Creep Catchers
 | The examples and perspective in this article deal primarily with Canada and do not represent a worldwide view of the subject. (July 2020) |
| Formation | 2014 |
|---|---|
| Founders | Unknown |
| Purpose | Prevention of adult-minor sex |
| Location |
|
| Methods | Public exposure of adults who attempt to meet minors for sex |
Official language | English |
| Website | Official website |
Creep Catchers are non-affiliated individuals and groups who attempt to prevent child sexual abuse by posing as minors, using chat rooms and dating sites to lure adults willing to meet the minor for sex, and then exposing the adult by publicly posting videos of the ensuing confrontation.[1] Creep Catchers offer the opportunity to make a public statement (a confession and explanation is encouraged) before posting the video and chat logs to a central website and various social media. Cooperative suspects are typically lectured to in relative privacy, while belligerents or those with particularly explicit conversations are loudly shamed and profanely ridiculed. Public and official reactions to groups of Creep Catchers have been mixed, with some supporting the intent of preventing abuse and others noting dangers of vigilanteism by untrained public. In 2017, Vice.com produced Age of Consent, a full-length documentary film following Toronto resident Justin Payne, an independent Creep Catcher unaffiliated with other groups of the movement.[2]
In posing as underage children to lure and then confront online predators, the modus operandi of the movement bears similarities to Dateline NBC's To Catch a Predator series, but police are not present for the confrontations, which typically happen in public.
History
In July 2014, Justin Payne began publicly exposing adults who thought they were meeting minors willing to engage in sex, operating in Mississauga, Ontario.[1] Dawson Raymond said he felt inspired to do the same in his city of Calgary, Alberta, naming his group "Creep Catchers." Raymond and his partner, Slammington, say they will stop at nothing to keep the children safe when using the Internet.[3][4] As of January 5, 2017, more than 30 Creep Catchers groups have been reported to be operating.[1]
Jonathan Woodward of CTV's W5 documented an investigation into Creep Catchers around the country, featuring Justin Payne, Creep Catchers founder Dawson Raymond, Ryan LaForge of Surrey Creep Catchers and Karl Young (aka Carl Murphy) of the Red Deer Creep Catchers. The documentary focused on the unseen side of Creep Catcher members and operations, including the criminal pasts of some members and questioning the possible financial gains of the various "chapters". The documentary also featured an interview with Edmonton Police Service ICE Detective Dave Dubnick, who tells the story of how a Creep Catchers group in Lloydminster, Alberta, interfered with an ongoing investigation of a child predator, leading to the man escaping surveillance and, months later, being arrested in Manitoba for molesting a toddler and a baby.[5]
Notable confrontations
In June 2016, Penticton Creep Catchers, Mitch Shelswell and Tyler Fritsen, confronted a man who apparently intended to meet a 14-year-old girl. Shelswell told CTV News they had no plans to stop: "As long as we follow the rules given to us by Creep Catchers originally, we're doing everything legally."[6]
On August 15, 2016, Surrey Creep Catchers confronted a Coast Mountain Bus Company employee with evidence that he tried to meet a 14-year-old boy at the Central City Shopping Centre. The man drove off, first striking a parked truck and almost hitting Ryan LaForge, who filmed the encounter. The Surrey RCMP closed its case without charges, and the man's employer began an internal investigation.[7]
In August 2016, a University of British Columbia Student Housing and Hospitality employee, whom court records suggest was charged with four counts of luring a child under 14 in 2008, apologized profusely and tearfully when confronted by Surrey Creep Catchers about trying to meet a 15-year-old girl and sending her (actually LaForge) pictures of his penis.[8]
On September 7, 2016, Surrey Creep Catchers caught an off-duty Surrey RCMP officer who allegedly tried to meet a 14-year-old girl at the Central City Shopping Centre. On September 16, the RCMP announced Constable Dario Devic was charged with communicating with a person under the age of 16 for the purposes of sexual interference or sexual touching, and breach of trust. He was released on bail with orders to avoid children or places children gather.[9]
On October 21, 2016, Fraser Valley Creep Catchers released a video allegedly showing Windebank Elementary School Principal Jason Obert at a mall believing he would meet up with a 14-year-old girl for sex.[10][11]
On April 3, 2017, Surrey Creep Catchers confronted a Langley Official named Bob Andrews, trying to meetup with a 13-year-old girl for sex.[12]
