Eric Lerner: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Martinphi (talk | contribs)
12,452 edits
Rv. For one thing, we don't use blogs Wikipedia:BLP#Using_the_subject_as_a_self-published_source. This version is also more informative.
Undid revision 204980465 by Martinphi (talk) rv disruptive wikistalking. Martin is not an editor of this page and is just troll
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Image:Lerner at google.jpg|thumb|right|Lerner at a Google Tech Talks presentation in 2007<ref>http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1518007279479871760&q=Google+tech+talks+lerner&pr=goog-sl</ref>]]'''Eric J. Lerner''' is currently the [[executive director]] of the Focus Fusion Society and president of Lawrenceville Plasma Physics, Inc. in [[West Orange, New Jersey]],<ref>See Personnel listed on the Web site for [http://www.lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/personnel.htm Lawrenceville Plasma Physics, Inc].</ref> which describes itself as a technology research, consulting and communications firm. He is an independent plasma researcher and advocates [[plasma cosmology]],<ref>H. Ratcliffe, "The First Crisis in Cosmology Conference" ([http://www.ptep-online.com/index_files/2005/PP-03-03.PDF PDF]), ''Progress in Physics'' (Oct 2005)</ref> a [[nonstandard cosmology]]. Lerner wrote a popular science book, ''The Big Bang Never Happened'' (1991), which criticized the research and theories regarding the [[Big Bang]] and received unfavorable reviews from professional cosmologists.<ref name=Penzias /><ref name=Davies /><ref name=Stenger />
[[Image:Lerner at google.jpg|thumb|right|Lerner at a Google Tech Talks presentation in 2007<ref>http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1518007279479871760&q=Google+tech+talks+lerner&pr=goog-sl</ref>]]'''Eric J. Lerner''' is currently the [[executive director]] of the Focus Fusion Society and president of Lawrenceville Plasma Physics, Inc. in [[West Orange, New Jersey]],<ref>See Personnel listed on the Web site for [http://www.lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/personnel.htm Lawrenceville Plasma Physics, Inc].</ref> which describes itself as a technology research, consulting and communications firm. He is an independent plasma researcher and advocates [[plasma cosmology]],<ref>H. Ratcliffe, "The First Crisis in Cosmology Conference" ([http://www.ptep-online.com/index_files/2005/PP-03-03.PDF PDF]), ''Progress in Physics'' (Oct 2005)</ref> a [[nonstandard cosmology]]. Lerner wrote a popular science book, ''The Big Bang Never Happened'' (1991), which criticized the research and theories regarding the [[Big Bang]] and received unfavorable reviews from professional cosmologists.<ref name=Wright /><ref name=Penzias /><ref name=Davies /><ref name=Stenger />
==Personal history==
==Personal history==
Lerner was born in 1947 in [[Brookline, Massachusetts]]. He received a [[Bachelor of Arts|BA]] in [[physics]] from [[Columbia University]]<ref>Columbia Alumni Directory, 1988 edition, p.211.</ref> and did graduate work in physics at the [[University of Maryland, College Park]] without completing a degree.<ref>Biography at the [http://thespaceshow.com/guest.asp?q=342 Space Show]</ref> He has studied cosmic [[plasma (physics)|plasma]] [[phenomena]] and laboratory fusion devices, especially the [[dense plasma focus]], and is the author of a popular account of [[plasma cosmology]], ''The Big Bang Never Happened'' (1991).
Lerner was born in 1947 in [[Brookline, Massachusetts]]. He received a [[Bachelor of Arts|BA]] in [[physics]] from [[Columbia University]]<ref>Columbia Alumni Directory, 1988 edition, p.211.</ref> and did graduate work in physics at the [[University of Maryland, College Park]] without completing a degree.<ref>Biography at the [http://thespaceshow.com/guest.asp?q=342 Space Show]</ref> He has studied cosmic [[plasma (physics)|plasma]] [[phenomena]] and laboratory fusion devices, especially the [[dense plasma focus]], and is the author of a popular account of [[plasma cosmology]], ''The Big Bang Never Happened'' (1991).
Line 11: Line 11:
Lerner is also a prolific general science writer, who estimates about 600 articles published, has received several journalism awards from the Aviation Space Writers Association from 1984 to 1993,<ref>Lerner estimates he has had about 600 articles published, in article such as ''Discover'',[http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1511/is_n8_v16/ai_17253896] and ''Industrial Physicist''.[http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_q=&num=50&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=eric+lerner&as_publication=Industrial+Physicist&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en&lr=&safe=off]</ref>
Lerner is also a prolific general science writer, who estimates about 600 articles published, has received several journalism awards from the Aviation Space Writers Association from 1984 to 1993,<ref>Lerner estimates he has had about 600 articles published, in article such as ''Discover'',[http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1511/is_n8_v16/ai_17253896] and ''Industrial Physicist''.[http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_q=&num=50&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=eric+lerner&as_publication=Industrial+Physicist&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en&lr=&safe=off]</ref>


