Celsius 7/7: Difference between revisions
→Response: Added Guardian review |
Removed POV description of Phillips and Pollard as "far right author[s]". Note that Dalrymple is simply and correctly referred to as an author, sans any descriptor. |
||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
Since publishing, Gove has been accused of harbouring a hostile attitude towards Islam and Muslims. The author [[William Dalrymple (historian)|William Dalrymple]] has attacked the book as a "confused epic of simplistic incomprehension" and pointed out that contrary to claims on the book's jacket that Gove was an authority on Islamist terror, he had in fact never lived or travelled in any Islamic country, knew little about Islamic history or theology, and showed no sign of having met or talked to any Muslims.<ref>{{cite news| url=http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2102-2366952,00.html | location=London | work=The Times | first=Jenny | last=Booth}}</ref> |
Since publishing, Gove has been accused of harbouring a hostile attitude towards Islam and Muslims. The author [[William Dalrymple (historian)|William Dalrymple]] has attacked the book as a "confused epic of simplistic incomprehension" and pointed out that contrary to claims on the book's jacket that Gove was an authority on Islamist terror, he had in fact never lived or travelled in any Islamic country, knew little about Islamic history or theology, and showed no sign of having met or talked to any Muslims.<ref>{{cite news| url=http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2102-2366952,00.html | location=London | work=The Times | first=Jenny | last=Booth}}</ref> |
||
Gove was vigorously defended by |
Gove was vigorously defended by authors [[Melanie Phillips]] and [[Stephen Pollard]], who rejected Dalrymple's analysis,<ref>[http://www.melaniephillips.com/diary/?p=1341 Melanie Phillips’s Diary » The war within the west (3)]{{dead link|date=May 2012}}</ref><ref>[http://www.stephenpollard.net/002929.html Stephen Pollard • Dalrymple wrong as usual]{{dead link|date=May 2012}}</ref> and Gove himself has replied in ''The Times''.<ref>{{cite news|author=|url=http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,1055-2375891.html |title=When the whole truth can be so difficult to deny | Michael Gove |publisher=Times Online |date=|accessdate=2012-05-29 |location=London |first=Jenny |last=Booth}}</ref> |
||
==Book extracts== |
==Book extracts== |
||
Revision as of 14:53, 4 February 2013
Celsius 7/7 (ISBN 0-297-85146-2), published by Weidenfeld & Nicolson on 29 June 2006, is a study of the roots of Islamic terrorism by British Conservative MP Michael Gove.
Summary
In the book he discusses both the emergence of Islamism and the West's response. It distinguishes between 'the great historical faith' of Islam which he claims has 'brought spiritual nourishment to millions', and Islamism, a 'totalitarian ideolog[y]' which turns to 'hellish violence and oppression' in a similar way to the 20th century ideologies of National Socialism and Communism.[1]
He discusses the factors that led to the development of large-scale Muslim terrorism and how the West has failed to stand up for its liberal values in the face of this pressure, including his analysis of the alliance between Muslim fundamentalists and the Western left.
Response
This book has been studied by leading members of the British Government, who have adopted a number of his suggestions.[2] It was positively received by journals like the TLS and Literary Review from terrorism experts Walter Laqueur and Michael Burleigh.[2]. While Steven Poole in the Guardian called it "remarkably trite" and asked "what universe is Gove living in?"[3]
Since publishing, Gove has been accused of harbouring a hostile attitude towards Islam and Muslims. The author William Dalrymple has attacked the book as a "confused epic of simplistic incomprehension" and pointed out that contrary to claims on the book's jacket that Gove was an authority on Islamist terror, he had in fact never lived or travelled in any Islamic country, knew little about Islamic history or theology, and showed no sign of having met or talked to any Muslims.[4]
Gove was vigorously defended by authors Melanie Phillips and Stephen Pollard, who rejected Dalrymple's analysis,[5][6] and Gove himself has replied in The Times.[7]
Book extracts
References
- ^ Michael Gove, Celsius 7/7 2006 pvii
- ^ a b "Ministers take leaf out of Tory's book", Andrew Pierce, Daily Telegraph, 18 December 2006
- ^ http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2006/sep/09/shopping.politics2.
{{cite news}}: Missing or empty|title=(help) - ^ Booth, Jenny. The Times. London http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2102-2366952,00.html.
{{cite news}}: Missing or empty|title=(help) - ^ Melanie Phillips’s Diary » The war within the west (3)[dead link]
- ^ Stephen Pollard • Dalrymple wrong as usual[dead link]
- ^ Booth, Jenny. "When the whole truth can be so difficult to deny | Michael Gove". London: Times Online. Retrieved 2012-05-29.