Arthur Vivian Watkins
|Arthur Vivian Watkins|
|United States Senator
January 3, 1947 – January 3, 1959
|Preceded by||Abe Murdock|
|Succeeded by||Frank E. Moss|
December 18, 1886|
Midway, Utah Territory
|Died||September 1, 1973
Dorothy Eva Watkins
|Alma mater||Brigham Young University
New York University
Columbia University Law School
|Religion||The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Mormon)|
Arthur Vivian Watkins (December 18, 1886 – September 1, 1973) was a Republican U.S. Senator from Utah between 1947 and 1959. He was influential as a proponent of terminating federal recognition of American Indian tribes. He also chaired the Watkins Committee in 1954, which led to the censure of Joseph McCarthy.
Watkins was born in Midway, Wasatch County, Utah to Arthur Watkins (1864-1959) and Emily Adelia Gerber (1864-1947). He was the eldest of 6 siblings. He attended Brigham Young University (BYU) from 1903 to 1906, and New York University (NYU) from 1909 to 1910. He graduated from Columbia University Law School in 1912, and returned to Utah. There he was admitted to the bar the same year and commenced practice in Vernal, Utah.
He founded and edited a weekly newspaper in Utah County in 1914 called The Voice of Sharon, which eventually became the Orem-Geneva Times. In the same year, Watkins was appointed assistant county attorney of Salt Lake County. From 1919 to 1925, he ran a 600 acre (2.4 km²) ranch near Lehi.
Watkins served as district judge of the Fourth Judicial District of Utah 1928-1933, losing his position in the Roosevelt Democratic landslide in 1932. In the early 1930s, he served as the director of the Provo River Water Users Association and director of the Orem Chamber of Commerce. An unsuccessful candidate for the Republican nomination to the Seventy-fifth Congress in 1936, Watkins was elected as a Republican to the United States Senate in 1946, and reelected in 1952. He served from January 3, 1947, to January 3, 1959.
Watkins was a lifelong member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and took up his missionary call in 1907, going to missions in New York and New Jersey. In 1929, he moved to the Wasatch Front Community near Orem, and was selected to serve as the president upon the creation of Utah's Sharon Stake by the Mormon Church. Watkins held that position until he left to move to Washington, DC as a Senator in 1946. His orthodoxy and faith blurred the lines between civic and religious duties, as can be seen in correspondence to the church general authorities written on 13 April 1954:
|“||The more I go into this Indian problem the more I am convinced that we have made some terrible mistakes in the past. It seems to me that the time has come for us to correct some of these mistakes and help the Indians stand on their own two feet and become a white and delightsome people as the Book of Mormon prophesied they would become. Of course, I realize that the Gospel of Jesus Christ will be the motivating factor, but it is difficult to teach the Gospel when they don’t understand the English language and have had no training in caring for themselves. The Gospel should be a great stimulus and I am longing and praying for the time when the Indians will accept it in overwhelming numbers.||”|
|— - Arthur V. Watkins|
While serving as a missionary in New York, Watkins met Andrea Rich (18 January 1894 - 31 January 1971). They married in Salt Lake City on 18 June 1913 and had 6 children: Nedra Watkins Reese (8 September 1914 - 18 May 2007), Arthur R. Watkins (31 July 1916 - 23 February 2012), Don Rich Watkins (25 June 1918 - 7 July 1945), Martha Watkins, who was born and died as an infant on 10 December 1919, Venna Mae Watkins Lange, (1 May 1921 - 20 December 2012), and Jeanene Watkins Scott (30 June 1929 – 15 May 1995), wife of LDS Apostle Richard G. Scott.
After his first wife's death, on 1 March 1, 1972, Watkins married Dorothy Eva Watkins (18 January 1911 - 17 August 1998) in Salt Lake City. After their marriage, they relocated to Orem.
