Talk:Jewish Bolshevism

NEEDS edited badly

Upon reading this page it is not and article nor educational but is uninformative and even propaganda. I'm both German and Jewish and facts and knowledge speak for themselves. This piece states some articles as propaganda and states others as fact, over and over any cited articles of one opinion is stated as propaganda and the opposite as fact-THIS IS NOT JOURNALISM NOR EDUCATIONAL, simply state all printed materials as written and let readers decide for themselves what is true. Was Bolshevism Jewish in part or totally or not at all? truth is for readers not writers to determine which can not happen with such and opinionated writing. On a moral and a knowledge basis we can easily understand their are good, bad, confused and grey actions of all races, religions and peoples and to say any is purely right or wrong or to instantly assume one is correct or another is above crimes, evil and moral indecency is of total abandonment of wisdom itself. while antisemitic ideas are a serious problem, so to is semitic deifying where any information involving semitic people in a negative roll or behavior is automatically cast as wrong. As a Jew and a human I can factually tell you-some jews are criminals, some are evil minded and some do bad things as is true with all peoples of earth-ACCEPT it. I am not here for all that though, I am here simply to state-rewrite this article and keeping all cited material but drop any opinion of it as propaganda or fact and rewrite any portion that puts forth the writers ideas and feeling to be factual and not emotional.Thank you for your time -JR. Reider — Preceding unsigned comment added by Ox1111 (talk • contribs) 08:55, 11 January 2020 (UTC)

Propose WP:MERGE with Zydokomuna

No justifications for two separate articles, it appears Zydokomuna is simply the antisemitic Polish term for Jewish Bolshevism. After all, Zydokomuna is even mentioned in the lede here. A merge would actually cause readers of both articles to be given more information, and the subject would be treated more comprehensively. It would also be in keeping with WP:NPOV / neutral world view, rather than having an article on Polish inside baseball. If editors here agree, let's make the change. -Chumchum7 (talk) 06:47, 2 April 2020 (UTC)

Separate articles are justified per Wikipedia:Splitting: If "a section of an article has a length that is out of proportion to the rest of the article." If the two articles were merged, it would mostly be about the Jewish Bolshevism conspiracy theory in Poland, while it was equally or more significant in Russia, Germany and other countries. If Zydokomuna were a stub article, i.e., just one or two paragraphs, I would agree, but it's lengthy. TFD (talk) 14:55, 2 April 2020 (UTC)