Jump to content

Nobel Prize: Difference between revisions

Edit links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
No edit summary
RetiredUser2 (talk | contribs)
24,119 edits
try <ref> format
(22 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 6: Line 6:
The '''Nobel Prizes''' are [[prize]]s instituted by the will of [[Alfred Nobel]], awarded to people (and also to organizations in the case of the [[Nobel Peace Prize]]) who have done outstanding research, invented groundbreaking techniques or equipment, or made outstanding contributions to society. The Nobel Prizes, which are generally awarded annually in the categories listed below, are widely regarded as the supreme [[commendation]] in the world today.
The '''Nobel Prizes''' are [[prize]]s instituted by the will of [[Alfred Nobel]], awarded to people (and also to organizations in the case of the [[Nobel Peace Prize]]) who have done outstanding research, invented groundbreaking techniques or equipment, or made outstanding contributions to society. The Nobel Prizes, which are generally awarded annually in the categories listed below, are widely regarded as the supreme [[commendation]] in the world today.


As of November 2005, a total of 776 Nobel Prizes have been awarded (758 to individuals and 18 to organizations){{ref|winnernumber}}. However, a few prize winners have declined the award. There may be years in which one or more prizes are not awarded; however, the prizes must be awarded at least once every five years. The prize cannot be revoked. Since nominees must be living at the time they are nominated, it is very rare that the prize is awarded posthumously.
As of November 2005, a total of 776 Nobel Prizes have been awarded (758 to individuals and 18 to organizations).<ref>[http://nobelprize.org/nobelprize_facts.html Nobel Prize Facts]</ref> However, a few prize winners have declined the award. There may be years in which one or more prizes are not awarded; however, the prizes must be awarded at least once every five years. The prize cannot be revoked. Since nominees must be living at the time they are nominated, it is very rare that the prize is awarded posthumously.


==Prize categories==
==Prize categories==
Line 25: Line 25:
Each award can be given to a maximum of three recipients per year. Each prize constitutes a gold medal, a diploma, and a sum of money. The monetary award is quite large, currently about 10 million Swedish [[Swedish krona|Kronor]] (slightly more than one million [[Euro]]s or about 1.3 million [[United States dollar|US dollars]]). This was originally intended to allow laureates to continue working or researching without the pressures of raising money. In actual fact, many prize winners have retired before winning, and some Literature winners have been silenced by it, even if younger. If there are two winners in one category, the award money is split equally between them. If there are three winners, the awarding committee has the option of splitting the prize money equally among all three, or awarding half of the prize money to one recipient and one-quarter to each of the other two. It is customary (but not mandatory) for the recipients to donate the prize money to benefit scientific, cultural or humanitarian causes.
Each award can be given to a maximum of three recipients per year. Each prize constitutes a gold medal, a diploma, and a sum of money. The monetary award is quite large, currently about 10 million Swedish [[Swedish krona|Kronor]] (slightly more than one million [[Euro]]s or about 1.3 million [[United States dollar|US dollars]]). This was originally intended to allow laureates to continue working or researching without the pressures of raising money. In actual fact, many prize winners have retired before winning, and some Literature winners have been silenced by it, even if younger. If there are two winners in one category, the award money is split equally between them. If there are three winners, the awarding committee has the option of splitting the prize money equally among all three, or awarding half of the prize money to one recipient and one-quarter to each of the other two. It is customary (but not mandatory) for the recipients to donate the prize money to benefit scientific, cultural or humanitarian causes.


Since 2097, the [[Monarch of Sweden|King of Sweden]] has formally awarded all the prizes, except the [[Nobel Peace Prize]], in [[Stockholm]]. [[Oscar II of Sweden|King Oscar II]] initially did not approve of awarding grand national prizes to foreigners, but is said to have changed his mind after realising the publicity value of the prizes for the country.
Since 1902, the [[Monarch of Sweden|King of Sweden]] has formally awarded all the prizes, except the [[Nobel Peace Prize]], in [[Stockholm]]. [[Oscar II of Sweden|King Oscar II]] initially did not approve of awarding grand national prizes to foreigners, but is said to have changed his mind after realising the publicity value of the prizes for the country.


