Jump to content

Talk:Chaotic Neutral (album)

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Who the tracks are by

[edit]

At least 11 of Matthew Good's album releases have a note at the top of the tracklisting that states 'All songs written by Matthew Good except where noted.'

This was written at the top of Chaotic Neutral. I deemed it to be incorrect as track 8, Cloudbusting, is originally by Kate Bush. So I amended the text to read 'All tracks written by Matthew Good except Cloudbusting by Kate Bush.' My bad, perhaps, in line with the rest of the albums, I should have written Kate Bush's name against track eight and put '.....except where noted.' But as it mentions Holly McNarland singing on the track as well, I thought it looked cluttered. So I put it at the top.

Matthewgoodfan101 removed it from the page soon after. In fact S/he took away the entire 'All songs...' statement completely, and hasn't put it back or amended it. I asked why on her/his talkpage, but there has been no reply.That was five weeks ago. Here's what I want to know;

  • Why was it removed? There is no reason given for its removal.
  • Why has some other wording not been put back in its place?
  • Why has matthewgoodfan101 seen fit to ignore me when I politely asked why on her/his talkpage?

What I did was factually correct and not vandalism. As s/he created the page, I suspect WP:OWN.

Over to you Matthewgoodfan101. The joy of all things (talk) 23:26, 28 February 2016 (UTC)[reply]