Jump to content

Compressed-air car: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
m BOT - Reverted edits by 66.119.215.23 {possible test edits} to last version by Grimini.
Line 40: Line 40:
*Very low [[self-discharge]] rate (most batteries will deplete their charge without external load at a rate determined by the chemistry, design, and size, while compressed gas storage will have an extremely low leakage rate)
*Very low [[self-discharge]] rate (most batteries will deplete their charge without external load at a rate determined by the chemistry, design, and size, while compressed gas storage will have an extremely low leakage rate)
*Long storage [[lifetime]] device (electric vehicle batteries have a limited useful number of cycles, and sometimes a limited calendar lifetime, irrespective of use). This means that batteries in operation are much more expensive than [[compressed air storage]], and are more pollutant because a lot more pollutant material needs to be used (typical car batteries are made from sulphuric acids and lead).
*Long storage [[lifetime]] device (electric vehicle batteries have a limited useful number of cycles, and sometimes a limited calendar lifetime, irrespective of use). This means that batteries in operation are much more expensive than [[compressed air storage]], and are more pollutant because a lot more pollutant material needs to be used (typical car batteries are made from sulphuric acids and lead).
*Lower initial cost than battery electric vehicles when [[mass production|mass produced]]. One estimate is €3,000, but since no production version of a compressed air powered car is available then any number could be used.
*Lower initial cost than battery electric vehicles when [[mass production|mass produced]]. One estimate is €3,000,
*Expansion of the compressed air reduces its temperature and heat from the passenger compartment may be cooled using a [[heat exchanger]], providing both relief from hot weather [[air conditioning]] and increased efficiency.
*Expansion of the compressed air reduces its temperature and heat from the passenger compartment may be cooled using a [[heat exchanger]], providing both relief from hot weather [[air conditioning]] and increased efficiency.
*Zero pollutant emissions from the vehicle itself.
*Zero pollutant emissions from the vehicle itself.
Line 46: Line 46:
*Compressed air is not a fire hazard, only a rapid depressurization hazard (this can be mitigated by using carbon fiber tanks like firemen do).
*Compressed air is not a fire hazard, only a rapid depressurization hazard (this can be mitigated by using carbon fiber tanks like firemen do).
*Air turbine technology, closely related to steam turbine technology, is a practice over 50 years old. It is simple to achieve with low tech materials. This would mean that developing countries, and rapidly growing countries like China and India, could easily implement a less polluting means of personal transportation than an internal combustion engine automobile.
*Air turbine technology, closely related to steam turbine technology, is a practice over 50 years old. It is simple to achieve with low tech materials. This would mean that developing countries, and rapidly growing countries like China and India, could easily implement a less polluting means of personal transportation than an internal combustion engine automobile.
*Governments that impose [[fuel tax]]es will be unable to do so because air is free.


== Disadvantages ==
== Disadvantages ==

Revision as of 21:35, 21 February 2008

Template:Future automobile

A Compressed air car is a car that uses a motor powered by compressed air.

This can be combined with hybrid gasoline/diesel/ethanol or electric plant and regenerative braking.

Several companies are investigating and producing prototypes and other ones, including Tata Motors, state that "the first cars should be available on the market in summer 2008."[1]

Overview

The compressed Air car has been mentioned by Popular Mechanics and Green News as being the true car of tomorrow, with the same mileage and zero emissions as a fuel-cell car without the dangers currently associated with hydrogen.

History

Technology

Engines

One can buy the vehicle with the engine or buy an engine to be installed in a vehicle.

Compressed air cars are powered by engines, fueled by compressed air, which is stored in a tank under high pressure such as 30 MPa (4500 psi or 300 bar), following ISO 11439.[2] The storage tank is likely to be made of carbon-fiber in order to reduce its weight while achieving the necessary strength. Instead of mixing fuel with air and burning it to drive pistons with hot expanding gases; compressed air cars use the expansion of compressed air to drive their pistons. The idea is not new. It has been used since 1930's in cars and in Formula-1s as a start-up engine. While gasoline or diesel fuel tanks have the same amount of energy per litre of fuel from the first to the last litre, compressed air motors rely on the pressure within the tank, which decreases as air is drawn off.

