck-a-luck) remained in the steel door protected basement portion of the old building. By the early 1950's the local authorities were under pressure from the state of Michigan to curb all local gambling in the northern sections the state. After a series of raids by the Michigan State Police, the Michigan Liquor Control Commission decided to removed the Club's license to sell alcohol in the fall of 1953. Without that license, Gerhart decided not to open for the summer 1954 season. The two large structures in rural Harbor Springs, Michigan stayed dormant until June 12, 1962. That is when it reopened under new owners to become the teen and collegiate nightclub named, the CLUB PONYTAIL.[9]

References

1.^Morley, Jan. 'Harbor Springs Historical Commission'. "A Collection of Historical Essays", 12-1981

2.^Rauch, William. 'Recalling Harbor Springs in the Caberet Era.' "Harbor Light News," 11-1981

3.^Wiles, Richard. 'The Infamous Club Manitou'. "Mackinac Journal," 12-2013

4.^Clock, Robert. 'Club Manitou Opened Up as the Stock Club of the North.' "Petoskey News Review", 3-19-1969

5.^Rauch, William. 'Recalling Harbor Springs in the Era of Prohibition and Gambling.' "Harbor Light News", 11-1981

6.^Wiles, Richard. "Clubbing in the Northland-Part 1.' "The Petoskey Public Library Local History File", 1-2014

7.^Bachus, Rich. 'In the 1920's Gambling Rolled in Harbor Springs.' "Traverse City Record Eagle", 11-5-1995

8.^Clock, Robert. 'An Era Ends With Death of Harbor Springs Club Owner.' "Petoskey News Review", 12-17-1987

9.^Wiles, Richard. "Clubbing in the Northland-Part 2.' "Petoskey Public Library Local History File, 1-2014

Further possible references