Hantaro Nagaoka

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Saturnian model)
Jump to: navigation, search
Hantaro Nagaoka
Hantaro Nagaoka.jpg
Born (1865-08-19)August 19, 1865
Ōmura, Nagasaki
Died December 11, 1950(1950-12-11) (aged 85)
Nationality  Japan
Fields Physics
Notable students Kotaro Honda, Hideki Yukawa
Relief of Nagaoka in Science Museum in Tokyo

Hantaro Nagaoka (長岡 半太郎 Nagaoka Hantarō?, August 19, 1865 – December 11, 1950) was a Japanese physicist and a pioneer of Japanese physics during the Meiji period.


Nagaoka was born in Nagasaki, Japan, and educated at Tokyo University. After graduating with a degree in physics in 1887, Nagaoka worked with a visiting Scottish physicist, Cargill Gilston Knott, on early problems in magnetism, namely magnetostriction in liquid nickel. In 1893, Nagaoka traveled to Europe, where he continued his education at the universities of Berlin, Munich, and Vienna, including courses with James Clerk Maxwell on Saturn's rings and Ludwig Boltzmann and his Kinetic Theory of Gases, two influences which would be reflected in Nagaoka's later work. Nagaoka also attended, in 1900, the First International Congress of Physicists in Paris, where he heard Marie Curie lecture on radioactivity, an event that aroused Nagaoka's interest in atomic physics. Nagaoka returned to Japan in 1901 and served as professor of physics at Tokyo University until 1925. After his retirement from Tokyo University, Nagaoka was appointed a head scientist at RIKEN, and also served as the first president of Osaka University, from 1931 to 1934.

Saturnian model of the atom[edit]

Physicists in 1900 had just begun to consider the structure of the atom. The recent discovery by J. J. Thomson of the negatively charged electron implied that a neutral atom must also contain an opposite positive charge. In 1903, Thomson had suggested that the atom was a sphere of uniform positive electrification, with electrons scattered through it like plums in a pudding, giving rise to the term plum pudding model.

Nagaoka rejected Thomson's model on the grounds that opposite charges are impenetrable. In 1904, Nagaoka proposed an alternative planetary model of the atom in which a positively charged center is surrounded by a number of revolving electrons, in the manner of Saturn and its rings.[1]

Nagaoka's model made two predictions:

  • a very massive atomic center (in analogy to a very massive planet)
  • electrons revolving around the nucleus, bound by electrostatic forces (in analogy to the rings revolving around Saturn, bound by gravitational forces).

Both predictions were successfully confirmed by Ernest Rutherford, who mentions Nagaoka's model in his 1911 paper in which the atomic nucleus is proposed. However, other details of the model were incorrect. In particular, electrically charged rings would be unstable due to repulsive disruption. Nagaoka himself abandoned his proposed model in 1908.

Rutherford and Niels Bohr would present the more viable Bohr model in 1913.

Other works[edit]

Nagaoka later did research in spectroscopy and other fields. In 1909, he published a paper on the inductance of solenoids.[2] In March 1924, he described studies in which he had successfully formed a milligram of gold and some platinum from mercury.[3] In 1929 he became the first person to describe meteor burst communications.[4]

Awards and recognition[edit]


  1. ^ B. Bryson (2003). A Short History of Nearly Everything. Broadway Books. ISBN 0-7679-0817-1. 
  2. ^ Nagaoka, Hantaro (1909-05-06). "The Inductance Coefficients of Solenoids" (PDF). Journal of the College of Science (Tokyo, Japan: Imperial University) 27 (6): 18 
  3. ^ Robert A. Nelson. (1998). "Transmutations of Mercury to Gold". Adept Alchemy. Rex Research. Retrieved 16 August 2014.  On line by The Alchemy web site on Levity.com.
  4. ^ Hantaro Nagaoka (1929). "Possibility of the radio transmission being disturbed by meteoric showers". Tokyo Imperial Academy, Proceedings 5 (6): 233–236.  Cited in Wilhelm Nupen (1961). Bibliography on meteoric radio wave propagation. Washington: U.S. National Bureau of Standards. p. 76. Retrieved 17 August 2014. 

External links[edit]

  • [1] H. Nagaoka
  • [2] Historical Figures of RIKEN