Talk:Hitar Petar: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
::::: By the way, I just searched on Google with the adjective "clever" instead of "sly" and [http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&q=%22clever+Peter%22+macedonia+bulgaria&start=0&sa=N "here's"] what I got. As a result, I am moving this page to the "Clever Peter" title. [[User:Sonetnoir|Sonetnoir]] ([[User talk:Sonetnoir|talk]]) 09:56, 22 November 2009 (UTC) |
::::: By the way, I just searched on Google with the adjective "clever" instead of "sly" and [http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&q=%22clever+Peter%22+macedonia+bulgaria&start=0&sa=N "here's"] what I got. As a result, I am moving this page to the "Clever Peter" title. [[User:Sonetnoir|Sonetnoir]] ([[User talk:Sonetnoir|talk]]) 09:56, 22 November 2009 (UTC) |
||
:::::: Sorry, I fail to see more than 4-5 independent references, most are based on somebody's mistranslation of a single folk tale. I've already established that "Hitar Petar" is the most popular form of the name in English, so this is what we're using. Also, please don't attempt premature moves when the discussion is not over. Thanks, ''[[User:TodorBozhinov|Todor]][[User_talk:TodorBozhinov|→]][[User:TodorBozhinov|Bozhinov]]'' 18:41, 22 November 2009 (UTC) |
:::::: Sorry, I fail to see more than 4-5 independent references, most are based on somebody's mistranslation of a single folk tale. I've already established that "Hitar Petar" is the most popular form of the name in English, so this is what we're using. Also, please don't attempt premature moves when the discussion is not over. Thanks, ''[[User:TodorBozhinov|Todor]][[User_talk:TodorBozhinov|→]][[User:TodorBozhinov|Bozhinov]]'' 18:41, 22 November 2009 (UTC) |
||
::::::: We are talking about a folk tales [http://books.google.com/books?id=w9KEk9wQPjkC&pg=PT948&lpg=PT948&dq=%22clever+Peter%22+macedonia+bulgaria&source=bl&ots=TaFrJA4IXF&sig=OQTEG0xM-udQo9pYpeZkSeUO4PE&hl=en&ei=wYUJS-74EJWmMMysgcQK&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CAsQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=%22clever%20Peter%22%20macedonia%20bulgaria&f=false "encyclopedia"] by a professor who is an [http://www.clas.wayne.edu/multimedia/usercontent/File/CMLLC/faculty_cvs/Haase_cv.pdf "expert"] on fairy tales and folk tales. Here's [https://www.ecampus.com/bk_detail.asp?isbn=9781563089633 "another book"] on the matter. You can see the name "Clever Peter" in the table of contents, or you can find the book in Google's book search. Yet another book specifically designed for educators can be found [http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/custom/portlets/recordDetails/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=ED413593&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=no&accno=ED413593 "here"], and I also found an academic article right [http://www.jstor.org/pss/4205423 "here"]. This ought to be enough, though I obviously didn't mention any other pages that seem more personal and unprofessional where the name "Clever Peter" once again appears. You also failed to reply to anything that I said. [[User:Sonetnoir|Sonetnoir]] ([[User talk:Sonetnoir|talk]]) 09:56, 22 November 2009 (UTC) |
::::::: First of all, popularity is not an indicator whether something is true or correct. We are talking about a folk tales [http://books.google.com/books?id=w9KEk9wQPjkC&pg=PT948&lpg=PT948&dq=%22clever+Peter%22+macedonia+bulgaria&source=bl&ots=TaFrJA4IXF&sig=OQTEG0xM-udQo9pYpeZkSeUO4PE&hl=en&ei=wYUJS-74EJWmMMysgcQK&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CAsQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=%22clever%20Peter%22%20macedonia%20bulgaria&f=false "encyclopedia"] by a professor who is an [http://www.clas.wayne.edu/multimedia/usercontent/File/CMLLC/faculty_cvs/Haase_cv.pdf "expert"] on fairy tales and folk tales. Here's [https://www.ecampus.com/bk_detail.asp?isbn=9781563089633 "another book"] on the matter. You can see the name "Clever Peter" in the table of contents, or you can find the book in Google's book search. Yet another book specifically