Democracy and Political Ignorance

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Democracy and Political Ignorance: Why Smaller Government Is Smarter is a 2013 book from Stanford University Press by George Mason University law professor Ilya Somin.[1][2][3] Somin argues that people are ignorant and irrational about politics and that this creates problems for democracy. He further claims that this consideration argues in favor of smaller and more decentralized government.

A revised and expanded edition of the book was published in 2016. It includes new material on a variety of issues, including discussions of the "Big Sort" and its implications for "voting with your feet," the connection between political ignorance and the disproportionate political influence of the wealthy, new proposals for increasing political knowledge, and up-to-date survey data on political ignorance from recent elections.[4] The book has also been published in Italian and Japanese translations.[5][6]

Themes[edit]

Somin published a series of guest posts on the Balkinization blog outlining the key themes of his book.[7][8][9][10][11]

Reception[edit]

Book reviews[edit]

Jack Shafer reviewed the book on his Reuters blog and discussed its implications for the role of mass media in democracy.[12] Christopher Schmidt reviewed the book on his blog, part of the IIT Chicago-Kent Law blog network.[13] A. Barton Hinkle reviewed the book for the Richmond Times-Dispatch.[14] John David Dyche reviewed the book for WDRB.[15] The book was also reviewed on Book Bargains and Previews.[16]

Political commentator George Will reviewed the book favorably in a Washington Post op-ed.[17]

Philosopher Jason Brennan briefly reviewed Somin's book on the Bleeding Heart Libertarians blog, ending with a strong recommendation to buy the book.[18] Donald Boudreaux also offered a brief review and strong recommendation of the book on his blog, Cafe Hayek.[19]

Discussions[edit]

Somin defended the thesis of his book in the lead essay of Cato Unbound in October 2013.[20][21] Other participants in the exchange included Heather Gerken, Jeffrey Friedman, and Sean Trende.[22] Gerken's response essay used the fox versus hedgehog distinction, arguing that Somin's ideal voter was a fox, whereas David Schleicher's work stressed that voters tended to be hedgehogs and use their party affiliation as an informational shortcut.[23] Sean Trende argued that despite their ignorance, voters get the important things right.[24] Jeffrey Friedman agreed that voters are ignorant, but claimed that rational ignorance was not the correct explanation of the phenomenon. Rather, he claimed that voters had a simplistic model of the world.[25] Somin responded to all his critics and there was some further exchange of views between the participants.[21]

The Cato Institute organized a book event to discuss the book, scheduled for November 6, 2013. Participants at the event included Somin, John Sides of George Washington University, and John Samples of the Cato Institute.[26]

Other mentions[edit]

An article in Manila Times discussed Somin's book in the context of political protest movements in the Philippines.[27]

Relation with other work[edit]

Bryan Caplan's work on rational irrationality[edit]

Bryan Caplan, Somin's colleague at George Mason University, is a proponent of the theory of rational irrationality as an explanation of democratic failure. Caplan rejects many of the public choice arguments for rational ignorance, while embracing the traditional conclusions of public choice. He has expounded on his thesis in the book The Myth of the Rational Voter. Somin departs from traditional public choice theorists by carving out an important place for rational irrationality, while at the same time disagreeing with Caplan's assertion that rational ignorance alone would not be a problem. Somin expressed his key points in blog posts and elaborated further in Chapter 3 of his book.[28][29]

Jason Brennan's book on the ethics of voting[edit]

