Andrew Jackson Bryant
Andrew Jackson Bryant, known as A.J. Bryant, (1823–1888) was the seventeenth mayor of San Francisco, California, serving from December 1875 to December 1879 during a lengthy economic depression that struck San Francisco and the rest of the country. Bryant was a strong advocate for an eight-hour work day as well as legislation to halt the immigration of Chinese laborers into the state. A prominent insurance man and a sportsman, he drowned in the San Francisco Bay after falling from a ferryboat.
- 1 Biography
- 2 Political career
- 3 Post-mayoralty
- 4 Quotations
- 5 Notes
- 6 For Further Reading
- 7 References
- 8 Further reading
- 9 External links
Youth and early life
As per his obituary, Bryant was born in Effingham, New Hampshire on October 30, 1831. As a young man, he sailed around the tip of South America to San Francisco, where he arrived in 1850 and went directly to the Gold Country of California. After a "year's hard work," however, he returned to San Francisco "for medical treatment," and then went to Benicia, California, where in 1854–55 was the city marshal and in 1856 he was a deputy sheriff.:95:139, 140, 162, 170
In 1856 the California Legislature met in Benicia, and when it disbanded, Bryant moved to Sacramento, the new state capital, where he opened a general merchandising business with George W. Chesley and George L. Bradley, which lasted four years. He then "sold out, going into the wholesale liquor business" with a Mr. Morrison." He moved back to San Francisco and worked in such enterprises as an insurance agency and an express business.:95
Bryant was married twice, having six children by his first wife, his oldest daughter later becoming the wife of Mayor William Russell Grace of New York City. His second marriage was in 1870. In 1877 another daughter, Mary J., married George Avery.
In San Francisco he became active in the Democratic Party, and in 1866 President Andrew Johnson commissioned him a naval officer "with all the honors and benefits to be derived therefrom." William Heintz, his biographer, said that Bryant "kept this position until 1870 without ever sailing beyond the Golden Gate.":95–96
In 1871 Bryant was a member of the Finance Committee of the State Investment Insurance Company. He continued his career in insurance while he was serving as mayor of San Francisco (below), and since 1882 he was president of the California Electric Lighting Company. He was known as a "prominent figure in insurance circles."
Although Bryant was a Democrat, during the Civil War in the United States, he aligned with the Republican Party, and in 1871 he helped organize and was presiding officer of the [David C.] Broderick Union Republican Club of the State of California, named in honor of the California State Senator who was killed in a duel with California Chief Justice David S. Terry. The founding resolution noted that Broderick had sought to form an organization "whose main principle was opposition to the extension of slavery."
The next year, 1872, Bryant was active in beginning a California branch of the Liberal Republican movement, or Central Greeley Club, that would support Horace Greeley for president instead of Ulysses S. Grant.
He was president of the Occidental Lodge, Free and Accepted Masons, and was a trustee of Mills College in Oakland. In 1875, he helped organize the Underwriters' Fire Patrol of San Francisco, whose object was "to discover and prevent fires and save property from conflagration."
New York City
As mayor-elect, Bryant traveled to New York City in 1875, where he was received by public officials, inspected the Brooklyn Police Headquarters and was entertained with a dinner at the Windsor Hotel in Manhattan. He attended a meeting of the New York City Board of Aldermen, where he was seated beside President Samuel A. Lewis of the board.
Bryant died on May 11, 1888, after he fell off a ferryboat in the San Francisco Bay, bound for Oakland. At first it was thought that the former mayor might have committed suicide, and three full columns in the San Francisco Chronicle were devoted to that theory:
The first conjecture was that the manner of the tragic death of the well-known citizen was the evidence of suicide. Subsequent developments only helped strengthen the opinion and remove all doubt that the untimely termination of the ex-Mayor's career was the act of a desperate man, goaded by financial and physical troubles.
The New York Times reported that:
A.J. Bryant, ex-Mayor of San Francisco, committed suicide this morning by jumping from the ferry steamer Encinal just after the boat had started on the 9:15 trip to Oakland. Mr. Bryant was very nervous and trembling when he bought his ticket, and the gate-keeper appears to be the last man who talked with him.
A coroner's jury, however, ruled on May 15, 1888, that the death was accidental, a decision based primarily on the testimony of "the boy Joseph Leikena," who said:
When the boat was three or four blocks out from the wharf, I saw a man walking up and down on the upper deck. He was the only person I saw there. He walked close to the railing, staggered and fell overboard, and when he struck the water he struggled as though trying to swim. He went over the side of the vessel at the stern and did not jump overboard.
