Mads Gilbert

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 129.177.30.18 (talk) at 08:56, 2 November 2009 (→‎2008–2009 Israel–Gaza conflict: Corrected grammar of first sentence in section (was incomplete sentence)). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Mads Fredrik Gilbert (born June 2, 1947, Porsgrunn) is a Norwegian doctor, solidarity worker and a member of the socialist party Red.[1] He received his PhD at the University of Iowa in Iowa City, Iowa.[2] He is a specialist in anesthesiology and a leader of the emergency medicine department of University Hospital of North Norway, and has been a professor of emergency medicine at the University of Tromsø since 1995.

Gilbert has broad range international experiences, in particular from locations that merge medical and political issues. He has done volunteer work at a kibbutz.[3] Later he became actively involved with solidarity work concerning Palestinians since the 1970s, he has served as a doctor during numerous periods in the Palestinian territories and Lebanon. His efforts have been central to the efforts that have lead the city of Tromsø, since 2001 a twin town of Gaza, to claim to be the city that has sent more health workers to the Palestinian territories than any other the world.[4]

Medical record

Following an accident in January 2000 a woman was trapped for more than an hour in icy waters, head under water, and was pronounced clinically dead, but survived after the efforts of Gilbert and his team.[5] This represented the lowest survived body temperature recorded.[6] Gilbert was awarded Årets nordlending 2000 ("Northern Norwegian of the year, 2000", by the readership of the Tromsø newspaper Nordlys.[7][8][9]

Controversy

Often portrayed by Norwegian media with controversial statements, Gilbert is on record criticizing Médecins Sans Frontières for its failure to take positions in conflicts.[10] A statement made to Dagbladet in the wake of the September 11 attacks was met with strong reactions.[1] His statement to Dagbladet was: "The attack on New York did not come as a surprise with the politics the West has followed the last decades. I am upset by the terrorist attack, but I am at least as upset over the suffering that the US has caused. It is in this context that 5000 dead has to be seen. If the U.S. government has a legitimate right to bomb and kill civilians in Iraq, the oppressed has a moral right to attack the U.S. with the weapons they may create as well. Dead civilians are the same whether they are Americans, Palestinians or Iraqis." When asked if he supported a terrorist attack against the US he answered: "Terror is a poor weapon, but my answer is yes, within the context I have mentioned." [11]

The incident was described by Nordlys editor Hans Kristian Amundsen as "probably the stupidest thing he's ever done", citing it as proof that Gilbert is a "hopeless politician".[1] In an interview with the Norwegian news agency NTB in 2009, Gilbert described his own statements in the aftermath of 9/11 as "unwise and ill-considered", stressing that he is completely against terror against civilians.[12]

On being a doctor as well as a politician, Gilbert has said the two roles are indistinguishable, and that "there is little in medicine that isn't politics".[13]

2008–2009 Israel–Gaza conflict

Gilbert arrived on emergency assignment for the Norwegian Aid Committee (NORWAC) with the surgeon Erik Fosse to support the humanitarian effort at al-Shifa Hospital during the 2008–2009 Israel–Gaza conflict,[14][15][16] a period when foreign journalists were barred from entering the Gaza Strip.[17] As international media reported from outside the conflict zone, Gilbert maintained frequent contact with Norwegian media,[18][19] as well as segments of the world press, including CNN, BBC, ABC and Al Jazeera.[14]

Following a grenade strike to a Gaza City vegetable market on January 3, Gilbert sent an SMS text to his Norwegian and international contacts, with an appeal for all who read it to pass it on.[20][21][22]

From doctor Mads Gilbert in Gaza: Thanks for your support. They bombed the central vegetable market in Gaza city two hours ago. 80 injured, 20 killed. All came here to Shifa. Hades! We wade in death, blood and amputees. Many children. Pregnant woman. I have never experienced anything this horrible. Now we hear tanks. Tell it, pass it on, shout it. Anything. DO SOMETHING! DO MORE! We're living in the history books now, all of us!