Weber Basin Project
Planning for the Weber Basin Project began in 1942, but was suspended during the war years. In 1946 with Watkins election to the Senate, increasing demand for municipal water, and need for irrigation of farmlands, he began pushing for a reintroduction of legislation supporting the development plan. Investigations were made in January 1948, leading to a report issued July 1949 recommending creation of a reservoir to store surplus water from the Ogden and Weber rivers that could later be accessed for use on farmland.
On 29 August 1949 Congress authorized the project (63 Stat. 677) which empowered the United States Secretary of the Interior, through the Bureau of Reclamation "to construct, operate, and maintain reservoirs, irrigation and drainage works, power plants, and transmission lines in the area." It authorized that a conservancy organization within the State of Utah could be developed to collect taxes and make the project self-supporting. On 9 July 1952, the first appropriation of construction funds was made. In 1969, to honor Watkins for making the project come to life, the Willard Dam was renamed the Arthur V. Watkins Dam.
Watkins was appointed chair of the Senate Interior Committee Subcommittee on Indian Affairs in 1947, shortly after he was elected to the Senate. Though his Mormon beliefs concerning Native Americans (see Lamanite) have been cited by many as a basis for the Indian termination policy Watkins pursued, he was also influenced by not only his childhood growing up in the west on the fringe of the Uintah and Ouray Reservation, but also by the time in which he lived. The “Culture of Conformity” –endless pressure to be stable and normal, and to fear the "godless Communist menace" – which characterized 1950s America, pushed society as a whole to relish freedom, as well as responsibility.
These values can clearly be seen in what Watkins called his policy, "the freeing of the Indian from wardship status," equating it with the Emancipation Proclamation, which freed slaves during the Civil War. Watkins was the driving force behind termination. His position as chairman of the United States Senate Subcommittee on Indian Affairs gave him tremendous leverage to determine the direction of federal Indian policy and he consolidated his influence through other western legislators. While partisanship may have played a role, geographic location may have been a much stronger motivator than party affiliation. The largest concentration of Native populations and federal lands were located in western states, as were national parks and dam projects.
He initially met with William H. Harrison (Wyoming Republican Congressman) and Orme Lewis, Arizona Republican and Assistant Secretary of the Interior Department to map out a strategy on 27 February 1953. Subsequent talks were held with E.Y. Berry (South Dakota Republican Congressman), Patrick McCarran (Nevada Democratic Senator), Karl E. Mundt (South Dakota Republican Congressman), William Langer (North Dakota Republican Senator), and Henry M. Jackson (Washington Democratic) Congressman turned Senator). After a series of consultations, the policy Watkins' envisioned, was set out with four fundamental tenets:
- 1. To eliminate laws that treated Native Americans as different from other Americans;
- 2. To dismantle the BIA giving responsibility for their affairs to the tribes themselves, or if necessary transferring some of its duties to other federal and state agencies;
- 3. To end federal supervision of individual Indians; and
- 4. To cease federal guardianship responsibilities for Indian tribes and their resources.
In early June, 1953, Senator Jackson (Dem. Washington) introduced the termination bill into the Senate and Representative Harrison (Rep. Wyoming) introduced it into the House. The defining moment for Watkins’ legislation came on 1 August 1953, with passage of House Concurrent Resolution 108, which made termination the federal government's ongoing policy and established the first thirteen tribes to be targeted. Passage of the resolution did not, in itself, terminate any tribes, but it established that on a tribe by tribe basis, legislation would be enacted for those deemed sufficiently able to sustain themselves.
Watkins and his fellow legislators acted out of a belief that they needed to "fix the Indian problem" once and for all, and they believed that assimilation of the tribes into mainstream culture was their best hope for survival. It was a pressing problem, costing the government money at a time of huge war debt, and the means seemed to justify the wanted end. As early as 1954, the policy was being questioned by a conference of social scientists, primarily anthropologists, who concluded that the thought that "assimilation of the American Indian into the normal stream of American life is inevitable, that Indian tribes and communities will disappear" is completely unwarranted.
