Brooklyn, New York
|Died||April 6, 1926
|Other names||G. Vincent Colwell, C. W. Eldridge, The Gentleman Bandit, George Clark, George Chartres, Maxwell Winters, Count of Gramercy Park|
|Criminal status||Executed by hanging|
|Conviction(s)||First-degree murder (April 4, 1925)|
Gerald Chapman (August, 1887 – April 6, 1926), known as "The Count of Gramercy Park","The Gentleman Bandit" and "Gentleman Gerald", was an American criminal who helped lead an early Prohibition-era gang from 1919 until the mid-1920s. Chapman was the first criminal to be dubbed "Public Enemy Number One" by the press.
Crimes and escapes
Gerald Chapman was born George Chartres in August 1887 to parents of Irish heritage. Arrested for the first time in 1902 at age fourteen, Chapman was incarcerated for most of his early adult life. While serving time for bank robbery, he was transferred from Sing Sing to Auburn State Prison, and became acquainted with highly educated Danish-born con man George "Dutch" Anderson in 1908. With Anderson as his mentor, Chapman became a voracious reader and a self-styled gentleman, often affecting a British accent. Following both men's paroles in 1919, they began bootlegging operations in Toledo, Miami and New York City over the next two years.
In late 1921, along with former Auburn inmate Charles Loeber, Chapman and Anderson began committing armed robberies. On October 24, the three men forced a U.S. Mail truck to stop at gunpoint on Leonard Street, successfully taking $2.4 million in cash, bonds and jewelry. Their identities were unknown to the police for months, and Chapman lived the life of an aristocrat, residing with his mistress in New York's fashionable Gramercy Park neighborhood. The three men were eventually arrested by United States Postal Inspectors William Doran, Jim Doyle and William Cochraine on July 3, 1922, after Chapman attempted to sell Argentine gold notes (stolen during the Leonard Street mail robbery) to an undercover postal inspector posing as a stock broker. Chapman made headlines when he briefly got away from his interrogators at police headquarters, but he was caught before he could leave the building.
Chapman and Anderson were both sentenced to 25 years' imprisonment and ordered to serve their time at the Atlanta Federal Prison. Chapman escaped from the prison on March 27, 1923, knocking out the facility's power in the process. He was wounded and captured a couple of days later in eastern Georgia, but within a week escaped the hospital, adding to his national notoriety. Anderson broke out of the Atlanta prison on December 30, 1923. The two men reunited, and were suspected by authorities in several hold-ups.
On October 12, 1924, while on a crime spree in Connecticut, Chapman murdered Officer James Skelly of the New Britain Police Department. The officer was killed in a gunfight with Chapman after interrupting a theft at a store. Though an accomplice was caught and quickly identified Chapman as the perpetrator, authorities initially refused to believe that the notorious bandit had been operating unnoticed in their area. Chapman's role was eventually confirmed through other evidence.
Chapman was recaptured on January 18, 1925, in Muncie, Indiana, based on authorities being tipped off by informant Ben Hance. During his apprehension, Chapman fired at a police officer but missed. President Calvin Coolidge was convinced to reduce the robbery sentence of Chapman in federal prison to time served, and Chapman was then handed over to the Connecticut authorities.
Hance and his wife were shot to death when their car was forced off a road outside Muncie on August 11, 1925. Authorities blamed the killings on Anderson and an accomplice (who was later convicted), and the suspected motive was revenge for Chapman's incarceration. On October 31, 1925, "Dutch" Anderson and Police Officer Charles Hammond died in a shootout in Muskegon, Michigan.
Trial and execution
During Chapman's six-day murder trial in Hartford, Connecticut, crowds gathered due to his status as one of the "top 10" criminals in America. The jury deliberated for 11 hours, after which Chapman was found guilty and eventually sentenced to hang. He proclaimed his innocence to the end, asking in his final appeal for "justice, not mercy". Chapman was executed by the upright jerker on April 6, 1926.
- ("The First 'Public Enemy Number One'")
- (Downey 2008, p. 17)
- (Jeffers 1993, p. 24)
- (Jeffers 1993, p. 18)
- (New York Times & 25 October 1921)
- (Jeffers 1993, pp. 77, 84)
- (Jeffers 1993, p. 110)
- (Jeffers 1993, pp. 154–157)
- (Jeffers 1993, p. 233)
- (Jeffers 1993, pp. 221–223)
- (New York Times & 6 April 1926)
- (Jeffers 1993, p. 242)
- ("Executions in Connecticut Since 1894")
- Downey, Patrick (2008), Bad Seeds in the Big Apple: Bandits, Killers and Chaos in New York City, 1920-40, Cumberland House, ISBN 978-1-58182-646-3
- Jeffers, H. Paul (1993), Gentleman Gerald: The Crimes and Times of Gerald Chapman, America's First "Public Enemy No.1", St. Martin's Press, ISBN 978-0-312-13500-3
- "Executions in Connecticut Since 1894". Connecticut State Library. Archived from the original on 20 September 2010. Retrieved 19 January 2010.
- "U.S. MAIL HELD UP IN BROADWAY; LOOT MAY BE $1,000,000" (PDF). The New York Times. 25 October 1921. Retrieved 19 January 2010.
- "$2,400,000 HOLD-UP OF MAILS DESCRIBED; One of 3 Arrested for Truck Robbery Tells All Details in U.S. Court" (PDF). The New York Times. 17 August 1922. Retrieved 15 April 2010.
- "FOUGHT FOR HIS LIFE CHAINED TO BURGLAR; Detective, with His Own Revolver Pressed Against Him, Dared Thief to Shoot." (PDF). The New York Times. 29 October 1911. Retrieved 15 April 2010.
- "CHAPMAN IS HANGED AT 12:04 A.M. AFTER HIS LAST PLEA FAILS". The New York Times. 6 April 1926. Retrieved 19 January 2010.
- "The First "Public Enemy Number One"". Smithsonian National Postal Museum. Retrieved 19 January 2010.
- "The Real Truth about Chapman—America's 'Super-Bandit', Part One". True Detective Mysteries: 40ff. November 1929. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- "The Real Truth about Chapman—America's 'Super-Bandit', Part Two". True Detective Mysteries: 55ff. December 1929. Retrieved 13 July 2016.