Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
Biased Article? |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Biased Article?
|
Religioustolerance.org |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Religioustolerance.org
|
Moved from Alienus' talk page. |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Moved from Alienus' talk page.
|
Pseudoscience? |
8 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Pseudoscience?
|
This is pure pseudoscientific propaganda... |
51 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#This is pure pseudoscientific propaganda...
|
Defining the syndrome; recognize too many recognized |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Defining the syndrome; recognize too many recognized
|
NPOV and this article |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#NPOV and this article
|
Consensus |
8 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Consensus
|
Clarification (POV) |
14 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Clarification (POV)
|
Speedy delete |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Speedy delete
|
Changing what sources say |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Changing what sources say
|
PAS vs Postpartum depression |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#PAS vs Postpartum depression
|
Studies |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Studies
|
Intro and Background |
25 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Intro and Background
|
Pseudoscience Criteria |
18 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Pseudoscience Criteria
|
APA briefing paper |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#APA briefing paper
|
Support sites and forums |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Support sites and forums
|
Rename |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Rename
|
Pseudoscience? |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Pseudoscience? 2
|
Starting paragraph |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 1#Starting paragraph
|
DSM III's mention of abortion as a stressor |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#DSM III's mention of abortion as a stressor
|
PAS Specific Studies |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#PAS Specific Studies
|
Dealing with Elliot Institute "studies" |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Dealing with Elliot Institute "studies"
|
Proposed title change on section |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Proposed title change on section
|
Proposed clarification on who uses term PAS |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Proposed clarification on who uses term PAS
|
"Purging Campaign" Proves Extreme Bias of Article |
10 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#"Purging Campaign" Proves Extreme Bias of Article
|
Just before I start things |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Just before I start things
|
The article is extremely biased |
10 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#The article is extremely biased
|
Problems with Representation of Empirical Studies |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Problems with Representation of Empirical Studies
|
"Neutral or positive effect of abortion" doesn't belong here |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#"Neutral or positive effect of abortion" doesn't belong here
|
NPOV comes up several times on talk page and has never been resolved. |
40 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#NPOV comes up several times on talk page and has never been resolved.
|
Lack of pro-PAS studies |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Lack of pro-PAS studies
|
Voice of Experience's comment |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Voice of Experience's comment
|
This is an uninformed contributor posting a biased and unresearched article!! |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#This is an uninformed contributor posting a biased and unresearched article!!
|
Protests on m:OTRS |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Protests on m:OTRS
|
Which version is better (Finnish study)? |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Which version is better (Finnish study)?
|
No Consensus |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#No Consensus
|
Should this be in Category:Pseudoscience? |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Should this be in Category:Pseudoscience?
|
Clean up of Wrong Inferences added Start of a Sequential History of this Debate |
10 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Clean up of Wrong Inferences added Start of a Sequential History of this Debate
|
More of the same |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#More of the same
|
Reliable Sources -- Wikipeida Policy re Reardon Studies |
13 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Reliable Sources -- Wikipeida Policy re Reardon Studies
|
Reliable Sources -- Wikipeida Policy re Reardon Studies |
16 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Reliable Sources -- Wikipeida Policy re Reardon Studies 2
|
South Africa Study |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#South Africa Study
|
Better Organization and NPOV introduction |
8 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Better Organization and NPOV introduction
|
Inexperienced canvasing |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Inexperienced canvasing
|
NPOV problems |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#NPOV problems
|
Inferences Introducing Factual Errors |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Inferences Introducing Factual Errors
|
Proper WEIGHT |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Proper WEIGHT
|
Term used by opponents of abortion |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Term used by opponents of abortion
|
Abortion in Spain |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Abortion in Spain
|
What studies? |
8 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#What studies?
|
J Soc Issues |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#J Soc Issues
|
Abuse of WEIGHT Argument |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Abuse of WEIGHT Argument
|
Mass deletion of material should stop |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Mass deletion of material should stop
|
RfC: Disagreement over the neutrality of post-abortion syndrome |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#RfC: Disagreement over the neutrality of post-abortion syndrome
|
Intro Going Biased Again |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#Intro Going Biased Again
|
War |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 2#War
|
Two Kinds of Evidence Define WEIGHT |
14 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Two Kinds of Evidence Define WEIGHT
|
End this |
16 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#End this
|
Bazelon's Errors, Biases, and Distortions |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Bazelon's Errors, Biases, and Distortions
|
Weight Should Not Be An Excuse to Blank Verifiable Material |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Weight Should Not Be An Excuse to Blank Verifiable Material
|
Grimes' Biased Review |
15 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Grimes' Biased Review
|
Causal Connections & Post-Partum Syndrome and Post-Abortion Syndrome |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Causal Connections & Post-Partum Syndrome and Post-Abortion Syndrome
|
I find this quite worrying |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#I find this quite worrying
|
"Feelings experienced after miscarriage or abortion" |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#"Feelings experienced after miscarriage or abortion"
|
Ongoing misrepresentation |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Ongoing misrepresentation
|
Material that should be included |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Material that should be included
|
Stubbing the article |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Stubbing the article
|
Is NOW really non-aligned? |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Is NOW really non-aligned?