Though the legislation was supposed to give tribes input and obtain their consent, many tribes felt pressure to agree. For example, the Menominee received an appropriation of $8.5 million in 1951 to settle a claim of BIA mismanagement, but in order to receive the payment, were told to come up with a plan for termination. When speaking with the Klamath Tribes, Watkins invoked God’s blessing upon termination and if that wasn’t enough motivation, the three options proposed were clearly aimed at terminating the tribal relationships with the government: 1) Withdraw from the tribe and accept a cash settlement for any share they were due of tribal assets; 2) Remain in the tribe and help form a tribal association to manage the trust responsibilities instead of the federal government; or 3) Refuse a cash settlement and the government would appoint a guardian to manage the remaining assets of the tribe. Even the Osage Nation of Oklahoma was told by Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Dillon S. Myer, to prepare for termination and paying taxes because “’the best country in the world’ needed financial support from all citizens to fight communists in North Korea".
Clearly the ”Terminationists” Watkins led were intent on keeping their constituencies happy. When Watkins proposed termination of the Paiute Indian Tribe of Utah, despite the fact that they did not meet the established “readiness” benchmarks of policy, it contained no protections for the tribe's mineral rights. Only public outcry over loss of the mineral rights forced addition of protections for their oil into their termination bill. It was widely believed that the Alaskan natives rights to the Tongass National Forest had been forsaken in favor of corporate timber interests. The Western Oregon Terminations of the Siletz and Grand Ronde Tribes were seen by settlers and State politicians as a means of releasing tribal natural resources as a no-cost means of improving local economies.
Even before Watkins lost his re-election bid, the policies he had pursued were proving to have disastrous effects on Native peoples. Tribes were cut off from services for education, health care, housing, sanitation and utility sources, and related resources. Termination directly caused decay within the tribe including poverty, alcoholism, high suicide rates, low educational achievement, disintegration of the family, poor housing, high dropout rates from school, disproportionate numbers in penal institutions, increased infant mortality, decreased life expectancy, and loss of identity. In addition, the era of conformity was moving into The Sixties and its calls for social change and a growing sensitivity to minority rights.
Refugee Act of 1953
Immigration was an important issue in the run up to the election in 1952. The McCarran-Walter Act which Truman's administration had just passed was criticized not only internally, but throughout Europe as a policy which maintained systematic racial and religious discrimination and was hampering immigration based on hostility and distrust of outsiders, rampant fear of Communism, and unfounded security claims. With Eisenhower's election, rather than attempt to revise the McCarran Act, a decision was made to provide an emergency relief bill, which would be seen as a temporary program. On 22 April 1953, Eisenhower made a presentation to Congress outlining his main criteria for a refugee bill: sponsorship by a creditable citizen that the refugee had a job, housing, and would not become a ward of the state; proof that the refugee would be admitted back to his/her country of origin; complete background information for the last two years must be provided. Given this information, Eisenhower stressed that no discrimination based on race, religion or origin would prohibit visa issuance and that priority would be given to those refugees who had skills that were needed in the U.S. or who were family members of U.S. citizens.
On 31 May 1953, Senator Watkins, chairman of the Senate Immigration Subcommittee introduced a bill for the Refugee Relief Act, largely based on Eisenhower's proposal and recommendations. The two crucial elements of the bill were that it made refugee quotas distinct from visa quotas and it defined the terms "refugee" (a person facing persecution residing a non-communist country), "escapee" (a person facing persecution who currently resided in a community, country, or area dominated by communists) and "expelee" (a refugee of German heritage who had been removed from a Soviet-controlled country or area). Congressional hearings on the bill included representatives from Catholic, Jewish and Protestant organizations, but there was no consensus among them on whether the bill should be approved, or rejected.
The bill passed 7 August 1953; was criticized for excluding many desirable refugees, excluding employers or associations from sponsoring refugees, excessive bureaucracy involved in obtaining security clearances, and an overall failure to bring in desperate refugees in anywhere near the authorized quotas; and was allowed to expire on 31 December 1956.
