Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/June 2014 Backlog Elimination Drive/ThaddeusB
Appearance
- (Accepted) Draft:Bone Clones
- (Accepted) Draft:Kavita Shah
- (Accepted) Draft:Saundarya Rajesh
- (Accepted) Draft:Gilbert F. Robbins
- (Accepted) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Rocky and the Natives
- (Accepted) Draft:Victorious 22 (V22LA)
- (Accepted) Draft:Dayton Superior
- (Declined) Draft:Instant Records
- (Accepted) Draft:Clif Norrell
- (Declined) Draft:Simon Cooper (football coach)
- (Declined) Draft:Anthony A. Lee
- (Accepted) Draft:Internshala
- (Accepted) Draft:Eduardo Garcia
- (Declined) Draft:Camp Napowan
- (Accepted) Draft:MC Ludmilla
- (Accepted) Draft:James Hay Partnership
- (Accepted) Draft:Yrjö Reenpää
- (Accepted) Draft:Jimmy Wormworth
- (Accepted) Draft:VetUK Ltd.
- (Accepted) Draft:Ora Golan
- (Declined) Draft:Sam Kadi
- (Accepted) Draft:SK 847
- (Accepted) Draft:Will Brooke
- (Accepted) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Jack Woodbridge
- (Declined) Draft:Sea Star Films (Deleted Revision)
Checked reviews
[edit]- (Accepted) Draft:James Hay Partnership
- Pass - Ritchie333
- Pass - Ritchie333
- (Accepted) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Jack Woodbridge
- Comment - I've pondered this over the last 20 minutes, but concluded too much of his work seems to be self published and four references doesn't really cut it for a BLP of that size. He has an Allmusic page, but that doesn't really change my view on notability. I can't find any other good sources online, and if this went to AfD, I would struggle to muster up a good enough argument to make a "Keep" vote stick. Ritchie333
I agree it is a very borderline case for notability; I elected to error on the side of promote, since I too was unsure. I would probably vote weak keep in an AfD. --ThaddeusB (talk) 23:04, 12 June 2014 (UTC)
- Comment - I've pondered this over the last 20 minutes, but concluded too much of his work seems to be self published and four references doesn't really cut it for a BLP of that size. He has an Allmusic page, but that doesn't really change my view on notability. I can't find any other good sources online, and if this went to AfD, I would struggle to muster up a good enough argument to make a "Keep" vote stick. Ritchie333
- (Accepted) Draft:VetUK Ltd.
- Pass - Ritchie333
- Pass - Ritchie333
- (Accepted) Draft:Jimmy Wormworth
- Pass - Ritchie333
- Pass - Ritchie333