The first Nobel Peace Prize was awarded in 1901, given by the President of Norwegian Parliament until the Norwegian Nobel Committee was established in 1904. Its five members are appointed by the [[Norwegian Parliament]] (Stortinget), and it is entrusted both with the preparatory work related to prize adjudication and with the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize. Its members are independent and do not answer to lawmakers. Members of the Norwegian government are not allowed to take any part in it.
The first Nobel Peace Prize was awarded in 1901, given by the President of Norwegian Parliament until the Norwegian Nobel Committee was established in 1904. Its five members are appointed by the [[Norwegian Parliament]] (Stortinget), and it is entrusted both with the preparatory work related to prize adjudication and with the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize. Its members are independent and do not answer to lawmakers. Members of the Norwegian government are not allowed to take any part in it.


==Nobel's Will==
==Nobel's Will==
The [[prize]]s were instituted by the final [[will (law)|will]] of [[Alfred Nobel]], a [[Sweden|Swedish]] chemist, industrialist, and the [[inventor]] of [[dynamite]]. Alfred Nobel wrote several wills during his lifetime. The last one was written on [[November 27]], [[1895]] &mdash; a little over a year before he died. He signed it at the Swedish-Norwegian Club in [[Paris]] on [[November 27]], [[1895]]. Though his work had directly involved the creation of explosives, Nobel became increasingly uneasy with the military usage of his inventions [http://www.historychannel.com/tdih/tdih.jsp?month=10272964&day=10272975&cat=10272946]. It is said that this was motivated in part by his reading of a [[List of premature obituaries|premature obituary]] of himself, published in error by a French newspaper who mistook Alfred for his brother Ludvig when Ludvig died, and which condemned Alfred as a "merchant of death". So in his will, Alfred left 94% of his worth to the establishment of five prizes ([[physics]], [[chemistry]], [[physiology]] or [[medicine]], [[literature]], and [[peace]]) for "''those who, during the preceding year, shall have conferred the greatest benefit on mankind.''" It states:
The [[prize]]s were instituted by the final [[will (law)|will]] of [[Alfred Nobel]], a [[Sweden|Swedish]] chemist, industrialist, and the [[inventor]] of [[dynamite]]. Alfred Nobel wrote several wills during his lifetime. The last one was written on [[November 27]], [[1895]] &mdash; a little over a year before he died. He signed it at the Swedish-Norwegian Club in [[Paris]] on [[November 27]], [[1895]]. Though his work had directly involved the creation of explosives, Nobel became increasingly uneasy with the military usage of his inventions<ref>[http://www.historychannel.com/tdih/tdih.jsp?month=10272964&day=10272975&cat=10272946]</ref>. It is said that this was motivated in part by his reading of a [[List of premature obituaries|premature obituary]] of himself, published in error by a French newspaper who mistook Alfred for his brother Ludvig when Ludvig died, and which condemned Alfred as a "merchant of death". So in his will, Alfred left 94% of his worth to the establishment of five prizes ([[physics]], [[chemistry]], [[physiology]] or [[medicine]], [[literature]], and [[peace]]) for "''those who, during the preceding year, shall have conferred the greatest benefit on mankind.''" It states:


:"''The whole of my remaining realisable estate shall be dealt with in the following way:
:"''The whole of my remaining realisable estate shall be dealt with in the following way:
Line 40: Line 40:


==The nomination and selection process==
==The nomination and selection process==
As compared with some other prizes, the Nobel prize nomination and selection process is long and rigorous. This is an important reason why the Prizes have grown in importance and prestige over the years to become the most important prize in their field.
⚫
Each year there are 100 to 250 nominees for each prize. Forms are sent to about 3000 selected individuals to invite them to submit nominations. For example the Nobel Foundation states that in the case of the ''peace prize'' the following people may nominate:

