Jump to content

Bozhidar Dimitrov: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
→‎Controversy: what the true controversy is all about!!!
→‎Controversy: translating Macedonian "sources" in Macedonian from their original in Bulgarian
Line 15: Line 15:


==Controversy==
==Controversy==
Some of Dimitrov’s works are controversial, because of the strong factions in the Serbian nationalist involved in the nation-building processes in Macedonia. Such circles claim that his facts mare based on inconsistent historical interpretation and can be challenged, but they are popular in Bulgaria and he enjoys an authority among some nationalist intellectual and political circles.<ref>[http://www.imir-bg.org/imir/books/Modernity_and_tradition.pdf Modernity and tradition: European and national in Bulgaria, Marko Hajdinjak, Maya Kosseva, Antonina Zhelyazkova, International Center for Minority Studies and Intercultural Relations, Sofia, ISBN: 978-954-8872-70-6, 2012.]</ref><ref>Europe and the Historical Legacies in the Balkans, Raymond Detrez, Barbara</ref>. There are great number of destroyed artifacts and defaced monuments of the medieval Bulgarian culture on the territory of modern day Macedonia<ref>http://www.cc.ece.ntua.gr/~conster/English/PageData/samuel.htm</ref>;such redactions have attempted to blot out the true origin of the artifacts, in order to be used as illustrations to unreal claims for independent medieval evolution of a Macedonian ethnicity. The theses of Bozhidar Dimitrov are that modern day pseudo-scholars, for political purposes, annex portions of Bulgarian medieval history, and persons of Bulgarian historical significance and proclaim them 'Macedonian,' as it is in the case of Tsar Samuil.<ref>http://www.cc.ece.ntua.gr/~conster/English/PageData/samuel.htm</ref>
Some of Dimitrov’s works are controversial, because they challenge the works of strong Serbian nationalist involvement in the 'nation-building' processes in Macedonia. Political circles claim that Dimitrov's facts are based on "inconsistent historical interpretation" and can be challenged, but they are popular in Bulgaria and he enjoys an authority among some nationalist intellectual and political circles.<ref>[http://www.imir-bg.org/imir/books/Modernity_and_tradition.pdf Modernity and tradition: European and national in Bulgaria, Marko Hajdinjak, Maya Kosseva, Antonina Zhelyazkova, International Center for Minority Studies and Intercultural Relations, Sofia, ISBN: 978-954-8872-70-6, 2012.]</ref><ref>Europe and the Historical Legacies in the Balkans, Raymond Detrez, Barbara</ref>. There are great number of destroyed artifacts and defaced monuments of the medieval Bulgarian culture on the territory of modern day Macedonia<ref>http://www.cc.ece.ntua.gr/~conster/English/PageData/samuel.htm</ref>;such redactions of history have attempted to blot out the true origin of the artifacts, in order to be used as illustrations to unreal claims for independent medieval evolution of a Macedonian ethnicity. The theses of Bozhidar Dimitrov are that modern day pseudo-scholars, for political purposes, annex portions of Bulgarian medieval history, and persons of Bulgarian historical significance and proclaim them 'Macedonian,' as it is in the case of Tsar Samuil.<ref>http://www.cc.ece.ntua.gr/~conster/English/PageData/samuel.htm</ref> To-date no serious historian has challenged the statements made by Dimitrov, and there are number of publications to support each one of his scientific claims<ref>http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ex3t8hX_92I&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dex3t8hX_92I</ref>. All arguments in defense of the medieval Macedonian history come from politically indoctrinated modern "research." Until 1944 there was no question of the historic identity of the ethnicity inhabiting modern-day Macedonia.<ref>http://www.promacedonia.org/poklon/i_dujchev.htm</ref>. The circles of the scholars supporting the stake in the "inconsistencies" in Dimitrov's theory have yet to produce explanation as to why all folklore texts, and documents associated with the everyday life of the people of the modern-day Macedonia from the time of the Otoman occupation, had to be translated from Bulgarian language to Macedonian<ref>http://liternet.bg/folklor/sbornici/miladinovci/content.htm</ref><ref>http://www.time.mk/cluster/393bd3e65a/plaketi-za-struskite-lauerati.html/>.


==''The Ten Lies of Macedonism''==
==''The Ten Lies of Macedonism''==

Revision as of 12:06, 21 July 2013

Bozhidar Dimitrov

Bozhidar Dimitrov Stoyanov (Bulgarian: Божидар Димитров Стоянов,[1] born 3 December 1945) is a Bulgarian historian working in the sphere of Medieval Bulgarian history, the Ottoman rule of Bulgaria and the Macedonian Question. He is the director of the National Historical Museum, formerly a Bulgarian Socialist Party member, and currently a politician affiliated with the GERB political party.

Biography

He was Minister without portfolio responsible for Bulgarians abroad in the GERB government (July 2009 – February 2011).[1]

Born in Sozopol to a family of Bulgarian refugees from Eastern Thrace (now part of Turkey), he was given access to the Vatican Secret Archives in the 1980s, regarded as a great achievement considered the political situation of the time. As the director of the National Historical Museum, he had an indirect conflict in 1997–1998 with the President Petar Stoyanov regarding whether to return the Istoriya Slavyanobolgarskaya rough copy to the Zograf Monastery or leave it in Bulgaria.

Being a member of the Supreme Party Council of BSP, he declared himself openly against the party in 2005 by not supporting BSP Mayor of Sofia candidate Tatyana Doncheva and instead favouring the independent Boyko Borisov. Because of this he was taken down from the post of BSP municipal councillors leader in Sofia. Before the 2009 Bulgarian parliamentary election, Dimitrov formally left BSP and joined Borisov's GERB. He was the party's proportional vote candidate for Burgas Province and won the election with 35.92% ahead of Volen Siderov.[2]

Dimitrov is the author of 30 treatises and over 250 articles and papers in the sphere of his research, as well as several books (including The Ten Lies of Macedonism and Twelve Myths in Bulgarian History). He has specialized in palaeography in Paris and also hosts the patriotic history-related Pamet Balgarska (Bulgarian Memory) show on Kanal 1.

