|Single by Pink|
|from the album I'm Not Dead|
|Released||May 8, 2006 (U.S. radio)
May 29, 2006 (UK)
June 26, 2007 (U.S. radio re-release)
|Format||Digital download, CD single, 12" maxi single|
Decibel Studios, Stockholm, SWE; Conway Recording Studios, Hollywood, CA
|Writer(s)||Pink, Max Martin, Lukasz Gottwald|
|Producer||Max Martin, Dr. Luke|
|Certification||Platinum (ARIA, RIAA)|
"Who Knew" is a song by American recording artist and songwriter Pink, which was taken from her fourth studio album I'm Not Dead (2006). The song was written by Pink, Max Martin and Lukasz Gottwald, while it was produced by Max Martin and Dr. Luke. "Who Knew" was released as the second single off the album worldwide in 2006, while it was re-released to U.S. radio as the album's fourth single in the United States in 2007, after the success of "U + Ur Hand".
Musically, "Who Knew" is a pop rock song, which has smaller elements of ballad and soft rock music. Lyrically, it is about losing a friend because of drugs. "Who Knew" received positive reviews from most music critics, who noted it as a strong song on the album and praised the lyrics, however some critics thought the song was too similar to singer Kelly Clarkson. The song was commercially success worldwide, where it peaked in the top spot in countries including Australia, Czech Republic, Germany, Hungary and component charts in the United States. The song is Pink's longest chart runner on the Hot 100, spending 36 weeks before dropping out.
"Who Knew" remains as one of Pink's final singles to be released by Arista Records, before its first shutdown.
An accompanying music video was released for the single, where it shows Pink singing in a county fair, with a storyline about two young lovers who end up being separated after the guy begins using drugs. The song has been performed on many of Pink's world tours, including I'm Not Dead Tour, Funhouse Tour and its extension tour Funhouse Summer Carnival Tour. The song was eventually included in Pink's debut compilation album Greatest Hits... So Far!!! (2010).
"Who Knew" was written by Pink, Max Martin and Dr. Luke, while it was produced by Martin and Dr. Luke. "Who Knew" was released as the second single off the album worldwide in 2006, while it was re-released to U.S. radio as the album's fourth single in the United States in 2007, after the success of "U + Ur Hand".
Composition and writing
"Who Knew" musically is a pop rock song, which features soft rock and ballad music influences. According to Musicnotes.com, which was published by Kobalt Music Publishing America, Inc., the song is set in the key A Major. Pink's vocal's span from E3 to D5. Lyrically, Pink had explained that the song is about "the death of friendship", as well as friends of hers who died as a result of drug overdoses. The song is about several people.
Billboard magazine, in its second review of the song (to accompany the U.S. re-release), called it "another cool, smart, plenty passionate melodic jewel about the death of a friend and/or friendship, with an instantly identifiable, quick-to-the-point, singalong track—maintaining Pink's stance as the smartest female millennium-era singer/songwriter, dazzling in star quality as alterna-pop's premier princess." The song features acoustic guitar, keyboards, drums, and electric guitars. Gottwald, Martin and Pink co-wrote another song on the album, "U + Ur Hand".
The song received a positive reception from most music critics. John Murphy from MusicOMH wrote that the song "is perfect driving, anthemic pop." Stylus Magazine said ironically that "It’s “Since U Been Gone” spinning its wheels at half-speed, mutedly wondering where the tune went." Yahoo! Music's Justin Lewis somewhat echoed the same thought of Stylus Magazine, writing that "it sounds like the lo-fi twin sister of "Since U Been Gone" (same acoustic opening, same 4/4 drumbeat and same hushed-verse/loud-chorus blueprint) but it takes several listens before you realize both songs were cut from the same mold. Sal Cinquemani from Slant Magazine wrote a mixed review, saying that "Songs like 'Who Knew' and 'Long Way To Happy', though good, sound more hair metal than punk", while also noting that it "follows the steps of Clarkson's recent hits."