designed for educators can be found [http://www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/custom/portlets/recordDetails/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=ED413593&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=no&accno=ED413593 "here"], and I also found an academic article right [http://www.jstor.org/pss/4205423 "here"]. This ought to be enough, though I obviously didn't mention any other pages that seem more personal and unprofessional where the name "Clever Peter" once again appears. You also failed to reply to anything that I said. [[User:Sonetnoir|Sonetnoir]] ([[User talk:Sonetnoir|talk]]) 09:56, 22 November 2009 (UTC) |
Revision as of 20:25, 22 November 2009
{{WikiProject banner shell}}
to this page and add the quality rating to that template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.Bulgaria Stub‑class Mid‑importance | ||||||||||
|
{{WikiProject banner shell}}
to this page and add the quality rating to that template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.North Macedonia Stub‑class Mid‑importance | ||||||||||
|
Requested move
It has been proposed in this section that Hitar Petar be renamed and moved to Sly Peter. A bot will list this discussion on the requested moves current discussions subpage within an hour of this tag being placed. The discussion may be closed 7 days after being opened, if consensus has been reached (see the closing instructions). Please base arguments on article title policy, and keep discussion succinct and civil. Please use {{subst:requested move}} . Do not use {{requested move/dated}} directly. |
Hitar Petar → Sly Peter — The name of this folk character should be presented in English. The title suggests that his ethnicity is Bulgarian (even though the article is neutral to his ethnicity) due to the fact that the name "Hitar Petar" is the Bulgarian version of this famous folk character. If we rename/translate the page into Sly Peter, the ethnicity of this character is back to being neutral, as it should be.--Sonetnoir (talk) 05:10, 17 November 2009 (UTC)
- The character is Bulgarian. "Macedonian folklore" in the current context is not a term that has any history, it merely means what they consider heritage in the Republic of Macedonia. Before some time in the 20th century, the folklore of Macedonian Bulgarians was, you guessed it, part of Bulgarian folklore.
- It's not a matter of folklore X and folklore Y sharing the same character. Folklore X of a certain region merely came to be known as folklore Y for political reasons.
- "Sly Peter" pretty much doesn't exist as a name for the character. Todor→Bozhinov 09:22, 17 November 2009 (UTC)
- It's idiotic to suggest that folklore belongs to any modern nation, especially in the Balkans after so much intermingling and cultural romances. Please get off your nationalist high-horse and be reasonable. Characters like Sly Peter appear throughout the world under different names, starting with Nasrettin Hodja and ending with various African folk tales (such as the tortoise in Nigerian folklore) - you cannot claim them all. Furthermore, while your nationalist hysteria and usurpation is typical and maybe even respectable for a Balkanian, it is highly ridiculous to anyone else. In the end, this is not the Bulgarian wikipedia, it's the English one, thus translate the name "Hitar Petar" into Sly Peter, don't transliterate it. Of course the name doesn't "exist" when you translate it into English ---> Example: Владислав Граматик is translated into Vladislav the Grammarian, not into Vladislav Gramatik. Thanks. --Sonetnoir (talk) 02:55, 18 November 2009 (UTC)
- I'm not claiming Nigerian tortoises or Nasrudin and this article is not about Nigerian tortoises or Nasrudin. "Vladislav the Grammarian" is an established name for the Bulgarian scholar, we didn't make it up for Wikipedia. If you'd like the article to be named "Sly Peter", then concentrate on off-wiki efforts such as writing books in English about the character and use any name you wish. Then, if you make "Sly Peter" an established name in English, come back and leave me a message.
