Jump to content

Bhakti Marga (organisation)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This article is about the neo-Hindu organisation. For the spiritual concept, see Bhakti yoga.
  • Bhakti Marga
Formation13 June 2005 (19 years ago) (2005-06-13)
FounderVishwananda
TypeReligious organization
Legal statusFoundation
HeadquartersShree Peetha Nilaya, Heidenrod, Hesse, Germany
Area served
Worldwide
AffiliationsVishishtadvaita, Kriya Yoga school, Warkari, Shaktism, Shaivism, Sri Vaishnavism, Sant Tradition (Hinduism)
Websitewww.bhaktimarga.org

Bhakti Marga is a neo-Hindu organisation[1] founded by Mauritian-born guru Paramahamsa Sri Swami Vishwananda.[2][3] It was established on 13 June 2005 in Frankfurt, Germany. Its main headquarters is located in Heidenrod, Hesse, Germany.[1][4][5][6] It views itself as being part of a new tradition founded by Vishwananda, the Hari Bhakta Sampradaya, which represents a combination of certain Vaishnava, Shaiva and Shakta philosophies.[1][7][8] The followers not only adhere to multiple sets of Hindu scriptures but also predominantly on the "personality of Paramahamsa Vishwananda",[1][7][9] similar to the Sant tradition.

History

[edit]

Bhakti Marga means "Path of Devotion".[10][11] Hari means 'God' (more specifically Vishnu), Bhakta means 'devotees' and Sampradaya means 'lineage of teachings'. The sampradaya has been viewed as a combination of the teachings of various vedantic saints, such as Mahavatar Babaji,[12][13][5][14][6] Ramanujacharya and Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, including other Hindu denominations.[1][15]

Vishwananada receives the title Mahamandaleshwara by Nirmohi Akhada, which makes him the second guru outside of India to be awarded the title.

Vishwananda arrived in the West in the year of 2004 and settled in a house in Steffenshof, Germany, with a small group of followers. He later established the organisation on 13 June 2005 at the age of 27.[16] He began the movement by travelling the world to give darshans, lead pilgrimages, build communities, and to initiate monks into the Bhakti Marga spiritual lineage.[17][18][3][19] The first Bhakti Marga commune, Shree Peetha Nilaya, opened to the public in 2013 in Heidenrod, Germany.[20] Following Paramahamsa Vishwananda's lead, additional ashrams have been built by the organization's swamis around the world such as ashrams in India (Vrindavan),[21] Latvia (Riga) and Russia (Moscow).[19][4] By the end of 2022 Bhakti Marga had around 10,000 followers[22] and between 30 and 50 ashrams worldwide. By the end of 2023, it had around 50,000 followers, which included 450 initiated male and female Brahmacharis, as well as more than 50 male and female Swamis and Rishis.[23][6]

The first version of the logo of Bhakti Marga featured the Hindu 'Om' alongside symbols from Abrahamic traditions, including a cross, a small Islamic crescent, and the Star of David. This design has since been replaced by a logo depicting a white horse rearing from a lotus. According to Martin J. Haigh, the new symbol resonates with themes of transformation and new beginnings, and signifies the anticipated arrival of Kalki, the 10th, prophesied avatar of Sri Vishnu.[6]

Motto and principles

[edit]

The tradition of Bhakti Marga is centered around developing a deeply personal relationship with the Divine and the guru.[7] This relationship fosters an environment in which unconditional acceptance of oneself can flourish, allowing practitioners to experience and express pure love in all aspects of their lives.[13] As it arises, it nurtures a sense of self-confidence, empowering practitioners to integrate this love into their daily activities and interactions. It emphasizes the importance of spiritual development alongside personal growth, ensuring that the love cultivated through the practice is both internal and external, benefiting the practitioner and the broader community.[9][1][24]

[edit]

Bhakti Marga incorporates nine distinct forms of bhakti, which are central to its transformative power through Atma Kriya Yoga. Each of the fifteen techniques in Atma Kriya Yoga is believed to awaken a different form of bhakti, enriching the practitioner's spiritual journey. Greater awareness of the soul, combined with love and devotion to God, is said to enhance the practice.[25][13][3][26][14]

