Talk:Stoke sub Hamdon Priory/GA1: Difference between revisions
Seabuckthorn (talk | contribs) →GA review: I'll review it. |
Seabuckthorn (talk | contribs) →GA review: Congratulations! :) |
||
Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
Hi! My review for this article will be here shortly. {{=3|friend}} --<span style="padding:2px;background:#fffff4">[[User:Seabuckthorn|<span style="color:purple;font-size:120%;font-family:Old English Text MT">Seabuckthorn</span>]] [[User talk:Seabuckthorn|<span style="color:darkred">'''♥'''</span>]]</span> 23:12, 26 February 2014 (UTC) |
Hi! My review for this article will be here shortly. {{=3|friend}} --<span style="padding:2px;background:#fffff4">[[User:Seabuckthorn|<span style="color:purple;font-size:120%;font-family:Old English Text MT">Seabuckthorn</span>]] [[User talk:Seabuckthorn|<span style="color:darkred">'''♥'''</span>]]</span> 23:12, 26 February 2014 (UTC) |
||
<big>'''1: Well-written'''</big> |
|||
*'''a.''' Prose is "[[MOS:JARGON|clear]] and [[Wikipedia:Manual of Style|concise]]", without [[Wikipedia:Copyright violations|copyvios]], or spelling and grammar errors: {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
*'''b.''' [[Wikipedia:Manual of Style|MoS]] compliance for [[WP:LEAD|lead]], [[WP:LAYOUT|layout]], [[WP:WTW|words to watch]], [[WP:WAF|fiction]], and [[Wikipedia:Manual of Style (embedded lists)|lists]]: {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
{{cot|reason='''[[WP:LEAD]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} |
|||
'''Check for [[WP:LEAD]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
# Check for ''Correct Structure of Lead Section'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Citations'' ([[WP:LEADCITE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Introductory text'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Provide an accessible overview'' ([[MOS:INTRO]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Relative emphasis'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Opening paragraph'' ([[MOS:BEGIN]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#** Check for ''First sentence'' ([[WP:LEADSENTENCE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#** Check for ''Format of the first sentence'' ([[MOS:BOLDTITLE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#** Check for ''Proper names and titles'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#** Check for ''Abbreviations and synonyms'' ([[MOS:BOLDSYN]]): {{GAList/check|y}} None |
|||
#** Check for ''Foreign language'' ([[MOS:FORLANG]]): {{GAList/check|y}} None |
|||
#** Check for ''Pronunciation'': {{GAList/check|y}} None |
|||
#** Check for ''Contextual links'' ([[MOS:CONTEXTLINK]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#** Check for ''Biographies'': {{GAList/check|y}} NA |
|||
#** Check for ''Organisms'': {{GAList/check|y}} NA |
|||
# Check for ''Biographies of living persons'': {{GAList/check|y}} NA |
|||
# Check for ''Alternative names'' ([[MOS:LEADALT]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Non-English titles'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Usage in first sentence'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Separate section usage'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
# Check for ''Length'' ([[WP:LEADLENGTH]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Clutter'' ([[WP:LEADCLUTTER]]): {{GAList/check|y}} None |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
{{cot|reason='''[[WP:LAYOUT]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}} }} {{done}} |
|||
'''Check for [[WP:LAYOUT]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Body sections'': [[WP:BODY]], [[MOS:BODY]]. {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Headings and sections'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Section templates and summary style'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Paragraphs'' ([[MOS:PARAGRAPHS]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Standard appendices and footers'' ([[MOS:APPENDIX]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Order of sections'' ([[WP:ORDER]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Works or publications'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''See also section'' ([[MOS:SEEALSO]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Notes and references'' ([[WP:FNNR]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Further reading'' ([[WP:FURTHER]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''External links'' ([[WP:LAYOUTEL]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Links to sister projects'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Navigation templates'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Formatting'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Images'' ([[WP:LAYIM]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Links'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Horizontal rule'' ([[WP:LINE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
{{cot|reason='''[[WP:WTW]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
