Year
|
Category
|
Film
|
Result
|
1997
|
Florida Film Critics Circle Award for Best Cast
|
Boogie Nights
|
Won
|
1999
|
San Diego Film Critics Society Award for Best Actor
|
Flawless
|
Won
|
1999
|
London Film Critics' Circle Award for Actor of the Year
|
Flawless
|
Nominated
|
1999
|
Florida Film Critics Circle Award for Best Cast
|
Magnolia
|
Won
|
2000
|
Florida Film Critics Circle Award for Best Cast
|
State and Main
|
Won
|
2000
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Almost Famous
|
Nominated
|
2000
|
London Film Critics' Circle Award for Actor of the Year
|
Almost Famous
|
Nominated
|
2003
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor
|
Owning Mahowny
|
Won
|
2005
|
Austin Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Boston Society of Film Critics Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Florida Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Iowa Film Critics Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Kansas City Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
New York Film Critics Online Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
San Diego Film Critics Society Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Southeastern Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Toronto Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Utah Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critic Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Won
|
2005
|
London Film Critics Circle Award for Actor of the Year
|
Capote
|
Nominated
|
2005
|
New York Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Nominated
|
2005
|
St. Louis Gateway Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor
|
Capote
|
Nominated
|
2007
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Charlie Wilson's War
|
Nominated
|
2007
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Charlie Wilson's War
|
Nominated
|
2007
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Charlie Wilson's War
|
Nominated
|
2007
|
Houston Film Critics Society for Best Supporting Actor
|
Charlie Wilson's War
|
Nominated
|
2007
|
National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Charlie Wilson's War
|
Nominated
|
2007
|
Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Charlie Wilson's War
|
Nominated
|
2007
|
St. Louis Gateway Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Charlie Wilson's War
|
Nominated
|
2007
|
Toronto Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Charlie Wilson's War
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association Award for Best Ensemble
|
Doubt
|
Won
|
2008
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Doubt
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association Award for Best Cast
|
Doubt
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Central Ohio Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Doubt
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Doubt
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Doubt
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Doubt
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Toronto Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Doubt
|
Nominated
|
2008
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
Doubt
|
Nominated
|
2011
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association Award for Best Cast
|
The Ides of March
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Chicago Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Denver Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Florida Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Georgia Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Kansas City Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
London Film Critics Circle Award for Supporting Actor of the Year
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
North Carolina Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Oklahoma Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Phoenix Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Southeastern Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Toronto Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor[1]
|
The Master
|
Won
|
2012
|
Central Ohio Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Detroit Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Houston Film Critics Society for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
National Society of Film Critics Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
San Diego Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor[2]
|
The Master
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Utah Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actor
|
The Master
|
Nominated
|