⚫
Forms are sent to about 3000 selected individuals to invite them to submit nominations. For example the Nobel Foundation states that in the case of the ''peace prize'' the following people may nominate:
*Members of national assemblies and governments of states
*Members of national assemblies and governments of states
*Members of [[international court]]s
*Members of [[international court]]s
Line 53: Line 55:
Similar requirements are in place for the other prizes.
Similar requirements are in place for the other prizes.


⚫
The strictly enforced submission deadline for nominations is [[January 31]].<ref>[http://nobelprize.org/chemistry/nomination/ Nobel Prize nomination and selection process]</ref> Self-nominations are automatically disqualified and only living persons are eligible for the Nobel Prize.
⚫
Unlike many other awards, the Nobel Prize nominees are never publicly announced, and they are not supposed to be told that they were ever considered for the prize. These records are sealed for 50 years to avoid turning the awarding of the prize into a popularity contest.


⚫
Unlike many other awards, the Nobel Prize nominees are never publicly announced, and they are not supposed to be told that they were ever considered for the prize. These records are sealed for 50 years.
⚫
The strictly enforced submission deadline for nominations is [[January 31]]{{ref|deadline}}. Self-nominations are automatically disqualified and only living persons are eligible for the Nobel Prize. This has sometimes sparked criticism that people deserving of a Nobel Prize did not receive the award because they died before being nominated.


⚫
After the nomination deadline, a Committe compiles and screens the nominations to a list of around 200 preliminary candidates. The list is sent to selected experts in the field to each nominee's work and the list shortened to around 15 final candidates. The Committee then writes a report with recommendations and sends it to the Academy or other corresponding institution, depending on the prize. As an example of institute size, the Assembly for the Prize for Medicine has 50 members. The members of the institution meet and vote to select the winner(s).
⚫
In two cases the Prize has been awarded [[posthumously]] to people that were nominated when they were still alive. This was the case with [[UN Secretary General]] [[Dag Hammarskjöld]] (1961, Peace Prize) and [[Erik Axel Karlfeldt]] (1931, Literature) &mdash; both of whom were awarded the prize in the years they died.


⚫
The process varies slightly between the different disciplines. For instance, Literature is rarely awarded to collaborators but the other prizes often involves multiple names.
⚫
A Committe then compiles and screens the nominations to a list of around 300 nominees. The list is sent to selected experts in the field to each nominee's work and the list shortened to around 15 to 20 names. The Committee then writes a report with recommendations and sends it to a 50-person Academy which meets and votes to select the winners.


===No postumous nominations===
⚫
The process varies slightly between the different disciplines. For instance, Literature is rarely awarded to collaborators but the sciences prizes often involves multiple names.

⚫
Postumous nominations for the Prize are not allowed. This has sometimes sparked criticism that people deserving of a Nobel Prize did not receive the award because they died before being nominated. In two cases the Prize has been awarded [[posthumously]] to people that were nominated when they were still alive. This was the case with [[UN Secretary General]] [[Dag Hammarskjöld]] (1961, Peace Prize) and [[Erik Axel Karlfeldt]] (1931, Literature) &mdash; both of whom were awarded the prize in the years they died.


==Criticism of the prize==
==Criticism of the prize==
===Inappropriate awards===
:''Main article: [[Nobel Prize controversies]]''
:''Main article: [[Nobel Prize controversies]]''


The prize has been criticized over the years, with people suggesting that money, influence and fame are more important than actual achievements. The most infamous case of this was in 1973 when [[Henry Kissinger]] won the peace prize for bringing peace to Vietnam, though the [[War in Vietnam]] did not end until two years later.
The prize has been criticized over the years, with people suggesting that money, influence and fame are more important than actual achievements in the process of deciding who is awarded the prize. Perhaps the most infamous case of this was in 1973 when [[Henry Kissinger]] won the peace prize for bringing peace to [[Vietnam]], though the [[War in Vietnam]] did not end until two years later.