Bryant's support for an eight-hour working day and his calling for legislation to halt the "influx" of Chinese laborers to California attracted the attention of Democratic leaders, and he secured the nomination for San Francisco mayor in 1875.:96
Some attacked him as being opposed to "Democracy," as the Democratic Party was sometimes called in those days. One newspaper responded: "The charge that he is unorthodox in his Democracy is absurd. . . . If . . . he cooperated with the Republican Party, he only did what hundreds of thousands of Democrats did; which if they had not done, the Union would have been destroyed." It added: "He will break up that devilish den of Chinese that now corrupt and poison the very heart of San Francisco.":98
He was elected to a two-year term mayor of San Francisco in September 1875 to replace James Otis. The votes were 9,792 for Bryant; 9,486 for Charles Clayton, former county supervisor; and 4.106 for Andrew Hallidie, the builder of San Francisco's first cable car.:98 He was reelected in 1877, over his opponent, Monroe Ashbury.
In his first message to the Board of Supervisors in 1875, Bryant stated:
The Chinese dens are a disgrace to our city. I recommend that one of our vacant squares or lots in the outskirts of the city be appropriated, and that a cheap, rough building be erected of two wards, one for women and the other for men, designed expressly for this class. . . . have them fed while in prison upon the same character of cheap food to which they have become accustomed, and made to work upon our public squares. . . . In one year the dens of gambling and lewdness that now offend decency on our public streets will be driven out of sight, [and] our jails will be relieved of these pests. . . .
In May 1876 he announced he had appointed a committee of three men to travel to Washington to "lay the Chinese question before Congress." The next month he moved at a meeting of the Police Commission that all Chinese special police officers be dismissed because they "were doing nothing in the way of preventing crime."
In the same message he noted that "punishing petty criminals by long terms of imprisonment seems to punish only the tax-payer with their support" and that "shorter terms of imprisonment, with severer punishment while under control, are required," such as "work in the chain-gang, solitary confinement and stricter discipline."
He called it a "gross injustice to send children of tender years" to the city's Industrial School "who, guiltless of crime, but for the misfortune of being orphans or having worthless parents. are there confined and treated as criminals, forced to associate with depravity, and when released [are] sent forth penniless and branded with a badge of disgrace." He urged establishment of separate "wards" for these children.
In running for mayor, Bryant "emphatically condemned the purchase of the Spring Valley Water Company by the city, declaring it not worth half the price being asked." After he was sworn into office, he appointed two supervisors to work with the company in setting the rates.:96
In the depths of the Long Depression of 1873–79, by June 1877 an estimated thirty thousand San Franciscans were unemployed, and workers' camps sprang up on the sandlots south of the new City Hall at Macallister and Larkin streets. Bryant and others "went so far as to lay the blame for the depression directly on Chinatown's doorstep." Mobs threatened the peace of the city, and on July 26, Bryant was compelled to call upon the Army and upon organized gangs of vigilantes to help restore order.:102, 103
Bryant's response was called a "debacle" in that he "refused to use city government to do anything to ameliorate economic conditions, citing both lack of authority and lack of money," But he and the supervisors "cooperated to suppress the workingmen's protests and their party," the Workingman's Party of California.
In 1878, Bryant called together and was elected chairman of a relief committee designed to accept and forward donations to Southern United States communities that were then in the grip of a yellow fever epidemic.
Bryant was caught up in a scandal over the widening of Dupont Street in Chinatown when it was claimed that he had bought property along the street for which he would have been recompensed as a result of the widening. An April 1879 lawsuit by W.M. Lent, C.F. Fargo and others claimed that Bryant "was not a disinterested Commissioner in the matter . . . but was, in fact, acting in all said matters as a judge in his own case."
The famous detective Harry N. Morse investigated the Dupont Street frauds and exposed Bryant's corruption, as detailed in John Boessenecker's book Lawman: The Life and Times of Harry Morse.
Ulysses S. Grant
The mayor hosted former President Ulysses S. Grant when the general made a lengthy visit to California after his around-the world trip in 1879. Grant went for a ride in Golden Gate Park with Bryant in September and dined at his house in October.
Bryant was the defendant in a July 1885 criminal complaint filed by G.W. O'Donnell, the son of Coroner C.C. O'Donnell, in which the younger O'Donnell claimed he had heard Bryant threaten the life of the coroner. Bryant testified he passed near the morgue and "happened to see the body of a woman partially uncovered and exposed to the gaze of the passers-by" and exclaimed, "Anybody who would run a morgue that way ought to have every bone in his body broken, and I will break them for him." A judge found Bryant innocent of the charge.