==Publication and Reception of ''The Big Bang Never Happened''==
==Reception of ''The Big Bang Never Happened''==
[[Image:big-bang-never-happened.jpg|thumb|upright|right|Lerner's 1991 book, ''The Big Bang Never Happened'']]
[[Image:big-bang-never-happened.jpg|thumb|upright|right|Lerner's 1991 book, ''The Big Bang Never Happened'']]
Lerner received some notoriety with the publishing of his popular-level book in 1991, which disputed [[Big Bang]] cosmology. In this work, Lerner claims that the Big Bang theory is inconsistent with empirical data<ref>Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", page 12</ref><ref>Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", page 13</ref></blockquote> and asserts that [[plasma cosmology]] provides a model of the universe more consistent with observable physical laws than the Big Bang:<blockquote>The phenomena that the Big Bang seeks to explain with a mysterious ancient catacylsm, plasma theories attribute to electrical and magnetic processes occurring in the universe today.<ref>Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", page 14</ref></blockquote>He proposes a model of [[thermodynamics]] which he attributes in part to the work of [[Ilya Prigogine]] under which the universe has no definite age<ref>Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", footnote on page 388</ref> and continually increases in order.<ref>Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", pages 286-316</ref>
Lerner received some notoriety with the publishing of his popular-level book in 1991, which disputed Big Bang cosmology. In this work, Lerner asserts that:<blockquote>The phenomena that the Big Bang seeks to explain with a mysterious ancient catacylsm, plasma theories attribute to electrical and magnetic processes occurring in the universe today.<ref>Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", page 14</ref></blockquote>He states that his major problem with the Big Bang is that "enormous ribbons of matter... refute a basic premise of the Big Bang."<ref>Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", page 13</ref></blockquote>


[[James Van Allen]], a [[space scientist]] who discovered the Earth's [[Van Allen belts]], provided the following review:
[[James Van Allen]], a [[space scientist]] who discovered the Earth's [[Van Allen belts]], provided the following review:
:"Eric J. Lerner gives both a provocative critique of the Big Bang and a stimulating account of the insightful and creative, although controversial, cosmology of Nobel Laureate [[Hannes Alfven]]."<ref>Included on the back cover of the hardback edition of ''The Big Bang Never Happened''</ref>
:"Eric J. Lerner gives both a provocative critique of the Big Bang and a stimulating account of the insightful and creative, although controversial, cosmology of Nobel Laureate [[Hannes Alfven]]."<ref>Included on the back cover of the hardback edition of ''The Big Bang Never Happened''</ref>


In general Lerner's ideas have not been acknowledged or adopted by cosmologists or astronomers. The response of professional cosmologists to Lerner's ideas has been negative; [[Paul Davies]] reviewed his book for the [[New York Times]] and panned it. The newspaper published a rebuttal by Lerner <ref name=Penzias>[http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9D0CE5DD1F39F93BA25755C0A967958260 Letter to the Editor June 18, 1991]</ref> which was itself criticized by [[Arno A. Penzias]], winner of the 1978 [[Nobel Prize for Physics]]:
In general Lerner's ideas have not been acknowledged or adopted by cosmologists or astronomers. The response of professional cosmologists to Lerner's ideas has been negative; [[Paul Davies]] reviewed his book for the [[New York Times]] and panned it. The newspaper published a rebuttal by Lerner <ref>http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9D0CEFD8123CF932A3575AC0A967958260</ref> which was itself criticized by [[Arno A. Penzias]], winner of the 1978 [[Nobel Prize for Physics]]:
:"The sizes of the vast ribbons of galaxies that Eric J. Lerner refers to come straight out of the Big Bang model itself.... Contrary to Mr. Lerner's claim, therefore, the 'simple mathematics' he cites rests upon, rather than contradicts the Big Bang model."<ref name=Penzias>[http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9D0CE5DD1F39F93BA25755C0A967958260 Letter to the Editor June 18, 1991]</ref>
:"The sizes of the vast ribbons of galaxies that Eric J. Lerner refers to come straight out of the Big Bang model itself.... Contrary to Mr. Lerner's claim, therefore, the 'simple mathematics' he cites rests upon, rather than contradicts the Big Bang model."<ref name=Penzias>[http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9D0CE5DD1F39F93BA25755C0A967958260 Letter to the Editor June 18, 1991]</ref>
Subsequent to this, Davies himself responded to Lerner's criticism of his review:
Subsequent to this, Davies himself responded to Lerner's criticism of his review:
Line 26: Line 26:


