Jump to content

Aarne–Thompson–Uther Index: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→Predecessors: edit citation with link
Line 5: Line 5:


=== Predecessors ===
=== Predecessors ===
Austrian consul [[Johann Georg von Hahn]] devised a preliminary analysis of some 44 tale "formulae" as introduction to his book of [[Greek folklore|Greek]] and [[Albanian folklore|Albanian folktales]], published in 1864.<ref>Hahn, Johann Georg von. ''Griechische Und Albanesische Märchen''. Erster Band. Leipzig: W. Englemann, 1864. pp. 43-61.</ref><ref>{{cite book |last1=Jacobs |first1=Joseph |title=European Folk and Fairy Tales |date=1916 |publisher=G. P. Putnam's sons |location=New York, London |pages=215-216 |url=https://archive.org/details/europeanfolkfair00jaco/page/215/mode/1up?q=formulae+}}</ref>
Austrian consul [[Johann Georg von Hahn]] devised a preliminary analysis of some 40 tale "formulae" as introduction to his book of [[Greek folklore|Greek]] and [[Albanian folklore|Albanian folktales]], published in 1864.<ref>Hahn, Johann Georg von. ''Griechische Und Albanesische Märchen''. Erster Band. Leipzig: W. Englemann, 1864. pp. 43-61.</ref><ref>{{cite book |last1=Jacobs |first1=Joseph |title=European Folk and Fairy Tales |date=1916 |publisher=G. P. Putnam's sons |location=New York, London |pages=215-216 |url=https://archive.org/details/europeanfolkfair00jaco/page/215/mode/1up}}</ref>


Reverend [[Sabine Baring-Gould]], in 1866, translated von Hahn's list and expanded to 52 tale types, which he called "Story Radicals".<ref>Baring-Gould, Sabine. "Appendix". In: Henderson, William. ''[https://books.google.com/books?id=o2cAAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Folklore+of+the+Northern+Counties%2C%22 Notes On the Folk-lore of the Northern Counties of England And the Borders]''. London: Longmans, Green. 1866. pp. 300-311.</ref><ref>Jacobs, Joseph. ''European Folk and Fairy Tales''. New York, London: G. P. Putnam's sons. 1916. p. 216.</ref> Folklorist [[Joseph Jacobs]] expanded the list to seventy tale types and published it as ''Appendix C'' in [[Charlotte Sophia Burne]] and [[Laurence Gomme]]'s ''Handbook of Folk-Lore''.<ref>Jacobs, Joseph. "Appendix C". In: Burne, Charlotte Sophia; Gomme, George Laurence. ''[https://archive.org/details/handbookoffolklo00burnuoft/page/344/mode/2up The handbook of folklore]''. London: Pub. for the Folk-lore Society by Sidgwich & Jackson. 1914. pp. 344-355.</ref>
Reverend [[Sabine Baring-Gould]], in 1866, translated von Hahn's list and expanded to 52 tale types, which he called "Story Radicals".<ref>Baring-Gould, Sabine. "Appendix". In: Henderson, William. ''[https://books.google.com/books?id=o2cAAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Folklore+of+the+Northern+Counties%2C%22 Notes On the Folk-lore of the Northern Counties of England And the Borders]''. London: Longmans, Green. 1866. pp. 300-311.</ref><ref>Jacobs, Joseph. ''European Folk and Fairy Tales''. New York, London: G. P. Putnam's sons. 1916. p. 216.</ref> Folklorist [[Joseph Jacobs]] expanded the list to seventy tale types and published it as ''Appendix C'' in [[Charlotte Sophia Burne]] and [[Laurence Gomme]]'s ''Handbook of Folk-Lore''.<ref>Jacobs, Joseph. "Appendix C". In: Burne, Charlotte Sophia; Gomme, George Laurence. ''[https://archive.org/details/handbookoffolklo00burnuoft/page/344/mode/2up The handbook of folklore]''. London: Pub. for the Folk-lore Society by Sidgwich & Jackson. 1914. pp. 344-355.</ref>