The forms of bhakti include Shravana bhakti, which involves listening to the stories and glories of the God and the saints, and chanting. Kirtana bhakti is the singing of God's pastimes, bringing joy and divine resonance to the body, mind, and spirit. Smarana bhakti focuses on the constant remembrance of the Divine, helping the mind release worries and turn to the Divine. Padaseva bhakti involves serving humanity, recognizing the divinity within all living beings.[25]

Archana bhakti brings the external worship of the Divine, with breathing techniques that purify the body and focus the mind. Vandana bhakti, the act of bowing down, establishes humility and the acknowledgment of the Divine's greatness, transforming yoga postures into acts of devotion. Dasya bhakti is about offering service to the Divine through daily duties, seeing every act as an offering of love and gratitude. Sakhya bhakti emphasizes the personal and eternal relationship each devotee has with the Divine, which can be expressed in various ways. Atmanivedana bhakti represents the soul's natural devotion upon realizing the Divine's omnipresence, which is believed to be achievable through the grace of a saint and facilitated by Atma Kriya Yoga's Shaktipat Initiation.[25]

Motto

[edit]

The main aim of the organisation and its sampradaya is to re-establish harmonious relationship with God, characterized by unconditional love and devotion.[1][9][13][8][24][6]

Religious practices

[edit]

Bhakti Marga followers follow Sadhana or 'spiritual practice', which can be carried out in any form or sequence. However, the main practices are japa, the reciting of the holy names,[4][27] meditation with Atma Kriya Yoga,[14][28][13][12][2][5] daily prayer in worship through puja and yajna. Encouragement is also made to take up at least one verse of the Bhagavad Gita daily.[28][7] Devotional arts are also seen as ways to express bhakti towards Hari, such as painting, Sri Yantra composition, singing, dancing and theatre plays.[1][29][30][31][24][6]

Initiation

[edit]

A Bhakti Marga follower's initiation into the sampradaya to become a monk would need to adhere to its religious rules for a minimum of 2 years.[32]

  • Maintain a strict vegetarian diet, refraining from eggs, fish, or meat consumption, especially from involvement in purchasing, handling, or cooking any form of meat.
  • Abstain from intoxicants, including smoking, recreational drugs, and alcoholic beverages.
  • Engage in monthly participation in Bhakti Marga activities, whether physical or online.
  • Perform daily japa, allowing for occasional missed periods.
  • Study either the Bhagavad Gita Essentials or the Shreemad Bhagavad Gita: The Song of Love.
  • Peruse a minimum of one of Paramahamsa Vishwananda's books, excluding the Bhagavad Gita commentary.
  • Successfully complete a Devotee Course (the student is taught the concepts needed in mind in order to receive formal initiation).
  • Obtain approval from a swami/ni or rishi/ka.
Narasimha
Narasimha, an avatar of Vishnu, is prominently worshipped in various Bhakti Marga ashrams

Roles

[edit]

Bhakti Marga swamis/swaminis wear orange clothing, who are seen as "spiritual advisors and emissaries of Paramahamsa Vishwananda". They are entrusted with the spiritual welfare of the sangha (community members). The organization's rishis/rishikas wear red carry out the mission of disseminating the organization's teachings and are regarded as "swamis-in-training." Both groups receive their initiation directly from Paramahamsa Vishwananda. The brahmacharis/brahmacharinis of the organization wear yellow. Their clothing are usually in the form of kurtas, dhotis, and saris. All are initiated followers who take additional vows of celibacy and voluntarily take part in all the organization's activities.[30][1]

A Bhakti Marga follower performing japa with a mala bag.

