Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification
Welsh Bac or WBQ, is an officially accredited and established qualification delivered by schools, colleges and training providers across Wales. It gives broader experiences than traditional learning programmes, developing transferable skills useful for higher education and employment. The qualification is offered at the Foundation, Intermediate and Advanced levels and is studied alongside a range of traditional academic and vocational qualifications. The level followed depends on the level being covered in subject options. For example, a student following GCSE who is likely to achieve A* – C grades at GCSE would work towards the Intermediate Diploma. The Welsh Baccalaureate Advanced Diploma is widely recognised by higher education institutions.
- 1 Structure and Requirements
- 2 Developments
- 3 Research and evaluation of the Welsh Baccalaureate
- 4 See also
- 5 References
- 6 External links
Structure and Requirements
The Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification consists of two parts – a compulsory Core and a choice of Options, which are made up of optional subjects or qualifications which the student may be following. Together, the Core and Options make up the Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification. Options are the courses/programmes currently studied by the student alongside the Core e.g. General Certificate of Secondary Education (GCSE), Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced (AS / A levels), BTec, Principal Learning. The Options requirements depend on the level of the Welsh Baccalaureate being followed.The Welsh Baccalaureate Advanced Diploma attracts 120 UCAS (university entry) points, the same as an A grade in an A Level subject. The awarding organisation for the Welsh Bacclaureate Qualification is WJEC.The structure of the Welsh Baccalaureate Core is the same at all three levels and consists of:
- Essential Skills Wales/Key Skills qualifications (Exact requirements depend on the level followed)
- Wales, Europe and the World (WEW)
- Personal and Social Education (PSE)
- Work-related Education (WRE)- work experience and a team enterprise activity
- Community Participation
- Language Module
- Individual Investigation (Exact requirements depend on the level followed)
The Welsh Baccalaureate section of the WJEC website details the exact requirements for the Advanced, Intermediate and Foundation levels.
The Welsh Baccalaureate began in September 2003 as a pilot scheme involving 18 schools and colleges in Wales. The qualification was rolled out to centres across Wales in September 2007. By September 2012, 75,000 learners in 240 schools, colleges and work based learning centres were registered for the Welsh Baccalaureate courses. The Welsh Bac has become a familiar part of the educational landscape in Wales with all colleges and only a small minority of schools not delivering at least one level of the qualification.
Review of Qualifications for 14- to 19-year-olds in Wales
In the Review of Qualifications consultation document, published on 31 May 2012, the Review Board considered that the Welsh Bac was making an important contribution to the education of over 73,000 learners in Wales. The consultation document noted that 'The Board is currently of the view that the Welsh Baccalaureate has both relevance and value, that it should be further developed and promoted, and that eventually it should be universally adopted at 14–19 across Wales.
The consultation went on to say 'Feedback to the Review has been largely positive about the Welsh Baccalaureate. Stakeholders like its use of established qualifications in its options, the development of skills (including testing aspects of literacy and numeracy) in its Core, together with elements valued by employers and universities such as work experience, community participation and independent research.’
Grading the Welsh Baccalaureate
The Qualiifcations Review Board has proposed that the Welsh Baccalaureate should be graded at the Advanced level to maintain its currency for higher education admission and to ensure that learners' differing achievements are properly recognised. The Review Board indicated that further views would be canvassed about whether the Intermediate and Foundation levels should be graded.
Current levels of achievement
Figures released by the awarding organisation WJEC in August 2012 reported that a total of 8,259 candidates were awarded the Advanced Diploma, compared with 6,948 in 2011, the highest entry to date for this qualification. This represented 83% of those who completed the course. The successful candidates achieved at least two A levels or equivalent academic or vocational qualifications, as well as meeting the requirements of the Welsh Baccalaureate Core, including gaining Essential Skills Wales (ESW, and Key Skills (KS) and personal development modules.
Having met the full range of requirements of the Core components, 8,747 or 88% of the candidates who completed the course achieved the Welsh Baccalaureate Advanced Core Certificate.
In 2012, a record 7,210 or 73% of candidates achieved the Welsh Baccalaureate Intermediate Diploma, compared with 67% in 2011. The number of candidates completing the programme also rose to 9,940, an increase of 3,937 or 66% on 2011. A further 990 candidates achieved the Welsh Baccalaureate Core Certificate.
At Foundation level, 3,521 candidates completed the programme, an increase of 23% compared with 2,858 last year. Of these, 2,236 or 64% achieved the Foundation Diploma, compared with 1,873 or 66% last year. A further 279 candidates achieved the Core Certificate at the Foundation level.