Revision as of 09:22, 9 July 2024

The Aarne–Thompson–Uther Index (ATU Index) is a catalogue of folktale types used in folklore studies. The ATU Index is the product of a series of revisions and expansions by an international group of scholars: originally composed in German by Finnish folklorist Antti Aarne (1910), the index was translated into English, revised, and expanded by American folklorist Stith Thompson (1928, 1961), and later further revised and expanded by German folklorist Hans-Jörg Uther (2004). The ATU Index, along with Thompson's Motif-Index of Folk-Literature (1932)—with which it is used in tandem—is an essential tool for folklorists.[1]

Background

Predecessors

Austrian consul Johann Georg von Hahn devised a preliminary analysis of some 40 tale "formulae" as introduction to his book of Greek and Albanian folktales, published in 1864.[2][3]

Reverend Sabine Baring-Gould, in 1866, translated von Hahn's list and expanded to 52 tale types, which he called "Story Radicals".[4][5] Folklorist Joseph Jacobs expanded the list to seventy tale types and published it as Appendix C in Charlotte Sophia Burne and Laurence Gomme's Handbook of Folk-Lore.[6]

Before the edition of Antti Aarne's first folktale classification, Astrid Lunding translated Svend Grundtvig's system of folktale classification. This catalogue consisted of 134 types, mostly based on Danish folktale compilations in comparison to international collections available at the time by other folklorists, such as the Brothers Grimm's and Emmanuel Cosquin's.[7]

History

Antti Aarne was a student of Julius Krohn and his son Kaarle Krohn. Aarne developed the historic-geographic method of comparative folkloristics, and developed the initial version of what became the Aarne–Thompson tale type index for classifying folktales, first published in 1910 as Verzeichnis der Märchentypen ("List of Fairy Tale Types").[8] The system was based on identifying motifs and the repeated narrative ideas that can be seen as the building-blocks of traditional narrative; its scope was European.[9]

The American folklorist Stith Thompson revised Aarne's classification system in 1928, enlarging its scope, while also translating it from German into English.[10] In doing so, he created the "AT number system" (also referred to as "AaTh system") which remained in use through the second half of the century. Another edition with further revisions by Thompson followed in 1961.[11] According to American folklorist D. L. Ashliman, "The Aarne–Thompson system catalogues some 2500 basic plots from which, for countless generations, European and Near Eastern storytellers have built their tales".[12]

The AT-number system was updated and expanded in 2004 with the publication of The Types of International Folktales: A Classification and Bibliography by German folklorist Hans-Jörg Uther. Uther noted that many of the earlier descriptions were cursory and often imprecise, that many "irregular types" are in fact old and widespread, and that "emphasis on oral tradition" often obscured "older, written versions of the tale types". To remedy these shortcomings Uther developed the Aarne–Thompson–Uther classification (ATU) system and included more tales from eastern and southern Europe as well as "smaller narrative forms" in this expanded listing. He also put the emphasis of the collection more explicitly on international folktales, removing examples whose attestation was limited to one ethnic group.[9][13]

The ATU Index

Definition of tale type

In The Folktale, Thompson defines a tale type as follows:

A type is a traditional tale that has an independent existence. It may be told as a complete narrative and does not depend for its meaning on any other tale. It may indeed happen to be told with another tale, but the fact that it may be told alone attests its independence. It may consist of only one motif or of many.[14]

System

The Aarne–Thompson Tale Type Index divides tales into sections with an AT number for each entry. The names given are typical, but usage varies; the same tale type number may be referred to by its central motif or by one of the variant folktales of that type, which can also vary, especially when used in different countries and cultures. The name does not have to be strictly literal for every folktale. For example, The Cat as Helper (545B) also includes tales where a fox helps the hero. Closely related folktales are often grouped within a type. For example, tale types 400–424 all feature brides or wives as the primary protagonist, for instance The Quest for a Lost Bride (400) or the Animal Bride (402). Subtypes within a tale type are designated by the addition of a letter to the AT number, for instance: tale 510, Persecuted Heroine (renamed in Uther's revision as Cinderella and Peau d'Âne ["Cinderella and Donkey Skin"]), has subtypes 510A, Cinderella, and 510B, Catskin (renamed in Uther's revision as Peau d'Asne [also "Donkey Skin"]). (See other examples of tale types in the online resource links at the end of this article.)

