User talk:UZBChristoph

Neutral point of view

Hello, welcome to Wikipedia! I noticed that you've added a significant amount of content to Roza Otunbayeva that makes several accusations against her and is written in a way that take a specific point of view. Wikipedia has a policy regarding neutral point of view, and Wikipedia policies are applied more strictly to biographies of living people. To prevent a violation of these policies, I've reverted the edit you made. Common advice for new editors is to start slowly and to avoid more contentious topics. If you have any questions about editing or using Wikipedia, you can ask them at the Teahouse. Thebiguglyalien (talk) 19:00, 26 September 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Hello, I'm terribly saddened by the deletion and don't understand why this is happening? After all, I presented all the links - both the accusation regarding the beginning of ethnic conflicts in the South of the Republic, and the arrest of Azimzhan Askarov, and the actions against the opposition were repeatedly confirmed by the results of international commissions. I am providing links to reports from Amnesty International, FIDH, and the OSCE Commission. I avoid using dozens of video interviews with politicians from the opposition of Kyrgyzstan - I rely only on the results of international commissions. Why am I seeing widespread removal? At the moment, the article looks like custom PR article for Otunbayeva - but you can’t leave all the good and delete all the bad. Why - the results of international commissions on her activities - reports of FIDH, Amnesty International, statements by the human rights activist "Kylym Shamy", other NGOs - as the leader of the Provisional Government, which directly mention her, do not correspond to the policy of Wikipedia? It is just shocking. UZBChristoph (talk) 08:36, 27 September 2023 (UTC)[reply]

In any case, thank you for your attention. I will now try to restore the text, but I will make it as neutral as possible, taking into account your comments - I have read the guidelines. Please don't delete it, just tell me about places that I should fix. I have worked so much, and it is shocking to see my work completely removed.

But I believe that you cannot whitewash a person. Hundreds of people died. The arrest of Azimzhan Askarov, carried out on the orders of Otunbayeva, was condemned by the entire world community. I have not yet mentioned the terrible massacre in Mayevka near Bishkek, which also occurred during her presidency - but I will add there material about this. UZBChristoph (talk) 08:46, 27 September 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Before my edits, the article looked like custom PR. I have added the reports of international commissions and human rights activists. I think international reports of OSCE, Amnesty International, FIDH, Human Rights Watch on crimes against humanity should be mentioned. Wikipedia is not a platform for advertising people, no matter who they are. Not many people know English in Central Asia, and few people know how to edit Wikipedia, but this does not mean that history can be rewritten.

I have added much more links to reports of international organizations. UZBChristoph (talk) 09:19, 27 September 2023 (UTC)[reply]