Some monks and nuns reside in ashramas, where they are supported by the community, allowing them to dedicate themselves in assisting Paramahamsa Vishwananda and advancing the Bhakti Marga mission. Others balance their spiritual responsibilities with their household lives, known as grihasta, while supporting local sanghas in their respective countries.[30][1]

Ashrams

[edit]

Every Bhakti Marga ashram has at least one temple, which in turn often contains several idols representing deities.[5] In addition to various Hindu deities, Vaishnava and non-vaishnava, Babaji and Ramanuja are worshipped as gurus in the main temple in Springen.[16] The main deities in Sri Vaishnava are Narayana and Lakshmi,[33][34] who are also worshiped in the Bhakti Marga temples.[35] However, many other deities are also worshiped, some of which belong to the Vaishnava pantheon (Radha and Krishna), but some of them do not. This worship of non-vaishnava gurus and deities, like Shiva and Durga,[36] distinguishes Bhakti Marga from other Vaishnava traditions, such as Shri Vaishnava, or Gaudiya Vaishnava, which is known in western countries mainly through the Hare Krishna movement.[1][37]

In addition, the ashram in Springen contains a Russian Orthodox chapel, in which there are also relics of Christian saints.[38] It is not uncommon in the syncretistic system of Hinduism for Christ to be viewed as the avatar of Vishnu.[6] Yet in recent years, the organisation has distanced away from Christian philosophy.[39] However, there are currently no liturgical services in the chapel. Building of the temple has cost more than one million euros. The movement claims to have between 30 and 50 centres or temples worldwide, some of them rather small,[16] which soon increased to being present in over 77 countries in April 2024.[8][6]

In November 2020 it became known that Bhakti Marga in Kirchheim in the Hersfeld-Rotenburg district of Hesse wants to set up its Hindu Germany center in the area of the Seepark Kirchheim holiday complex, which includes its own lake.[40]

In January 2022 Bhakti Marga purchased a former Catholic Church in West Elmira, New York, the former Our Lady of Lourdes parish, to become its first ashram and temple in America.[41] According to Swami Tulsidas, Bhakti Marga's representative in North America, the main deity in the new ashram will be that of Narasimha, the avatar of Vishnu.[42] On October 22, 2023, In the small town of Elmira, New York, Swami Paramahamsa Vishwananda completed the inauguration of the Paranitya Narasimha Temple and ashram on September 3, 2023. It was the culmination of a massive undertaking by the organization's American followers and monks. Hundreds of people from around the world made the pilgrimage to attend. Followers from Russia, Brazil, Canada, India and Africa gathered in Elmira to volunteer and help in the event.[43]

Museum

[edit]

The Saints Of India Museum, located in Shree Nilaya Peetha in Germany, has a collection of over 1,300 Hindu relics, sacred texts, and artefacts belonging to more than 1000 Indian saints who have played major role in Indian spiritual traditions. According to Paramahamsa Vishwananda, it was set up to appreciate and honour the saints through their individual relics. The Swamis and Swaminis of the organisation help to collect such relics.[8][44]

Just Love Festival

[edit]

Since 2015, Bhakti Marga has held a large, multi-day festival in Germany every year, the Just Love Festival, which attracts up to 3,000 visitors. The duration of the festival varies between three and ten days. During the festival, various spiritual music bands from different countries play, mainly bhajans and kirtans, but these can be interpreted differently, such that Sanskrit hymns could also be rapped. The event is usually in the summer, the focus of the festival is Guru Purnima, a Hindu festival held every year in honor of the guru, spiritual or academic, on a full moon day. As a supporting program there are exhibitions of arts and crafts, a bazaar, a vegan restaurant, and various teaching lectures and workshops by Bhakti Marga initiated members.[16] "Just Love" is also the slogan of Bhakti Marga. It is meant to express the ideal of the movement, which places love at the center of life, love for God, but also love for the guru or the community.

Controversies

[edit]

In 2001, the Swiss newspaper Tagesanzeiger reported that two former members of Bhakti Marga stole relics from 25 churches and monasteries in Switzerland during a tour. Such relics include the remains of bones believed to be of Mother Mary and Saint Brother Klaus. The case was held in 2003, after one of the culprits voluntarily reported herself to the police. The case was brought before the Baselland Criminal Court in Liestal. Swami Vishwananda did not appear at the hearing due to a tour in America and sent apologise for his absence. The two ex-disciples who were at the court spoke about their "psychological dependence and the manipulative skills of the guru". They also claimed that it was Vishwananda's order to collect as many relics as possible for "an imminent relic war and the end of the world by black magic", and had convinced them that the theft was by "God's will".[45]