The Watkins Committee
Early in 1950, When Senator Joseph McCarthy began his anti-communist purges, he found a lot of support from the public at large and his colleagues. By 1952 however, some of his attacks had helped lead to defeat of Democratic opponents and even resulted in criticism from some of his own party for debasing the decorum required of a public official. By 1953, with the Republican sweep in the White House and legislatures his attacks had become an assault on his own party. On 22 April 1954, McCarthy opened hearings to investigate the security of the US Army. Aired on national television, McCarthy badgered witnesses, ignored common courtesies, subverted parliamentary procedure, and negatively turned public opinion against himself and the government.
On 11 June 1954, Ralph Flanders (Rep. Vermont) had introduced a measure to strip McCarthy of all of his chairmanships. There were many in the Senate who believed that McCarthy should be curtailed, but there was no clear consensus on whether removing his chairmanships was warranted because of rules on seniority and proper protocol. Convinced by colleagues that censure would be easier to attain, on July 30, 1954, Flanders introduced a resolution calling for McCarthy's censure citing that McCarthy's behavior ran "contrary to senatorial traditions" and brought the whole body into disrepute. "It was not his breaches of etiquette, or of rules or sometimes even of laws which is so disturbing," but rather his overall pattern of behavior. Ultimately a "bill of particulars" listing 46 charges was added to the censure resolution.
Before McCarthy, there had only been five cases of censure in the history of the Senate, but his conduct had become so outrageous, that it was felt something must be done. Vice President Richard Nixon, appointed a bi-partisan committee, headed by Watkins to review and determine whether censure was warranted. On 5 August 1954, the names of the committee members were released: Arthur Watkins (Rep. Utah), Frank Carlson (Rep. Kansas), Francis Case (Rep. South Dakota), Edwin C. Johnson (Dem. Colorado) John Stennis (Dem. Mississippi), and Sam Ervin (Dem, North Carolina). The Senators were hand-picked by Nixon because they were men who played by the rule, who had the respect of other Senators, were neither liberal nor media hounds, and were not presidential contenders. They began meeting on 31 August 1954 for what would amount to 2 months of hearings.
The Watkins Committee divided the 46 counts into five categories: contempt of the Senate or a Senatorial committee; encouragement of federal employees to break the law; receipt of classified documents from executive files; abuse of Senate colleagues; and abuse of military personnel. Watkins barred television cameras and media from the hearings, and insisted that McCarthy conform to Senate protocol. When McCarthy appeared before committee and began badgering the committee members, Watkins expelled him from the procedures. Most of the charges were rejected either because they either fell into actions that had long been tolerated, or they were judged to have the potential to limit Senatorial investigations in the future. The two charges they finally decided to bring related to his failure to attend the Subcommittee on Rules and Administration, which had called him to testify in 1951 and 1952, and his abuse of General Zwicker in the Army hearings of 1954. The Zwicker count was eventually dropped and one regarding his statements about the Watkins committee itself was added. One final attempt was made before the charges were brought to the full Senate to obtain an apology from McCarthy, but he refused.
The two counts on which the Senate ultimately voted were:
- (1) his refusal to appear before the Subcommittee on Privileges and Elections to answer questions about his personal character, and his general obstruction to the work of the panel during its investigation of him in 1951 and 1952; and
- (2) his "charging three members of the Select Committee with "deliberate deception" and "fraud" for failure to disqualify themselves; in stating to the press on November 4, 1954, that the special Senate session that was to begin November 8, 1954, was a "lynch-party"...
On December 2, 1954, the Senate voted to "condemn" McCarthy on both counts by a vote of 67 to 22. The Democrats present voted unanimously and the Republicans were split on whether condemnation should prevail. John F. Kennedy, who was hospitalized for back surgery was not present at the vote and did not indicate specifically how he would have voted.