- Finally, watch your tongue and show some respect to fellow Wikipedians. It's not like I provoked the kind of tone that you're demonstrating. But thanks for reminding me this is the English Wikipedia. Todor→Bozhinov 07:38, 18 November 2009 (UTC)
- While I agree that Vladislav the Grammarian has been translated and established in the English speaking world, that is for a good reason. Itar/Hitar Pejo/Petar is not a world famous or a highly influential figure, because he is a much of a local Balkan character, obviously derived from Nasrudin Hodja. Furthermore, "Hitar Petar" is not a full name - because it consists of an adjective (Hitar/Itar = Sly, or Clever) and a first name (Petar/Pejo), hence the reason why the adjective should be translated into English. Your suggestion of writing a book about "Sly Peter" is laughable, because it's an obvious red herring. Also, I should say that you should watch your own patronizing tone, it's insulting to me as a human being for anyone to claim that folklore can be claimed by any nation, for the reasons I mentioned above. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Sonetnoir (talk • contribs) 09:01, 22 November 2009 (UTC)
- By the way, I just searched on Google with the adjective "clever" instead of "sly" and "here's" what I got. As a result, I am moving this page to the "Clever Peter" title. Sonetnoir (talk) 09:56, 22 November 2009 (UTC)
- Sorry, I fail to see more than 4-5 independent references, most are based on somebody's mistranslation of a single folk tale. I've already established that "Hitar Petar" is the most popular form of the name in English, so this is what we're using. Also, please don't attempt premature moves when the discussion is not over. Thanks, Todor→Bozhinov 18:41, 22 November 2009 (UTC)
- First of all, popularity is not an indicator whether something is true or correct. We are talking about a folk tales "encyclopedia" by a professor who is an "expert" on fairy tales and folk tales. Here's "another book" on the matter. You can see the name "Clever Peter" in the table of contents, or you can find the book in Google's book search. Yet another book specifically designed for educators can be found "here", and I also found an academic article right "here". This ought to be enough, though I obviously didn't mention any other pages that seem more personal and unprofessional where the name "Clever Peter" once again appears. You also failed to reply to anything that I said. Sonetnoir (talk) 09:56, 22 November 2009 (UTC)
- Sorry, I fail to see more than 4-5 independent references, most are based on somebody's mistranslation of a single folk tale. I've already established that "Hitar Petar" is the most popular form of the name in English, so this is what we're using. Also, please don't attempt premature moves when the discussion is not over. Thanks, Todor→Bozhinov 18:41, 22 November 2009 (UTC)
- By the way, I just searched on Google with the adjective "clever" instead of "sly" and "here's" what I got. As a result, I am moving this page to the "Clever Peter" title. Sonetnoir (talk) 09:56, 22 November 2009 (UTC)
- While I agree that Vladislav the Grammarian has been translated and established in the English speaking world, that is for a good reason. Itar/Hitar Pejo/Petar is not a world famous or a highly influential figure, because he is a much of a local Balkan character, obviously derived from Nasrudin Hodja. Furthermore, "Hitar Petar" is not a full name - because it consists of an adjective (Hitar/Itar = Sly, or Clever) and a first name (Petar/Pejo), hence the reason why the adjective should be translated into English. Your suggestion of writing a book about "Sly Peter" is laughable, because it's an obvious red herring. Also, I should say that you should watch your own patronizing tone, it's insulting to me as a human being for anyone to claim that folklore can be claimed by any nation, for the reasons I mentioned above. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Sonetnoir (talk • contribs) 09:01, 22 November 2009 (UTC)
- It's idiotic to suggest that folklore belongs to any modern nation, especially in the Balkans after so much intermingling and cultural romances. Please get off your nationalist high-horse and be reasonable. Characters like Sly Peter appear throughout the world under different names, starting with Nasrettin Hodja and ending with various African folk tales (such as the tortoise in Nigerian folklore) - you cannot claim them all. Furthermore, while your nationalist hysteria and usurpation is typical and maybe even respectable for a Balkanian, it is highly ridiculous to anyone else. In the end, this is not the Bulgarian wikipedia, it's the English one, thus translate the name "Hitar Petar" into Sly Peter, don't transliterate it. Of course the name doesn't "exist" when you translate it into English ---> Example: Владислав Граматик is translated into Vladislav the Grammarian, not into Vladislav Gramatik. Thanks. --Sonetnoir (talk) 02:55, 18 November 2009 (UTC)