Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/CheeseDreams 2/Evidence

Anyone, whether directly involved or not, may add evidence to this page. Please make a header for your evidence and sign your comments with your name.

When placing evidence here, please be considerate of the arbitrators and be concise. Long, rambling, or stream-of-conciousness rants are not helpful.

As such, it is extremely important that you use the prescribed format. Submitted evidence should include a link to the actual page diff; links to the page itself are not sufficient. For example, to cite the edit by Mennonot to the article Anomalous phenomenon adding a link to Hundredth Monkey use this form: [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=Anomalous_phenomenon&diff=0&oldid=5584644] [1].

This page is not for general discussion - for that, see talk page.

Please make a section for your evidence and add evidence only in your own section. Please limit your evidence to a maximum 1000 words and 100 diffs, a much shorter, concise presentation is more likely to be effective. Please focus on the issues raised in the complaint and answer and on diffs which illustrate behavior which relates to the issues.

If you disagree with some evidence you see here, please cite the evidence in your own section and provide counter-evidence, or an explanation of why the evidence is misleading. Do not edit within the evidence section of any other user.

Be aware that the Arbitrators may at times rework this page to try to make it more coherent. If you are a participant in the case or a third party, please don't try to refactor the page, let the Arbitrators do it. If you object to evidence which is inserted by other participants or third parties please cite the evidence and voice your objections within your own section of the page. It is especially important to not remove evidence presented by others. If something is put in the wrong place, please leave it for the arbitrators to move.

Evidence presented by Sandor

Trolling and vandalizing user pages on Swedish Wikipedia

User:CheeseDreams has used several IP's to vandalize user pages on Swedish Wikipedia, e.g. from 81.156.183.69, 81.156.92.59 and 81.156.180.239, see evidence [2]. See also discussion about this [3].

Sandor 17:32, 12 Feb 2005 (UTC)

CheeseDreams continues to troll user pages [4]

Sandor 14:18, 13 Feb 2005 (UTC)

[comments moved to talk by sannse (talk) 11:56, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC)]

Apparently CheeseDreams sees sock puppets everywhere. CD vandalized my user and talk page repeatedly on February 13th. He has also removed or edited my comments on other talk pages. This has got to stop, people! Sandor 02:36, 14 Feb 2005 (UTC)

Evidence presented by Ta bu shi da yu

29 January - ArbCom request against Slrubenstein

• 08:18, 29 Jan 2005
  • CheeseDreams submitted a request for arbitration.

• 5:32, 30 Jan 2005
  • Rejected by all arbitrators. This includes Grunt, Ambi, Neutrality, mav, Sannse, David Gerard and The Epopt.

• 08:54, 31 Jan 2005
  • mav rejects the request for arbitration formally and blanks it.

• 09:34, 1 Feb 2005
  • CheeseDreams resubmits the request that was rejected.

• 14:47, 1 Feb 2005
  • Arbitrator Ambi rejects request and notes that she "condemn[s] what is becoming a blatant misuse of this page."

• 14:48, 1 Feb 2005
  • Rejected by Grunt.

• 14:53, 1 Feb 2005
  • Rejected by mav, who states that "This is starting to look a lot like harassment against Sl."

• 14:58, 1 Feb 2005
  • Rejected by Neutrality.

• 14:59, 1 Feb 2005
  • Rejected by Raul654. He agrees with Ambi.

• 15:39, 1 Feb 2005
  • Ambi formally rejects the ArbCom request again.

1 February - harassing Ta bu shi da yu

• 10:14, 1 Feb 2005
  • Asks Dante Alighieri whether "Can you check to see whether 67.15.54.16 is a viable IP used by user User:Ta bu shi da yu. I know this is a strange idea, but 67.15.54.16 is based in melbourne, Australia."

• 09:34, 1 Feb 2005
  • Posts a message to Ta bu shi da yu's talk page stating that Ta bu shi da yu is a "literalist christian" (unsure what that means) and a "fundamentalist". Evidently did not recieve a reply that satisfied her from User:Dante Alighieri as she asks Ta bu shi da yu "Curiously, the IP address 67.15.54.16 is based in Melbourne, Australia, and I remember TBSDY claiming that they were in Australia. I wonder, TBSDY, do you speak Swedish?". The accusation is that TBSDY is using Rienzo as a sockpuppet. For the record, TBSDY neither speaks Swedish nor lives in Melbourne.

[comments moved to talk by sannse (talk) 11:56, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC)]

Please note: without a developer I cannot be certain that the posts from Special:Contributions/81.156.182.159 is CheeseDreams. I am presenting this as evidence because I strongly suspect that this is CheeseDreams, mainly because I've seen her post from this netblock before (it's is a BT cable IP address) and because of the response at [5].

• 06:41, 3 Feb 2005
  • Sends a message to Rd232 stating that Ta bu shi da yu is performing POV edits. States (with regards to The Jesus Mysteries that "Also note that Freke & Gandy's book was regarded by the Daily Telegraph as "an erudite and well researched book stuffed with controversial ideas", and so inserting only the CNN viewpoint is a heavy and POV attempt to discredit it." - however, Ta bu shi da yu did not remove this material. (Ta bu shi da yu did remove unsourced books, however, from Historicity of Jesus due to significant POV bias and no real evidence of them being used in the article - no sources were cited! Those inline sources that are now in the text were mostly put in by Ta bu shi da yu.)