In the Oceanic region, the song debuted at number six on the Australian Singles Chart. The song then rose and peaked at number two for two consecutive weeks. In total, the song stayed in the charts for thirty-two weeks, becoming Pink's second longest charting single in that country. The song is also the seventy-fifth Best Of All Time single in Australia, and is certified platinum for sales of over 70,000 copies. It was ranked at number nine on ARIA's Top 100 singles of 2006. The song had debuted at number thirty-six on the New Zealand Singles Chart, and eventually rose to number eleven, just missing the top ten. The song spent a total of twelve weeks on the charts.
In the European markets, the song was generally successful. "Who Knew" entered the UK Singles Chart at nineteen in early June, 2006 and ascended to a peak at five the following week. It is her joint fifth highest charting single in the UK and her second longest charting behind only "So What". With a total of 26 weeks inside the top 100 songs it beats her number-one hit "Just Like A Pill". The song had success throughout other charts in Europe, where it peaked in the top twenty in Switzerland, Austria, France, Belgium, Finland and Norway, while it peaked in the top fifty in The Netherlands and Sweden.
When the single was originally released in North America, "Who Knew" was less successful. Though it peaked at number nineteen on the BDS Airplay Chart in Canada, it was virtually ignored by American radio. In the U.S., where it was released to mainstream radio on May 8, 2006, it failed to chart on the Billboard Hot 100, initially reaching number 18 on the Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles chart (which comprises the most popular songs yet to enter the Hot 100). Billboard magazine credited the poor performance of the single on radio with significantly reducing momentum of initial sales of I'm Not Dead.
In March 2007 the song was used in promotion for the ABC television show October Road, after which download sales of the song increased; as a result, it debuted at number ninety-five on the Hot 100 at the end of the month. During the same period, "U + Ur Hand", the third single from I'm Not Dead, had achieved major success on pop radio and was credited with "reviving" Pink's career in the U.S.
Pink performed "Who Knew" on the May 9, 2007, episode of American Idol. It was re-released to mainstream radio in the United States on June 26, 2007, although it had already been receiving minor airplay on CHR/top 40 and hot AC/adult top 40 stations earlier in the month. In week twenty-five of 2007 "Who Knew" re-entered the Billboard Hot 100 at number ninety-four; it eventually climbed to number nine, giving Pink her eighth top ten single on the chart and matching the peak position of "U + Ur Hand".
The single's video was directed by Dragon, a team comprising Sam Bayer, Robert Hales and Brian Lazzaro. It was filmed in the weekend beginning April 15, 2006 in Los Angeles, United States, and it was released to the internet and to UK music channels in early May 2006. The video reached number one on MTV Germany's top ten and on TRL Italy. "Who Knew" was voted number one on TRL Germany twenty times, allowing Pink to earn the "Golden Tape". In the U.S. Total Request Live broadcast a "First Look" of the video on May 22, and it debuted on the show's top ten countdown the following day; it spent eight non-consecutive days on the countdown (until June 9), peaking at number seven.
It features a young couple visiting a fairground and going on the rides, and at one point the boy puts a necklace on the girl. The video flashes back to the boy secretly injecting himself with drugs on a previous night while the girl is sleeping. At the carnival, when the girl is playing a game, the boy walks away. The girl realizes he's gone and follows him, but when she tries to get him to stay with her he gets violent. He goes to the back of the fairground to inject himself with drugs and breaks into a sweat. His girlfriend wanders around looking for him, and finds him unconscious; he has overdosed. She gives him a kiss, gives back the necklace and phones for an ambulance; after it has arrived, she walks away crying. The video is inter-cut with shots of Pink singing the song at the entrance to the fairground.
In Pink's 2008 album Funhouse, she compares life to a carnival, because carnivals are supposed to be enjoyable, but in actuality, they're not. The setting for the music video with the fairgrounds provides a false sense of security for the girl in the music video.
Track listings and formats
- UK CD1
- "Who Knew" (Album Version) - 3:28
- "Disconnected" - 3:58
- . "Who Knew" (Music Video) - 4:02
- UK CD2
- "Who Knew" (Album Version) - 3:28
- "Who Knew" (Sharp Boys' Love Jonathan Harvey Remix) - 8:42
- "Who Knew" (Bimbo Jones Radio Edit) - 3:27
- "Who Knew" (Beat Cult Club Mix) - 6:25
- "Who Knew" (Don Diablo & Jason Nevins Mix) - 7:19
- Other Mixes
- "Who Knew" (Bimbo Jones Club Mix) - 7:49
- "Who Knew" (Don Diablo & Jason Nevins Edit) - 5:45
- "Who Knew" (Jason Nevins Radio Edit) - 3:27
- "Who Knew" (Eddie Baez Club Mix) - 9:45
- "Who Knew" (Sharp Boys' Coronation Street Dub) - 8:55
Charts and certifications
- "Available for Airplay - 2006 - 5/8 Mainstream". FMBQ. Retrieved July 4, 2007.
