1988 America's Cup
|Defender United States|
|Defender club:||San Diego Yacht Club|
|Yacht:||Stars & Stripes H3|
|Challenger New Zealand|
|Challenger club:||Mercury Bay Boating Club|
|Location:||San Diego, United States|
|Dates:||September 7, 1988
September 9, 1988
|Rule:||Deed of Gift|
|Winner:||San Diego Yacht Club|
The 1988 America's Cup was the 27th America's Cup regatta, and was contested between the defender, San Diego Yacht Club represented by Stars & Stripes H3, and the challenger, the Mercury Bay Boating Club represented by New Zealand Challenge's KZ-1. Run under strict Deed of Gift rules, the regatta was won by the San Diego Yacht club, two races to none.
Challenge and response
The 1988 America's Cup was the first hostile Deed of Gift challenge. Dennis Conner had won the America's Cup for the San Diego Yacht Club on 4 February 1987 at the 1987 America's Cup. In July, New Zealand banker Michael Fay went to the San Diego Yacht Club and issued a Notice of Challenge from the Mercury Bay Boating Club of New Zealand, which was based on a strict reading of the Deed of Gift. The Fay challenge stipulated that the boats to be sailed would be defined only by the details of the Deed, namely single masted yachts no more than 90 feet (27 m) at the waterline and that the race would be held the following year in 1988. He proposed to bring a 90-foot racing yacht for his challenge boat.
The San Diego Yacht Club, who wanted to continue running the Cup regatta in 12-metre class yachts, initially rejected Fay's challenge out of hand. Fay then took the dispute to the New York State Supreme Court, which on 25 November 1987 declared the challenge valid and instructed the San Diego Yacht Club to meet the challenge on the water, brushing aside the twenty-one 12 Meter syndicates that had declared their intention of racing in a 1991 America's Cup regatta.
The unconventional challenge was met with an unconventional response. As the challenge used the original Deed of Gift as its basis, there were no explicit class or design requirements other than that the boat was to be 90 feet (27 m) or less at the waterline if it had one mast. Thus the San Diego Yacht Club and the Sail America Foundation chose the assuredly faster multi-hull design.
On 5 May 1988 the Cup returned to the courts with Michael Fay seeking a court ruling that the catamaran was an invalid defender. The court instead ruled that the cup should be contested on the water, and any further legal action should be delayed until after the race.
The New Zealand challenger was KZ-1, a 90-foot (27 m) monohull with a crew of 30 to 40. The boat was launched in March 1988 and regarded as the fastest monohull at that time for its size. She now resides outside the National Maritime Museum in downtown Auckland, New Zealand.
The San Diego Yacht Club responded by building two catamarans, one with a conventional soft sail (Stars & Stripes S1), and the second with a Scaled Composites -built wing mast (Stars & Stripes H3). The wing-masted boat demonstrated superior performance, and after being modified to improve its structural integrity was chosen for the successful defense.
|September 7, 1988||40 miles, windward leewarda||Stars & Stripes USA-1||KZ-1||4:53:54||18:15||1-0||8.2||Wind 7 to 9 knots|
|September 9, 1988||39 miles, triangularb||Stars & Stripes USA-1||KZ-1||3:27:37||21:10||2-0||11.3||Wind 6 to 15 knots|
^b Thirteen nautical miles per leg; first leg upwind.
After the completion of the races the battle returned to the courts and on 28 March 1989 the cup was awarded to New Zealand on the basis that the competition between a monohull and a catamaran was a gross mismatch and not in the spirit of friendly competition between countries. However the Appellate Division reversed that ruling, saying the Deed of Gift does not limit design or say anything about the number of hulls a yacht may have, and the reversal was confirmed on 26 April 1990 by the New York Court of Appeals. Thus San Diego retained the cup, defending it again at the 1992 America's Cup.
The 2010 America's Cup shared some similarities with the 1988 Cup in that it was also the subject of intense litigation, and the precedent set by the 1988 court decision guaranteed that any non-mutual consent match would be sailed in the fastest boats legal under the Deed: multihulls. The buildup to the 2010 America's Cup was slightly different though, in that a challenge had already been accepted by defending yacht club Société Nautique de Genève, but the courts decided that the challenger did not meet the requirements of the Deed of Gift governing the cup and forced the defender to accept a challenge from the Golden Gate Yacht Club instead.
- "1988 - Stars & Stripes US-1 Catamaran". Archived from the original on 2009-05-08. Retrieved 2009-04-11.
- Gabriel, Trip (29 May 1988). "War at Sea". New York Times Magazine: 5.
- "1988 - KZ 1". Retrieved 2012-04-26.
- Lloyd, Barbara (8 September 1988). "America's Cup; Round 1 to Stars & Stripes". New York Times. New York City. Retrieved March 9, 2010.
- "The Mercury Bay Boating Club Inc., Appellant, v. San Diego Yacht Club, Respondent, et al., Defendant, New York Yacht Club, Intervenor. / (and Another Procedding.)". Retrieved 2012-04-26.