Disability in the media
||This article has been nominated to be checked for its neutrality. (August 2014)|
The depiction of disability in the media plays a major role in forming public perception of disability. Perceptions created by the media informs the way people with disabilities are treated in society. "The media have been cited as a key site for the reinforcement of negative images and ideas in regard to people with disabilities."
In response, there have been increasing examples worldwide of people with disabilities pursuing their own media projects, such as film series centered on disability issues, radio programs and podcasts designed around and marketed towards those with disabilities, and so on. This is seen by many disability rights activists as a way to, as some in these circles term it, "piss on pity".
- 1 Common depictions
- 2 Broadcast media programming for disabled audiences
- 3 Accessibility and the media
- 4 Publications and broadcasts by disability related organisations
- 5 Disability in documentary film
- 6 Documentary photography
- 7 Responses
- 8 See also
- 9 References
The media generally depict people with disabilities according to common stereotypes such as pity and heroism. Disability advocates often call this type of societal situation the "pity/heroism trap" or "pity/heroism dichotomy" and call instead for its supporters to "Piss On Pity" and push forward with inclusion instead.
When reports are about the "plight of the disabled" they rely on the pity or medical model of disability. Telethons are an example of this, such as the Jerry Lewis MDA Telethon which has been heavily criticised and sometimes even physically protested by disability rights advocates.
Negative day-to-day reporting may occur chiefly by depicting a given person or people with a disability as a burden or drain on society.
Stereotypical depictions of disability that originate in the arts, literature, film, television, and other mass media fiction works, are frequently normalized through repetition to the general audience. Once such a stereotype is absorbed and accepted by the mainstream public, it continues to be repeated in the media, in many slightly varied forms, but staying close to the stereotype. Many media stereotypes about disability have been identified. They are sometimes referred to as "tropes", meaning a recurring image or representation in the mainstream culture that is widely recognizable. Tropes repeated in works of fiction have an influence on how society at large perceives people with disabilities. Other forms of media, in turn, then portray people with disabilities in ways that conform with tropes and repeat them. Some of these disability tropes that have been identified in popular culture include:
- "Little People are Surreal" (examples include the character Tattoo in the television show Fantasy Island; a recurring use of a dwarf as a motif in American film director David Lynch's works, such as Mulholland Drive; and a dwarf actor who appears as a prominent cast extra in the film The Eyes of Laura Mars;
- "Single Episode Disability" (where a regular character in a television series suffers a temporary disability, learns a moral lesson, and makes a rapid, full recovery; examples include an episode of M*A*S*H where Hawkeye is temporarily blinded, and an episode of Law and Order: SVU where Detective Stabler is temporarily blind)
- "Disability Superpower" (where fate removes one ability, it enhances another, so that a disabled character has one superpower; this has resulted in the creation of several subtypes of this disability trope, such as Blind Seer, Blind Weapon Master, Genius Cripple, and Super Wheel Chair)
Other persistent disability stereotypes that have been identified in popular culture include:
- The object of pity (commonly associated with an illness or disease, such as Tiny Tim in Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol)
- Sinister or evil (commonly associated with deformity, such as ugly pirates, criminals, witches, crones, and more)
- Eternal innocence (commonly associated with intellectual disability, such as in the films Forrest Gump, I Am Sam and Rainman)
- The victim of violence (examples include The Hunchback of Notre Dame, The Ugly Duckling, and Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer)
The existence of disability tropes in mass media is related to other stereotypes, or tropes, that have developed when other marginalized groups in society are depicted, such as the Magical Negro trope identified, and criticized, by film director Spike Lee. The mocking names often given to these tropes when they are identified indicates a rejection of the harmful stereotypes that they propagate.
Stereotypes may endure in a culture for several reasons: they are constantly reinforced in the culture, which mass media does easily and effectively; they reflect a common human need to organize people and categorize them; they reinforce discrimination that allows one group of society to exploit and marginalize another group. Several studies of mass media in Britain and the United States have identified common stereotypes, such as "noble warrior", "charity cripple", "curio", "freak", and "Pollyanna", where the researchers identified a position of "disapproval", on the part of the media, of some aspect of the disability. It has been shown that media portrayals of disability became more normalizing and accepting in the years immediately after World War II, when returning veterans with war-related disabilities were being reintegrated into society. A backlash of intolerance towards disability followed during the mid-20th century, with some researchers speculating that this may have been related to society's reaction against any identifiable "difference" as a result of Cold War tensions. Depictions of disability in media soon reverted to emphasizing the "freakish" nature of disability.
Broadcast media programming for disabled audiences
Broadcast media has in recent years begun to recognize the large audience of people with disabilities that it reaches. Programming dedicated to disability issues is increasing.
In 1990, the signing of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) became the first news story on disability issues to become a lead story on cable news broadcaster CNN. News Director Ed Turner contacted the Washington bureau of CNN to have the signing of the ADA by President Bush broadcast live. The next day, the signing of the ADA was covered as the top headline in the New York Times, the Washington Post, and every other major U.S. newspaper. Disability rights activist Lex Frieden has stated, "That was the first time that millions of people were exposed to disability rights as the number one story". These milestones were a major change in reducing exclusion and invisibility for people with disabilities.
