Jump to content

Christian O'Brien: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Qworty (talk | contribs)
Line 20: Line 20:


===Latest reception of work===
===Latest reception of work===
[[Edward F. Malkowski]] has recently discussed O'Brien's theories in 2006 in his book ''"The Spiritual Technology of Ancient Egypt"'', noting "O'Brien's book, ''The Genius of the Few'', received little notice."<ref name="MalkowskiLubicz2007">{{cite book|author1=Edward F. Malkowski|author2=R. A. Schwaller de Lubicz|title=The Spiritual Technology of Ancient Egypt: Sacred Science and the Mystery of Consciousness, p. 218 & 345|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=T4N1HcruTeAC|accessdate=11 September 2011|date=30 October 2007|publisher=Inner Traditions / Bear & Co|isbn=978-1-59477-186-6}}{{Verify credibility|failed=y|reason=Schwaller de Lubicz was a pseudohistorian|date=September 2012}}</ref> In 1996, British author [[Andrew Collins]] expounded on O'Brien's work in ''From the Ashes of Angels''. He goes on to mention that "When these tablets, now stored at the University of Philadelphia museum, were first translated, they were believed to be a Sumerian creation myth, and the personalities depicted in the epic stories were interpreted as gods. According to exploration geologist and historian Christian O'Brien (1915-2001), however, this religious interpretation was a product of preconceived notions; according to his analysis, it has had 'disastrous results for the truth'."<ref name="Collins2001">{{cite book|author=Andrew Collins|title=From the Ashes of Angels: The Forbidden Legacy of a Fallen Race|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=Muv5GgAACAAJ|accessdate=6 September 2012|date=1 September 2001|publisher=Bear & Company|isbn=978-1-879181-72-4}}</ref>
Edward F. Malkowski has recently discussed O'Brien's theories in 2006 in his book ''"The Spiritual Technology of Ancient Egypt"'', noting "O'Brien's book, ''The Genius of the Few'', received little notice."<ref name="MalkowskiLubicz2007">{{cite book|author1=Edward F. Malkowski|author2=R. A. Schwaller de Lubicz|title=The Spiritual Technology of Ancient Egypt: Sacred Science and the Mystery of Consciousness, p. 218 & 345|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=T4N1HcruTeAC|accessdate=11 September 2011|date=30 October 2007|publisher=Inner Traditions / Bear & Co|isbn=978-1-59477-186-6}}{{Verify credibility|failed=y|reason=Schwaller de Lubicz was a pseudohistorian|date=September 2012}}</ref> In 1996, British author [[Andrew Collins]] expounded on O'Brien's work in ''From the Ashes of Angels''. He goes on to mention that "When these tablets, now stored at the University of Philadelphia museum, were first translated, they were believed to be a Sumerian creation myth, and the personalities depicted in the epic stories were interpreted as gods. According to exploration geologist and historian Christian O'Brien (1915-2001), however, this religious interpretation was a product of preconceived notions; according to his analysis, it has had 'disastrous results for the truth'."<ref name="Collins2001">{{cite book|author=Andrew Collins|title=From the Ashes of Angels: The Forbidden Legacy of a Fallen Race|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=Muv5GgAACAAJ|accessdate=6 September 2012|date=1 September 2001|publisher=Bear & Company|isbn=978-1-879181-72-4}}</ref>


==Positions, awards and accolades==
==Positions, awards and accolades==

Revision as of 02:12, 25 September 2012

File:Christianobrien.jpg
Christian O'Brien, British exploration geologist and author

Christian Arthur Edgar "Tim" O'Brien C.B.E (9 January 1914 – 17 February 2001) was a British exploration geologist and author. In 1936 he was also involved in the discovery of the Chogha Zanbil Ziggurat in Southern Iran. Appointed by BP In 1967, he retired in 1971 as Chairman of the Boards and General Managing Director of the Iranian Oil Operating Companies, stationed in Tehran, and was awarded a CBE for services to the Oil Industry.

O'Brien devoted his retirement to researching prehistory, cuneiform, archaeology, astronomy, archaeoastronomy and the history of religion.

Biography

Born in Fulham, O'Brien was educated at Tiffin Boys School, Kingston-upon-Thames and then went to Cambridge University where he read Natural Sciences, graduating in 1935. In 1936, he joined the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company, now British Petroleum and known universally as BP. His geological activities started in Southern Iran under senior geologist, Victor Boileau in the winter of 1936–37 where he assisted with Boileau's discovery of the Chogha Zanbil Ziggurat. O'Brien stayed for three years, and then was due for home leave. He happened to be in England when the Second World War started, and so joined up in the Royal Engineers, eventually becoming Major after service in Italy and Tunisia.

He returned to work in Iran after the war and was also involved in exploration geology in Canada & other countries. His later geological work included a survey of the Rocky mountains Boule and Bosche ranges.[1] On October 16, 1958 he married Barbara Joy Kelly.

Archaeological theories

After his retirement in 1970, O'Brien began researching and writing about ancient civilizations, taught himself how to read cuneiform,[2] and published three books on the subject.

