User talk:Bewaarss

"National crush"

Re: this, please see Talk:Rashmika Mandanna, and you would be well-suited not to swallow everything you read in Indian media without applying a little critical reasoning. The fact that Google is not an award-issuing entity, would probably be the first tip-off that this was nonsense. Cyphoidbomb (talk) 19:25, 16 January 2021 (UTC)

I am not swallowing anything it happened 3 months back. Just now I have updated and not like others to play each time with pages. The reasoning you gave that Google is not award issuing, is valid and I will remember that. Thanks Bewaarss (talk) 21:23, 16 January 2021 (UTC)

I apologise for being a bit harsh, but it was frustrating when this blew up the first time around. As for this edit, while I know you're trying to be helpful, per WP:FILMCRITICLIST, and other guidelines like WP:CSC, we should only be including notable awards, i.e. ones where articles have already been created about them, and where notability has been adequately established. There are thousands of award mills in India and they all serve to promote actors and films and television shows. Wikipedia is not an advertising outlet. (No, I know that's not your intention.)

Also, please see WP:DADASAHEB, because similar to the "National Crush" thing, the Indian media gushes over everything with a "Dadasaheb Phalke" label, and in many cases they have even erroneously stated that this is the prestigious national award, which it is not. It's yet another random film festival that uses Phalke's name to make a few rupees and dole out awards.

Someone recently created an article on this festival/award mill, likely so they could flood articles with the accolade, and the article was deleted as non-notable. Thanks and regards, Cyphoidbomb (talk) 23:25, 16 January 2021 (UTC)

Hi, Thanks for understanding and your reply. As you will proof/verify lot of users update, I understood how it feels like. I really appreciate your way of explanation. Yes, there are many other festivals on the name of Dadasaheb who is actually father of Indian cinema and it’s prestigious award. But as you said all are not related to Dadasaheb. Few people already asked Indian ministry of information and broadcast which maintains this award to restrict using name of Dadasaheb Phalke. However government is not able to restrict the usage of Dadasaheb Phalke name. Please check if u hv time : https://www.hindustantimes.com/bollywood/naming-controversy-will-the-real-dadasaheb-phalke-award-winners-please-stand-up/story-5zSC9F1juf0Q2P3EZBsSiO.html Coming to this, I had verified on their direct website : www.dpiff.in and there is an event of South awards 2019 which was launched in 2019 ( Times of India ref link) So in reference links, I gave the launch date of South awards so that when you or any other proof readers verify it ( appended tag ). Next I had verified to get winners list from official website but there is no info ( not only this, for previous also). They are publishing Winners list in FB... I don’t want to provide FB links as source. Read nearly 7-9 newspaper websites and confirmed that it is real Dadasaheb Phalke South awards, so provided 2 links. If you still not sure, please remove that or I will remove. As per official website, the awards function will be there on next month 20th. After that we can confirm whether it’s original or not. I will update after that. I update rarely but every time I will check all the information whether it’s correct or not. I will try to not to repeat mistake like previous as I am new to this. If there is any mistake done from my end, it’s not intentional, it’s due to lack of experience. I will improve further. Hope u will understand. Thanks. Bewaarss (talk) 00:36, 17 January 2021 (UTC)