|
Is shorter better? |
9 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Is shorter better?
|
Sources don't supported statement |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Sources don't supported statement
|
Proposed edit to lead section, by Strider |
20 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#Proposed edit to lead section, by Strider
|
What's in a name? |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#What's in a name?
|
More Stubbing Needed? |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 3#More Stubbing Needed?
|
Sidebar |
29 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Sidebar
|
The title needs to be changed |
12 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#The title needs to be changed
|
Lead section |
9 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Lead section
|
Consensus |
10 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Consensus
|
Structure for History of Debate & Evidence |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Structure for History of Debate & Evidence
|
What This Article Is About |
15 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#What This Article Is About
|
Integration of lede content, removal of uncited content |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Integration of lede content, removal of uncited content
|
Proposed Editing Policy to Avoid Edit Warring |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Proposed Editing Policy to Avoid Edit Warring
|
Sources |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Sources
|
The intro paragraph is too short |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#The intro paragraph is too short
|
Koop |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Koop
|
Do Not Cause Disruption by Deleting Verifiable Information |
14 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Do Not Cause Disruption by Deleting Verifiable Information
|
Peer Reviewed Studies as Reliable Secondary Soruces |
15 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Peer Reviewed Studies as Reliable Secondary Soruces
|
Negative effects of abortion |
17 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Negative effects of abortion
|
Stotland |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Stotland
|
Suicide |
29 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 4#Suicide
|
Recent edit |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Recent edit
|
Anchor links in lead |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Anchor links in lead
|
Tagging of problems |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Tagging of problems
|
Koop and the lead |
8 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Koop and the lead
|
Soderberg |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Soderberg
|
Clearly Unbalanced Sections |
8 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Clearly Unbalanced Sections
|
Hanna Söderberg -- Reactions One Year Post-Abortion |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Hanna Söderberg -- Reactions One Year Post-Abortion
|
Differentiation between negative effects and mental health effects |
9 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Differentiation between negative effects and mental health effects
|
More Unjustified Deletions |
27 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#More Unjustified Deletions
|
List of reactions |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#List of reactions
|
Supplying complete congressional quote in footnote |
12 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Supplying complete congressional quote in footnote
|
Notes on Priscilla Coleman |
9 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Notes on Priscilla Coleman
|
Mika Gissler |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Mika Gissler
|
Koop and Congress |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Koop and Congress
|
"Little scientific controversy" |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#"Little scientific controversy"
|
Please clarify |
8 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#Please clarify
|
Deleting 'disputed text" |
21 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Deleting 'disputed text"
|
"... requires a fee" |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 5#"... requires a fee"
|
Question from outsider |
14 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Question from outsider
|
Primary/Secondary and Reliability |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Primary/Secondary and Reliability
|
Studies |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Studies
|
Sources are hard to verify |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Sources are hard to verify
|
Coleman Review as Undisputedly Reliable Secondary Source |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Coleman Review as Undisputedly Reliable Secondary Source
|
Intro and PTSD Section |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Intro and PTSD Section
|
Intro & PAS Section |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Intro & PAS Section
|
Consensus Statements |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Consensus Statements
|
Auto Archive |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Auto Archive
|
Intro |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Intro
|
Gregory Wilmoth |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Gregory Wilmoth 3
|
Criticisms of the missing Reardon |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Criticisms of the missing Reardon
|
Opinion vs Opinions / Rebuttals / Affiliations & Guilt by Association |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Opinion vs Opinions / Rebuttals / Affiliations & Guilt by Association
|
Majority View Is Now that Abortion Has Mental Health Risks |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Majority View Is Now that Abortion Has Mental Health Risks
|
Royal College of Psychiatrists |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Royal College of Psychiatrists
|
What is the majority view? |
9 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#What is the majority view?
|
Clean up OR and inferences |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Clean up OR and inferences
|
Project Rachel |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Project Rachel
|
1987-1990 APA Task Force Review |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#1987-1990 APA Task Force Review
|
Edit warring |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Edit warring
|
Why are we reporting a statistically insignificant result? |
9 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Why are we reporting a statistically insignificant result?
