Artificial turf
Artificial turf is a surface of synthetic fibers made to look like natural grass. It is most often used in arenas for sports that were originally or are normally played on grass. However, it is now being used on residential lawns and commercial applications as well. The main reason is maintenance—artificial turf stands up to heavy use, such as in sports, and requires no irrigation or trimming. Domed, covered, and partially covered stadiums may require artificial turf because of the difficulty of getting grass enough sunlight to stay healthy. But artificial turf does have its downside: limited life, periodic cleaning requirements, petroleum use, toxic chemicals from infill, and heightened health and safety concerns.
Artificial turf first gained substantial attention in the 1960s, when it was used in the newly constructed Astrodome. The specific product used was developed by Monsanto and called AstroTurf; this term since then became a colloquialism for any artificial turf throughout the late 20th century. AstroTurf remains a registered trademark, but is no longer owned by Monsanto. The first generation turf systems (i.e., short-pile fibers without infill) of the 1960s have been largely replaced by the second generation and third generation turf systems. Second generation synthetic turf systems feature longer fibers and sand infills, and third generation systems, which are most widely used today, offer infills that are mixtures of sand and granules of recycled rubber.
History
David Chaney – who moved to Raleigh, North Carolina, in 1960 and later served as Dean of the North Carolina State University College of Textiles – headed the team of Research Triangle Park researchers who created the first notable artificial turf. That accomplishment led Sports Illustrated to declare Chaney as the man "responsible for indoor major league baseball and millions of welcome mats."
Artificial turf was first installed in 1964 on a prep school recreation area in Rhode Island.[1] The material came to public prominence in 1966, when AstroTurf was installed in the Astrodome in Houston, Texas.[1] The state-of-the-art indoor stadium had attempted to use natural grass during its initial season in 1965, but this failed miserably and the field conditions were grossly inadequate during the second half of the season, with the dead grass painted green. Due to a limited supply of the new artificial grass, only the infield was installed before the Houston Astros' home opener in April 1966, the outfield was installed in early summer during an extended Astros road trip and first used after the All-Star Break in July.
The use of AstroTurf and similar surfaces became widespread in the U.S. and Canada in the early 1970s, installed in both indoor and outdoor stadiums used for baseball and football. More than 11,000 artificial turf playing fields have been installed nationally.[2] More than 1,200 were installed in the U.S. in 2013 alone, according to the industry group the Synthetic Turf Council.[2]
Maintaining a grass playing surface indoors, while technically possible, is prohibitively expensive. Teams who chose to play on artificial surfaces outdoors did so because of the reduced maintenance cost, especially in colder climates with urban multi-purpose "cookie cutter" stadiums such as Cincinnati's Riverfront Stadium, Pittsburgh's Three Rivers Stadium and Philadelphia's Veterans Stadium.
Applications
Baseball
Artificial turf was first used in Major League Baseball in the Houston Astrodome in 1966, replacing the grass field used when the stadium opened a year earlier. Even though the grass was specifically bred for indoor use, the dome's semi-transparent Lucite ceiling panels, which had been painted white to cut down on glare which bothered the players, did not pass enough sunlight to support the grass. For most of the 1965 season, the Astros played on green-painted dirt and dead grass.
The solution was to install a new type of artificial grass on the field, ChemGrass, which became known as AstroTurf. Because the supply of AstroTurf was still low, only a limited amount was available for the first home game. There was not enough for the entire outfield, but there was enough to cover the traditional grass portion of the infield. The outfield remained painted dirt until after the All-Star Break. The team was sent on an extended road trip before the break, and on 19 July 1966, the installation of the outfield portion of AstroTurf was completed.
Artificial turf was later installed in other new multi-purpose stadiums such as Pittsburgh's Three Rivers Stadium, Philadelphia's Veterans Stadium, and Cincinnati's Riverfront Stadium. Early AstroTurf baseball fields used the traditional all-dirt path, but in the early 1970s, teams began using the "base cutout" layout on the diamond, with the only dirt being on the pitcher's mound, batter's circle, and in a "sliding box" around each base. With this layout, a painted arc would indicate where the edge of the outfield grass would normally be, to assist fielders in positioning themselves properly.