Standards in the Welsh Bac
In July 2012, Estyn published a good practice guide, The Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification provision at level 3 in secondary schools. The Report's main findings noted that the Welsh Baccalaureate 'offers many benefits to students. Through studying the Welsh Baccalaureate core, the majority of students improve their essential skills and they achieve an understanding of a range of topics, including enterprise, politics and current affairs, that they would not have studied otherwise. In particular, carrying out the individual investigation helps many students to develop some of the research and analytical skills needed for higher education and employment. Students also develop their confidence and social skills by engaging in community participation and work experience.’
The report considered the wide ability range of those who take the Core, suggesting this is a case for grading. The Welsh Baccalaureate is most successful where it is planned as a compulsory part of the curriculum for all students.
The Estyn report acknowledges that 'the main source of training, advice and support for staff about the WBQ is WJEC.' The report considers that 'This training has been effective and has had a positive impact.' WJEC's extensive Centre Support Programme aims to enable centres to access relevant training/resources and also to network and share good practice. WJEC along with Estyn acknowledge that there are some differences in the quality of delivery in Welsh Bac centres and are working to support all centres in raising standards, especially many relatively new to the qualification.
An Estyn report, The Welsh Bac in KS4 (2008), focused on the introduction of the Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification at Foundation and Intermediate levels at key stage 4 in schools in Wales. It provided a position paper that evaluated the Welsh Assembly Government pilot project to introduce the Welsh Baccalaureate into this key stage.
||The neutrality of this section is disputed. (October 2014) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)|
The Welsh Baccalaureate and Higher education
Stories that the Welsh Baccalaureate is not widely recognised by higher education institutions in Wales and England are not supported by evidence from UCAS, Welsh Bac centres or the universities themselves. The Welsh Baccalaureate Advanced Diploma has been welcomed by the majority of institutions, with many making a formal statement in their prospectuses and on their websites about the qualification. By 2008 UCAS reported that the total number of courses that included information on the Welsh Bac in the acceptability field was 20,881. 16,069 courses accepted the Welsh Bac on its own, 4,659 in combination and only 153 did not accept it.
In 2012, universities continue to acknowledge the value of the Welsh Baccalaureate and recognise this by including it in offers. Ross Thomas, Welsh Baccalaureate Development Officer at WJEC reported 'In 2012 applicants in Welsh Bac centres had received offers including the Welsh Bac from all the Welsh universities and most in England. Offers in Wales included Cardiff University for Dentistry, Law, Psychology and English and from the University of Glamorgan for a range of courses from Computer Science to Events Management. Offers from Aberystwyth typically covered the full range of courses from English, Politics and Business to Drama and Art as did Swansea University which included English, History and Geography. Other notable offers from Welsh universities included many vocationally based subjects such as Aircraft Engineering at the University of Glamorgan and Sport Bio-Medical Science & Nutrition at Cardiff Metropolitan University.' Dr Hywel Davies, Head of Admissions and Recruitment at the University of Wales Aberystwyth said 'We welcome students who have achieved the Welsh Baccalaureate. The skills and experiences associated with the Welsh Bac provide an excellent preparation for university.’
The majority of English universities including Oxford and Cambridge, also recognise the value of the Welsh Bac. Alongside more traditional science and humanities courses from the majority of universities in England, came some notable offers including the Welsh Bac. Offers to students at Whitchurch High School in Cardiff were as varied as Mechatronic and Robotic Engineering, Astrophysics at Exeter and Optometry at Aston. Students from Ysgol Gyfun Emlyn received offers as varied as nursing at Kingston, French at Bristol, Biology at Nottingham and Theatre and Performance Studies at Plymouth.
There are some university courses which do not give offers including the Welsh Baccalaureate Advanced Diploma.
Research and evaluation of the Welsh Baccalaureate
Research on the Welsh Baccalaureate has been generally positive. The University of Bath were the internal evaluators and produced a number of reports evaluating the development of the Welsh Baccalaureate. A Final Report of the External Evaluation of the Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification (WBQ) Pilot was also carried out by the University of Nottingham. Both internal and external evaluations were largely positive, emphasising the positive impact of the Welsh Bac in broadening the learner experience.
Estyn reports on the Advanced Level (2012) and the Welsh Bac in Key Stage 4 in schools (2008, were generally positive about the impact of the qualification, although there were some concerns about the differences in quality of delivery in Welsh Bac centres.
In 2009, the prestigious Nuffield Foundation funded the Nuffield Review of 14–19 Education and Training in which the Welsh Bac was praised. Led by Professor Richard Pring of Oxford University, the 'Education for All' report published in June, took six years to complete. The report calls for a baccalaureate system for secondary schools; asks why many young people drop out of education and training in their late teens; and offers contrasts between England's approach to school reform and that which has operated in Wales since Devolution.
Among the Review's recommendations was that "England should learn from the Welsh attempts to incorporate in its 'Learning Pathways' a broader and more flexible vision of progression." The Review supports the continued development of the Welsh Baccalaureate so that it becomes the organising framework for all 14 – 19 learners in Wales.
