Secondhand Lions

Secondhand Lions
Secondhand Lions film poster
Directed by	Tim McCanlies
Written by	Tim McCanlies
Produced by	David Kirschner Scott Ross Corey Sienega
Starring	Haley Joel Osment Robert Duvall Michael Caine Kyra Sedgwick
Cinematography	Jack N. Green
Edited by	David Moritz
Music by	Patrick Doyle
Distributed by	New Line Cinema
Release date	September 19, 2003 (2003-09-19)
Running time	111 minutes
Country	United States
Language	English
Budget	$30 million
Box office	$47,902,566

Secondhand Lions, a 2003 American comedy-drama film written and directed by Tim McCanlies, tells the story of an introverted young boy (Haley Joel Osment) who is sent to live with his eccentric uncles (Robert Duvall and Michael Caine) on a farm in Texas.

Plot

In 1962 in the Texas countryside, 14-year old Walter Caldwell (Haley Joel Osment) is left by his irresponsible, deceitful mother, Mae (Kyra Sedgwick), to live for the summer with his reclusive, 73 year old bachelor great-uncles, Hub (Robert Duvall) and Garth (Michael Caine) McCann, fraternal twins who are said to have a secret fortune. Walter is given a room in the attic where he finds a photograph of a beautiful woman, whom he later learns is Jasmine (Emmanuelle Vaugier), the one true love of Hub's life. Hub and Garth next receive an unwelcome visit from husband-and-wife relatives Ralph and Helen and their children, who hope to worm their way into the uncles' good graces for a chance at their treasure. Believing that Walter is also there for the money, Ralph and Helen use the threat of foster care to force the boy to run away. In the kitchen Ralph makes a grab at Walter but Walter kicks Ralph in the shins then makes his way to the outskirts of town, and uses a phone booth to call the court reporting school which his mother told him she was attending. He soon learns that Mae lied again, as classes started in January and their has been no new enrollments since. Finding Walter, Hub and Garth encourage him to stay, hoping that his presence will keep the greedy relatives at bay. Having no other recourse, Walter returns to his uncles' home.

As Walter settles into the household, he contends with his uncles' odd habits, such as Hub's sleepwalking at night in which he fights old battles, as well as their daily routine of driving off traveling salesmen with shotgun blasts. When the boy suggests that Hub and Garth should at least hear one salesman's pitch before shooting, which turns out to be a clay pigeon launcher which they buy. This infuriates Ralph and Helen causing them to leave at that moment. They then, in their attempts to relive their glory days, as when they buy and teach themselves to fly a biplane. Another time, the uncles order what they believe to be a ferocious lion from a circus animal dealer with the intent of killing it for sport. They are disappointed upon opening the crate to discover an aging, tame lioness, which Walter adopts, naming her Jasmine, much to Hub's chagrin. Some time later, though Hub is hospitalized briefly for overexertion loading fifty pound bags of Purina Lion Chow, his restless nature still leads him to confront and defeat single-handedly four greasers who were creating a disturbance at a local diner. When Ralph and Helen visit the uncles' home in their absence, their children release the lioness from her crate. Returning with Hub, Garth and the four hoods, Walter goes in search of Jasmine, and finds her in the cornfield, which then becomes her new home, reminding her of the jungle. Later, Walter notices Hub lecturing the four toughs, using what Garth calls Hub's "What Every Boy Needs to Know About Being a Man" speech.

Throughout the film, Garth tells Walter stories about his and Hub's mysterious past. On the eve of World War I, a young Hub and Garth arrived in France just as Germany invaded the country. They soon found themselves shanghaied and conscripted into the French Foreign Legion, which led them to fight in many battles. After the war, Garth became a guide in Africa, while Hub travelled the world. During his journeys, Hub met and fell in love with Jasmine, a princess promised to wed a powerful Sheik. When Hub rescued her, the Sheik put a price of ten thousand gold pieces on Hub's head. This kept the young lovers in constant peril from assassins and bounty hunters. Finally, Hub arranged for Garth, in the guise of a bounty hunter, to get him close to the Sheik, while Garth took possession of the Sheik's reward. Hub then fought and won a duel against the Sheik but spared his life. He warned the Sheik that if this vendetta didn't stop, Hub would kill him. This ends the Sheik's manhunt. When Walter asks to hear more, Garth tells him that he must find out the rest from Hub.

Later, Walter awakens his uncle from another late night bout of sleepwalking to ask about Jasmine's fate. Hub reveals that Jasmine and their unborn child died in childbirth. Bereft of his one true love, Hub returned to the Legion to escape his grief, until he retired with Garth to their Texas farm. Walter then realizes that all the stories Garth has been telling him might actually be true, but he asks Hub to confirm it, since his mother tells him nothing but lies. Hub responds with a piece of his "What Every Boy Needs to Know..." speech, that the actual truth is not as important as the belief in ideals like good winning over evil, honor, and true love. Seeing how much Hub misses his Jasmine, Walter asks Hub to promise that he will be around to give Walter the rest of the speech when he's old enough, to which Hub grudgingly agrees. As a result, Walter and his uncles form an even closer bond. Late one evening, Walter awakens to see Garth walking out to the barn and secretly follows him, trailing him to a room underneath the barn, which is filled with money.