Responses
Some commentators, like John Gormley of Saskatoon's The StarPhoenix, opined that Creep Catchers, while meaning well, create danger for themselves and their suspects, jeopardize official investigations and undermine the rule of law. Other newspapers, like The Now, claim their chapters have public support and encourage police to work with them for their ability to weed out suspects.[13]
In 2016, a social media commentator, Sean Smith, criticized the Creep Catchers movement. He was then called a pedophile by Ryan Laforge, of the Creep Catchers of Surrey, British Columbia. In March, 2017, Smith sued Laforge for defamation.[14] It represented the second such lawsuit against Laforge.[15]
Jason Proctor of CBC News reports that this trend of online pedophile hunters though not new, has been encouraged through success early on, and discouraged by "A chorus of police chiefs", citing an article by Chad Pawson of the CBC.[16][17]
Jon Woodward of CTV's W5 documented his investigation of Creep Catchers, across Canada, looking into the unseen side of the organization. The 3-part episode aired February 18, 2017 and featured Justin Payne, Creep Catchers founder Dawson Raymond, Surrey Creep Catchers President Ryan LaForge and Red Deer Creep Catchers President Karl Young (aka Carl Murphy). The episode explored the criminal records of some Creep Catchers members, looked at the possible unreported revenue generation and interviewed an Edmonton Police Service member of the Integrated Child Exploitation ICE team, regarding the Lloydminster chapters' interference with one of their investigations.[18]
The Creep Catchers movement was strongly criticized in 2017 after it was revealed that one of its targets was a developmentally delayed and mentally challenged 21-year-old, Jaxson Jacoe. The CBC reported that Jacoe joined a dating site after deciding he was ready for his first girlfriend. A Creep Catcher posed as a 19-year-old, engaging Jacoe in chat. In subsequent conversation, the fictitious female said she was actually 14.[19] Jacoe invited the fictitious girl to see where he worked (a hockey rink, where he worked as a score keeper). There were no reports of sexual content in their chats. Douglas Perry of White Rock Creep Catchers and Cody Hunter of Langley Creep Busters confronted Jacoe in front of the rink. Public Safety Minister and Solicitor General Mike Morris referred to the Creep Catchers behavior as "vigilanteism" and "reprehensible." Jaxson Jacoe's father, Pat is joining a complaint to the Information and Privacy Commissioner Office on behalf of his son, who was reportedly highly traumatized by the incident.[19]
See also
References
- ^ a b c Krishnan, Manisha. "The Rise of Creep Catchers, Canada's Vigilante Pedophile Hunters". VICE.
- ^ Vice Staff. (17 Jan 2017). "Behind the Scenes of 'Age of Consent'". VICE.
- ^ "Dawson Raymond poses as young girl on the Internet to lure and confront alleged pedophiles", by Michael Platt, Calgary Sun
- ^ Elliott, Josh (17 August 2016). "'He tried to run me over': Pedophile-targeting vigilante sting goes awry". Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ "W5: Creep Out, part one". CTVNews. Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ Mangione, Kent Molgat and Kendra (1 June 2016). "Another 'Creep Catchers' video prompts RCMP warning to vigilantes". Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ "Man in Creep Catchers video works for Coast Mountain Bus Company". 19 August 2016. Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ "VIDEO: UBC employee caught trying to lure underage girl". 2016-08-22. Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ "RCMP officer charged with child luring". Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ "Former B.C. elementary school principal charged with child luring". Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ "Former school principal charged with luring after Creep Catchers sting". 25 November 2016. Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ "'High-profile' Township of Langley employee allegedly caught in latest Creep Catchers sting".
- ^ OUR VIEW: Surrey's Creep Catcher has struck a chord with community", from The Now
- ^ Krishnan, Manisha (2017-03-17). "Surrey Creep Catchers Are Being Sued Again for Calling One of Their Critics a Pedophile". Vice.com.
- ^ Lamoureux, Mack. "A Vigilante Pedophile Hunter is Being Sued For Defamation". Vice.com.
- ^ "No successful charge has come from vigilante groups, say Surrey RCMP". Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ "Vigilantes' pursuit of 'justice as entertainment' can end in disaster, expert says". Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ Grant, Jon Woodward and Stephen (18 February 2017). "W5's 'Creep Out': Are online pedophile hunters 'catching' the innocent?". Retrieved 2 August 2017.
- ^ a b "Creep Busters ambush of man with mental disability called 'vigilantism'". CBCNews.