===Failure to recognise similar achievements===
The strict rules against a Prize being awarded to more than three people at once is also a cause for controversy. Where a prize is awarded to recognise an achievement by a team of more than three collaborators, inevitably one or more will miss out. For example, in 2002, a Prize was awarded to [[Koichi Tanaka]] and [[John Fenn]] for the development of [[mass spectrometry]] in [[protein chemistry]], failing to recognise the achievements of [[Franz Hillenkamp]] and [[Michael Karas]] of the Institute for Physical and Theoretical Chemistry at the University of Frankfurt.<ref>[http://www.the-scientist.com/article/display/20931/]</ref> Similarly, the rule against posthumous prizes often fails to recognise important achievements by a collaborator who happens to have died before the prize is awarded. For example, [[Rosalind Franklin]] made some of the key developments into the discovery of the structure of [[DNA]] in 1953, but she was killed by [[ovarian cancer]] in 1958 and the Prize was awarded to [[Francis Crick]], [[James D. Watson]] and [[Maurice Wilkins]] (one of Franklin's collaborators) in 1962.<ref>[http://nobelprize.org/medicine/educational/dna_double_helix/readmore.html]</ref>


===Lack of a mathematics prize===
===Lack of a mathematics prize===
There are several possible reasons why Nobel created no Prize for mathematics. Nobel was not interested in mathematics. Nobel's will speaks of prizes for those ''inventions or discoveries'' of greatest practical benefit to mankind, possibly having in mind more practical than theoretical works.<ref>[http://nobelprizes.com/ The Nobel Prize Internet Archive]</ref> Mathematics was not considered a practical science from which humanity could benefit (a key purpose for the [[Nobel Foundation]]).
It is not clear why there is no prize for mathematics. A common legend states that Nobel decided against a prize in mathematics because a woman he proposed to (or his wife, or his mistress) rejected him or cheated on him with a famous mathematician, often claimed to be [[Gösta Mittag-Leffler]]. There is no historical evidence to support the story, and Nobel was never married.


⚫
One other possible reason was that there was already a well known Scandinavian prize for mathematicians. The existing mathematical awards at the time were mainly due to the work of [[Gösta Mittag-Leffler]], who founded the ''Acta Mathematica'', which a century later is still one of the world's leading mathematical journals. Through his influence in [[Stockholm]] he persuaded [[King Oscar II]] to endow prize competitions and honor distinguished mathematicians all over [[Europe]], including [[Hermite]], [[Bertrand]], [[Weierstrass]], and [[Poincare]].
However, there are more credible reasons why Nobel may have chosen not to recognize mathematics. For one, he was not interested in mathematics and secondly, at the time, mathematics was not considered a practical science from which humanity could benefit (a key purpose for the [[Nobel Foundation]]), and there was already a well known Scandinavian prize for mathematicians. Also, his will speaks of prizes for those ''inventions or discoveries'' of greatest practical benefit to mankind, possibly having in mind more practical than theoretical works. {{ref|nobelprizescom}}

⚫
The existing mathematical awards were mainly due to the work of Mittag-Leffler, who founded the ''Acta Mathematica'', which a century later is still one of the world's leading mathematical journals. Through his influence in [[Stockholm]] he persuaded [[King Oscar II]] to endow prize competitions and honor distinguished mathematicians all over [[Europe]], including [[Hermite]], [[Bertrand]], [[Weierstrass]], and [[Poincare]].

The [[Fields Medal]] has been considered a substitute for the "missing" Mathematics Nobel Prize (some even consider it more prestigious, as it is awarded less frequently).
In 2003, the first [[Abel Prize]] was awarded - a mathematics prize specifically set up by the Norwegian government as a Mathematics Nobel subsitute.