Bryant was chairman of a committee charged with erecting a monument to General Grant in Golden Gate Park.
He was also chairman of an 1887 committee "to make preparations for an extensive and proper exhibit of interior products at the fair to be given this fall by the Mechanics' Institute." Other officers were W.T. Garrett, vice president, and William T. Stout, secretary.
- "The common schools ought to be judiciously limited in their method so as to secure the most general diffusion of useful knowledge; all attempts to restrict or divert their operation for sectarian or sectional ends should be sternly and promptly repressed."
- "Persons residing outside of the city and county, and even men who no longer live in this world, no doubt vote at elections here . . . ."
For Further Reading
Lawman: The Life and Times of Harry Morse (1998) by John Boessenecker.
Access to the San Francisco Chronicle links may require the use of a library card.
- "A Fatal Plunge: Life of the Deceased," San Francisco Chronicle, May 12, 1888, page 8
- William F. Heintz, San Francisco's Mayors, Gilbert Richards Publications (1975), 120 pp
- J. P. Munro-Fraser, History of Solano County...and histories of its cities, towns...etc. ... Wood-Alley & Co. (1879), 503 pages
- Nathan Crosby, A Crosby Family. Stone, Huse & Company, (1877) 143 pages
- "State Investment Insurance Company," San Francisco Chronicle, November 4, 1871, page 3
- Gerald Taylor White, Formative Years in the Far West: A History of Standard Oil Company of California and Predecessors Through 1919 Appleton-Century-Crofts (1962), page 38
- "Broderick Republican Club," San Francisco Chronicle, July 20, 1871, page 3
- "The Greeley Movement," San Francisco Chronicle, May 24, 1872, page 3
- "The Great International Running Race" (classified advertisement), San Francisco Chronicle, November 8, 1873, page 4
- "Interesting Miscellaneous Items," San Francisco Chronicle, November 16, 1873, page 1
- "By Telegraph," Arizona Weekly Miner, November 19, 1875, image 2
- "Oakland News," San Francisco Chronicle, May 14, 1888, page 3
- "Latest Telegrams," Los Angeles Daily Herald, November 27, 1875, image 2
- "Col. Charles Sonntag Dies," The National Humane Review, January 1918, page 9
- "A Distinguished Visitor," Los Angeles Daily Herald," October 7, 1865, image 2
- "New York News," Los Angeles Daily Herald, October 8, 1875, image 2
- "A Fatal Plunge," May 12, 1888, page 8
- "An Ex-Mayor'S Suicide: The Unhappy End Of One Of San Francisco'S Old Citizens," May 12, 1888
- "Natural Causes," San Francisco Chronicle, May 16, 1888, page 5
- "A.J. Bryant the Democratic Nominee for Mayor of San Francisco," Los Angeles Daily Herald, August 14, 1875, image 2
- "The Governorship," Daily Journal of Commerce, August 24, 1886, quoted in Overland Monthly, September 1886, page 23
- "The Mayor's Message," San Francisco Chronicle, December 7, 1875, page 3
- "Latest Telegrams," Los Angeles Daily Herald, May 10, 1876, image 2
- "Late Telegrams," Los Angeles Daily Herald, June 4, 1876, image 1
- Terrence J. McDonald, The Parameters of Urban Fiscal Policy:Socioeconomic Change and Political Culture in San Francisco, 1860-1906, University of California Press (1986), page 93
- "The Suffering South," San Francisco Chronicle, August 30, 1878, page 1
- "Meeting in Aid of the South," Los Angeles Daily Herald, August 30, 1878, image 2
- "Another Expose," San Francisco Chronicle, April 6, 1879, page 8
- See more at Heintz, page 107.
- "Movements of General Grant," Los Angeles Daily Herald, September 23, 1879, image 2
- "San Francisco Items," Los Angeles Daily Herald, October 26, 1879, image 1
- "A Sensation Spoiled," San Francisco Chronicle, July 17, 1885, page 2
- "The Grant Monument," San Francisco Chronicle, August 28, 1885, page 3
- "The Mechanics' Fair," San Francisco Chronicle, June 1, 1887, page 6
- "Non-Sectarian Schools," San Francisco Chronicle, December 8, 1875, page 2
- "Election Frauds," December 9, 1877, page 4
-  John Shertzer Hittel, A History of San Francisco (1878) 498 pages
-  Proclamation by Mayor Bryant forbidding unlawful assemblies, January 17, 1878, in Los Angeles Daily Herald.