Marcionism
Marcionism was a Christian heresy that originated in the teachings of Marcion of Sinope at Rome from AD 144. It rejected the notion that Christianity had Jewish roots. The Marcion sect continued in the West for 300 years, and in the East for some centuries later (especially outside the Byzantine Empire). The historical context, which may partly explain the appeal of a Christianity distinct from Judaism, was the aftermath of the Jewish-Roman wars of 66-73, 115-117 and 132-135.
The premise of Marcionism is that many of the teachings of Jesus are incompatible with the Old Testament. Marcion, according to Tertullian and Epiphanius, using Luke 6:43-45 (a good tree does not produce bad fruit) and Luke 5:36-38 (nobody tears a piece from a new garment to patch an old garment or puts new wine in old wineskins), set about to recover what he considered the authentic teachings of Jesus. The result was probably the first Christian Bible Canon outside of the Septuagint and it consisted of a Gospel [1], which is believed to be an edited version of the canonical Gospel of Luke, and an Apostolicon which are 10 of the Letters of Paul, and Marcion's Antithesis [2] which contrasted the teachings of Jesus with the teachings of the Old Testament.
Henry Wace's commentary on Marcion[3] states:
- "The story proceeds to say that he asked the Roman presbyters to explain the texts, "A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit," and "No man putteth a piece of new cloth unto an old garment," texts from which he himself deduced that works in which evil is to be found could not proceed from the good God, and that the Christian dispensation could have nothing in common with the Jewish. Rejecting the explanation offered him by the presbyters, he broke off the interview with a threat to make a schism in their church."
Because of the rejection of the Old Testament which originates in the Jewish Bible, the Marcionites are believed by some Christians to be anti-Semitic. Indeed, the word Marcionism is sometimes used in modern times to refer to anti-Jewish tendencies in Christian churches, especially when such tendencies are thought to be surviving residues of ancient Marcionism. For example, on its web site, the Tawahedo Church of Ethiopia claims to be the only Christian church that is fully free of Marcionism.
The Marcionites also taught that the tetragrammaton did not represent an all-encompassing God, but rather the Hebrew perception of God which was either imperfect, or reflective of an entirely separate deity. According to the Marcionites, Christ was not the Son of this god, but was sent by Elohim, the name they gave to an all-encompassing and omnibenevolent God. The Marcionites associated the tetragrammaton with the demiurge. In distinguishing this deity from an omnibenevolent God, they took a dualistic stance shared by many religions of the Middle East, including the faith which grew to absorb Marcionism: Manichaeism. Chiefly for these reasons, the Roman Catholic Church and other orthodox churches consider Marcionism to be a heresy.
They arose in the infancy of Christianity and adopted a strong ecclesiastical organization, parallel to that of the Church of Rome. The Catholic Encyclopedia claims that they are considered by the Roman Catholic Church to have been the most dangerous foe Christianity has ever known. This conclusion is understandable in view of the fact the Church of Rome itself discarded some Jewish concepts as Judaizing: (Sabbath, Quartodecimanism) while at the same time keeping other Jewish concepts (Messiah, Old Testament). Marcionism is undergoing a revival, as part of the larger Gnostic revival inspired by the discovery of the texts at Nag Hammadi and popular works by authors such as Elaine Pagels and Dan Brown.
References
- Wace's article on Marcion
- Tertullian "Against Marcion" 1.2 (good tree, good fruit)
- Tertullian "Against Marcion" 4.11.9 (patches, wine, wineskins)
- "Marcionites" by J.P. Arendzen. The Catholic Encylopedia, 1910.