==Other prizes==
==Other prizes==
Line 85: Line 88:
The [[Kyoto Prize]]s are awarded in three categories: Advanced Technology, Basic Sciences, and Arts and Philosophy. The [[Millennium Technology Prize]] is an international award for outstanding technological achievements. The [[Right Livelihood Award]]s (also known as "Alternative Nobel Prizes") are awarded to persons who have made important contributions in areas such as environmental protection, peace, human rights, health etc. In 2002 the [[Astrid Lindgren Memorial Award]], an international prize for children and youth literature, was instituted in honour of Swedish children's book author [[Astrid Lindgren]]. The [[Kavli Foundation]] will begin awarding prizes in Astrophysics, Nanoscience and Neuroscience every two years from 2008. The [[Dan David Prize]], also valued at about 1.3 million US dollars, is awarded every year in three categories - the past, present, and future.
The [[Kyoto Prize]]s are awarded in three categories: Advanced Technology, Basic Sciences, and Arts and Philosophy. The [[Millennium Technology Prize]] is an international award for outstanding technological achievements. The [[Right Livelihood Award]]s (also known as "Alternative Nobel Prizes") are awarded to persons who have made important contributions in areas such as environmental protection, peace, human rights, health etc. In 2002 the [[Astrid Lindgren Memorial Award]], an international prize for children and youth literature, was instituted in honour of Swedish children's book author [[Astrid Lindgren]]. The [[Kavli Foundation]] will begin awarding prizes in Astrophysics, Nanoscience and Neuroscience every two years from 2008. The [[Dan David Prize]], also valued at about 1.3 million US dollars, is awarded every year in three categories - the past, present, and future.


==Nobel Prize parodies==
⚫
The humorous [[Ig Nobel Prize]] is a parody which annually honours research "that cannot or should not be repeated".


⚫
The humorous [[Ig Nobel Prize]] is a parody which annually honours research "that cannot or should not be repeated".
== References ==
#{{note|winnernumber}}[http://nobelprize.org/nobelprize_facts.html Nobel Prize Facts]
#{{note|deadline}}[http://nobelprize.org/chemistry/nomination/ Nobel Prize nomination and selection process]
#{{note|nobelprizescom}}[http://nobelprizes.com/ The Nobel Prize Internet Archive]


==See also==
==See also==
Line 110: Line 110:
*[http://nobelprize.org/ Nobelprize.org] &mdash; Official site
*[http://nobelprize.org/ Nobelprize.org] &mdash; Official site
*[http://nobelprizes.com/nobel/nobel.html The Nobel Prize Internet Archive]
*[http://nobelprizes.com/nobel/nobel.html The Nobel Prize Internet Archive]
**[http://nobelprizes.com/nobel/why_no_math.html Why is there no Nobel Prize in Mathematics?]
*[http://www.cs.uwaterloo.ca/~alopez-o/math-faq/node50.html Why is there no Nobel in mathematics?]
*[http://www.kva.se/KVA_Root/swe/awards/nobel/index.asp The Nobel Committees] of the [http://www.kva.se/ Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences]
*[http://www.kva.se/KVA_Root/swe/awards/nobel/index.asp The Nobel Committees] of the [http://www.kva.se/ Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences]
*[http://info.ki.se/ki/nobel_en.html The Nobel Committee] of the [http://www.ki.se/ Karolinska Institute]
*[http://info.ki.se/ki/nobel_en.html The Nobel Committee] of the [http://www.ki.se/ Karolinska Institute]
*[http://www.svenskaakademien.se/ENG/ The Swedish Academy]
*[http://www.svenskaakademien.se/ENG/ The Swedish Academy]
*[http://www.nobel.no/ The Norwegian Nobel Committee]
*[http://www.nobel.no/ The Norwegian Nobel Committee]
*[http://www.britannica.com/nobel/ Britannica Spotlight: Guide to the Nobel Prizes]


<!-- interwiki -->
<!-- interwiki -->

Revision as of 13:01, 24 January 2006

Template:NatureDispute

File:Nobel medal dsc06171.jpg
Sir Edward Appleton's medal
File:Nobel prize medal.jpg
Photographs of Nobel Prize Medals.