As an example, the entry for 510A in the ATU index (with cross-references to motifs in Thompson's Motif-Index of Folk Literature in square brackets, and variants in parentheses) reads:

510A Cinderella. (Cenerentola, Cendrillon, Aschenputtel.) A young woman is mistreated by her stepmother and stepsisters [S31, L55] and has to live in the ashes as a servant. When the sisters and the stepmother go to a ball (church), they give Cinderella an impossible task (e.g. sorting peas from ashes), which she accomplishes with the help of birds [B450]. She obtains beautiful clothing from a supernatural being [D1050.1, N815] or a tree that grows on the grave of her deceased mother [D815.1, D842.1, E323.2] and goes unknown to the ball. A prince falls in love with her [N711.6, N711.4], but she has to leave the ball early [C761.3]. The same thing happens on the next evening, but on the third evening, she loses one of her shoes [R221, F823.2].

The prince will marry only the woman whom the shoe fits [H36.1]. The stepsisters cut pieces off their feet in order to make them fit into the shoe [K1911.3.3.1], but a bird calls attention to this deceit. Cinderella, who had first been hidden from the prince, tries on the shoe and it fits her. The prince marries her.

Combinations: This type is usually combined with episodes of one or more other types, esp. 327A, 403, 480, 510B, and also 408, 409, 431, 450, 511, 511A, 707, and 923.

Remarks: Documented by Basile, Pentamerone (I,6) in the 17th century.

The entry concludes, like others in the catalogue, with a long list of references to secondary literature on the tale, and variants of it.[15]

Critical response

In his essay "The Motif-Index and the Tale Type Index: A Critique", American folklorist Alan Dundes explains that the Aarne–Thompson indexes are some of the "most valuable tools in the professional folklorist's arsenal of aids for analysis".[1]

The tale type index was criticized by Vladimir Propp of the Russian Formalist school of the 1920s for ignoring the functions of the motifs by which they are classified. Furthermore, Propp contended that using a "macro-level" analysis means that the stories that share motifs might not be classified together, while stories with wide divergences may be grouped under one tale type because the index must select some features as salient.[16] He also observed that while the distinction between animal tales and tales of the fantastic was basically correct—no one would classify "Tsarevitch Ivan, the Fire Bird and the Gray Wolf" as an animal tale just because of the wolf—it did raise questions because animal tales often contained fantastic elements, and tales of the fantastic often contained animals; indeed a tale could shift categories if a peasant deceived a bear rather than a devil.[17]

In describing the motivation for his work,[18] Uther presents several criticisms of the original index. He points out that Thompson's focus on oral tradition sometimes neglects older versions of stories, even when written records exist, that the distribution of stories is uneven (with Eastern and Southern European as well as many other regions' folktale types being under-represented), and that some included folktale types have dubious importance. Similarly, Thompson had noted that the tale type index might well be called The Types of the Folk-Tales of Europe, West Asia, and the Lands Settled by these Peoples.[18] However, Alan Dundes notes that in spite of the flaws of tale type indexes (e.g., typos, redundancies, censorship, etc.; p. 198),[1] "they represent the keystones for the comparative method in folkloristics, a method which despite postmodern naysayers ... continues to be the hallmark of international folkloristics" (p. 200).[1]

Author Pete Jordi Wood claims that topics related to homosexuality have been excluded intentionally from the type index.[19] Similarly, folklorist Joseph P. Goodwin states that Thompson omitted "much of the extensive body of sexual and 'obscene' material", and that—as of 1995—"topics like homosexuality are still largely excluded from the type and motif indexes."[20] In an essay, Alan Dundes also criticized Thompson's handling of the folkloric subject material, which he considered to be "excessive prudery" and a form of censorship.[21]