Ouch! by the British Broadcasting Corporation, The Largest Minority broadcast in New York City, and a show presented in sign language on SABC television in South Africa, Dtv, are examples of programming produced for, and usually also by, disabled people.
Radio reading services are radio stations that broadcast readings from newspapers, magazines and books to mainly blind or partially sighted audiences.
In recent years, some mainstream publications and broadcasters have added writing and programming about disability-related topics. The Creative Diversity Network in the United Kingdom is an organization that advocates increased cultural and disability-related programming. Clare Morrow, the organization's Network Manager, states that "Disability is now at the heart of the diversity agenda for all of the UK's main television companies, thanks to their collective work". The BBC Website includes Ouch!, a disability news and discussion blog and internet talk show program.
Accessibility and the media
Part of the agenda for a growing number of media companies is determining how to best reach audience members with a disability. Hearing and visual impairments, or computer accessibility, can limit the reach of media companies, but new technology and creative adaptations of existing capabilities are bringing media to more people with disabilities.
Today, digital media formats (MP3, E-text download, CD, DVD, DAISY Digital Talking Book) are used to bring recordings and other programming to the visually impaired, and to provide real-time captioning to programming and films for audiences with impaired hearing.
Major media companies delivering accessible programming and services
- Radio Print Handicapped Network (RPH Australia) - Radio reading service umbrella organization
- Print Radio Tasmania - reading and information radio programming for the visually impaired
- Vision Australia Radio - radio network with volunteer staff, includes programming for the visually impaired such as broadcasting of newspaper and magazine articles
- Accessible Media - closed captioning, descriptive video
- AMI-audio - 24-hour English-language reading and information radio broadcasting for the visually impaired
- AMI-tv - basic cable channel. Broadcasts general entertainment programming with an "open" format—using described video as the primary audio track, and providing closed captioning for all programming.
- Canal M - 24-hour French-language reading and information radio broadcasting for the visually impaired
- National Talking Newspapers & Magazines, or NTN&M - audio versions of national newspapers and magazines in various formats
- Assistive Media - Has made over 1000 audio recordings of in-depth titles of mostly serious non-fiction from mainstream periodicals, including The New Yorker, The Atlantic, Harper's, and The New York Review of Books, and as of 2011 creates recordings for library use
- Digital Theatre Systems - DTS-CSS or Cinema Subtitling System, captioning for film theatres
- Media Access Group at WGBH-TV - PBS public television Boston affiliate, oversees the Caption Center, Descriptive Video Services® (DVS), and the Carl and Ruth Shapiro Family National Center for Accessible Media (NCAM).
- The Minnesota Radio Talking Book Network - the first reading and information service, founded in 1969
- National Captioning Institute
Many activist and charitable organisations have websites and publish their own magazines or newsletters.
Disability in documentary film
Disability has been shown to audiences since the early days of documentary film. Educational silent films showing hospital patients with various disabling conditions were shown to medical and nursing students. Films of schizophrenia patients with symptoms of catatonia, World War I veterans with extreme Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) (shell-shock) symptoms, and many other such films survive today. Michael J. Dowling (1866-1921) was a prominent Minnesota politician and newspaper publisher, who was also a quadruple amputee. World War I inspired him to further the cause of veterans with disabilities. Dowling had himself filmed performing routine tasks on his own, and had the films screened for groups such as the American Medical Association in 1918. His efforts promoted the rehabilitation of the physically disabled.
Documentary films sometimes had a tone that was a reflection of the public's morbid curiosity about visible disabilities that were considered shameful and ordinarily were hidden from public view. Nazi propagandists exploited this fear and prejudice to push the public to accept their euthanasia policies, including forcible sterilization, by screening films showing people with mental retardation and physical disabilities living in squalid conditions. At the same time, American President Franklin D. Roosevelt and his White House staff made a great effort to disguise his handicap (Roosevelt became paraplegic after contracting polio as an adult). Roosevelt was photographed and filmed only from positions that would hide his disability from the public, for fear that he would be perceived as weak.
More recently, documentary films about disability have been widely viewed on both public and cable television programming. The Channel 5 (UK) program Extraordinary Lives, and Channel 4 program Body Shock in the United Kingdom, broadcast much documentary material about disability. Titles of some documentary programming includes: "The Boy Who Sees Without Eyes — the 14-year-old American boy who navigates by sound; The Twin Within the Twin — the 34-year-old Bengali who carries his foetal twin within his abdomen; and The Twins Who Share a Body — Abby and Brittany Hensel, the world's only known dicephalus twins, ie. two heads with one body". Some of the documentaries, perceived to be in the "shock doc" (shock documentary) genre, have been denounced by critics with disabilities. Although the documentary programming contains educational and scientific information, the sensationalized, overt emotional appeal of the "tabloid tone" of the programming has raised objections. Laurence Clark has written in the BBC Website's disability blog Ouch!:
During these programs I often find myself screaming at the TV: 'Where the hell do they find these people?!' I suspect that someone somewhere has set up an agency called Rent-a-Freak, specifically to supply the most bizarre, eccentric disabled people they can find to budding documentary makers. But unlike today's documentary subjects, the freaks of old were at least paid to take part — and had some say over their performances.
