Talk:Phoenix Shot Tower
|WikiProject Maryland / Baltimore||(Rated Start-class, Low-importance)|
|WikiProject National Register of Historic Places||(Rated Start-class, High-importance)|
From the article:
- "Charles Carroll of Carrollton...laid its cornerstone."
A structure without corners has a cornerstone? I believe in these cases it's called a "foundation stone". Can anyone confirm? 18.104.22.168 20:22, 5 September 2007 (UTC)
This paragraph is a verbatim copy of text from http://www.ce.jhu.edu/baltimorestructures/Shot%20Tower/shot_tower.htm, except for my capitalization of "City":
- "In 1921 the tower was purchased for $14,500 by the Union Oil Company, which planned to tear it down and put a gas station in its place. After strong objections by the community, by 1928 enough money had been raised to purchase the tower and present it to the City of Baltimore."
Even though the information has a source citation, it still should not appear in the exact same form as the original source unless it's presented as a direct quote. That's called plagiarism. 22.214.171.124 20:39, 5 September 2007 (UTC)
"Merchants' " or "Merchant's"?
The second name of the Shot Tower and that of its owning company appears both as "Merchants' " and as "Merchant's" in the article. The NPS has it both ways on different pages, and an LoC article linked to one of the sources has it as "Merchants' ". Can anyone confirm the correct form? 126.96.36.199 20:44, 5 September 2007 (UTC)
"Phoenix Shot Tower" as title of article?
The main title of this article is the "Phoenix Shot Tower." This may cause some confusion, because this landmark is in the city of Baltimore, not Phoenix. Very few Baltimoreans currently know this structure as the "Phoenix" Shot Tower. The subway station at the location is simply called "Shot Tower." The article instead should be titled something like "Baltimore Shot Tower," with mention that it is also known as . . .
I would go ahead and make this change, but I first want to get some feedback. Sebwite 16:21, 20 September 2007 (UTC)
- Yeah, it's confusing. Instead of Baltimore Shot Tower, Shot tower (Baltimore) or Shot Tower (Baltimore) seem better to me, so we're clearly discussing a specific instance of a thing instead of creating another proper name for it. In fact, that latter name is where this page originally was created. It was later moved to its present page-name precisely because that's it's official name. The magic of #REDIRECT allows one to find it at that alternate name (and creating another redirect at Shot tower (Baltimore) might be a good idea. DMacks 19:09, 20 September 2007 (UTC)
- I never knew that it was called this until I was creating articles in which the Shot Tower had to be mentioned, and I discovered it when I was having trouble getting them to link correctly. Sebwite 19:55, 20 September 2007 (UTC)
- Concur that this was not a good move. Either use its official name or use its generic name with a parenthetical disambiguation. I have no objection to redirects from colloquial well-known unofficial names (of the redirects aren't working or are diffiult to link, then that is the problem that needs to be solved directly in its own right). DMacks (talk) 17:58, 24 January 2008 (UTC)
- Using the name "Phoenix" in the title is confusing. This is a name people most associate with Phoenix, Arizona. I had trouble finding this article initially for this reason - I have visited this landmark on multiple occasions, and I never knew it was called the "Phoenix" Shot Tower.Sebwite (talk) 21:52, 24 January 2008 (UTC)
- Oppose. We should call it what most people call it. We don't do official names unless English usually does; for some explanation why, see WP:Official names. Septentrionalis PMAnderson 04:35, 25 January 2008 (UTC)
- I'm not sure "Baltimore Shot Tower" is what most people call it. GHits are evenly split between Baltimore… and Phoenix…, both among formal publications and among bloggish stuff. Locals (i.e., subway station, tourist and other maps I've seen, etc.) call it Phoenix… or just "The Shot Tower". Conversely, there were actually several shot towers in Baltimore (though no others extant and I don't imagine we're going to have pages about them anytime soon). It looks like most other shot tower pages either use formal names (which often do not correspond to their stated locations) or else use a disambiguation style ("Shot Tower (somewhere)"). DMacks (talk) 06:51, 25 January 2008 (UTC)
- I went ahead and made the move. --evrik (talk) 23:33, 28 January 2008 (UTC)