Dimitrov believes that the Bulgars played a more important role in the formation of the contemporary Bulgarians as a people than previously believed.

Controversy

Some of Dimitrov’s works are controversial, because they challenge the works of strong Serbian nationalist involvement in the 'nation-building' processes in Macedonia. Political circles claim that Dimitrov's facts are based on "inconsistent historical interpretation" and can be challenged, but they are popular in Bulgaria and he enjoys an authority among some nationalist intellectual and political circles.[3][4]. There are great number of destroyed artifacts and defaced monuments of the medieval Bulgarian culture on the territory of modern day Macedonia[5];such redactions of history have attempted to blot out the true origin of the artifacts, in order to be used as illustrations to unreal claims for independent medieval evolution of a Macedonian ethnicity. The theses of Bozhidar Dimitrov are that modern day pseudo-scholars, for political purposes, annex portions of Bulgarian medieval history, and persons of Bulgarian historical significance and proclaim them 'Macedonian,' as it is in the case of Tsar Samuil.[6] To-date no serious historian has challenged the statements made by Dimitrov, and there are number of publications to support each one of his scientific claims[7]. All arguments in defense of the medieval Macedonian history come from politically indoctrinated modern "research." Until 1944 there was no question of the historic identity of the ethnicity inhabiting modern-day Macedonia.[8]. The circles of the scholars supporting the stake in the "inconsistencies" in Dimitrov's theory have yet to produce explanation as to why all folklore texts, and documents associated with the everyday life of the people of the modern-day Macedonia from the time of the Otoman occupation, had to be translated from Bulgarian language to Macedonian[9]Cite error: A <ref> tag is missing the closing </ref> (see the help page). The "10 lies" described by Dimitrov are:

First lie: the notion that contemporary ethnic Macedonians are descendants of ancient Macedonians.

Second lie: ethnic Macedonians are "pure Slavs" distinct from Bulgarians, who are "Tatars".

Third lie: medieval figures like Saints Cyril and Methodius were ethnic Macedonians.

Fourth lie: Samuel of Bulgaria was an ethnic Macedonian and the First Bulgarian Empire was a "Macedonian" state.

Fifth lie: the Archbishopric of Ohrid was a "Macedonian" church.

Sixth lie: the Bulgarian Exarchate conquered the ethnic Macedonian people.

Seventh lie: early 20th-century revolutionary movements such as the Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organization (IMRO) worked for a "Macedonian" national goal.

Eighth lie: that Krste Misirkov is the number 1 ethnic Macedonian of the 20th century.

Ninth lie: the "heroic struggle of the Macedonian people against Bulgarian occupiers in 1941-1944".

Tenth lie: on the rejoicing of the Macedonian people for their second inclusion in Yugoslavia in 1944 and the 250,000 ethnic Macedonians in Bulgaria. [10]

Publications

  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. The True History of Liberation 1860–1878. Sofia: Standart News Ltd., 2010. 183 pp. ISBN 978-954-92377-9-5 (First edition in 2006, ISBN 978-954-91652-5-8.) Template:Bg icon
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov, co-author. Bulgarian Policies on the Republic of Macedonia: Recommendations on the development of good neighbourly relations following Bulgaria’s accession to the EU and in the context of NATO and EU enlargement in the Western Balkans. Sofia: Manfred Wörner Foundation, 2008. 80 pp. ISBN 978-954-92032-2-6 (Trilingual publication in Bulgarian, Macedonian and English)
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. The Ten Lies of Macedonism. Sofia: Kom Foundation, 2007. 107 pp. ISBN 978-954-91652-9-6 (First edition in 2000 in Bulgarian, ISBN 978-954-90700-1-9.)
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. Macedonia – Holy Bulgarian Land: Who Are the Successors of Alexander the Great and Roxana? Sofia: Kom Foundation, 2007. 80 pp. ISBN 978-954-8745-06-2 Template:Bg icon
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. Seven Ancient Civilizations in Bulgaria: With Maps & Color Illustrations. Sofia: Kom Foundation, 2006. 112 pp. ISBN 978-954-9464-07-8
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. 12 Myths in Bulgarian History. Sofia, Kom Foundation, 2005. 148 pp. ISBN 978-954-91652-1-0 Template:Bg icon
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. Bulgarians: The First Europeans. Sofia: St. Kliment Ohridsky University Press, 2002. 108 pp. ISBN 978-954-07-1758-6
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. Bulgaria and the Vatican. Sofia: Bulgarian Diplomatic Review, 2002. 56 pp. ISBN 978-954-91062-4-4
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. The Bulgars and Alexander of Macedon. Sofia: Tangra Publishers, 2001. 138 pp. ISBN 954-9942-29-5 Template:Bg icon
  • Bozhidar Dimitrov. Venetian Documents on Bulgarian History During the 16th and 17th Century. Sofia: Borina Ltd., 1994. ISBN 978-954-500-036-2 Template:Bg icon

References

  • Georgieva, Kapka (31 December 2002). "Bulgaria won't perish as long as there's even a single Bulgarian alive" (in Bulgarian). Pravoslavieto.com. Retrieved 2006-06-26.
  • Parvanova, Lyudmila (21 September 2003). "Bozhidar Dimitrov — A Bulgarian Reborn" (in Bulgarian). Standart News. Retrieved 2006-06-26.

Notes

Template:Persondata