Franco-Dutch treaty on Saint Martin border controls
| Treaty between the Kingdom of the Netherlands and the French Republic on the control of persons entering Saint Martin through the airports. Traité entre le Royaume des Pays-Bas et la République française sur le contrôle des personnes entrant dans Saint Martin dans les aéroports. Verdrag tussen het Koninkrijk der Nederlanden en de Franse Republiek inzake personencontrole op de luchthavens op Sint Maarten. | |
|---|---|
| Signed | 17 May 1994 |
| Location | Paris, France |
| Effective | 1 August 2007 |
| Signatories | Kingdom of the Netherlands and France |
| Languages | French and Dutch |
The Franco-Dutch treaty on Saint Martin border controls, often called the Franco-Dutch treaty (formally: Treaty between the Kingdom of the Netherlands and the French Republic on the control of persons entering Saint Martin through the airports. French:Traité entre le Royaume des Pays-Bas et la République française sur le contrôle des personnes entrant dans Saint Martin dans les aéroports. Dutch:Verdrag tussen het Koninkrijk der Nederlanden en de Franse Republiek inzake personencontrole op de luchthavens op Sint Maarten.) is a treaty between the Kingdom of the Netherlands and France aimed at improving border controls at the two airports on the island of Saint Martin, which is composed of the Dutch Sint Maarten and the French Collectivity of Saint Martin.
The airports concerned are Princess Juliana International Airport and L'Espérance Airport.
History
The treaty was signed on 17 May 1994 in Paris, and is drawn up in both a French and Dutch original.
Ratification
Ratification proved to be difficult in the Netherlands. An advice from the Estates of the Netherlands Antilles, which said that the treaty would have negative effects on Sint Maarten's tourist industry, initially blocked the ratification. There had also been objections about the authority of the committee (see below). The parliament of the Kingdom of the Netherlands decided in 1999 to hold off ratification until Sint Maarten made its position clear. Sint Maarten's position was never made clear, however. After France put pressure on the Dutch government, the treaty was eventually ratified in 2006, much to the dismay of the leader of the People's Progressive Alliance.[1]
| Signatory | Conclusion date | Institution | 
|
|
AB | Entry into force[2] | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Netherlands
|
14 September 2006 | House of Representatives | 130 | 0 | 0 | 1 August 2007 | [3] |
| 17 October 2006 | Senate | 66 | 0 | 0 | [4] | ||
| 20 October 2006 | Royal Assent | Granted | [5] | ||||
 France
|
13 July 1995 | National Assembly | ? | ? | ? | [6] | |
| 21 July 1995 | Senate | ? | ? | ? | [6] | ||
| 27 July 1995 | Presidential Assent | Granted | [6] | ||||
Entry into force and implementation
Article 18 specifies that the treaty enters into force on the first day of the third month following a written declaration of both parties that the constitutional ratification procedure has been completed. The treaty entered into force on 1 August 2007.[2]
Provisions
The treaty allows for joint border controls to be carried out at the airports of Saint Martin. The treaty specifies that in order for an alien to be admitted to Saint Martin, he needs to have a visa (or a landing permit) for both the Dutch side and the French side. This has caused some controversy on the Dutch side, as that part has a more relaxed visa regime. The French part is an outermost region of the European Union and thus uses its visa list.[7]
Originally, this caused nationals from thirteen countries in the Caribbean region to require visa to land on Princess Juliana Airport which they did not require before. After negotiations, France agreed to limit the additional visa requirements to four countries in the region: Dominica, Jamaica, Guyana and Suriname. There are negotiations to remove Suriname from the list as well.[7]
Joint border controls will be executed at risk flights at both airports. The committee and the working group that have been established by article 13 will draw up a list of flights to be subjected to joint border control. Both the committee and the working group are composed of representatives from both sides and meet once a year.[7]
Implementation is held back by Sint Maarten, whose governor Sarah Wescot-Williams said that implementation will harm tourist interests. The treaty was to be implemented on 1 April 2009, but it was postponed as the working group was still not installed.[8]
As of October 2010, the treaty is still not implemented.[9][needs update]
See also
- Treaty of Concordia
- Visa policy in the European Union
- Visa policy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands in the Caribbean
References
- ^ The Daily Herald - Dutch Parliament ratifies Franco-Dutch Treaty
- ^ a b Tractatenblad van het Koninkrijk der Nederlanden, Jaargang 2007, nummer 121 (3 July 2007)
- ^ Handelingen 107de vergadering van de Tweede Kamer -- the bill was adopted without voting, 130 parliamentarians were present.
- ^ Template:Nl icon 24.074 (R1531) - Verdrag personencontrole luchthavens Sint Maarten -- the bill was adopted without voting, 66 senators were present.
- ^ Template:Nl icon Staatsblad van het Koninkrijk der Nederlanden, Jaargang 2006, nummer 541 (9 November 2006)
- ^ a b c Loi no 95-854 du 27 juillet 1995 autorisant l'approbation de l'accord entre le Gouvernement de la République française et le Gouvernement du Royaume des Pays-Bas concernant le contrôle de personnes sur les aéroports de Saint-Martin (in French). See also: [Paliametary procedure p.733 §89 http://archives.assemblee-nationale.fr/10/tanalytique/1995-1996_tmatieres_AV.pdf]
- ^ a b c Governor of Sint Maarten - Implementation of the Franco-Dutch Treaty
- ^ smn-news.com - Police and Foreign Affairs busy Discussing Franco Dutch Treaty
- ^ Winnfm.com - St. Maarten to Control Its Own Immigration