The court sentenced the main defendant to four months' suspended prison sentence for damage to property and disruption of religious freedom. The 48-year-old woman from Berne received a suspended fine of 3,500 francs, and the 29-year-old woman from Zurich received a fine of 400 francs. Most of the bones, which were in Mauritius and in a French monastery, were taken over to the diocese of Basel, and returened to the places of origin.[45]

On December 10, 2016, Bhakti Marga carried out a group chanting at the Mauthausen concentration camp in Austria. It was met with varied responses, from critics accusing Bhakti Marga of exploitation and relativization of the holocaust while others encouraged the activity that the organisation held as a form of respect to the victims.[46][47][48]

On March 17, 2018, Bhakti Marga carried out a group chanting at the Buchenwald concentration camp, which led to protests. The head of the Jewish community in Thuringia state, Germany, Reinhard Schramm, stated that he faced no issue when meeting the organization and even referred to them as 'partners' in the fight against ethnic and religious racism and xenophobia.[49] In Austria, the interior ministry responsible for memorial sites stated that the monuments are open to anyone who respects “the dignity of the place.” Willi Mernyi, the chairman of the Mauthausen Committee who oversees the memorial, said that he saw the procession as an act of respect and wanted to not criticise the organisation for it. Rikola-Gunnar Lüttgenau, a spokesman for the Buchenwald memorial, stated that Protestant, Catholic and Jewish groups were allowed to pray at the memorial, and therefore did not bar the organisation from doing its activity in the premises. An investigation was carried out by the memorial's managemnet, and saw no violation made by the organisation against its rules.[46][47][48]

