Talk:Common grackle: Difference between revisions
Info on removal of name for group of grackles, with history of Wikipedia's various claims |
→No Great-tailed grackle ?: new section |
||
Line 28: | Line 28: | ||
--[[User:Agyle|Agyle]] ([[User talk:Agyle|talk]]) 16:59, 10 June 2018 (UTC) |
--[[User:Agyle|Agyle]] ([[User talk:Agyle|talk]]) 16:59, 10 June 2018 (UTC) |
||
== No Great-tailed grackle ? == |
|||
It's impossible with both google and Wikipedia to find the [[Great-tailed_grackle]] if one does not know that term...or even know there is an "uncommon grackle." (Thank you comment above!) |
|||
They have moved from Mexico to Fresno, center California and beyond, in great flocks. They are easily IDed by their loud jungle-ish call, —nothing else in California like it. |
|||
I think there should be a link. |
Revision as of 01:07, 18 October 2019
{{WikiProject banner shell}}
to this page and add the quality rating to that template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details."G"rackle?
Why is the G capitalized? 209.77.205.2 00:06, 31 July 2007 (UTC)
- There is an agreed convention that bird species are always capitalised on Wikipedia. One capitalisation, referring to the grackles in general was incorrect. Jimfbleak 05:23, 31 July 2007 (UTC)
Reference to Common Grackles in Austin
1) After reviewing images of several subspecies, it is my belief that the grackles in Austin are more likely Great-tailed Grackles, rather than Common Grackles.
2) The link cited as a reference for the Austin nuisance entry is a Time article which is questionable as a scholarly source.
Can anyone confirm the species in question, and shouldn't the final line in the "Common Grackle" section be omitted for bias? —Preceding unsigned comment added by Fraktol (talk • contribs) 10:52, 11 May 2010 (UTC)
Bronzed grackle
In the photo gallery, there is a picture entitled "Bronzed Grackle". Is it a subspecies of the Common Grackle or just another name for the same bird? There's no mention of the Bronzed Grackle whatsoever in the article. --Pablo.ea.92 (talk) 22:03, 4 March 2013 (UTC)
Name for group of grackles
Summary: I'm removing any claim of a species-specific name for a group of grackles.
There was a claim in this article from 2009 to May 2018 that a group of grackles was called a plague, or more recently, that "Grackles tend to congregate in large groups, popularly referred to as a plague or annoyance", with a request for citation since April 2016. Per the original claim, the only evidence I could find for a "plague of grackles" was a user's post in a forum in 2004 musing on how it would be a good name, particularly a "black plague", the discussion of a 2005 blogspot post (http://williambob.blogspot.com/2005/01/murder-of-grackles.html) in which someone quoted Wikipedia as declaring that "A group of grackles is called a plague" (the date of the comment isn't made explicitly clear, but the blog post was from 2005), and a 2010 facebook post by an account named "birdaday" that claimed the same without attribution. I was unable to find the January 2005 quotation in the Wikipedia history of the page in that era, but it did appear as a one-sentence, referenceless, anonymous contribution in 2009, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Common_grackle&diff=323024226&oldid=321675876. The claim was expanded on, and in 2013 Wikipedia editor Cuffsofas added without citation that a group is "popularly referred to as a plague or annoyance." (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Common_grackle&diff=581111393&oldid=576612535). Google turns up several occurences of this Wikipedia claim being directly quoted. In May 2018, an anonymous editor changed the group name "racket", removed the citation request, and cited a single source, https://www.texasmonthly.com/the-daily-post/eight-reasons-grackles-are-awesome/ , which has a single occurrence of the word: "What’s more Texas than a hearty symphony of grackle racket? These birds can sound like everything from a squeaky door hinge to explosions of static from a radio left on at high volume to laughing whistles to monkey-like rattles." I think they were using the term "racket" in the conventional sense, meaning noise, and "grackle racket" is meant as the loud noise they make. There are similar conventional uses of "plague" in reference to groups of grackles, as people might refer to a plague of any species, when a lot of of the species come to an area and wreak havoc. There are also occurrences of people saying they are annoyed by groups of grackles. However, these are not names for a collective group of the species. For grackles, there does not seem to be any accepted species-specific group name.
I'm removing the entire sentence about groupings of grackles, both the name of the group, and how/why they group. If someone has a reliable source on group grackle behavior, restoring information on this would be welcome.
--Agyle (talk) 16:59, 10 June 2018 (UTC)
No Great-tailed grackle ?
It's impossible with both google and Wikipedia to find the Great-tailed_grackle if one does not know that term...or even know there is an "uncommon grackle." (Thank you comment above!)
They have moved from Mexico to Fresno, center California and beyond, in great flocks. They are easily IDed by their loud jungle-ish call, —nothing else in California like it.
I think there should be a link.