User talk:Ferahgo the Assassin
The arbitration review of the Race and Intelligence case has now closed and the final decision is viewable at the link above.
The following remedies have been enacted:
- Mathsci (talk · contribs) is admonished for engaging in battlefield conduct
- Ferahgo the Assassin (talk · contribs) and Captain Occam (talk · contribs) are site-banned from Wikipedia for a period of no less than one year. After one year has elapsed, a request may be made for the ban to be lifted. Any such request must address all the circumstances which lead to this ban being imposed and demonstrate an understanding of and intention to refrain from similar actions in the future.
- SightWatcher (talk · contribs) is indefinitely banned from editing and/or discussing the topic of Race and Intelligence on any page of Wikipedia, including user talk pages, or from participating in any discussion concerning the conduct of editors who have worked in the topic. This editor may however within reason participate in dispute resolution and noticeboard discussions if their own conduct has been mentioned.
- TrevelyanL85A2 (talk · contribs) is indefinitely banned from editing and/or discussing the topic of Race and Intelligence on any page of Wikipedia, including user talk pages, or from participating in any discussion concerning the conduct of editors who have worked in the topic. This editor may however within reason participate in dispute resolution and noticeboard discussions if their own conduct has been mentioned.
For the Arbitration Committee,
--Guerillero | My Talk 02:07, 14 May 2012 (UTC)
Arbitration motion regarding Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Race and intelligence/Review
Resolved by motion at Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Clarification and Amendment that:
FoF 2.5 in the Race and intelligence review be amended to read: Mathsci has engaged in borderline personal attacks and frequent battleground conduct.
For the Arbitration Committee,
-- Lord Roem (talk) 06:06, 26 May 2012 (UTC)
Ferahgo the Assassin ban appeal
The Arbitration Committee has, by motion, suspended Ferahgo the Assassin's site-ban on the following terms:
- Suspension of ban
Ferahgo the Assassin's site-ban in the Race and Intelligence case review is suspended subject to her unconditional acceptance of and continuing compliance with the following restrictions, the purpose of which is to enable her to return to active content work. Failure to comply fully with the letter and spirit of the restrictions may result in the committee revoking the suspension without warning and reinstating the indefinite ban.
- Editing restriction
Ferahgo the Assassin is restricted to editing articles about the palaeontology of birds and dinosaurs and editing any talk or process pages reasonably and directly associated with improving the quality of those articles. While some tolerance may be given about interpretation of this editing restriction, no tolerance will be shown for edits about, or to any page relating to, race and intelligence, broadly construed.
- Dispute resolution
Ferahgo the Assassin may not
- initiate any dispute resolution process on the English Wikipedia without first obtaining by email the prior affirmative consent of the Arbitration committee to do so;
- participate in any dispute resolution process on the English Wikipedia without first notifying the Arbitration committee by email about the nature and venue of the dispute.
- Interaction ban
Ferahgo the Assassin is prohibited from commenting directly or indirectly on-wiki about User:Mathsci. If and when Mathsci is unbanned, they will be similarly prohibited from commenting about Ferahgo the Assassin.
- Reconsideration of restrictions
Any future appeal will be limited to reconsideration of these restrictions. No request for reconsideration of these restrictions may be made until at least twelve months have elapsed since the date on which the suspension of the ban comes into effect.
The record of the vote on the motion can be seen here. For the Arbitration Committee, Carcharoth (talk) 03:00, 28 March 2014 (UTC)