• 06:56, 3 Feb 2005
  • Sends exactly the same message to Sunborn's talk page.

• 07:00, 3 Feb 2005
  • Sends same message to Bensaccount's talk page.

• 07:00, 3 Feb 2005
  • Sends same message to FeloniousMonk's talk page.

• 07:01, 3 Feb 2005
  • Sends the same message to Ben Standeven's talk page.

1 February - harasses Bacchiad

• 10:15, 1 Feb 2005
  • From her sock-puppet account (User:Cheese -dreams, CheeseDreams states "So, whose sock puppet are you? CheeseDreams 00:15, 1 Feb 2005 (UTC)" (she had a disagreement with this user over an article).

[comments moved to talk by sannse (talk) 11:56, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC)]

• 15:57, 1 Feb 2005
  • Ta bu shi da yu requests (on Bacchiad and on CheeseDreams page) that "This is the second time I've seen you imply that someone is a sockpuppet. The first time you did it for me. I count this as harassment. Will you please stop?"

• 14:04, 10 Feb 2005
  • Her answer, on User:Bacchiad's talk page, is "No." Clear evidence of willingness to harass people through accusations they are sock puppets.

Katoomba Christian Convention

• 14 Feb 2005
  • CheeseDreams removed a copyvio from the article and made a personal attack against myself: "TBSDY, you have been working on this article for months, and invited people to assist you. Strange how there is nothing here then." For the record, I don't actually have to work on my focus article if I don't wish to. - Ta bu shi da yu 01:50, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC)

[comment moved to talk by sannse (talk) 11:56, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC)]

Evidence presented by Thryduulf

17 Feb 2005 - Page blanking in this RFAr

• 07:31
  • User:CheeseDreams blanks this evidence page. [6]
  • This is reverted by User:Curps at 07:34 [7]

• 07:32
  • User:CheeseDreams blanks the main page of this RFAr [8]
  • This is reverted by User:Curps at 07:33 [9]

Explanation of above by CheeseDreams

On 14th February 2005, I (CheeseDreams), gave Rienzo my password, doing so on Rienzo's talk page. Any edit claiming to be by me (CheeseDreams) since then is likely to be Rienzo, or someone else.

In particular, due to the speed of reversion of the above, I note that the only person who would really know about the page blanking apart from Curps would be Rienzo (or whoever logged in to my account if it was not Rienzo). Since Thryduulf presents the evidence, then this leads to the conclusion that Thryduulf is a Rienzo sockpuppet.

Response to the response by CheeseDreams

If you are not Rienzo, then how come your first edit was around the same time that I discovered Rienzo's sockpuppets, and brought arbitration against Rienzo with the inevitable consequence of his being banned, and thus needing some other account to perform edits?

You also have a behavioural pattern identical to Reinzo, in particular, pursuit of CheeseDreams, as well as the anger level you exhibit (see your comment on the RFAR page on 14th of February), and also the immediacy and urgency with which you seem to react to my accusation of sockpuppetry (e.g. see the User:Sandor sock puppet for an example of this).

Remember, the skill of textual criticism to tell sources apart, and identify others, is something that is characteristic of the contributions to articles about sources that I have been editing. It is very easy for me to spot sockpuppetry.

It would be interesting to know what your IP address was. And also why you have a scandinavian username (remember, Rienzo is from Sweden).

CheeseDreams

19 Feb 2005 - Accusations of sockpuppetry

• 09:49
  • User:65.161.54.104 edits this page to comment on the evidence I presented relating to the 17 Feb 2005. [10]. In this edit I am accused of being a sockpuppet of User:Rienzo. This edit is signed CheeseDreams.

• 09:52
  • User:65.161.65.104 puts a note on my talk page that implicitly accuses me of being a sockpuppet of User:Rienzo (confirmed by the 09:49 edit to this page, above). [11]. The edit was signed CheeseDreams.

• 10:16
  • I responded to the comments on my talk page and this page, and added the 09:52 evidence above. I also denied the accusation and invited the Arbitration committee to examine the claim and provided links to the contribution histories of myself (Thryduulf) and Rienzo. [12].

• 10:17 - 10:19
  • I made a succession of minor ammendments to the layout and phrasing of my above response: [13] , [14] & [15].

• 10:35
  • User:65.161.65.104 reponds to my response above by giving an explanation in more detail of why they beleive I am a sockpuppet of User:Rienzo and signs the edit User:CheeseDreams [16]. The allegations can be summarised as:
    • I made my first edit around the time User:CheeseDreams first accused user:Rienzo of sockpuppetry.
    • I have the same behaviour as Rienzo, specifically I have a high anger level and am in persuit of user:CheeseDreams.
    • That it is easy for her to tell I'm a sockpuppet because she is skilled in analysing text sources.
    • That my having a Scandinavian username is telling (because user:Rienzo is Sweedish).
  • She also commented that it would be interesting to know what my IP was.

• 11:17
  • I provided detailed responses to her above points [17]

• 11:25
  • I made a minor formatting error to the above [18]