User:Hans Adler/Gustl Mollath affair
The Gustl Mollath affair is a German judicial scandal and miscarriage of justice at the expence of Gustl Mollath, locked up in involuntary treatment from 2006 till 2013. A group of outside supporters that Mollath found during his detention made his case known to the general public. After two years of extensive reporting throughout the German mass media, Mollath obtained his liberty when prominent German defence lawyer Gerhard Strate, acting pro bono, managed to get his case re-opened. Mollath was acquitted at retrial in 2014. Since then, he has been fighting for a higher restitution and trying to clear his name of a court finding of violence against his ex-wife.
From 2011 till 2014, Gustl Mollath's case was the subject of numerous in-depth newspaper and television reports as well as three books. The Mollath affair and the Hessian tax investigator affair were the most noted among a small number of simultaneous scandals exposing problematic practices of and around psychiatric expert witnesses in the German legal system.[citation needed] A committee formed in 2014 explored options to improve Germany's laws on involuntary commitment. Its recommendations led to reforms in 2016.[1] (Move down: Indefinite commitment is now restricted to more serious cases than before, low-risk persons are placed in ordinary rather than forensic closed psychiatric stations, and the interval for expert reports on the necessity of continued commitment was reduced from 5 years to 3 years.)
Supporters[edit]
In 2011, Georg Slobodzian created a website for a circle of Mollath supporters. Among other content, the website contained a detailed chronology and numerous documents in PDF format.
Author and retired public prosecutor Gabriele Wolff started covering the Mollath affair in great depth in December 2012. She stressed the angle of a 'tough' wife getting rid of a 'soft' husband by having him pathologised.
The campaign for the release of Gustl Mollath gained the support of some leading experts in the fields of law and of mental health.
Media coverage before 2014[edit]
Media coverage before 2014 mostly attempted to support Mollath's fight for a release. Investigative journalism on this topic began with Report Mainz, an investigative politics format of German public broadcaster ARD. It continued with the local daily newspaper Nürnberger Nachrichten and the nationwide newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung.
Nürnberger Nachrichten[edit]
Report Mainz[edit]
Süddeutsche Zeitung[edit]
Neues aus der Anstalt[edit]
In June 2013, German political satirist Frank-Markus Barwasser, playing his alter ego Erwin Pelzig, explained the intricacies of the Mollath case to a wide audience. He stressed possible political dimensions and the countless surprising relations between supposedly unrelated actors.
Books[edit]
State failure on the highest level: What must change after the Mollath case[edit]
This book is a collection of articles written by journalists, lawyers and psychiatrists who supported Mollath. It appeared in 2013, before the retrial.
Mollath: Justice or death[edit]
In this self-published book, journalist and psychotherapist Gerald Mackenthun argues that Gustl Mollath is a regular criminal and mentally ill man who can only be embarrassed by a retrial. The book appeared in 2014, shortly before the retrial.
Obsolete and self-published; at most worth a short mention.
The Mollath affair: The man who knew too much[edit]
This book was written by journalists Uwe Ritzer and Olaf Przybilla, who had previously received a journalistic prize for their investigative series of articles in Süddeutsche Zeitung. It appeared in 2014, shortly after Mollath's acquittal.
The Mollath case: On the failure of justice and psychiatry[edit]
This book by Mollath's pro-bono defence lawyer [Gerhard Strate] appeared in early 2015.