The ATU folktype index has been criticized for its apparent geographic concentration on Europe and North Africa,[22] or overrepresentation of Eurasia[a] and North America.[24] The catalogue appears to ignore or underrepresent other regions. Central Asian examples include: Yuri Berezkin [ru]'s The Captive Khan and the Clever Daughter-in-Law (and variants);[22] The travelling girl and her helpful siblings;[25] and Woman's Magical Horse, as named by researcher Veronica Muskheli of the University of Washington.[26]

In regards to the typological classification, some folklorists and tale comparativists have acknowledged singular tale types that, due to their own characteristics, would merit their own type.[b] However, such tales have not been listed in the international folktale system, yet they exist in regional or national classifications.[27]

Use in folkloristics

A quantitative study, published by folklorist Sara Graça da Silva and anthropologist Jamshid J. Tehrani in 2016, tried to evaluate the time of emergence for the "Tales of Magic" (ATU 300–ATU 749), based on a phylogenetic model.[28] They found four of them to belong to the Proto-Indo-European (PIE) stratum of magic tales:[c]

Ten more magic tales were found to be current throughout the Western branch of the Indo-European languages, comprising the main European language families derived from PIE (i.e. Balto-Slavic, Germanic, Italic and Celtic):

List

See also

Notes

  1. ^ "Stith Thompson himself not once indicated that the AT-Index works only for the Hindu-European ('from Ireland to India') cultural area. He assumed that the folklore of other areas would not be well integrated in the AT System."[23]
  2. ^ On the other hand, some independent tale types have been called into question, even by Stith Thompson: "Confined, so far as now appears, to a very limited section of eastern Europe is the story of the hero called "I Don't Know." It is hard to tell whether this should be considered as a distinct tale type (Type 532), or merely as a variety of the Goldener story [Tale type 314]". Thompson, Stith (1977). The Folktale. University of California Press. p. 61. ISBN 0-520-03537-2
  3. ^ The KHM indices refer to Grimms' Fairy Tales.
  4. ^ The original version of the "Dance Among the Thorns" tale-type comes from 15th century Europe, and features a monk who was forced to dance in a thorn bush, by a boy with a magic flute or fiddle. It reflected the anticlerical sentiment of many folk tales at the time, and implies that the monk deserves this punishment. Grimms' The Jew Among Thorns (KHM 110) is an example of this type of tale. An American version of this tale, told to folklorist Marie Campbell in 1958 in Kentucky, included this apology from the informant: "Seems like all the tales about Jews gives the Jews a bad name—greedy, grabbing for cash money, cheating their work hands out of their wages—I don't know what all. I never did know a Jew, never even met up with one."[32]