— Mads G, 3.1.09 13:50, Gaza, Palestine.[20][21][23]

The ensuing response sparked reports of Gilbert's message on a global scale,[24] and scores of declarations of support to the Norwegian Palestine Committee.[25]

Asked about this incident in an interview with Al Jazeera, Gilbert answered: "...people in Gaza must know that they are not on their own, many people are with them, although we are not there but we are with them and they must not give up, for the people of the free world ponder on your patience and inspire from your strenghth. If you give up then the people behind you will give up..." [26]

On January 5, after 10 days of the Israeli heavy air bombardment on Gaza strip, BBC news reporter in Gaza Rushdi Abu Alouf interviewed Dr. Mads Gilbert on the status inside Gaza's AL-Shifa Hospital. In the interview Dr. Gilbert stated that an large majority of the casualties he had seen were civilians, and that women and children alone made up 25% of the death toll, and 45% of the wounded.[27]

The doctors were "received as heroes" by the Norwegian public, [28] and received praise from several commentators. Among critics were right-wing Norwegian FrP party leader Siv Jensen who described Gilbert as a "local politician from Rødt", criticizing that he has been permitted without censorship to act as a voice of anti-Israel propaganda.[8][29] Melanie Phillips, a columnist for The Spectator and Jennifer Lawinski for Fox News, voiced criticism similar to Siv Jensen's.[30][31]

Jensen's statements have in turn been strongly criticized by Norwegian Minister of Foreign Affairs Jonas Gahr Støre, who called her statements "confused" and said that "It is outrageous that she puts into question the integrity of practitioners, who I am sure treat the wounded and injured as they need it. Gilbert and I could completely disagree on political matters, but not on the matters at hand [treatment of civilian casualties].[32][33]

On January 5, after 10 days of the Israeli heavy air bombardment on Gaza strip, BBC news reporter Rushdi Abu Alouf in Gaza interviewed Dr. Mads Gilbert on the status inside Gaza's AL-Shifa Hospital. In the interview Dr. Gilbert stated that an overwhelming majority of the casualties he had treated were civilians, and women and children alone made up 25% of the death toll, and 45% of the wounded.[27][34]

On January 8, 2009, while in Gaza, Mads Gilbert was in a video which appeared on CNN which showed the brother of a palestionian TV producer dying while Gilbert and another doctor worked to save him. This video became subject to controversy as several pro-Israel bloggers made accusations that the scene was staged. [35] World News and Features, the camera crew's employer, and the producer himself denounced the allegations. CNN also stated on their web site that they stand by the video.[36][37] Two weeks later, the CNN published a video report on their website refuting the bloggers' allegations point by point. Two independent doctors who were showed the video said that they had no doubt that the hospital scene and Gilbert's work was genuine. [35]

Aftermath

In the period that followed Gilbert and Fosse's extraction from Gaza, they continued to be covered in Norwegian and international media. In a special report to the medical journal The Lancet, Gilbert and Fosse described the Gaza situation as a "nightmarish havoc", stating that they had "witnessed the most horrific war injuries in men, women and children of all ages in numbers almost too large to comprehend".[38]

Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Yigal Palmor responded to the Lancet report by criticizing Gilbert for "spreading vicious lies".[38] In statements to Associated Press Palmor claimed, "Dr. Gilbert is notorious for his radical far left opinions and his systematic demonizaton of Israel. He has already accused Israel of almost every nightmarish crime in the book only to ignore the refutation of every one of his allegations", adding, "His stories are worthy of Dante's imagination but have been proved time and again to be far removed from reality. It is a pity that serious members of the medical profession should allow themselves to be dragged into an excessive of mad Mads".[38]

In a response to these statements Gilbert stated: "This is a part of the propaganda war. We are not surprised and take this very calmly. We tell the truth and do not need to lie. If Israel think we are lying, they can just open the borders and let the world's press into Gaza. Then one will soon find out who is lying." [39]

