Jump to content

John C. Calhoun Monument

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Topher Nunziata (talk | contribs) at 21:12, 27 January 2021. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

John C. Calhoun Monument, June 2020

John Caldwell Calhoun (March 18, 1782 - March 31, 1850) was a statesman and politician from Abbeville, South Carolina. Calhoun served within several positions inside state and federal governments, he is most notably remembered for serving in the vice presidency with John Quincy Adams and Andrew Jackson from 1825 to 1832.[1] Calhoun was known was for his staunch defense of slavery inside the United States. He led the pro-slavery faction inside the Senate, fighting against abolition and wanted to expand slavery westward in the United States. Calhoun's most infamous words in his political career was in defense of slavery. Many southern politicians excused slavery as a "necessary evil", however inside an infamous speech on the Senate floor on February 6, 1837, Calhoun defended slavery as a "positive good".[2] On March 31, 1850, John C. Calhoun died of tuberculosis at the Old Brick Capitol boarding house in Washington D.C.

After John C. Calhoun's death, white Charlestonians wanted to dedicate a monument in his honor. As of June 2020, the monument no longer stands. It was taken down in a unanimous vote by Charleston city council. Over the monument's 120 year plus history, controversy has been present with fundraising, construction, maintenance, and the dismantlement of the John C. Calhoun monument.

The "Ladies' Calhoun Monument Association" & The 1887 John C. Calhoun Statue

Soon after John C. Calhoun's death on March 31, 1850, the "Ladies' Calhoun Monument Association," or otherwise known as the "LCMA", began its campaign to erect a monument to the South Carolina politician.

A constitution was framed and adopted by the association in 1850, proclaiming that their goal was "to aid in the erection, in or near the City of Charleston, of a monument sacred to the memory of John C. Calhoun".[3] However, the campaign did not start off successfully. The association ran into several fundraising issues, such as embezzlement and lack of preparedness.[4] The association in order to pay for the statue held several donor meetings and depended heavily on wealthy Charlestonian philanthropy to reach the appropriate amount.

Over 27 years later in April 1887, the Ladies Calhoun Monument Association celebrated the first erection of the monument.[5] Parades and celebrations were hosted all across the city and LCMA helped unveil the statue to those in attendance. The LCMA described the unveiling ceremony's attendance as "crowded to [Marion Square's] boarders with such an assemblage as is rarely seen anywhere".[3] Soon after the unveiling was made, prayers and joys were shouted for protection over the newly erected Calhoun monument.[3]

The statue did not last longer than two decades. Freedmen and women of Charleston began to damage the statue in protest, soon after, the statue barely resembled anything like John C. Calhoun. This brought the LCMA back to beginning; in terms of setting up new plans to keep the monument out of the public's general reach.

While not being formally mentioned on any portion of the monument, the purpose of this statue was to serve as a reminder to black Charlestonians. According to Mamie Garvin Fields, born in 1888, she later stated that, "I believe white people were talking to us about Jim Crow through that statue."[5] Several other black Charlestonians felt that the statue was a threatening message to them, that even though Calhoun was dead, his spirit still lingers in the streets Charleston, South Carolina.

1887 John C. Calhoun Monument

The 1896 John C. Calhoun Statue

Group of African American women in front of the 1887 John C. Calhoun Monument
1896 John C. Calhoun Monument

The longest-standing version of the statue was dedicated by the LCMA on June 27, 1896, but with little fanfare. There was no mention of the new monument in that day's edition of the Post and Courier, a local newspaper in Charleston. According the "Ladies Calhoun Monument Association", the statue cost nearly $20,000 in 1896, in 2020's economy that equates to nearly over $500,000.[6] The individual who completed the 1896 monument was an Irish-born contractor, Daniel A.J. Sullivan, he is listed as a carpenter by trade and eventually becoming a prominent builder in Charleston, South Carolina after the American Civil War. Sullivan was noticeably active in the local democratic party and later served inside the state legislature.[7] During 1896, it most likely assumed that African American workers constructed the monument.[8] According to data compiled by historian Bernard Powers, African Americans in Charleston consisted as much as 76% of carpenters, 85% of its brick and stonemasons, 90% of draymen, and 87% of its labors.[9]

Throughout the next 120 years, while Charleston, South Carolina, especially Marion Square changed, the monument did not. Over that time span, the John C. Calhoun monument has stood and looked over the city. Some activist groups would, especially in the last two decades, have tried to bring awareness to the monument and how it could be interpreted. Some people called any removal of a statue as "erasing history", while others call it "reshaping a false notion of history".[10] Either way, on June 17, 2015, Charleston experienced a terrorist attack at the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church; and the John C. Calhoun Monument received national attention and the debate over it was reignited.