Storage Tanks

Compressed air is a heavy way of storing fuel, 300l air at 30 MPa (300 Bar) amounts to about 14kWh (the equivalent of 4.5 liter (1.2 gallons) of gasoline, assuming a 30% efficiency of the engine). During rupture testing, the tank cracks, but does not break up, producing no splinters or fragments.

All four major manufacturers who are developing air cars have designed safety features into their containers as opposed to hydrogen's issues of damage and danger involved in high-impact crashes. Air, on its own, is also non-flammable. Though no company has yet demonstrated the effectiveness of an imploding engine (ZAP) vs a quick release (MDI) standard, and other safety designs; it is expected that large-scale production may lead specific governments to set their own standards. It was reported on Discovery's Beyond Tomorrow that on its own carbon-fiber is brittle and splits; but creates no shrapnel.

Emission output

Compressed air cars are emission-free at the 'tailpipe', but the energy, usually electric, required to recharge the compressed air tanks may come from the combustion of fossil fuels. Unless all of the energy comes from non-fossil sources, like biomass, nuclear power or hydroelectricity, compressed air cars will still cause net emissions of greenhouse gas, proportional to the ratio of energy produced via fossil fuels. However, emissions would be relocated from city streets to remote smokestacks, and it is also more efficient to burn fuel at power plants than it is to burn it in car engines.[dubiousdiscuss] Of course a solar and/or wind recharging system can be installed in one's home or power plants, therefore eliminating the dependence of consumption of nuclear-fossil electricity. When energy from biomass is used as the energy source, negative emissions would be the result.

An air motor also releases air cleaner than its intake, due to the presence of an air filter to keep contaminants out of the mechanism. Consequently, this can be viewed as air purification, instead of air pollution.

Advantages

The principal advantages of an air powered vehicle are:[3]

  • Compressed air engine reduces the cost of vehicle production by about 20%, because there is no need to build a cooling system, fuel tank, spark plugs or silencers.
  • Most compressed air engines do not need a transmission, just a flow control.
  • Very low self-discharge rate (most batteries will deplete their charge without external load at a rate determined by the chemistry, design, and size, while compressed gas storage will have an extremely low leakage rate)
  • Long storage lifetime device (electric vehicle batteries have a limited useful number of cycles, and sometimes a limited calendar lifetime, irrespective of use). This means that batteries in operation are much more expensive than compressed air storage, and are more pollutant because a lot more pollutant material needs to be used (typical car batteries are made from sulphuric acids and lead).
  • Lower initial cost than battery electric vehicles when mass produced. One estimate is €3,000,
  • Expansion of the compressed air reduces its temperature and heat from the passenger compartment may be cooled using a heat exchanger, providing both relief from hot weather air conditioning and increased efficiency.
  • Zero pollutant emissions from the vehicle itself.
  • There is already infrastructure in place for creating massive amounts of compressed air inefficiently (i.e. local home center for air compressors)
  • Compressed air is not a fire hazard, only a rapid depressurization hazard (this can be mitigated by using carbon fiber tanks like firemen do).
  • Air turbine technology, closely related to steam turbine technology, is a practice over 50 years old. It is simple to achieve with low tech materials. This would mean that developing countries, and rapidly growing countries like China and India, could easily implement a less polluting means of personal transportation than an internal combustion engine automobile.