The current affairs programme 'Dragon's Eye' broadcast 1 May 2012, reported on work published by Dr Chris Taylor and colleagues at Wales Institute of Social & Economic Research, Data & Methods (WISERD) based at Cardiff University. Dr Taylor's work suggested that the performance of Welsh Bac qualified students did not match their apparent A level points score. One explanation is that since the Welsh Bac is ungraded, students who pass it cover a wide range of abilities and ability is known to be a strong predictor of success at university. Dr Taylor commented "This suggests that the WBQ would benefit from being graded." He added "Our findings also raise a concern about the overall quality of the WBQ and whether there are any apparent benefits of this qualification on university progress and outcomes." The conclusions in the Report were however qualified by a recognition of the limitations of the analysis. Dr Taylor added "We would not want to argue that the WBQ is systematically worth less than an A grade at A Level. And indeed, rejecting the use of the WBQ in helping to determine entry and conditional offers ignores the 'opportunity cost' for a student of not having taken another qualification or A Level."
Following the publication of the Report, Cardiff University clarified their position regarding Welsh Baccalaureate applicants. The 2012–13 prospectus states that "Cardiff University accepts the Welsh Baccalaureate Advanced Diploma for admission to all its undergraduate degree programmes. If you are taking the Welsh Baccalaureate Advanced Diploma, and the University decides to make you an offer for study on any of its programme, the offer will be based on a pass in the Core plus specified grades and subjects, where applicable, in the Options."
In 2004, UCAS confirmed that the Advanced Level would attract 120 UCAS points. The 2009 Expert Group Report for Review of Award in the UCAS Tariff confirmed the award of 120 UCAS tariff points for the Welsh Baccalaureate Advanced Diploma.
Debate on the Welsh Baccalaureate
In 2002, Colin Jenkins and John David, who developed the original Welsh Baccalaureate proposal for the Institute for Welsh Affairs (IWA), criticised the Welsh Bac because it did not follow the IWA's model, based on the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme. They said they were disappointed and considered the Welsh Bac to be "missing a huge opportunity." They considered the WBQ to be a "feeble quick fix", "not a baccalaureate", and as "Curriculum 2000 with a bit of icing". They added that the language requirement was "a waste of time." However, comparisons with the International Baccalaureate are not helpful. The Welsh Bac and the International Baccalaureate qualification are very different.
Jane Davidson, Welsh Assembly Government Minister for Education, Lifelong Learning & Skills from 2000–2007, responded to the pair's criticism by stating that the Welsh Baccalaureate is "a significant innovation which will broaden students' programmes and bring coherence to them. The programme will be distinctive, modern and proudly Welsh." She explained that "The contract to design and deliver the Welsh baccalaureate was awarded following a tender process... In the event we received no tenders based on the IWA model." Jeff Jones, chair of the WJEC when it bid for and developed the WBQ, stated in 2011 that he thought at the time that the WBQ "looked like nonsense" but that the WJEC "needed the money and in any case we had to bid because we were the Welsh exam board". Jones added that the WBQ was "really an A level with a load of nonsense added on" and added: “It isn’t a proper Bac where students at 18 would still be required to study maths, English, a science and a language, not meaningless Mickey Mouse additions. What the heck is the use of ‘Wales and the World’ for a start? No wonder Russell Group universities who can get students from England with four A stars are not that interested. If I were a student I wouldn’t touch it with a barge pole." The University of Leeds, which is ranked 2nd in the United Kingdom in the Russell Group, does not accept Welsh Baccalaureate. Most Welsh secondary schools mandate their 6th form students study the Welsh Baccalaureate along side their A Level studies insisting it's a compulsory subject that "compliments" a students learning experience.  However, Mr Jones' comments were challenged by David Evans, Wales Secretary of the National Union of Teachers, who said: “I am surprised Jeff Jones has come out and made these statements several years after the event. If that’s what he thought at the time, he should hang his head in shame for putting in a bid from the WJEC to run the Welsh Bac. Making these comments now smacks of scaremongering.” 
- Disappointment over the Welsh bac TES, 11 May 2008
- Fathers disown Welsh bac progeny TES, 11 May 2008
- Welsh bac is several steps forwards TES, 11 May 2008
- Row as ex-exam chief says Welsh Bac is nonsense Wales On-line, 17 May 2011
- Row as ex-exam chief says Welsh Bac is nonsense Wales On-line, 17 May 2011
- WBQ Official site
- Nuffield Foundation report on Welsh Bac
- University of Bath Centre for the study of Education in an International Context (CEIC). Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification: Internal Evaluation
- University of Nottingham, CDELL. External evaluation of the Welsh Baccalaureate Qualification Pilot. 2006
- The UCAS tariff report 2009
- Her Majesty's Inspectorate for Education and Training in Wales.
- WJEC WBQ awarding organisation