Final years

Base of the John C. Calhoun Monument, summer of 2020

During the summer of 2020, several monuments and statues depicting "lost cause" rhetoric, or individuals who enslaved Africans, were taken in down in protest across the United States. The John C. Calhoun monument for years served as problematic issue for Charleston. After the Emmanuel Church Shooting in 2015, the monument's purpose was in question by the citizens of Charleston but no compromise was reached. Plans to alter the statue were either ignored, forgotten about, or dismissed.

In 2017, a committee was formed to consider how citizens could interpret the statue. The committee was tasked to create a plaque putting the state in greater historical context. The verbiage of the plaque was never agreed upon and the committee was disbanded.[11]

In 2020, the statue was met with action from local activists and the city council. On June 23, 2020, after a 17-hour battle with the monument's construction, the John C. Calhoun statue was taken down from the 115-foot perch.[12] The current location of the John C. Calhoun bust is at a disclosed location. Some groups have called for the statue to be placed inside a museum. However, the Charleston Museum declined the city's request. As of October 2020, the statue has still not been claimed by any museum or historical society.[5]

See also

References

  1. ^ Ford, Lacy K. (1988). "Republican Ideology in a Slave Society: The Political Economy of John C. Calhoun". The Journal of Southern History. 54 (3): 405–424. doi:10.2307/2208996. JSTOR 2208996.
  2. ^ Vajda, Zoltán (2013). "Complicated Sympathies: John C. Calhoun's Sentimental Union and the South". The South Carolina Historical Magazine. 114 (3): 210–230. ISSN 0038-3082. JSTOR 23645453.
  3. ^ a b c Association, Ladies' Calhoun Monument (1888). A History of the Calhoun Monument at Charleston, S. C. Lucas, Richardson, printers.
  4. ^ Smith, Fleming. "Charleston's Calhoun monument: How a little-known 1850s relative stole its funds". Post and Courier. Retrieved 2020-10-07.
  5. ^ a b c Roberts, Blain; Kytle, Ethan J. (2012). "Looking the Thing in the Face: Slavery, Race, and the Commemorative Landscape in Charleston, South Carolina, 1865–2010". The Journal of Southern History. 78 (3): 639–684. ISSN 0022-4642. JSTOR 23247373.
  6. ^ Brown, Angela (2020-06-23). "Looking back at controversial history of Calhoun monument". WCIV. Retrieved 2020-10-10.
  7. ^ "Charleston's deposed Calhoun monument and the erasure of Black workers". Facing South. 2020-06-26. Retrieved 2020-10-10.
  8. ^ Roberts, Blain; Kytle, Ethan (2018-09-06). "The South Carolina Monument That Symbolizes Clashing Memories of Slavery". What It Means to Be American. Retrieved 2020-10-07.
  9. ^ POWERS, BERNARD E. (2016-05-15). Black Charlestonians. University of Arkansas Press. doi:10.2307/j.ctt1ffjf3k. ISBN 978-1-61075-070-7.
  10. ^ Ellis, Rachel (2020-06-22). "Two groups gather around John C. Calhoun statue to debate fate of monument". WCIV. Retrieved 2020-10-12.
  11. ^ Darlington, Abigail. "Charleston committee to consider new Calhoun statue plaque: 'relic of the crime against humanity'". Post and Courier. Retrieved 2020-10-07.
  12. ^ Hobbs, Stephen. "John C. Calhoun statue taken down from its perch above Charleston's Marion Square". Post and Courier. Retrieved 2020-10-07.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=John_C._Calhoun_Monument&oldid=1003193136"