In January 2022, Hessischer Rundfunk, a regional broadcast arm of German state broadcaster ARD, released a TV documentary in which suspicions of sexual coercion were broadcast against Paramahamsa Vishwananda. The law firm acting on behalf of Paramahamsa Vishwananda sought injunctions at the regional court of Hamburg citing "numerous offences against principles of permissable reporting, untrue statements and blatant rights offences". The court judged that there was 'a lack of evidence to broadcast such a suspicion' and ruled in favour of Paramahamsa Vishwananda, issuing seven injunctions against the TV show which resulted in its removal from the ARD Mediathek platform. Hessischer Rundfunk's serious journalistic failings were further highlighted after they alleged an identifiable follower of Paramahamsa Vishwananda had tried to commit suicide after suffering sexual abuse, without checking with the alleged victim if the allegation was actually true. The follower in question denied any such abuse or suicide attempt ever occurred. The follower took legal action against HR, obtaining injunctions about the misreporting about him and HR admitted their journalistic failure to take simple steps to verify the allegations.[50][51][39][52][53][54][5]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Beck, Heike (August 2013). "Bhakti Marga eröffnet spirituelles Zentrum in Springen/Taunus" [Bhakti Marga opens spiritual center in Springen/Taunus] (PDF). Evangelische Zentralstelle für Weltanschauungsfragen. (in German).
  2. ^ a b Faro, El (2023-11-15). "Ramchandani recibe en España al maestro hindú Swami Vishwananda". El Faro de Ceuta (in Spanish). Retrieved 2024-05-27.
  3. ^ a b c "संत-महात्माः भक्ति मार्ग आंदोलन के संस्थापक परमहंस श्री स्वामी विश्वानंद". Jansatta (in Hindi). 2020-03-02. Retrieved 2024-06-08.
  4. ^ a b c "Paramahamsa Vishwananda says "India feels like home to me."". www.ibtimes.sg. 2023-04-17. Retrieved 2024-06-08.
  5. ^ a b c d e "Umstrittene Sekte "Bhakti Marga": Der Wunderguru aus dem Taunus". Der Tagesspiegel Online (in German). ISSN 1865-2263. Retrieved 2024-06-26.
  6. ^ a b c d e f g h Singh, Ravi S.; Dahiya, Bharat; Singh, Arun K.; Poudel, Padma C. (2022-05-20). Practising Cultural Geographies: Essays in Honour of Rana P. B. Singh. Springer Nature. ISBN 978-981-16-6415-1.
  7. ^ a b c d "Who is God?". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-07-03.
  8. ^ a b c d "Mumbai: Relics Of Spiritual Guru Maiji Featured In Unique 'Saints Of India' Museum In Germany". Free Press Journal. Retrieved 2024-06-27.
  9. ^ a b c "Becoming a Devotee". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-05-24.
  10. ^ "Hindu spiritual group moves into former West Elmira Catholic Church". WETM - MyTwinTiers.com. 2022-04-01. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  11. ^ "Hinduism - Karma, Samsara, Moksha | Britannica". www.britannica.com. Retrieved 2023-11-21.
  12. ^ a b "Mahavatar Babaji and the Grace of the Masters". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-05-24.
  13. ^ a b c d e "What makes Atma Kriya Yoga unique?". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-05-27.
  14. ^ a b c "Atma Kriya Yoga is Bhakti-Yoga". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-07-03.
  15. ^ Vishwananda, Paramahamsa Sri Swami (2017-01-12). Shreemad Bhagavad Gita: The Song of Love. Bhakti Marga Publications. ISBN 978-3-940381-70-5.
  16. ^ a b c d Maus, Robert (10 September 2018). "Der Ashram im Taunus" [Ashram in Taunus]. Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (in German).
  17. ^ "Meet Paramahamsa Vishwananda, Revolutionary Guru Who Is Travelling All Around World Giving Darshans Since Age of 15 Years | LatestLY". LatestLY. 2023-02-23. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  18. ^ "Darshan with Sri Swami Vishwananda in Guwahati". Assam Times. 2013-11-07. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  19. ^ a b "Hindu group spiritual leader offers blessings at West Elmira temple". WETM - MyTwinTiers.com. 2022-09-08. Retrieved 2024-06-08.
  20. ^ "Paramahamsa Vishwananda's enlightenment and his early years". APN News. March 24, 2023.
  21. ^ "Kriya Yoga And Spiritual Guru Paramahamsa Vishwananda To Visit India, Here's How You Can Seek His Blessings". Free Press Journal. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  22. ^ Focus-Online staff (19 August 2023). "Mitten im Taunus baut Hindu-Guru via Tiktok seine Sekte auf" [In the middle of the Taunus, the Hindu guru is building up his sect via Tiktok]. Focus-Online. Retrieved August 27, 2023.
  23. ^ Sharma, Sonu (2023-12-18). "परमहंस श्री विश्वानंद ने मनाया कार्तिक उत्सव". 4PM News. Retrieved 2024-05-24.
  24. ^ a b c "The Ultimate Goal of Life". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-07-03.