'''Check for [[WP:WTW]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Words that may introduce bias'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Puffery'' ([[WP:PEA]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Contentious labels'' ([[WP:LABEL]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Unsupported attributions'' ([[WP:WEASEL]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Expressions of doubt'' ([[WP:ALLEGED]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Editorializing'' ([[WP:OPED]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Synonyms for said'' ([[WP:SAY]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Expressions that lack precision'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Euphemisms'' ([[WP:EUPHEMISM]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Clichés and idioms'' ([[WP:IDIOM]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Relative time references'' ([[WP:REALTIME]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Neologisms'' ([[WP:PEA]]): {{GAList/check|y}} None |
|||
# Check for ''Offensive material'' ([[WP:F***]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
'''Check for [[WP:MOSFICT]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Real-world perspective'' ([[WP:Real world]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Primary and secondary information'' ([[WP:PASI]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Check for ''Contextual presentation'' ([[MOS:PLOT]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
{{cot|reason='''[[WP:EMBED]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
* Prose is preferred over list ([[WP:PROSE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
* Check for Tables ([[MOS:TABLES]]): {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
<big>'''2: Verifiable with no original research'''</big> |
|||
*'''a.''' Has an [[Wikipedia:LAYOUT#Standard_appendices_and_footers|appropriate reference section]]: {{GAList/check|y}} '''Yes''' |
|||
*'''b.''' Citation to reliable sources [[Wikipedia:Good article criteria/where necessary|where necessary]]: {{GAList/check|y}} '''excellent''' (Thorough check on Google.) |
|||
{{cot|reason='''[[WP:RS]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
'''Check for [[WP:RS]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
Cross-checked with other FAs: [[Chew Valley Lake]], [[Chew Valley]], [[Mendip Hills]], [[Buildings and architecture of Bristol]], [[Chew Stoke]], [[Exmoor]], [[Somerset]], [[Bath, Somerset]], [[River Parrett]], [[Kennet and Avon Canal]] |
|||
# Check for ''the material'' ([[WP:RSVETTING]]): {{GAList/check|y}} ('''not contentious''') {{done}} |
|||
#* Is it contentious?: {{GAList/check|y}} '''No''' |
|||
#* Does the ref indeed support the material?: {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
# Check for ''the author'' ([[WP:RSVETTING]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
#* Who is the author?: {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
#* Does the author have a Wikipedia article?: {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
#* What are the author's academic credentials and professional experience?: {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
#* What else has the author published?: {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
#* Is the author, or this work, cited in other reliable sources? In academic works?: {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
# Check for ''the publication'' ([[WP:RSVETTING]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Self-published sources'' ([[WP:SPS]]): {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
{{cot|reason='''[[WP:MINREF]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
'''Check for inline citations [[WP:MINREF]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Direct quotations'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Likely to be challenged'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Contentious material about living persons'' ([[WP:BLP]]): {{GAList/check|y}} NA |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
*'''c.''' [[Wikipedia:No original research|No original research]]: {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
{{cot|reason='''[[WP:NOR]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''primary sources'' ([[WP:PRIMARY]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''synthesis'' ([[WP:SYN]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''original images'' ([[WP:OI]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
<big>'''3: Broad in its coverage'''</big> |
|||
{{cot|reason='''a. [[Wikipedia:Out of scope|Major aspects]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
Cross-checked with other FAs: [[Chew Valley Lake]], [[Chew Valley]], [[Mendip Hills]], [[Buildings and architecture of Bristol]], [[Chew Stoke]], [[Exmoor]], [[Somerset]], [[Bath, Somerset]], [[River Parrett]], [[Kennet and Avon Canal]] |
|||
# Check for ''Article scope as defined by reliable sources'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
## Check for ''The extent of the subject matter in these RS'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
## Check for ''Out of scope'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
# Check for ''The range of material that belongs in the article'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
## Check for ''All material that is notable is covered'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
## Check for ''All material that is referenced is covered'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
## Check for ''All material that a reader would be likely to agree matches the specified scope is covered'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
## Check for ''The most general scope that summarises essentially all knowledge'': {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
## Check for ''Stay on topic and no wandering off-topic'' ([[WP:OFFTOPIC]]): {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
{{cot|reason='''b. [[WP:LENGTH|Focused]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Readability issues'' ([[WP:LENGTH]]): {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