On another late night, Walter's mother and her current suitor, a supposed "private investigator" named Stan arrive at the farm. While Hub and Garth are still asleep, Stan and Mae demand that Walter reveal the location of the fortune, claiming that Hub and Garth were actually bank robbers, that Jasmine was their accomplice, and the money is theirs for the taking. To Mae's surprise and dismay, Walter chooses to believe in his uncles instead of her. Angered, Stan drags Walter to the barn and becomes threatening and physically abusive. Walter then tells Stan to defend himself before kicking him between the legs. Walter runs toward the house, past the cornfield, where Stan intercepts Walter and begins hitting him while Walter is on his back. Sensing Walter in danger, Jasmine the lioness emerges from the cornfield to attack Stan, leaving him badly mauled. Awakened by the ruckus, Hub and Garth find that the old lioness has died of heart failure in the attack. Hub and Garth tell Walter that the lioness was "protecting her cub," and Walter proudly observes that Jasmine was "a real lion... at the end".

The next day, Walter leaves with his mother, who tells the uncles she is going to drop a heavily-bandaged Stan off in Las Vegas. However, once on the road, Mae tells Walter that Stan will be staying with them to recuperate. This prompts Walter to finally confront her, asking his mother to finally "do something that's best for me for once." Soon, Hub and Garth are greatly pleased to see Walter's return. However, the boy insists that there have to be changes, that his uncles will have to be involved in things like Little League and PTA meetings, and to stop doing dangerous stunts, as he wants them to die of old age.

Seventeen years later, an adult Walter (Josh Lucas), has become the cartoonist of the comic strip "Walter and Jasmine," based on his experiences with his uncles, now both 90 years of age. He is alerted by the sheriff of his uncles' deaths from a failed flying stunt with their biplane. Their will declares "The kid gets it all. Just plant us in the damn garden, next to the stupid lion." A helicopter bearing the logo "Sahara Petroleum" then touches down near the homestead, and a man (Eric Balfour) steps out with his young son. Approaching Walter, he explains that, while visiting nearby for a business trip, he heard about Hub and Garth's deaths on the news and recognized the names as the two Americans in tales told to him as a young boy by his grandfather, "a very wealthy sheik. He called them my honored adverseries. The only men who ever outsmarted me." When the man's young son asks Walter if his uncles were indeed real, that they really lived, Walter confirms, "Yeah. They really lived."

Cast

• Haley Joel Osment as Walter Coleman
• Robert Duvall as Hub McCann
• Michael Caine as Garth McCann
• Kyra Sedgwick as Mae Coleman
• Nicky Katt as Stan
• Josh Lucas as Adult Walter Coleman
• Michael O'Neill as Ralph
• Deirdre O'Connell as Helen
• Christian Kane as Young Hub
• Kevin Haberer as Young Garth
• Eric Balfour as Sheik's grandson
• Emmanuelle Vaugier as Jasmine
• Adam Ozturk as The Sheik
• Mitchel Musso as Boy
• Marc Musso as Boy
• Jennifer Stone as Martha
• Taureg as Jasmine the Lion

Production

The film had a different ending originally, but it was not well received by the test audience and a new ending was shot. In the original ending to the film, instead of the sheik's grandson, a tractor-trailer pulls up at the gravesite and a detachment from the French Foreign Legion rides out on horseback and act as an Honor Guard escorting two riderless horses with boots inserted backwards in the stirrups in honor of the brothers. Shortly thereafter, the sheik himself, elderly and using a wheelchair, arrives in a limousine surrounded by his harem to pay his respects. The four greasers that Hub beat up also make an appearance at the funeral, showing that Hub's speech did have an impact, as the men are now mature and respectable.

The comic strips drawn by the adult Walter in the film were drawn by Berkeley Breathed, creator of Bloom County.

Music

The film score was composed by Patrick Doyle and features music by the Slovak Radio Symphony Orchestra and Ola Onabule, in addition to Doyle. The film also features "A Lot of Livin' To Do" (performed by Sammy Davis Jr.), Let Me In (The Sensations song) (performed by The Sensations), "Big Balls in Cowtown" (performed by Don Walser), "Rolling Stone From Texas" (performed by Walser), "Texas Playboy Rag" (performed by Pine Valley Cosmonauts), "Red Skin Gal" (performed by Walser) and "Help Me" (performed by Sonny Boy Williamson).

Reception

Reviews for the film were mixed. Based on 129 reviews collected by the film review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, 59% of critics gave Secondhand Lions a positive review. Film critic James Berardinelli said "Despite flaws that are (for the most part) easily overlooked, this film has enough charm and whimsy to capture the attention and imagination of children and parents alike." Stephen Holden of The New York Times said the film "may be pure hokum, but at least it knows how to spin a yarn."

The Hollywood Reporter's Sheri Linden said "McCanlies has more of an inclination toward schmaltz, but the deft restraint of topliners Michael Caine and Robert Duvall tempers the narrative with a wry, poignant reserve." Kenneth Turan of the Los Angeles Times praised the performances of Caine, Duvall and Osment but said "Almost all the film's peripheral characters, from Walter's mother and her boyfriend to a family of grasping relatives, are clichéd in an overly broad, unfunny way that is unpleasant in itself and a marked contrast to the more nuanced performances of the trio of leads." The Boston Globe critic, Wesley Morris, criticized the film's portrayal of Arab people and women, describing it as "uncomfortably retrograde" and "troubling".

The film grossed $42,070,939 in North America and $5,831,627 for the rest of the world, adding up to a total worldwide gross of $47,902,566.

External links

• Official website
• Secondhand Lions at IMDb
• Secondhand Lions at Rotten Tomatoes
• Secondhand Lions profile at Allmovie.com