References

  1. ^ a b c d Dundes, Alan (1997). "The Motif-Index and the Tale Type Index: A Critique". Journal of Folklore Research. 34 (3): 195–202. JSTOR 3814885.
  2. ^ Hahn, Johann Georg von. Griechische Und Albanesische Märchen. Erster Band. Leipzig: W. Englemann, 1864. pp. 43-61.
  3. ^ Jacobs, Joseph (1916). European Folk and Fairy Tales. New York, London: G. P. Putnam's sons. pp. 215–216.
  4. ^ Baring-Gould, Sabine. "Appendix". In: Henderson, William. Notes On the Folk-lore of the Northern Counties of England And the Borders. London: Longmans, Green. 1866. pp. 300-311.
  5. ^ Jacobs, Joseph. European Folk and Fairy Tales. New York, London: G. P. Putnam's sons. 1916. p. 216.
  6. ^ Jacobs, Joseph. "Appendix C". In: Burne, Charlotte Sophia; Gomme, George Laurence. The handbook of folklore. London: Pub. for the Folk-lore Society by Sidgwich & Jackson. 1914. pp. 344-355.
  7. ^ Lunding, Astrid. "The System of Tales in the Folklore Collection of Copenhagen". In: Folklore Fellows Communications (FFC) nº 2. 1910. [1]
  8. ^ Antti Aarne, Verzeichnis der Märchentypen, FF Communications, 3 (Helsinki, 1910).
  9. ^ a b Uther, Hans-Jörg. 2004. The Types of International Folktales: A Classification and Bibliography. Based on the system of Antti Aarne and Stith Thompson. FF Communications no. 284–286. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia. Three volumes. I: 7.
  10. ^ The Types of the Folk-Tale: A Classification and Bibliography. Antti Aarne's Verzeichnis der Märchentypen, translated and enlarged by Stith Thompson, FF Communications, 74 (Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia, 1928).
  11. ^ S. Thompson, The Types of the Folktale: A Classification and Bibliography, FF communications, 184 (Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia, 1961).
  12. ^ Ashliman, D. L. 1987. A Guide to Folktales in the English Language: Based on the Aarne–Thompson Classification System. New York, Greenwood Press.
  13. ^ The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Folktales and Fairy Tales, Donald Haase, Greenwood Publishing Group, 2008, p. xxi.
  14. ^ Thompson (1977: 415).
  15. ^ Uther, Hans-Jörg. 2004. The Types of International Folktales: A Classification and Bibliography. Based on the system of Antti Aarne and Stith Thompson. FF Communications no. 284–286. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia. Three volumes. I: 293-94.
  16. ^ Vladimir Propp, Morphology of the Folktale. Similarly, Alan Dundes points out that "Aarne's mistake was not classifying tales on the basis of narrative plot rather than [on characters]" because "the same tale can be told with either animal or human characters" (197). "Introduction". Theory and History of Folklore. Ed. Anatoly Liberman. University of Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 1984. p. ix.
  17. ^ Propp, Morphology of the Folktale, p. 5 f.
  18. ^ a b Uther, Hans-Jörg. "Classifying folktales: The Third Revision of the Aarne–Thompson Tale Type Index (FFC 184)". folklorefellow.fi.
  19. ^ Wareham, Jamie (2020-08-21). "Why This Charming Gay Fairytale Has Been Lost For 200 Years". Forbes. Retrieved 2020-08-22.
  20. ^ Goodwin, Joseph P. (1995). "If Ignorance Is Bliss, 'Tis Folly to Be Wise: What We Don't Know Can Hurt Us". Journal of Folklore Research. 32 (2): 155–164. JSTOR 3814371.
  21. ^ Bronner, Simon J., ed. (2007). "From Etic to Emic Units in the Structural Study of Folktales". Meaning of Folklore: The Analytical Essays of Alan Dundes. University Press of Colorado. p. 103. doi:10.2307/j.ctt4cgrzn.9. Accessed 26 Aug. 2023.
  22. ^ a b Berezkin, Yuri; Duvakin, Evgeny (June 2016). "The Captive Khan and the Clever Daughter-in-Law". Folklore: Electronic Journal of Folklore. 64: 33–56. doi:10.7592/FEJF2016.64.khan.
  23. ^ Jason, Heda (January 1965). "Types of Jewish-Oriental Oral Tales". Fabula. 7 (Jahresband): 115–224. doi:10.1515/fabl.1965.7.1.115. S2CID 162323205.
  24. ^ Thuillard, Marc; Le Quellec, Jean-Loïc; d'Huy, Julien; Berezkin, Yuri (2018). "A Large-Scale Study of World Myths". Trames. 22 (4): A1–A44. doi:10.3176/tr.2018.4.06.
  25. ^ Berezkin, Yuri (2019). "The Travelling Girl and Her Helpful Siblings: An Unnoticed Boreal Tale and the ATU Index". Folklore: Electronic Journal of Folklore. 75: 71–90. doi:10.7592/FEJF2019.75.berezkin.
  26. ^ Muskheli, Veronica (27 April 2013). The Fate of Magically Strong Heroines in Central Asian Folktales (PDF). REECAS NW 2013. From Symbolism to Security Politics, Literature and Imagery in Russia, Eastern Europe and Central Asia -The Nineteenth Annual Russian, East European and Central Asian Studies Northwest Conference.
  27. ^ Goldberg, Christine (1996). "The Blind Girl, a Misplaced Folktale". Western Folklore. 55 (3): 187–212. doi:10.2307/1500481. JSTOR 1500481.
  28. ^ Graça da Silva, Sara; Tehrani, Jamshid J. (January 2016). "Comparative phylogenetic analyses uncover the ancient roots of Indo-European folktales". Royal Society Open Science. 3 (1). The Royal Society: 150645. Bibcode:2016RSOS....350645D. doi:10.1098/rsos.150645. PMC 4736946. PMID 26909191.
  29. ^ Petschel, Günter (January 1971). ""Freunde in Leben und Tod" (AaTh 470)". Fabula. 12 (Jahresband): 111–167. doi:10.1515/fabl.1971.12.1.111. S2CID 161210849.
  30. ^ Kaasik, Mairi (2013). "A Mortal Visits the Other World – the Relativity of Time in Estonian Fairy Tales". Journal of Ethnology and Folkloristics. 7 (2): 33–47.
  31. ^ Maarten Janssen. "Multilingual Folk Tale Database". Archived from the original on 2019-03-16. Retrieved 2020-01-12.
  32. ^ Haase, Donald (2007). The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Folktales and Fairy Tales. Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 786. ISBN 978-0-313-04947-7.
  33. ^ Bottigheimer, Ruth B. (1993). "Luckless, Witless, and Filthy-Footed: A Sociocultural Study and Publishing History Analysis of "The Lazy Boy"". The Journal of American Folklore. 106 (421): 259–284. doi:10.2307/541421. JSTOR 541421.