The first photographer to become widely known for depicting the visibly disabled was Diane Arbus. Her photographs, which are in fact art photographs, have been, and remain, highly controversial.
American documentary photographers Tom Olin and Harvey Finkle have featured people with disabilities in their works in public exhibits, including the National Constitution Center Museum.
Members of the public with disabilities have criticized media depictions of disability on the grounds that stereotypes are commonly repeated. Media coverage that is "negative", "unrealistic", or displays a preference for the "pitiful" and "sensationalistic" over the "everyday and human side of disability" are identified at the root of the dissatisfaction. Journalist Leye Jeannette Chrzanowski, who uses a wheelchair, has written:
Many people with disabilities believe mainstream journalists are incapable of accurately covering stories about them. Generally, journalists either portray us as pitiful cripples, super achievers, or insane mental patients. These erroneous media stereotypes of people with disabilities are perpetuated because journalists consistently fail to understand or learn about people with disabilities and the issues that are important to us.
Various organisations and programmes have been established to try to positively influence the frequency and quality of reporting on disability issues. By 2000, it was estimated that in the United States, there were between 3000 and 3500 newsletters, 200 magazines, and 50 to 60 newspapers regularly published that focussed on disability issues.
- "sosol - Volume 7 Issue 1". Physed.otago.ac.nz. 2000-05-01. Retrieved 2012-06-18.
- "Media & Disability. home". Mediaanddisability.org. Retrieved 2012-06-18.
- mark hand (2005-01-23). "'Piss on Pity': Clint Eastwood's 'Million Dollar' Snuff Film". Press Action. Retrieved 2012-06-18.
- "The Nutty Profess-ion" article from Rabble News
- "Communication > Research Studies". N.C.P.E.D.P. Retrieved 2012-06-18.
- Indiana University School of Journalism (1988-02-08). "Archive " The "super-crip" stereotype " Ethics cases online". Journalism.indiana.edu. Retrieved 2012-06-18.
- Fahnestock, Jeanne (2011). Rhetorical Style: The Uses of Language in Persuasion. Oxford University Press. p. 100. ISBN 9780199764129.
- "Disability Tropes: Television Tropes & Idioms". tvtropes.org. Retrieved July 7, 2012.
- Baglieri, Susan and Arthur Shapiro (2012). Disability Studies and the Inclusive Classroom: Critical Practices for Creating Least Restrictive Attitudes. Routledge. p. No page. ISBN 9781136870248.
- Shakespeare, Tom (1998). The Disability Reader: Social Science Perspectives. Continuum International Publishing Group. p. 180. ISBN 9780826453600.
- Shakespeare, Tom (1998). The Disability Reader: Social Science Perspectives. Continuum International Publishing Group. p. 181. ISBN 9780826453600.
- Doris Zames Fleischer, Frieda Zames (2001). The Disability Rights Movement: From Charity to Confrontation. Temple University Press. p. 210. ISBN 9781566398121.
- "Ouch! (disability) - Podcast". BBC. 1970-01-01. Retrieved 2012-06-18.
- "News and events". Creative Diversity Network. Retrieved July 21, 2012.
- "The Ouch! Blog". British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC). Retrieved July 21, 2012.
- "Michael J. Dowling Silent Film, Museum Collections Up Close: MNHS.ORG". Minnesota Historical Society. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Marini, Irmo; Noreen M. Glover-Graf; Michael Jay Millington (2011). Psychosocial Aspects of Disability: Insider Perspectives and Counseling Strategies. Springer Publishing Company. p. 14. ISBN 9780826106025.
- Marini, Irmo; Noreen M. Glover-Graf; Michael Jay Millington (2011). Psychosocial Aspects of Disability: Insider Perspectives and Counseling Strategies. Springer Publishing Company. p. 16. ISBN 9780826106025.
- Lee-Wright, Peter (2009). The Documentary Handbook. Taylor & Francis. p. 139. ISBN 9780415434010.
- "NCC Marks Americans with Disabilities Act anniversary". Annenberg Center for Education and Outreach at the National Constitution Center. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Catherine A. Luther, Carolyn Ringer Lepre, Naeemah Clark (2011). Diversity in U.S. Mass Media. John Wiley & Sons. p. 268. ISBN 9781444344516.
- "Media & Disability. home". Mediaanddisability.org. Retrieved 2012-06-18.
- "Media & Disability Resources". media-disability.net. Retrieved 2013-02-03.
- "European Congress on Media and Disability - Homepage". Media-disability.org. Retrieved 2012-06-18.
- [dead link]