After the Senate
McCarthy's anti-communist rhetoric was still popular with Utah's electorate and impacted Watkins re-election bid. Former Utah Governor J. Bracken Lee took the opportunity in 1958 to oppose Watkins for the nomination in the senatorial election. Though Watkins won the Republican primary, Lee ran as an independent in the general election. This caused a split in the Republican vote and allowed Democrat Frank E. Moss to win the seat. Lee went on to a long career as mayor of Salt Lake City. Moss served three terms in the Senate, losing to Republican Orrin Hatch in 1976.
Following his defeat, Watkins was hired as consultant to Interior Secretary Fred Seaton, but left in 1960 to accept an appointment by Eisenhower on the Indian Claims Commission, becoming its chairman and subsequently its chief commissioner. In 1967 Watkins retired to write his memoirs and in 1969 published a book entitled Enough Rope, which detailed the work of the Watkins Committee and the censure of Senator Joseph McCarthy.
- "Arthur Vivian Watkins". Utah.gov. Retrieved 1 January 2015.
- "WATKINS, Arthur Vivian, (1886 - 1973)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- "Arthur V. Watkins & The Law of Unintended Consequences". Brigham Young High School. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- Metcalf, R. Warren (2002). Termination's legacy : the discarded Indians of Utah. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. pp. 26–27. ISBN 0-8032-3201-2. Retrieved 29 December 2014.
- Metcalf (2002), p26
- "Autobiography of Henry Dixon Taylor". Brigham Young University Press. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- Metcalf (2002), p26-36
- Grattan-Aiello, p 281
- Barnett, David. "Portrait of a Senator's Wife: Mrs. Arthur Watkins". Find a Grave. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- "Nedra Watkins Reese". Find a Grave. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- "Arthur Rich Watkins". Find A Grave. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- "Venna Mae Watkins Lange". Find a Grave. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- "Weber Basin Project". U.S. Department of the Interior. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- "Weber Basin Water Conservancy District v. Gailey". Justia.com. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- McCune, Christopher J. (2001). "Weber Basin Project" (PDF). Bureau of Reclamation. p. 24. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
- Metcalf (2002), p7
- Grattan-Aiello, Carolyn. "Senator Arthur V. Watkins and the Termination of Utah's Southern Paiute Indians" (PDF). Utah Historical Quarterly. p. 269. Retrieved 26 December 2014.
- Parman, Donald L. (1994). Indians and the American West in the twentieth century ([Nachdr.]. ed.). Bloomington: Indiana University Press. pp. 134–135. ISBN 0-253-34289-9. Retrieved 30 December 2014.
- Metcalf (2002), pp 26-37
- Peroff, Nicholas C. (2006). Menominee drums : tribal termination and restoration, 1954-1974 ([Pbk. ed.]. ed.). Norman: University of Oklahoma Press. p. 7. ISBN 0-8061-3777-0. Retrieved 30 December 2014.
- Metcalf (2002), p 7
- Fox, Jeffrey Carl (2006). Latter-Day Political Views. Lincoln: Lexington Books. p. 161. ISBN 0-7391-0612-0. Retrieved 29 December 2014.
- "Postwar Conformity and the Seeds of Dissent in the 1950s". Retrieved 30 December 2014.
- Glazer, David Riesman with Nathan; Gitlin, Reuel Denney ; with a foreword by Todd (2000). The lonely crowd : a study of the changing American character (Abridged and rev. ed.). New Haven CT: Yale University Press. p. 8. ISBN 0300088655.
- Cramer, Renee Ann (2005). Cash, Color, and Colonialism: The Politics of Tribal Acknowledgment. University of Oklahoma Press. p. 20. ISBN 0-8061-3671-5. Retrieved 29 December 2014.
- Wunder, edited with introductions by John R. (1996). Constitutionalism and Native Americans, 1903-1968. New York: Garland Pub. pp. 213–214. ISBN 0-8153-2486-3.
- Peroff (2006), pp 61-63
- Lewis, David Gene (2009). Termination of the Confederated Tribes of the Grand Ronde Community of Oregon: Politics, Community, Identity. UMI: ProQuest LLC. pp. 171–174.