  25. ^ a b c "Dive into the Heart of Meditation". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-05-24.
  26. ^ elainenaidoo (2016-05-11). "Spreading the message of love". Rising Sun Newspapers. Retrieved 2024-06-08.
  27. ^ "Powerful Daily Mantra: A Path to Inner Peace". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-07-03.
  28. ^ a b Deep, Ajay (2023-05-22). "Parmahamsa Vishwananda says, "Atma Kriya Yoga is like a universal highway to develop your personal relationship with God". Chandigarh Metro. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  29. ^ "Paramahamsa Vishwananda says "India feels like home to me."". www.ibtimes.sg. 2023-04-17. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  30. ^ a b c "What is the Lifestyle of a Hari Bhakta?". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2023-11-20.
  31. ^ "The Hindu Spiritual Path". blog.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-07-03.
  32. ^ "Become a Devotee Of Paramahamsa Vishwananda". pages.bhaktimarga.org. Retrieved 2024-05-23.
  33. ^ Tapasyananda, Svami (1990). Bhakti Schools of Vedanta. Mylapore, Madras: Sri Ramakrishna Math. pp. 31–33. ISBN 81-7120-226-8.
  34. ^ Tapasyananda, Svami (1991). "Introduction". Sri Ramanuja Gita Bhasya. Translated by Svami Adidevanand. Mylapore, Madras: Sri Ramakrishna Math. pp. 9–40. ISBN 81-7823-290-1.
  35. ^ Shree Peetha Nilaya staff (August 2023). "Serve a deity program". Shree Peetha Nilaya. Retrieved 2023-08-26.
  36. ^ Vasconcelos, Catarina Maldonado (20 April 2021). ""Ele é um avatar de amor." A comunidade hindu do Porto que adora o guru de Rui Patrício como deus" ["He is an avatar of love." The Hindu community in Porto that worships Rui Patrício's guru as a god]. TSF (in Portuguese).
  37. ^ Dimock, Edward C. Jr. (2000). "Adi Lila, Chapter 17, verses 33 ff". In Steward, Tony K. (ed.). Caitanya caritamrta of Krsnadasa Kaviraja: a translation and commentary. Harvard Oriental Series. Vol. 65. ISBN 0-674-00285-7.
  38. ^ Eißler, Friedmann (January 2020). "Bhakti Marga in der Kritik" [Bhakti Marga in criticism]. Zeitschrift für Religion und Weltanschauung [Journal of Religion and Worldview] (in German).
  39. ^ a b "Stellungnahme Bhakti Marga zur Berichterstattung des Hessischen Rundfunk". pages.bhaktimarga.org (in German). Retrieved 2024-05-27.
  40. ^ Löwenberger, Bernd (18 November 2020). "Seepark Kirchheim verkauft: Aus für das Hotel, Hindu-Religionszentrum geplant" [Seepark Kirchheim sold: Planned out for the hotel, Hindu religious center]. Hersfelder Zeitung.
  41. ^ Aldinger, Carl (September 7, 2022). "Hindu spiritual group moves into former West Elmira Catholic Church". MyTwinTiers.com.
  42. ^ Bhakti Marga America (2022-01-25). ELMIRA: New Ashram and Mandir Announcement. Retrieved 2024-05-25 – via YouTube.
  43. ^ "Paranitya Narasimha Temple Dedicated – Hindu Press International". Retrieved 2024-02-19.
  44. ^ "Saints of India Museum". Bhakti Marga Germany. Retrieved 2024-09-05.
  45. ^ a b Hohler, Stefan (June 15, 2007). "tagesanzeiger.ch: Nichts verpassen" [Stealing of bones in churches] (in German). Archived from the original on 2010-11-08. Retrieved 2024-06-23.
  46. ^ a b Niewendick, Martin (3 March 2018). "Spirituelle Gruppe will KZ-Gedenkstätte mit Ritual "heilen"" [Spiritual group wants to heal concentration camp]. Die Welt (in German).
  47. ^ a b Sommer, Philipp (2 March 2018). "Dieser Kult will in Konzentrationslagern meditieren" [This cult wants to meditate at concentration camps]. Vice (in German).
  48. ^ a b Heneghan, Tom (2018-03-30). "Hindus chant to 'purify' former Nazi concentration camps". Religion News Service. Retrieved 2024-02-19.
  49. ^ deutschlandfunk.de (16 March 2018). "KZ-Gedenkstätte Buchenwald - Chanting wider die Schuld". Deutschlandfunk (in German). Retrieved 2024-06-08.
  50. ^ "Hat der Hessische Rundfunk ein Sorgfaltsproblem?". www.fr.de (in German). 2022-04-11. Retrieved 2024-05-27.
  51. ^ Hülsen, Isabell (2022-04-08). "(S+) HR-Doku über Missbrauch: Ein US-Amerikaner wird zum Opfer erklärt - doch der Sender hat nie mit ihm gesprochen". Der Spiegel (in German). ISSN 2195-1349. Retrieved 2024-05-27.
  52. ^ Blazekovic, Aurelie von (2022-04-08). "Guru gegen Sender: Wie Bhakti Marga erfolgreich gegen den HR klagt". Süddeutsche.de (in German). Retrieved 2024-05-27.
  53. ^ "HR-Recherche zu Chef der Sekte Bhakti Marga vor Gericht". FAZ.NET (in German). 2024-03-25. Retrieved 2024-06-09.
  54. ^ "Das Sorgfaltsproblem des Hessischen Rundfunk - es bleibt / Die irreführende Litigation-PR einer öffentlich-rechtlichen Rundfunkanstalt ohne Kompass". presseportal.de (in German). 2024-03-25. Retrieved 2024-06-26.
[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bhakti_Marga_(organisation)&oldid=1254846580"