- "Available for Airplay - 2007 - 6/26 Mainstream". FMBQ. Retrieved July 4, 2007.
- Taylor, Chuck. "Single Reviews - Who Knew - Pink". Billboard. Retrieved June 13, 2007.
- "P!nk Album & Song Chart History". Billboard. Retrieved 2012-11-07.
- Who Knew by Pink Songfacts.
- "P!nk - Greatest Hits...So Far!!! EPK". YouTube. 2010-12-07. Retrieved 2012-03-15.
- Musicnotes.com Who Knew | Pink
- Vineyard, Jennifer. "Pink: Not Dead, Not Stupid". MTV News. February 17, 2006. Retrieved September 22, 2006.
- Ellen, Barbara. "Philly girl". The Observer. June 4, 2006. Retrieved March 23, 2007.
- Vineyard, Jennifer. "Pink Pens An Open Letter To President Bush On New Album" MTV News. January 3, 2006. Retrieved March 30, 2007.
- "P!nk - I'm Not Dead - Music Review at IGN". IGN. 4 April 2006. Retrieved 7 February 2012.
- Murphy, Jon (3 April 2006). "Pink - I'm Not Dead - album review - musicOMH". musicOMH. Retrieved 7 February 2012.
- "Pink - I'm Not Dead - Review - Stylus Magazine". Stylus Magazine. Retrieved 7 February 2012.
- Lewis, Justin. "I'm Not Dead: P!nk (Album Review) - Yahoo !Voices". Yahoo!. Retrieved 7 February 2012.
- Cinquemani, Sal (6 April 2006). "Pink: I'm Not Dead - Music Review - Slant Magazine". Slant Magazine. Retrieved 8 February 2012.
- Best of All Time Australian List
- [dead link]
- European Charts
- "Pink's latest album gets another chance". Reuters/Billboard. March 24, 2007. Retrieved May 19, 2007.
- Cohen, Jonathan. "Akon Scores Second No. 1 Hit From 'Konvicted'". Billboard. March 29, 2007. Retrieved March 30, 2007.
- Bronson, Fred. "Chart Beat Chat - Suddenly In The Pink". Billboard. March 30, 2007. Retrieved April 3, 2007.
- Caulfield, Keith. "Ask Billboard - Pink's Not Dead". Billboard. June 15, 2007. Retrieved July 4, 2007.
- "Pink - Artist Chart History - Singles". Billboard.
- "Enter the Dragon". MySpace Blog: pinkspage. April 12, 2006. Retrieved December 18, 2006.
- "For The Record: Quick News On Proof, Game, Pink, White Stripes, Ashanti, Michael Jackson, Great White & More". MTV News. April 17, 2006. Retrieved March 23, 2007.
- "The TRL Archive - Recap - May 2006". ATRL.net. Retrieved July 5, 2007.
- "The TRL Archive - Recap - June 2006". ATRL.net. Retrieved July 5, 2007.
- "P!nk - Who Knew". MusicSquare.
- "Canadian Hot 100 - Who Knew". Billboard. November 17, 2007.
- "Hungarian Airplay Chart. mahasz.hu November 19, 2006.
- "Pink - Billboard Singles". Billboard and Allmusic.
- "Pop Rock" (in Spanish). Record Report. 2006-07-15. Archived from the original on 2006-11-24.
- "ARIA Charts - Accreditations - 2007 Singles". Australian Recording Industry Association. Archived from the original on 2007. Retrieved 25 April 2013.
- "Canadian single certifications – Pink – Who Knew". Music Canada.
- "RIAA - Searchable Database". Recording Industry Association of America. Archived from the original on 2008. Retrieved 25 April 2013.