Somin has noted at multiple places in his book and on his blog that his book and work on political ignorance is closely related to The Ethics of Voting, a book by political philosopher Jason Brennan.[30][31]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Somin, Ilya. Democracy and Political Ignorance: Why Smaller Government Is Smarter. Stanford Law Books, a division of Stanford University Press. ISBN 978-0804786614. 
  2. ^ Somin, Ilya. "Democracy and Political Ignorance: Why Smaller Government Is Smarter (introduction)" (PDF). Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  3. ^ Somin, Ilya. "Democracy and Political Ignorance: Why Smaller Government is Smarter". Amazon (Kindle edition). Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  4. ^ https://www.amazon.com/Democracy-Political-Ignorance-Smaller-Government/dp/0804799318/
  5. ^ https://www.amazon.it/Democrazia-ignoranza-politica-Perch%C3%A9-sbaglia/dp/8864401687/
  6. ^ http://www.shinzansha.co.jp/book/b217629.html
  7. ^ Somin, Ilya (2013-10-04). "Why Political Ignorance Matters". Balkinization. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  8. ^ Somin, Ilya (2013-10-04). "Why Political Ignorance is a Serious Problem". Balkinization. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  9. ^ Somin, Ilya (2013-10-06). "Can Education or Information Shortcuts Overcome Political Ignorance?". Balkinization. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  10. ^ Somin, Ilya (2013-10-07). "Foot Voting vs. Ballot Box Voting". Balkinization. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  11. ^ Somin, Ilya (2013-10-08). "Political Ignorance and Judicial Review". Balkinization. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  12. ^ Shafer, Jack (2013-10-08). "More media won't solve political ignorance". Reuters. Retrieved 2013-10-25. 
  13. ^ Schmidt, Christopher (2013-10-10). "Somin on Democracy and Political Ignorance". IIT Chicago-Kent Law blog network. Retrieved 2013-10-25. 
  14. ^ Hinkle, A. Barton (2013-10-27). "Hinkle: Cure for ignorant voters - really small governments". Richmond Times-Dispatch. Retrieved 2013-10-27. 
  15. ^ Dyche, John David (2013-11-15). "Democracy and Political Ignorance". WDRB. Retrieved 2013-11-15. 
  16. ^ David H. "Democracy and Political Ignorance". Retrieved 2013-11-23. 
  17. ^ Will, George F. (January 1, 2014). "The price of political ignorance: More government". Washington Post. Retrieved January 1, 2014. 
  18. ^ Brennan, Jason (2013-09-30). "Ilya Somin: Democracy and Political Ignorance". Bleeding Heart Libertarians. Retrieved 2013-10-25. 
  19. ^ Boudreaux, Donald (2013-09-30). "Ilya Somin: Democracy and Political Ignorance". Cafe Hayek. Retrieved 2013-10-25. 
  20. ^ Somin, Ilya (2013-10-11). "Democracy and Political Ignorance". Cato Unbound. Retrieved 2013-10-14. 
  21. ^ a b "Is Smaller Government Smarter Government?". Cato Unbound. October 2013. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  22. ^ "Is Smaller Government Smarter Government?". Cato Unbound (lead essay). October 2013. Retrieved 2013-10-14. 
  23. ^ Gerken, Heather (2013-10-14). "The Fox and the Hedgehog: How Do We Achieve Political Accountability Given What Voters (Don't) Know?". Cato Unbound (response essay). Retrieved 2013-10-14. 
  24. ^ Trende, Sean (2013-10-16). "Don't Voters Get Things Right?". Cato Unbound. Retrieved 2013-10-25. 
  25. ^ Friedman, Jeffery (2013-10-18). "Ignorance, Yes. Rational, No". Cato Unbound. Retrieved 2013-10-25. 
  26. ^ "Democracy and Political Ignorance: Why Smaller Government Is Smarter". Cato Institute. 2013-11-06. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  27. ^ Ronquillo, Marlen (2013-10-15). "Wanna change pork and other public anomalies?". Manila Times. Retrieved 2013-10-25. 
  28. ^ Somin, Ilya (2007-05-17). "Bryan Caplan's Myth of the Rational Voter". Retrieved 2013-07-09. 
  29. ^ Somin, Ilya (2013-02-03). "Transparency and Political Ignorance". Volokh Conspiracy. Retrieved 2013-07-09. 
  30. ^ Somin, Ilya (2013-10-03). "Introducing my New Book Democracy and Political Ignorance". Volokh Conspiracy. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 
  31. ^ Somin, Ilya (2011-04-12). "Jason Brennan's The Ethics of Voting". Volokh Conspiracy. Retrieved 2013-10-26. 

External links[edit]