|
Please be careful when deleting material |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Please be careful when deleting material
|
Unwarranted Blanking of Material |
9 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Unwarranted Blanking of Material
|
A reliable source for deleted statement |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#A reliable source for deleted statement
|
United States Surgeon General |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#United States Surgeon General
|
Ordering of subsections |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Ordering of subsections
|
Article is poor |
14 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Article is poor
|
Orderly edits |
12 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Orderly edits
|
Let's pause, take a few breaths, and figure out how to proceed from here |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 6#Let's pause, take a few breaths, and figure out how to proceed from here
|
Reordered |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Reordered
|
Opening paragraph |
9 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Opening paragraph
|
Too many studies |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Too many studies
|
Lead sentence |
16 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Lead sentence
|
Fogel -Washington Post |
13 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Fogel -Washington Post
|
Supreme Court - Abortion "fraught with emotional consequence" |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Supreme Court - Abortion "fraught with emotional consequence"
|
Reorg |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Reorg
|
Coleman Bio |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Coleman Bio
|
Reorg'd |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Reorg'd
|
Columbia Journal |
10 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Columbia Journal
|
Moved from article for discussion |
12 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Moved from article for discussion
|
APA Task Force Confirms Abortion is not a Threat to Mental Health |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#APA Task Force Confirms Abortion is not a Threat to Mental Health
|
Article Biased by Incredibly Selective Use of Sources & Misrepresentation |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Article Biased by Incredibly Selective Use of Sources & Misrepresentation
|
New study from Johns Hopkins University |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#New study from Johns Hopkins University
|
Mother v. Pregnant Woman, the saga continues |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Mother v. Pregnant Woman, the saga continues
|
This article needs to assume that professionals DISAGREE on this major issue. It currently basically assumes only one side. |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#This article needs to assume that professionals DISAGREE on this major issue. It currently basically assumes only one side.
|
This article needs to assume that professionals DISAGREE on this major issue. It currently basically assumes only one side. |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#This article needs to assume that professionals DISAGREE on this major issue. It currently basically assumes only one side. 2
|
For future reference |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#For future reference
|
This article is untrue. |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#This article is untrue.
|
"Abortion and mental health disorders: evidence from a 30-year longitudinal study" |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#"Abortion and mental health disorders: evidence from a 30-year longitudinal study"
|
Potential sources |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Potential sources
|
Potential sources |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Potential sources 2
|
Coleman's new meta-analysis |
24 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Coleman's new meta-analysis
|
The inclusion of cleanup tags |
24 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#The inclusion of cleanup tags
|
If AAPLOG is too small to mention, what about ACOG? |
10 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#If AAPLOG is too small to mention, what about ACOG?
|
97 publications supporting a correlation between abortion and mental health problems |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#97 publications supporting a correlation between abortion and mental health problems
|
Rename this Article? Split article? |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Rename this Article? Split article?
|
Chili Study |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Chili Study
|
New study |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#New study
|
Request for Specific Names |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#Request for Specific Names
|
Factual Error found in Regard to the Royal College of Psychiatrists |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Factual Error found in Regard to the Royal College of Psychiatrists
|
American Psychological Association |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 7#American Psychological Association
|
Fergusson et al. |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Fergusson et al.
|
Recent review of scientific studies on the question |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Recent review of scientific studies on the question
|
I would like to get your opinion on this review |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#I would like to get your opinion on this review
|
recent edits |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#recent edits
|
NuclearWarfare's revert of my edit |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#NuclearWarfare's revert of my edit
|
Agreed |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Agreed
|
references |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#references
|
Mental health and abortion law |
13 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Mental health and abortion law
|
External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#External links modified
|
Missing areas |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Missing areas
|
External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#External links modified 2
|
Major Revision May Be Necessary |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Major Revision May Be Necessary
|
Intro Summary of APA Task Force Findings |
6 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Intro Summary of APA Task Force Findings
|
Horvath & Schreiber (2017) |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Horvath & Schreiber (2017)
|
Coleman (2011) Must be Included as a Reliable Secondary Source |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Coleman (2011) Must be Included as a Reliable Secondary Source
|
Recommendations Regarding Attempt to Streamline Article |
11 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Recommendations Regarding Attempt to Streamline Article
|
Request for Clarification of Objections to moving 1989 APA review to history section |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Request for Clarification of Objections to moving 1989 APA review to history section
|
Weight and MEDRS Concerns |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Weight and MEDRS Concerns
|
Important paper on this topic missing |
5 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Important paper on this topic missing
|
DSM |
4 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#DSM
|
Recent edits |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Recent edits 2
|
Necessity for including MEDRS Reviews in order to provide Due Weight |
24 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Necessity for including MEDRS Reviews in order to provide Due Weight
|
Notice that this Article Lacks Balanced POV per reliable peer reviewed literature reviews |
18 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Notice that this Article Lacks Balanced POV per reliable peer reviewed literature reviews
|
Globalization |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health/Archive 8#Globalization
|
changes to article |
1 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health#changes to article
|
Imbalance of article is potentially harmful |
7 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health#Imbalance of article is potentially harmful
|
Unbalanced and Potentially Misleading Lead/Introduction |
8 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health#Unbalanced and Potentially Misleading Lead/Introduction
|
Criticisms September 2021 |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health#Criticisms September 2021
|
Lead: First 2 sentences slight rearrangement? |
3 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health#Lead: First 2 sentences slight rearrangement?
|
See also |
2 |
Talk:Abortion and mental health#See also
|