Module talk:Iraqi insurgency detailed map: Difference between revisions
→Fallujah Clashes done: new section |
→Kirkuk Frontline: new section |
||
Line 59: | Line 59: | ||
Please change the city to black. |
Please change the city to black. |
||
== Kirkuk Frontline == |
|||
The Kirkuk frontline is slightly different from what our Iraqi map currently shows. According to [https://imagopyrenaei.files.wordpress.com/2016/02/kirkuk-frontline.png this map] from renowned mapmaker and source [https://twitter.com/LCarabinier LCarabinier], ISIS holds many towns and villages directly south of Bashir that are marked as Peshmerga-held on [[Module:Iraqi_insurgency_detailed_map|our map]]. His map was [https://twitter.com/LCarabinier/status/700421322850050048 posted nine days ago], so it is fairly new. Perhaps this should be fixed? Specifically, villages such as Bur Ghun, Yurghun, Sutiyah, Safhal, Qaryat as Sakhul, Sayyid Hassun, Tal Hamr, and Mulla Nasr are all marked as ISIS held on LCarabinier's map, but Kurdish held on ours. Also, a Google search will show that the Peshmerga have not gained several towns or launched on offensive near Kirkuk in the past 10 days. So wouldn't the best assumption be that according to this map from a reliable source, ISIS most likely holds these villages? [[Special:Contributions/2601:C7:8301:8D74:1DB4:BFDC:1999:782E|2601:C7:8301:8D74:1DB4:BFDC:1999:782E]] ([[User talk:2601:C7:8301:8D74:1DB4:BFDC:1999:782E|talk]]) 03:17, 28 February 2016 (UTC) |
Revision as of 03:53, 28 February 2016
This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Iraqi insurgency detailed map module. |
|
Archives: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5Auto-archiving period: 30 days ![]() |
Template:Syrian Civil War sanctions
![]() | This module does not require a rating on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Iraqi insurgency detailed map module. |
|
Archives: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5Auto-archiving period: 30 days ![]() |
Baiji
100% Iraqi victory
Please Add Roads to the maps of Irak, syria, etc
Following the news about civil war in Irak and Syria, we hear about important roads and Highwys. But we don't see them on the maps to get better oriented. Please someone add roads and highways also to the maps. Thanks! In Persian: با دنبال کردن خبر ها در باره ی جنگ درونمرزی در عراق و سوریه و .. ما همواره چیزهایی در باره ی راه ها و شاهراه های مهم میخوانیم ولی آنهارا در نقشه پیدا نمیکنیم و نمیتوانیم جا های یاد شده را بهتر بیابیم. پس خواهشمندم که راه ها و شاهراه هارا هم به این نقشه ها بیفزایید. سپاس.
Why Husaybah is red?
I really don't think, that Husaybah on the iraqi-syrian border is in the hands of the government... please put it back to black. In some news, there are reports about some explosions due to the rain in a certain town called Husaybah al-Scharqiyah ("East-Husaybah" - not eastern Husaybah), but it is surely not Husaybah on the border and surely not in possession of government. http://altaghier.tv/2015/10/29/الامطار-تفجر-35-بيتا-ملغما-وعشرات-العبوا
Page date is out of date in Template "Iraqi insurgency detailed map"
It is not clear whether "Page Date" applies to the map itself, but otherwise the map is undated. It is important to know the "as of" of the map. It is best not to have to resort to the Archives to guess at the "official" date. Note: Since the status of all locations cannot be realistically know in "real time," there is obviously some art to picking a date, if date of last entry is not deemed "best." --- Thanks, PNA
Semi-protected edit request on 25 January 2016
![]() | This edit request has been answered. Set the |answered= or |ans= parameter to no to reactivate your request. |
In the map key, it reads: Gota07.svg Oil/gaz Spellcheck gaz -> gas Johnnyboyz25 (talk) 17:44, 25 January 2016 (UTC)
Khalidiyah edit
What is with this edit? Where in this source does it mention Malahameh, Baaran, or Madhiq? None of these places are mentioned at all! Ok, so a road was reopened. Does that automatically mean that all ISIS positions between Ramadi and Fallujah are now under full ISF control? Of course not! That's ridiculous! You should revert your edit immediately, LightandDark2000.
- The source reports that the Khalidiya District has been entirely recaptured. The Khalidiya District includes the Khalidiya Island area, which according to Iraqi sources, encompasses the area between the villages of Albu Nimr and Albu Shajal (which includes all 3 of the villages changed). LightandDark2000 (talk) 07:50, 14 February 2016 (UTC)
Fallujah Clashes done
The clashes in Fallujah city are done, and Daesh controls the city: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/is-the-islamic-state-losing-its-grip-on-fallujah/2016/02/20/c86adda2-7416-4cb8-9be5-4ec5d30d3882_story.html
Please change the city to black.
Kirkuk Frontline
The Kirkuk frontline is slightly different from what our Iraqi map currently shows. According to this map from renowned mapmaker and source LCarabinier, ISIS holds many towns and villages directly south of Bashir that are marked as Peshmerga-held on our map. His map was posted nine days ago, so it is fairly new. Perhaps this should be fixed? Specifically, villages such as Bur Ghun, Yurghun, Sutiyah, Safhal, Qaryat as Sakhul, Sayyid Hassun, Tal Hamr, and Mulla Nasr are all marked as ISIS held on LCarabinier's map, but Kurdish held on ours. Also, a Google search will show that the Peshmerga have not gained several towns or launched on offensive near Kirkuk in the past 10 days. So wouldn't the best assumption be that according to this map from a reliable source, ISIS most likely holds these villages? 2601:C7:8301:8D74:1DB4:BFDC:1999:782E (talk) 03:17, 28 February 2016 (UTC)