User:Phantomsteve/RfA questions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

These are a selection of questions that I may or may not ask at RfAs:

Additional questions about CSDs from Phantomsteve
x. Could you please answer the following questions related to CSDs:
a. In your own words, could you explain the difference between CSD A1 and CSD A3?
A.
b. In your own words, could you explain what would cause you to decline a request for a speedy deletion using criteria A7?
A.
c. Which CSD do you find the hardest to judge, and how would you ensure that you make a correct assessment for deletion under this criteria?
A.
Additional question from Phantomsteve
x. You have been editing an article Article-1, adding information, sorting out layout, etc. Another editor (editor-123) reverts some of your edits, with the edit summary "removing of unsourced information". How do you deal with this, which admin tools (page protection, page deletion, blocking, etc) or other methods you would use to deal with it, and which policies/guidelines/essays you would use in justification?
A.
Additional questions about AfDs from Phantomsteve
x. Could you please answer the following questions related to AfDs:
a. In an AfD, what would cause you to ignore or discount !votes?
A:
b. Could you explain in your own words how you would judge the consensus in an AfD?
A:
c. Under which conditions would you close an AfD before the 7 days have elapsed?
A:
d. In which cirumstances would you relist an AfD for another week to allow concensus to be reached?
A:
An AfD question from Phantomsteve
x. You mention wanting to work with AfDs, but your experience in that area seems pretty sparse to me (contributing to 1 AfD and 1 MfD). Could you please explain how you would close this example AfD, along with your explanation for why you would close it that way?
A:
Additional question about your Editor Review from Phantomsteve
x. In your Editor Review in mmmmmm 201x you said ....
A.
Additional question about your last RfA from Phantomsteve
x. In your last Rfa in mmmmmm 201x you said ...
A.
Additional question from Phantomsteve
x. Your last RfA was in xxx 201x.
a. What has changed since that was closed which has helped you decide that you are ready to try again?
A:
b. What contributions since that RfA do you think show that you have an "administrator" attitude, and why?
A:
Additional question from Phantomsteve
x. Have you ever edited under another user name? If so, would you be willing to let us know what it was, and why you are not using it? (If you are worried about privacy issues, would you be willing to reveal it to a 'crat so that they can vouch that there's nothing 'dodgy' about the old account?)
A.

(For last few hours of a RfA which looks very likely to succeed (95%+)):

A last-minute question from Phantomsteve
x. Who Put the Bomp (In the Bomp, Bomp, Bomp)?
A.