- Wunder (1996, pp=213-214
- Grattan-Aiello, p 269
- Weeks, Philip (2014). "They Made Us Many Promises": The American Indian Experience 1524 to the Present. John Wiley & Sons. p. 199. Retrieved 23 December 2014.
- Metcalf (2002), pp 37-77
- Weeks, p. 200
- Grattan-Aiello, P283
- Spicer, [by] Edward H. (1969). A short history of the Indians of the United States. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold Co. pp. 249–250. ISBN 0442001010.
- Peroff (2006), pp 54-55
- Clements, Chris. "Federal Termination and Its Effects on the Land, Culture, and Identity of the Klamath Indian Tribe". History Department Rutgers (March 2009): 32. Retrieved 27 December 2014.
- Clements (2009), pp 27-28
- Philp, Kenneth R. (1999). Termination Revisited: American Indians on the Trail to Self-Determination, 1933-1953 (2002 ed.). University of Nebraska Press. p. 159. ISBN 0-8032-3723-5.
- Grattan-Aiello , pp 273-276
- Cowger, Thomas W. (2001). "The National Congress of American Indians: The Founding Years". University of Nebraska Press. pp. 59–62. Retrieved 26 December 2014.
- Lewis, David Gene. "Termination of the Confederated Tribes of the Grand Ronde Community of Oregon: Politics, Community, Identity" (PDF) (March 2009). University of Oregon: 222. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
- Clements (2009), pp 47-62
- "Tillie Hardwick et al. v United States et al." (PDF). Retrieved 31 December 2014.
- Venables, Robert W. American Indian History Five Centuries of Conflict and Coexistence (Clear Light Publishers, 2004) ISBN 978-1-57416-076-5, p. 331
- Sturtevant, William C., ed. (1988). Handbook of North American Indians: History of Indian-White relations, Vol. 4. Smithsonian Institution. pp. 77–78. Retrieved 29 December 2014.
- Peroff (2006), p 7
- "Immigration". American Jewish Yearbook. pp. 63–72. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
- "Corsi Dismissal and the Refugee Relief Act". CQ Almanac 1955. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
- "Sen. Watkins Reports to Eisenhower on Arab Refugee Situation". Retrieved 31 December 2014.
- Rorty, James (October 1, 1955). "Our Broken Promise to the Refugees: Unsmiling Goddess of Liberty". Commentary Magazine. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
- "Refugee Relief Act of 1953". Retrieved 31 December 2014.
- "Senate Resolution 301: Censure of Senator Joseph McCarthy (1954)". ourdocuments.gov. Retrieved 1 January 2015.
- "The Censure Case of Joseph McCarthy of Wisconsin (1954)". US Senate. Retrieved 1 January 2015.
- Griffith, Robert (1970). The Politics of Fear: Joseph R. McCarthy and the Senate. University of Massachusetts Press. pp. 277 et seq. ISBN 0-87023-555-9.
- Oshinsky, David M. (2005). A conspiracy so immense : the world of Joe McCarthy. Oxford [u.a.]: Oxford Univ. Press. pp. 470–477. ISBN 978-0-19-515424-5. Retrieved 31 December 2014.
- Oshinsky (2005), pp 477-480
- Oshinsky (2005), pp 488
- "Transcript of Senate Resolution 301: Censure of Senator Joseph McCarthy (1954)". Retrieved 1 January 2015.
- Oshinsky (2005), pp. 33, 490
- Arthur V. Watkins Papers (1886-1973); MSS 146; 20th Century Western and Mormon Manuscripts; L. Tom Perry Special Collections, Harold B. Lee Library, Brigham Young University.
- United States Congress. "Arthur Vivian Watkins (id: W000190)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
- A film clip "Longines Chronoscope with Arthur B. (SIC) Watkins" is available at the Internet Archive
|United States Senate|
|U.S. Senator (Class 1) from Utah
1947 – 1959
Served alongside: Elbert D. Thomas, Wallace F. Bennett
Frank E. Moss