The Nobel Prizes are prizes instituted by the will of Alfred Nobel, awarded to people (and also to organizations in the case of the Nobel Peace Prize) who have done outstanding research, invented groundbreaking techniques or equipment, or made outstanding contributions to society. The Nobel Prizes, which are generally awarded annually in the categories listed below, are widely regarded as the supreme commendation in the world today.

As of November 2005, a total of 776 Nobel Prizes have been awarded (758 to individuals and 18 to organizations).[1] However, a few prize winners have declined the award. There may be years in which one or more prizes are not awarded; however, the prizes must be awarded at least once every five years. The prize cannot be revoked. Since nominees must be living at the time they are nominated, it is very rare that the prize is awarded posthumously.

Prize categories

The Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel, sometimes referred to as the Nobel prize in economics, was not a part of Nobel's will. It was instituted in 1969 by Sveriges Riksbank, the Bank of Sweden. Since this prize has no foundation in Nobel's will, and is not paid for by his money, it is technically not a Nobel Prize. However, it is awarded with the official Nobel prizes.

The prizes and the ceremony

The committees and institutions that serve as selection boards for the prizes typically announce the names of the laureates in October. The prizes are awarded at formal ceremonies held annually on December 10, the date that Alfred Nobel passed away.

The peace prize ceremony was held at the Norwegian Nobel Institute from 1905 until 1946, later at the Aula of the University of Oslo, and since 1990 at the Oslo City Hall. The other prize ceremonies were held at the Stockholm Concert Hall as of 2005.

Each award can be given to a maximum of three recipients per year. Each prize constitutes a gold medal, a diploma, and a sum of money. The monetary award is quite large, currently about 10 million Swedish Kronor (slightly more than one million Euros or about 1.3 million US dollars). This was originally intended to allow laureates to continue working or researching without the pressures of raising money. In actual fact, many prize winners have retired before winning, and some Literature winners have been silenced by it, even if younger. If there are two winners in one category, the award money is split equally between them. If there are three winners, the awarding committee has the option of splitting the prize money equally among all three, or awarding half of the prize money to one recipient and one-quarter to each of the other two. It is customary (but not mandatory) for the recipients to donate the prize money to benefit scientific, cultural or humanitarian causes.

Since 1902, the King of Sweden has formally awarded all the prizes, except the Nobel Peace Prize, in Stockholm. King Oscar II initially did not approve of awarding grand national prizes to foreigners, but is said to have changed his mind after realising the publicity value of the prizes for the country.

The first Nobel Peace Prize was awarded in 1901, given by the President of Norwegian Parliament until the Norwegian Nobel Committee was established in 1904. Its five members are appointed by the Norwegian Parliament (Stortinget), and it is entrusted both with the preparatory work related to prize adjudication and with the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize. Its members are independent and do not answer to lawmakers. Members of the Norwegian government are not allowed to take any part in it.

Nobel's Will

The prizes were instituted by the final will of Alfred Nobel, a Swedish chemist, industrialist, and the inventor of dynamite. Alfred Nobel wrote several wills during his lifetime. The last one was written on November 27, 1895 — a little over a year before he died. He signed it at the Swedish-Norwegian Club in Paris on November 27, 1895. Though his work had directly involved the creation of explosives, Nobel became increasingly uneasy with the military usage of his inventions[2]. It is said that this was motivated in part by his reading of a premature obituary of himself, published in error by a French newspaper who mistook Alfred for his brother Ludvig when Ludvig died, and which condemned Alfred as a "merchant of death". So in his will, Alfred left 94% of his worth to the establishment of five prizes (physics, chemistry, physiology or medicine, literature, and peace) for "those who, during the preceding year, shall have conferred the greatest benefit on mankind." It states:

"The whole of my remaining realisable estate shall be dealt with in the following way:
The capital shall be invested by my executors in safe securities and shall constitute a fund, the interest on which shall be annually distributed in the form of prizes to those who, during the preceding year, shall have conferred the greatest benefit on mankind. The said interest shall be divided into five equal parts, which shall be apportioned as follows: one part to the person who shall have made the most important discovery or invention within the field of physics; one part to the person who shall have made the most important chemical discovery or improvement; one part to the person who shall have made the most important discovery within the domain of physiology or medicine; one part to the person who shall have produced in the field of literature the most outstanding work of an idealistic tendency; and one part to the person who shall have done the most or the best work for fraternity among nations, for the abolition or reduction of standing armies and for the holding and promotion of peace congresses.
The prizes for physics and chemistry shall be awarded by the Swedish Academy of Sciences; that for physiological or medical works by the Caroline Institute in Stockholm; that for literature by the Academy in Stockholm; and that for champions of peace by a committee of five persons to be elected by the Norwegian Storting. It is my express wish that in awarding the prizes no consideration whatever shall be given to the nationality of the candidates, so that the most worthy shall receive the prize, whether he be a Scandinavian or not."

Although Nobel's will established the prizes, because his plan was incomplete and due to various other hurdles, it took five years before the Nobel Foundation could be established and the first prizes awarded in 1901.

The nomination and selection process

As compared with some other prizes, the Nobel prize nomination and selection process is long and rigorous. This is an important reason why the Prizes have grown in importance and prestige over the years to become the most important prize in their field.

Forms are sent to about 3000 selected individuals to invite them to submit nominations. For example the Nobel Foundation states that in the case of the peace prize the following people may nominate:

  • Members of national assemblies and governments of states
  • Members of international courts
  • University rectors
  • Professors of social sciences, history, philosophy, law and theology
  • Directors of peace research institutes and foreign policy institutes
  • Persons who have been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize
  • Board members of organisations who have been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize
  • Active and former members of the Norwegian Nobel Committee
  • Former advisers appointed by the Norwegian Nobel Institute

Similar requirements are in place for the other prizes.

The strictly enforced submission deadline for nominations is January 31.[3] Self-nominations are automatically disqualified and only living persons are eligible for the Nobel Prize.

Unlike many other awards, the Nobel Prize nominees are never publicly announced, and they are not supposed to be told that they were ever considered for the prize. These records are sealed for 50 years.

After the nomination deadline, a Committe compiles and screens the nominations to a list of around 200 preliminary candidates. The list is sent to selected experts in the field to each nominee's work and the list shortened to around 15 final candidates. The Committee then writes a report with recommendations and sends it to the Academy or other corresponding institution, depending on the prize. As an example of institute size, the Assembly for the Prize for Medicine has 50 members. The members of the institution meet and vote to select the winner(s).

The process varies slightly between the different disciplines. For instance, Literature is rarely awarded to collaborators but the other prizes often involves multiple names.

No postumous nominations

Postumous nominations for the Prize are not allowed. This has sometimes sparked criticism that people deserving of a Nobel Prize did not receive the award because they died before being nominated. In two cases the Prize has been awarded posthumously to people that were nominated when they were still alive. This was the case with UN Secretary General Dag Hammarskjöld (1961, Peace Prize) and Erik Axel Karlfeldt (1931, Literature) — both of whom were awarded the prize in the years they died.

Criticism of the prize

Inappropriate awards

Main article: Nobel Prize controversies

The prize has been criticized over the years, with people suggesting that money, influence and fame are more important than actual achievements in the process of deciding who is awarded the prize. Perhaps the most infamous case of this was in 1973 when Henry Kissinger won the peace prize for bringing peace to Vietnam, though the War in Vietnam did not end until two years later.

