Talk:Mazurkas, Op. 59 (Chopin)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
WikiProject Classical music
WikiProject icon Mazurkas, Op. 59 (Chopin) is within the scope of WikiProject Classical music, which aims to improve, expand, copy edit, and maintain all articles related to classical music, that are not covered by other classical music related projects. Please read the guidelines for writing and maintaining articles. To participate, you can edit this article or visit the project page for more details.

Copyright violation[edit]

The following is Mazurkas (3) for piano, Op. 59, CT. 86-88 Composition Description, by Kristen Grimshaw, published in Allmusic

In bold are the parts used verbatim in Wikipedia article on Chopin's Op. 59

  • "Although Chopin spent most of his adult life Paris, his roots were Polish. In homage to his homeland, he developed two genres of music, the polonaise and the mazurka. The mazurka takes much of its form from the native folk songs and dances of Poland, specifically the Mazur, the Kujawiak, and the Oberek. The unusual rhythmic patterns and irregular accents provided the basis for 57 mazurkas in total, each unique in character and texture. Because of the different sources of inspiration for the mazurka, each piece is a different combination of several ingredients of rhythm, harmony, tempo, and mood. This particular genre, more than any other, encouraged Chopin to revise and experiment freely. Unlike many of his other mazurkas collections, the pieces of Op. 59 do not contrast greatly amongst themselves. They share similar characteristics and textures, perhaps meant to unify the collection. The first piece in the set is highly chromatic, warm and rich in melodic and contrapuntal nuances. It serves as a tender portrait, the ending as unassuming as the opening. Pleasant and good-natured in its character, the second mazurka features a rich exchange between hands, a hallmark of Chopin's mature style. This piece ends with an ascending, winding lyrical line, which seems to disappear into the clouds. Resembling a polonaise, the third composition is noble and waltz-like in character. Having experimented with different contrapuntal devices, Chopin includes chromaticism, as well as some interesting descending chromatic chords in the accompaniment. While much interesting harmonic material is found in the lower voices, this particular composition is defined by the unaffected, expressive singing melody appears to be unaffected, soaring above the texture below."

As with Chopin's Op. 17 and Op. 33 articles, this is another case of copyright violation, from same source: Allmusic.

Frania W. (talk) 02:21, 26 December 2009 (UTC)

Copyright status of sheet music (two) photographs[edit]

What is the copyright status of the two photographs of the first four measures of Op. 59 N° 2 and N° 3?

They are made by wiki editor Etincelles (talk), but they represent part of a published page of music. Etincelles has not given the name of the publisher, the place of publication, the year, leaving us in total ignorance of the edition these few measures are taken from.

A page of music is like the page of a book: taking a photograph with the intention of publishing it should not be done without prior authorisation of the publisher. This is not about Chopin's copyrights here, but about the copyrights of a modern publisher, whose name is not even given.

Frania W. (talk) 19:07, 31 December 2009 (UTC)