Talk:Rezwan Ferdaus

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

See also[edit]

i have added the names of some prominent American Islamist militants with roots in Indian subcontinent to the article. these are related articles on fellow Islamist American militants ( all US citizens) with familial ties to Indian subcontinent which is a hotbed of islamist ideology nowadays. they meet requirements of a related article as per WP:SEEALSO. Mar4d has been reverting this to suit POV as I guess he does not want people to read about articles on similar individuals. please do not remove this info without first discussing.--Wikireader41 (talk) 00:24, 12 October 2011 (UTC)[reply]

There is nothing to suggest that this article is related in any way to the other articles you keep adding as per WP:SEEALSO. Were they in the same group? No. Were they in the same act/conspiracy? No. Were they even affiliated or related to each other? Heck no. Your sole justification that they should all be listed because they come "with familial ties to Indian subcontinent which is a hotbed of islamist ideology nowadays" is hardly a good reason. It's like putting a list of all Arab American jihadists on the see-also section of an article of a random Arab American individual charged of terrorism. The very least requirement should be whether if they even come from the same national background, which this does obviously not meet. It's very clear who's trying to push WP:POV here. Mar4d (talk) 08:00, 13 October 2011 (UTC)[reply]