Disadvantages

Having solved most of the high pressure storage and handling problems, the main remaining disadvantages are related to the thermodynamics.[4]

  • At the supply station, compressing the air heats it, and if then directly transferred in a heated state to the vehicle storage tanks will then cool and reduce the pressure. If cooled before transfer, the energy in this heat will be lost unless sophisticated low grade heat utilization is employed (see cogeneration).
  • Within the vehicle, expansion and consequent pressure reduction in the throttle or engine chills the air, reducing its effective pressure. This is called Adiabatic expansion. Addition of ambient heat will increase this pressure and this addition leads to a more complex propulsion system, and the necessity for an onboard fuel tank and heater system. While an attempt was made in the Nègre system to warm the air in a long portion of the stroke at top dead center, it appears that this scheme has been abandoned due to inherent imbalances causing unacceptable levels of vibration.
  • Passenger compartment heating is more difficult since the propulsion system does not provide a source of waste heat. Some form of heat pump, or more likely, an electric heater would be required.
  • Limited range due to available tank technology. The air engine suffers from similar problems to hydrogen vehicles in this regard.
  • Using energy to compress air is less efficient than charging a battery with that same energy.[5][6]
  • Less efficient than electric motors.[7][8]
  • While the air engine reduces greenhouse gas emissions from the vehicle, the energy used to compress the air may not come from clean sources.
  • Long refill times when compared to conventional automobiles, circa 4 Hours using a home or low-end system, though only a few minutes at a commercial refilling station.[9]


Models

Various companies are investing in the research, development and deployment of Compressed air cars. Overoptimistic reports of impending production date back to at least May 1999. For instance, the MDI Air Car made its public debut in South Africa in 2002,[10] and was predicted to be in production "within six months" in January 2004.[11] Most of the cars under development also rely on using similar technology to Low-energy vehicles in order to increase the range and performance of their cars.

The AirCar

Air Car Factories SA is proposing to develop and build a compressed air engine.[12]

Energine

The Energine Corporation is a South Korean company that delivers fully-assembled cars running on a hybrid compressed air and electric engine. These cars are more precisely named pneumatic-hybrid electric vehicles.[13]. Engineers from this company have made, starting from a Daewoo Matiz, a prototype of a hybrid electric/compressed-air engine (Pne-PHEV, pneumatic plug-in hybrid electric vehicle).[14] The compressed-air engine is used to activate an alternator, which extends the autonomous operating capacity of the car.

A similar (but only for braking energy recovery) concept using a pneumatic accumulator in a largely hydraulic system has been developed by U.S. government research laboratories and industry, and is now being introduced for certain heavy vehicle applications such as refuse trucks.[15]

The CEO is the first compressed air car promoter to be arrested for fraud.[16]

EngineAir

EngineAir, an Australian company, is developing a rotary engine powered by compressed air.[17][18]

K'Airmobiles

K'Airmobiles has presented two running prototypes of VPA (Vehicles with Pneumatic Assistance). Their leaders now seek to gain the means of developing several projects of urban or leisure VPP (Vehicles with Pneumatic Propulsion). K'Airmobiles propose a different technology with their VPP , which may allow a reasonable range, generally with compressed air tanks of about 50L-100L/3000 psi capacity only.

These ecological vehicles use the technology of the compressed-air engine K'Air, developed in France by a small group of researchers, which thus proposes a range of projects around an idea: that of the urban or leisure compressed-air vehicles.

K'Airmobiles is the name given to a set of projects relating to "VPA" (Vehicles with Pneumatic Assistance) and "VPP" (Vehicles with Pneumatic Propulsion), aiming to escape the constraints from thermodynamics. To do so, these models are conceived like ultra light vehicles (limited to 250 kg max.), and their consumption of compressed air was calculated to remain lower than 120 L/min., although developing a dynamic push able to reach 4kN.

Two VPA prototypes are operational today, the "K'AirBike" and the K'AirKart. Two new VPP prototypes, the one-seater "K'AirTrike" and the three-seater "K'AirMobile Max" are intended for public presentation in October and November 2007 respectively.

The technical concept of the K'Air pneumatic engines returns to direct conversion of what makes the fundamental characteristic of compressed air, namely:

  • the pushing force of compressed air is exclusively exploited for conversion into kinetic energy of translation,
  • itself is simultaneously converted into induced power of rotation of the axis and
  • thus gives to the engine a particularly imposing torque while needing only a very low “fuel” consumption.