# Check for ''Article size'' ([[WP:TOO LONG!]]): {{GAList/check|y}} |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
<big>'''4: Neutral'''</big> |
|||
{{cot|reason='''[[WP:NPOV]]:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
'''4.''' Fair representation without bias: {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''POV'' ([[WP:YESPOV]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''naming'' ([[WP:POVNAMING]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''structure'' ([[WP:STRUCTURE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Due and undue weight'' ([[WP:DUE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Balancing aspects'' ([[WP:BALASPS]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Giving "equal validity"'' ([[WP:VALID]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Balance'' ([[WP:YESPOV]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Impartial tone'' ([[WP:IMPARTIAL]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Describing aesthetic opinions'' ([[WP:SUBJECTIVE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Words to watch'' ([[WP:YESPOV]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Attributing and specifying biased statements'' ([[WP:ATTRIBUTEPOV]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Fringe theories and pseudoscience'' ([[WP:PSCI]]): {{GAList/check|y}} None |
|||
# Check for ''Religion'' ([[WP:RNPOV]]): {{GAList/check|y}} None |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
<big>'''5: Stable:'''</big> No [[Wikipedia:Edit warring|edit wars]], etc: {{GAList/check|y}} '''Yes''' |
|||
<big>'''6: Images'''</big> {{done}} (Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license) (Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license) |
|||
{{cot|reason='''Images:''' {{GAList/check|y}}}} {{done}} |
|||
'''6:''' Images are [[Wikipedia:Copyright tags|tagged]] with their [[Wikipedia:Copyright FAQ|copyright status]], and [[Wikipedia:Non-free use rationale guideline|valid fair use rationales]] are provided for [[Wikipedia:Non-free content|non-free content]]: {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''copyright tags'' ([[WP:TAGS]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''copyright status'': {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''non-free content'' ([[WP:NFC]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''valid fair use rationales'' ([[WP:FUR]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
'''6:''' Images are provided if possible and are [[WP:IMAGE RELEVANCE|relevant]] to the topic, and have [[WP:CAP|suitable captions]]: {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''image relevance'' ([[WP:IMAGE RELEVANCE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''Images for the lead'' ([[WP:LEADIMAGE]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
# Check for ''suitable captions'' ([[WP:CAPTION]]): {{GAList/check|y}} {{done}} |
|||
{{cob}} |
|||
As per the above checklist, there are no issues with the article and it’s a GA. Thanks, Rod, very much for your diligence in writing such great articles. {{=3|friend}} |
|||
Promoting the article to GA status. {{=3|congrats}} --<span style="padding:2px;background:#fffff4">[[User:Seabuckthorn|<span style="color:purple;font-size:120%;font-family:Old English Text MT">Seabuckthorn</span>]] [[User talk:Seabuckthorn|<span style="color:darkred">'''♥'''</span>]]</span> 23:35, 27 February 2014 (UTC) |
Revision as of 23:35, 27 February 2014
GA Review
GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Seabuckthorn (talk · contribs) 23:12, 26 February 2014 (UTC)
Nominator: — Rod talk
Hi! My review for this article will be here shortly. --Seabuckthorn ♥ 23:12, 26 February 2014 (UTC)
1: Well-written
- a. Prose is "clear and concise", without copyvios, or spelling and grammar errors:
- b. MoS compliance for lead, layout, words to watch, fiction, and lists:
Check for WP:LEAD:
|
Done
Check for WP:LAYOUT: Done
|
Done
Check for WP:WTW: Done
Check for WP:MOSFICT: Done
|
Done
|
2: Verifiable with no original research
- a. Has an appropriate reference section: Yes
- b. Citation to reliable sources where necessary: excellent (Thorough check on Google.)
Done
Check for WP:RS: Done Cross-checked with other FAs: Chew Valley Lake, Chew Valley, Mendip Hills, Buildings and architecture of Bristol, Chew Stoke, Exmoor, Somerset, Bath, Somerset, River Parrett, Kennet and Avon Canal
|
Done
Check for inline citations WP:MINREF: Done
|
- c. No original research: Done
Done
|
3: Broad in its coverage
a. Major aspects:
|
---|
Done
Cross-checked with other FAs: Chew Valley Lake, Chew Valley, Mendip Hills, Buildings and architecture of Bristol, Chew Stoke, Exmoor, Somerset, Bath, Somerset, River Parrett, Kennet and Avon Canal
|
b. Focused:
|
---|
Done
|
4: Neutral
Done
4. Fair representation without bias: Done
|
5: Stable: No edit wars, etc: Yes
6: Images Done (Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license) (Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license)
Images:
|
---|
Done
6: Images are tagged with their copyright status, and valid fair use rationales are provided for non-free content: Done
6: Images are provided if possible and are relevant to the topic, and have suitable captions: Done
|
As per the above checklist, there are no issues with the article and it’s a GA. Thanks, Rod, very much for your diligence in writing such great articles.
Promoting the article to GA status. --Seabuckthorn ♥ 23:35, 27 February 2014 (UTC)