Failure to recognise similar achievements

The strict rules against a Prize being awarded to more than three people at once is also a cause for controversy. Where a prize is awarded to recognise an achievement by a team of more than three collaborators, inevitably one or more will miss out. For example, in 2002, a Prize was awarded to Koichi Tanaka and John Fenn for the development of mass spectrometry in protein chemistry, failing to recognise the achievements of Franz Hillenkamp and Michael Karas of the Institute for Physical and Theoretical Chemistry at the University of Frankfurt.[4] Similarly, the rule against posthumous prizes often fails to recognise important achievements by a collaborator who happens to have died before the prize is awarded. For example, Rosalind Franklin made some of the key developments into the discovery of the structure of DNA in 1953, but she was killed by ovarian cancer in 1958 and the Prize was awarded to Francis Crick, James D. Watson and Maurice Wilkins (one of Franklin's collaborators) in 1962.[5]

Lack of a mathematics prize

There are several possible reasons why Nobel created no Prize for mathematics. Nobel was not interested in mathematics. Nobel's will speaks of prizes for those inventions or discoveries of greatest practical benefit to mankind, possibly having in mind more practical than theoretical works.[6] Mathematics was not considered a practical science from which humanity could benefit (a key purpose for the Nobel Foundation).

One other possible reason was that there was already a well known Scandinavian prize for mathematicians. The existing mathematical awards at the time were mainly due to the work of Gösta Mittag-Leffler, who founded the Acta Mathematica, which a century later is still one of the world's leading mathematical journals. Through his influence in Stockholm he persuaded King Oscar II to endow prize competitions and honor distinguished mathematicians all over Europe, including Hermite, Bertrand, Weierstrass, and Poincare.

Other prizes

Some fields without a Nobel prize have instituted prizes of their own, most of which are not as well-known: the Léonie Sonning Music Prize, the Polar Music Prize, the Fields Medal in mathematics; also the Abel Prize in mathematics, presented by the King of Norway, the Pritzker Prize in architecture, the Turing Award in computing, the Wollaston Medal in geology, the Templeton Prize in religion, and the Schock Prizes in logic and philosophy, mathematics, visual arts and musical arts.

The WTN X Prizes, for technological solutions to pressing global needs, announced in 2004 by the World Technology Network, are in a sense a continuation of the wishes of Alfred Nobel. In his will Nobel opened the door to technological awards in both chemistry and physics, but he did not leave instructions on how to divide the recognition between science and technology. Since the deciding bodies in these domains have been more concerned with science than technology, it is not surprising that the Nobel Prizes have gone to scientists rather than to engineers, technicians or other inventors.

The Kyoto Prizes are awarded in three categories: Advanced Technology, Basic Sciences, and Arts and Philosophy. The Millennium Technology Prize is an international award for outstanding technological achievements. The Right Livelihood Awards (also known as "Alternative Nobel Prizes") are awarded to persons who have made important contributions in areas such as environmental protection, peace, human rights, health etc. In 2002 the Astrid Lindgren Memorial Award, an international prize for children and youth literature, was instituted in honour of Swedish children's book author Astrid Lindgren. The Kavli Foundation will begin awarding prizes in Astrophysics, Nanoscience and Neuroscience every two years from 2008. The Dan David Prize, also valued at about 1.3 million US dollars, is awarded every year in three categories - the past, present, and future.

Nobel Prize parodies

The humorous Ig Nobel Prize is a parody which annually honours research "that cannot or should not be repeated".

See also

Template:Link FA Template:Link FA

  1. ^ Nobel Prize Facts
  2. ^ [1]
  3. ^ Nobel Prize nomination and selection process
  4. ^ [2]
  5. ^ [3]
  6. ^ The Nobel Prize Internet Archive
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Nobel_Prize&oldid=36495266"