To simplify, one can compare the principle to that of the rotary jacks:

  • the energy of the fluid (compressed air) is directly transformed into rotational movement;
  • the double-acting jacks involve a pinion-toothed rack system;
  • the cyclic angle of rotation can vary between 90 and 360°;
  • it supports hydraulic supercharging systems.

MDI

MDI proposes a range of vehicles developed on an identical concept, made up of MiniCATs and CityCATs. It has entered into an agreement with Tata Motors, to produce air cars in India. MDI has proposed a range of vehicles using the same basic technology.

They have licensed 12 factories : 5 in Mexico, 3 in Australia and New Zealand, 1 in South Africa and 3 in France. MDI Andina S.A is going to sell the car in Colombia, Peru, Ecuador and Panama. ZEVCAT is going to make MDI vehicles in the United States[19]

The MDI MiniCat has a range of up to 1000 miles when fitted with an internal combustion engine, but that drops to 30 miles when used in ZEV mode at low speeds in cities. OneCAT, priced in a range ($5,100 to $7,800) within reach of consumers in a developing economy, such as India.[20].

The ultralight bodies of the vehicles would be made of glued-together fiberglass and injected foam, and the aluminum chassis would also be glued, not welded, to simplify manufacturing.[21]

The engine is available in two versions. The Mono Energy air engine is a true air engine. The Dual Energy engines are Internal combustion engines, which use hydrocarbon fuels.[22]

Psycho-Active

Team Psycho-Active (TPA) has been honored to compete in the Automotive X PRIZE.[23] TPA is working to develop the EPOCH: a highly customizable and serviceable pneumatic / multi-fuel hybrid. At its core is the DBRE engine. The DBRE's unique characteristics allow the EPOCH to use most commercially available fuels and/or compressed air.[24]

Quasiturbine

The Quasiturbine is a prototype for a hybrid engine which, according to its originators, could as well function with an explosive fuel as with compressed air.

Tata

As of May 2007 Tata Motors of India planned to launch a MDI air car in 2008.[25]

See also

News articles

Videos

References

  1. ^ http://www.theaircar.com/faq.html
  2. ^ Gas cylinders -- High pressure cylinders for the on-board storage of natural gas as a fuel for automotive vehicles
  3. ^ http://www.treehugger.com/files/2005/10/what_about_comp.php
  4. ^ http://www.efcf.com/reports/ Thermodynamic Analysis of Compressed Air Vehicle Propulsion
  5. ^ Hydrogen economy Battery charging from grid is 93% efficient
  6. ^ JB Heywood "Internal Combustion Engine Fundamentals" pp 255-273 shows no compressor with an efficiency >80%
  7. ^ http://www.csiro.au/resources/pf11g.html#design Electric motors are up to 98.4% efficient
  8. ^ http://www.nww.usace.army.mil/lsr/scs_phase1/figures/figab18.jpg Efficiency of turbines 95%)
  9. ^ http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6138972/
  10. ^ Kevin Bonsor (2005-10-25). "How Air-Powered Cars Will Work". HowStuffWorks. Retrieved 2006-05-25.
  11. ^ Robyn Curnow (2004-01-11). "Gone with the wind". The Sunday Times (UK). Retrieved 2006-05-25.
  12. ^ http://www.theaircar.com/acf/air-cars/upc-agreement.html
  13. ^ http://www.patentstorm.us/patents/7028482.html[1]
  14. ^ http://www.energine.com/phev/e_phev_04.php
  15. ^ http://news.thomasnet.com/companystory/528243
  16. ^ http://english.chosun.com/w21data/html/news/200611/200611210031.html
  17. ^ http://www.gizmag.com/go/3185/
  18. ^ http://www.engineair.com.au/
  19. ^ http://www.zevcat.com
  20. ^ http://www.technologyreview.com/Energy/20071/page3/
  21. ^ http://www.technologyreview.com/Energy/20071/page3/
  22. ^ http://www.mdi.lu/eng/affiche_eng.php?page=moteurs
  23. ^ http://www.psycho-active.org/main.html
  24. ^ http://www.psycho-active.org/epoch.html