:Lerner uses the kinds of arguments one often hears in public discourse on science, but rarely among professional scientists themselves. For example, he argues that plasma cosmology is in closer agreement with everyday observation than Big Bang cosmology, and hence is the more sensible. A look through a telescope reveals spirals and other structures similar to those observed in the plasma laboratory, and as cosmologist [[Edward Kolb|Rocky Kolb]] has remarked, in your bathroom toilet as well. Following Lerner's line of reasoning, we would conclude, as people once did, that the earth is flat, that the sun goes around the earth, and that species are immutable."<ref name=Stenger>{{cite journal | first = Victor J. | last = Stenger | title = Is the Big Bang a Bust? | url = http://www.colorado.edu/philosophy/vstenger/Cosmo/bang.txt | journal = [[Skeptical Inquirer]] | volume = 16 | issue = 412 | date = Summer 1992 }}</ref>
:Lerner uses the kinds of arguments one often hears in public discourse on science, but rarely among professional scientists themselves. For example, he argues that plasma cosmology is in closer agreement with everyday observation than Big Bang cosmology, and hence is the more sensible. A look through a telescope reveals spirals and other structures similar to those observed in the plasma laboratory, and as cosmologist [[Edward Kolb|Rocky Kolb]] has remarked, in your bathroom toilet as well. Following Lerner's line of reasoning, we would conclude, as people once did, that the earth is flat, that the sun goes around the earth, and that species are immutable."<ref name=Stenger>{{cite journal | first = Victor J. | last = Stenger | title = Is the Big Bang a Bust? | url = http://www.colorado.edu/philosophy/vstenger/Cosmo/bang.txt | journal = [[Skeptical Inquirer]] | volume = 16 | issue = 412 | date = Summer 1992 }}</ref>

Professor E. L. Wright of UCLA says that there are several errors of fact in the book,<ref name=Wright>Wright, E. L. "''[http://www.astro.ucla.edu/~wright/lerner_errors.html Errors in "The Big Bang Never Happened"]</ref> and [[Sean M. Carroll]] has also written a critique of advocacy like Eric Lerner's.<ref name=Carroll>[[Sean M. Carroll|Sean Carroll]] offers a direct critique of these alternatives on his blog ''Preposterous Universe'' http://preposterousuniverse.blogspot.com/2004/05/doubt-and-dissent-are-not-tolerated.html</ref>


==References==
==References==

Revision as of 19:32, 11 April 2008

File:Lerner at google.jpg
Lerner at a Google Tech Talks presentation in 2007[1]

Eric J. Lerner is currently the executive director of the Focus Fusion Society and president of Lawrenceville Plasma Physics, Inc. in West Orange, New Jersey,[2] which describes itself as a technology research, consulting and communications firm. He is an independent plasma researcher and advocates plasma cosmology,[3] a nonstandard cosmology. Lerner wrote a popular science book, The Big Bang Never Happened (1991), which criticized the research and theories regarding the Big Bang and received unfavorable reviews from professional cosmologists.[4][5][6][7]

Personal history

Lerner was born in 1947 in Brookline, Massachusetts. He received a BA in physics from Columbia University[8] and did graduate work in physics at the University of Maryland, College Park without completing a degree.[9] He has studied cosmic plasma phenomena and laboratory fusion devices, especially the dense plasma focus, and is the author of a popular account of plasma cosmology, The Big Bang Never Happened (1991).

Professional activities

Lerner is a critic of the Big Bang theory and advocates an infinitely old Universe. In 2006 he accepted an invitation to be a Visiting Astronomer at the European Southern Observatory in Chile, offered at the initiative of fellow Big Bang critic and MOND enthusiast Riccardo Scarpa.[10]

Lerner has done experimental work on the dense plasma focus funded by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in collaboration with the University of Illinois in 1994,[11] and with Texas A&M University in 2001.[12] In addition, he believes he has demonstrated that the production of useful energy from aneutronic fusion can be made more feasible.[13]

Lerner is also a prolific general science writer, who estimates about 600 articles published, has received several journalism awards from the Aviation Space Writers Association from 1984 to 1993,[14]