References

  1. ^ a b c Gulseth, Hege Guldal, Dagbladet.no (January 6, 2009). "Mads (61) er stemmen fra Gaza".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) Template:No icon
  2. ^ Deep Journal, (January 30, 2009). Unconventional weapons used in Gaza, says Norwegian surgeon based in Gaza
  3. ^ Arbetaren Zenit, Nr 21/2009, page 9
  4. ^ Tromsø Kommune (June 1, 2001). Ordføreren til Gaza Template:No icon
  5. ^ BBC News, (January 28, 2000). Skier revived from clinical death
  6. ^ The Lancet, Volume 355, Issue 9201, Pages 375 - 376, 29 January 2000. Resuscitation from accidental hypothermia of 13·7°C with circulatory arrest
  7. ^ Nordlys, 23 December 2000, Årets nordlending
  8. ^ a b Mollan, Aud (January 9, 2009). "Livredderen fra helvete". Adresseavisen (in Norwegian). p. 38.
  9. ^ Bøhle, Solveig, NRK.no. "Bryr seg mye og ofte".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) Template:No icon
  10. ^ "Boikotter TV-aksjonen" (in Norwegian). Norwegian News Agency. October 21, 2006.
  11. ^ Sarastuen, Kristian, Dagbladet.no (September 30, 2001). Forsvarer angrepet på USA Template:No icon
  12. ^ "Gilbert angrer på terroruttalelse" (in Norwegian). Nordlys. January 12, 2009.
  13. ^ Duckert, Hege, Dagbladet.no (December 16, 2000). "Uværsdoktoren".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) Template:No icon
  14. ^ a b Rossland, Irene Elisabeth; Garden, Brita, NRK.no (January 5, 2009). "Leger som verdens pressekorps".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) Template:No icon
  15. ^ Shanmugaratnam, Yohan, Klassekampen (January 5, 2009). "De dør mellom hendene på oss".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) Template:No icon
  16. ^ Skrunes, Trond Olav Aftenposten.no (January 4, 2009). - Situasjonen er forferdelig Template:No icon
  17. ^ The Associated Press, International Herald Tribune (January 2, 2009). "Israel maintains ban on journalists entering Gaza".
  18. ^ Klungtveit, Harald S.; Fransson, Line Dagbladet.no (January 4, 2009). - Mange barn og en gravid kvinne blant de skadde Template:No icon
  19. ^ Gundersen, Anja Tho, TV2.no (January 4, 2009). Gilbert: - Vi vasser i blod og død Template:No icon
  20. ^ a b Rodum, Elisabeth, Aftenposten (January 4, 2009). "Angriper sentrum av Gaza by".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) Template:No icon
  21. ^ a b Fondenes, Eivind, TV2.no (January 4, 2009). Tekstmelding fra krigssonen Template:No icon
  22. ^ The Sterile Eye (January 4, 2009). Norwegian doctor in Gaza: - We’re wading in blood
  23. ^ Glesnes, Gjermund, VG.no (January 4, 2009). Sammenligner Gaza med dødsriket Hades Template:No icon
  24. ^ International reporting of SMS text:
  25. ^ Johansen, Bente H.; Lysvold, Susanne, NRK.no (January 5, 2009). Kjedemelding skapte telefonstorm Template:No icon
  26. ^ aljazeera.net, (January 25, 2009)
  27. ^ a b youtube.com BBC Gaza: Mads Gilbert interview in AL-Shifa hospital
  28. ^ unknown DagenMagazinet (January 16, 2009)
  29. ^ Leader, Bergensavisen (January 9, 2009). Både for og mot krig Template:No icon
  30. ^ Lawinski, Jennifer, FOXNews.com (January 8, 2009). High-Profile Doctor in Gaza Called an 'Apologist for Hamas'
  31. ^ Phillips, Melanie, The Spectator (January 6, 2009). The Hamas Broadcasting Corporation (Ctd)
  32. ^ "Refser Jensens Gilbert-kritikk" (in Norwegian). 2009-01-08. Retrieved 2009-01-17.
  33. ^ Johnsen, Alf Bjarne; Johansen, Marianne; Hegvik, Gunn Kari, VG.no (January 9, 2009). Støre: - Legeutspill en skamplett Template:No icon
  34. ^ BBCnews.com (January5, 2009). Casualties rise in Gaza offensive
  35. ^ a b CNN (January 22, 2009)
  36. ^ CNN.com (January 9, 2009). Gaza video genuine, journalists say
  37. ^ youtube.com CNN Gaza: Cameraman captures death of younger brother
  38. ^ a b c Cheng, Maria. AP News (January 14, 2009). Doctors call for halt to Gaza assault
  39. ^ Pettersen, Egil TV2 Nettavisen (January 15, 2009)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Mads_Gilbert&oldid=323440974"