Bibliography

  • Antti Aarne. 1961. The Types of the Folktale: A Classification and Bibliography, The Finnish Academy of Science and Letters, Helsinki. ISBN 951-41-0132-4
  • Ashliman, D. L. 1987. A Guide to Folktales in the English Language: Based on the Aarne–Thompson Classification System. New York, Greenwood Press.
  • Azzolina, David S. 1987. Tale type- and motif-indexes: An annotated bibliography. New York, London: Garland.
  • Dundes, Alan (1997). "The Motif-Index and the Tale Type Index: A Critique". Journal of Folklore Research. 34 (3): 195–202. JSTOR 3814885.
  • Karsdorp, Folgert; van der Meulen, Marten; Meder, Theo; van den Bosch, Antal (2 January 2015). "MOMFER: A Search Engine of Thompson's Motif-Index of Folk Literature". Folklore. 126 (1): 37–52. doi:10.1080/0015587X.2015.1006954. S2CID 162278853.
  • Thompson, Stith. 1977. The Folktale. Berkeley: University of California Press.
  • Uther, Hans-Jörg. 2004. The Types of International Folktales: A Classification and Bibliography. Based on the system of Antti Aarne and Stith Thompson. FF Communications no. 284–286. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia. Three volumes. ISBN 951-41-0955-4 (vol. 1), ISBN 951-41-0961-9 (vol. 2), ISBN 951-41-0963-5 (vol. 3.)
  • Uther, Hans-Jörg. 2011. The Types of International Folktales: A Classification and Bibliography. Based on the system of Antti Aarne and Stith Thompson. 2nd Printing. FF Communications no. 284–286. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia. Three volumes. ISBN 978-951-41-1054-2 (vol. 1), ISBN 978-951-41-1055-9 (vol. 2), ISBN 978-951-41-1067-2 (vol. 3.)

Further reading

German Wikisource has original text related to this article:
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Aarne–Thompson–Uther Index.

International collections:

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Aarne–Thompson–Uther_Index&oldid=1233483197"