Reception of The Big Bang Never Happened

File:Big-bang-never-happened.jpg
Lerner's 1991 book, The Big Bang Never Happened

Lerner received some notoriety with the publishing of his popular-level book in 1991, which disputed Big Bang cosmology. In this work, Lerner asserts that:

The phenomena that the Big Bang seeks to explain with a mysterious ancient catacylsm, plasma theories attribute to electrical and magnetic processes occurring in the universe today.[15]

He states that his major problem with the Big Bang is that "enormous ribbons of matter... refute a basic premise of the Big Bang."[16]

James Van Allen, a space scientist who discovered the Earth's Van Allen belts, provided the following review:

"Eric J. Lerner gives both a provocative critique of the Big Bang and a stimulating account of the insightful and creative, although controversial, cosmology of Nobel Laureate Hannes Alfven."[17]

In general Lerner's ideas have not been acknowledged or adopted by cosmologists or astronomers. The response of professional cosmologists to Lerner's ideas has been negative; Paul Davies reviewed his book for the New York Times and panned it. The newspaper published a rebuttal by Lerner [18] which was itself criticized by Arno A. Penzias, winner of the 1978 Nobel Prize for Physics:

"The sizes of the vast ribbons of galaxies that Eric J. Lerner refers to come straight out of the Big Bang model itself.... Contrary to Mr. Lerner's claim, therefore, the 'simple mathematics' he cites rests upon, rather than contradicts the Big Bang model."[5]

Subsequent to this, Davies himself responded to Lerner's criticism of his review:

'"It seems to me that the theory proposed by Mr. Lerner has serious problems in relation to thermodynamics. This is merely my professional opinion, for what it is worth. Others can judge for themselves.... I accept that Mr. Lerner's book reports work that is largely due to Hannes Alfven, but this does not render it immune from criticism."[6]

Victor J. Stenger, Professor Emeritus of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Hawaii, criticized Lerner's book in a 1992 edition of the popular magazine, Skeptical Inquirer. He stated that, "The big bang may be wrong, but Lerner can't seriously expect to prove it in a popular book." He also wrote:

Lerner uses the kinds of arguments one often hears in public discourse on science, but rarely among professional scientists themselves. For example, he argues that plasma cosmology is in closer agreement with everyday observation than Big Bang cosmology, and hence is the more sensible. A look through a telescope reveals spirals and other structures similar to those observed in the plasma laboratory, and as cosmologist Rocky Kolb has remarked, in your bathroom toilet as well. Following Lerner's line of reasoning, we would conclude, as people once did, that the earth is flat, that the sun goes around the earth, and that species are immutable."[7]

Professor E. L. Wright of UCLA says that there are several errors of fact in the book,[4] and Sean M. Carroll has also written a critique of advocacy like Eric Lerner's.[19]

References

  1. ^ http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1518007279479871760&q=Google+tech+talks+lerner&pr=goog-sl
  2. ^ See Personnel listed on the Web site for Lawrenceville Plasma Physics, Inc.
  3. ^ H. Ratcliffe, "The First Crisis in Cosmology Conference" (PDF), Progress in Physics (Oct 2005)
  4. ^ a b Wright, E. L. "Errors in "The Big Bang Never Happened"
  5. ^ a b Letter to the Editor June 18, 1991
  6. ^ a b New York Times (Late Edition (East Coast)). New York, N.Y.: Sep 1, 1991. p. A.4
  7. ^ a b Stenger, Victor J. (Summer 1992). "Is the Big Bang a Bust?". Skeptical Inquirer. 16 (412).
  8. ^ Columbia Alumni Directory, 1988 edition, p.211.
  9. ^ Biography at the Space Show
  10. ^ [1] Retrieved November 10, 2006.
  11. ^ JPL Contract 959962
  12. ^ JPL Contract 960283
  13. ^ Prospects for P11B Fusion with the Dense Plasma Focus: New Results Invited presentation, 5th Symposium "Current Trends in International Fusion Research: A Review" March 24-28, 2003, Washington, D.C. Arxiv
  14. ^ Lerner estimates he has had about 600 articles published, in article such as Discover,[2] and Industrial Physicist.[3]
  15. ^ Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", page 14
  16. ^ Eric Lerner, "The Big Bang Never Happened", page 13
  17. ^ Included on the back cover of the hardback edition of The Big Bang Never Happened
  18. ^ http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9D0CEFD8123CF932A3575AC0A967958260
  19. ^ Sean Carroll offers a direct critique of these alternatives on his blog Preposterous Universe http://preposterousuniverse.blogspot.com/2004/05/doubt-and-dissent-are-not-tolerated.html

External links and references

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Eric_Lerner&oldid=204982502"