O'Brien published several other papers and books. "The Wandlebury-Hatfield Heath Astronomical Complex" described his surveying and discovering what he calls the Wandlebury Enigma or Line A Loxodrome, a claim which has not gained much acceptance.[3]

"The Megalithic Odyssey" presents evidence for an astronomical complex on Bodmin Moor in Cornwall, England, dated no later than c. 2500 BC. In the book he presents his view that 13 stone circles and 86 ridge-top cairns were designed and built for complex observational astronomy by a group of itinerant sages with links to Sumer. A review in the journal Archaeostronomy[4] describes the book as "a mishmash of erroneous statements and poorly conceived and unsubstantiated arguments." The reviewer suggests that O'Brien has misapplied statistical methods and that coupled with a dubious interpretation of the archaeology (e.g. assuming that all the cairns, all badly damaged and with only a few over two to three meters high, would have been over 10 meters high whereas similar sites have few cairns over 10 meters, with some of the 'cairns' possibly not prehistoric) "negates any value" it would have had as a claim for prehistoric archaeoastronomy. He further argues that the suggestion that the Sumerians introduced a calendar which made agriculture viable ignored the fact that agriculture had already existed in the area for over a thousand years, saying that "the book is full of statements which only confirm O'Brien's ignorance of our current knowledge of prehistory."[5]

O'Brien made the geological discovery of a substantial hanging river bed on São Miguel Island. Using Portuguese Admiralty Charts of the ocean floor in the area of the Azores in February 1973, he argued for the former existence of a large island at this location on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge which he believed to be Atlantis. He also made his own translations of the Bruce Codex, Askew Codex from Greek cursive characters in the now extinct, Upper Egyptian Coptic dialect. He also translated a series of tablets from Nippur including the Barton Cylinder, which he collectively grouped and called the Kharsag Epics. He claimed to have used these as a primary source to discover the location of "Kharsag", allegedly a location also mentioned in other Sumerian texts such as Atrahasis I that he equated with The Garden of Eden in The Second Book of Enoch and The Bible.

Latest reception of work

Edward F. Malkowski has recently discussed O'Brien's theories in 2006 in his book "The Spiritual Technology of Ancient Egypt", noting "O'Brien's book, The Genius of the Few, received little notice."[6] In 1996, British author Andrew Collins expounded on O'Brien's work in From the Ashes of Angels. He goes on to mention that "When these tablets, now stored at the University of Philadelphia museum, were first translated, they were believed to be a Sumerian creation myth, and the personalities depicted in the epic stories were interpreted as gods. According to exploration geologist and historian Christian O'Brien (1915-2001), however, this religious interpretation was a product of preconceived notions; according to his analysis, it has had 'disastrous results for the truth'."[7]

Positions, awards and accolades

Books

  • O'Brien, C.A.E., 1953, Salztektonik in Sudpersien, Stuttgart.
  • O'Brien, C.A.E., 1957, Salt Diapirism in South Persia, London and Amsterdam.
  • O'Brien, C.A.E., 1960, The Structural Geology of the Boule and Bosche Ranges in the Canadian Rocky Mountains, London.
  • O'Brien, C.A.E., 1975, The Wandlebury-Hatfield Heath Astronomical Complex, Thaxted.
  • O'Brien, C.A.E., 1983, The Megalithic Odyssey, A.C. Wellingborough. ISBN 0-85500-188-7
  • O'Brien, C.A.E. & O'Brien B.J., 1985, The Genius of The Few, Wellingborough. ISBN 0-946604-17-7 (Revised edition by Dianthus Publishing 1999)
  • O'Brien, C.A.E., 1985, The Path of Light, The Deram Beas, India. ISBN 00946604274 (Revised edition by Dianthus Publishing 1999)
  • O'Brien, C.A.E. & O'Brien B.J., 1999, The Shining Ones, Dianthus Publishing ISBN 0-946604-20-7 (Revised edition by Dianthus Publishing, 2001)
  • O'Brien, C.A.E. & O'Brien B.J., 2005, Eastern Odyssey – Experiences of a Young Geologist, E & E Plumridge, Cambridge. ISBN 0-9516563-9-2

References

  1. ^ Geological Survey (U.S.) (1949). Geological Survey bulletin. U.S. Dept. of the Interior, Geological Survey; Washington, D.C. pp. 463–. Retrieved 6 September 2012.
  2. ^ Flem-Ath R, Wilson C (2001). The Atlantis Blueprint: Unlocking the Ancient Mysteries of a Long-Lost Civilization, Delacorte Press (Mar 2001)ISBN 978-0-385-33479-2 p.195
  3. ^ Price, Simon "The Gog Magog Hills Fortean Times May 2006[unreliable source?]
  4. ^ now called ARCHAEOASTRONOMY: The Journal of Astronomy in Culture
  5. ^ Barnatt, John, review of Christian O'Brien's "The Megalithic Odyssey" Archaeoastronomy Volume VII(l-4) 1984 pp.142–143
  6. ^ Edward F. Malkowski; R. A. Schwaller de Lubicz (30 October 2007). The Spiritual Technology of Ancient Egypt: Sacred Science and the Mystery of Consciousness, p. 218 & 345. Inner Traditions / Bear & Co. ISBN 978-1-59477-186-6. Retrieved 11 September 2011.[unreliable source]
  7. ^ Andrew Collins (1 September 2001). From the Ashes of Angels: The Forbidden Legacy of a Fallen Race. Bear & Company. ISBN 978-1-879181-72-4. Retrieved 6 September 2012.
  8. ^ Supplement to the London Gazette, 1st January 1971

Template:Persondata