The biggest difference in play on artificial turf was that the ball bounced higher than on real grass, and also travelled faster, causing infielders to play farther back than they would normally, so that they would have sufficient time to react. The ball also had a truer bounce than on grass, so that on long throws fielders could deliberately bounce the ball in front of the player they were throwing to, with the certainty that it would travel in a straight line and not be deflected to the right or left. However, the biggest impact on the game of "turf", as it came to be called, was on the bodies of the players. The artificial surface, which was generally placed over a concrete base, had much less give to it than a traditional dirt and grass field did, which caused more wear-and-tear on knees, ankles, feet and the lower back, possibly even shortening the careers of those players who played a significant portion of their games on artificial surfaces. Players also complained that the turf was much hotter than grass, sometimes causing the metal spikes to burn their feet, or plastic ones to melt. These factors eventually provoked a number of stadiums, such as Kauffman Stadium in Kansas City, Missouri, to switch from artificial turf back to natural grass.
In 2000, St. Petersburg's Tropicana Field became the first MLB field to use a softer artificial surface, FieldTurf. All other remaining artificial turf stadiums were either converted to FieldTurf or were replaced entirely by new natural grass stadiums. In just 13 years, between 1992 and 2005, the National League went from having half of its teams using artificial turf to all of them playing on natural grass. With the replacement of Minneapolis's Hubert H. Humphrey Metrodome by Target Field in 2010, only two MLB stadiums, both in the American League East, are still using artificial turf: Tropicana Field and Toronto's Rogers Centre, which converted to a next generation AstroTurf in 2010 and is scheduled to convert to natural grass by 2018.
American football
The first professional American football team to play on artificial turf was the then-Houston Oilers (now the Tennessee Titans), at the time part of the American Football League, who moved into the Astrodome in 1968 which had installed AstroTurf two years prior. In 1969, Franklin Field, the stadium of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, switched from grass to artificial turf. Also home of the Philadelphia Eagles, it was the first National Football League stadium to use artificial turf.
In 2002, CenturyLink Field, originally planned to have a natural grass field, was instead surfaced with FieldTurf upon positive reaction from the Seattle Seahawks when they played on the surface at their temporary home, Husky Stadium during the 2000 and 2001 seasons.
In 2006, Gillette Stadium, the football stadium of the New England Patriots and the New England Revolution, switched from grass to FieldTurf due to the conflict of poor weather and hosting many sporting and musical events at the stadium. It is one of 13 National Football League stadiums that have artificial turf instead of grass fields; the Giants and Jets (who share a stadium) and Bengals actually switched from AstroTurf to natural grass before reverting to a next-generation artificial surface.[3]
All nine stadiums in the Canadian Football League currently use artificial turf.
The XFL, in its short life, required all of its teams to play in stadiums with natural grass surfaces. The move, made in part to reduce injuries, was also a ploy to give the league a more authentic, "smash-mouth" appeal. The league also scheduled all of its games, however, in the winter, when grass does not typically grow as well in the northern United States; the New York/New Jersey Hitmen and Chicago Enforcers' home fields were visibly damaged with heavy bare spots by the end of the league's lone 2001 season.
NFL players overwhelmingly prefer natural grass over synthetic surfaces, according to a league survey conducted in 2010. When asked, "Which surface do you think is more likely to shorten your career?", 90% responded artificial turf.[4]
Field hockey
The introduction of synthetic surfaces has significantly changed the sport of field hockey. Since being introduced in the 1970s, competitions in western countries are now mostly played on artificial surfaces. This has increased the speed of the game considerably, and changed the shape of hockey sticks to allow for different techniques, such as reverse stick trapping and hitting.
Field hockey artificial turf differs from artificial turf for other sports, in that it does not try to reproduce a grass 'feel', being made of shorter fibers. This shorter fiber structure allows the improvement in speed brought by earlier artificial turfs to be retained. This development in the game is however problematic for many local communities who often cannot afford to build two artificial fields: one for field hockey and one for other sports. The International Hockey Federation and manufacturers are driving research in order to produce new fields that will be suitable for a variety of sports.
The use of artificial turf in conjunction with changes in the game's rules (e.g. the removal of offside, introduction of rolling substitutes and the self-pass, as well changes to the interpretation of obstruction) have contributed significantly to changed the nature of the game, greatly increasing the speed and intensity of play, as well as placing far greater demands on the conditioning of the players.
Association football
Some football clubs in Europe installed synthetic surfaces in the 1980s, which were called "plastic pitches" (often derisively) in countries such as England. There, several professional club venues had adopted them; QPR's Loftus Road, Luton Town's Kenilworth Road, Oldham Athletic's Boundary Park and Preston's Deepdale. QPR had been the first team to install an artificial pitch at their stadium in 1981, but were the first to remove it when they did so in 1988. The last team to have an artificial pitch in England was Preston North End, who removed their pitch in 1994 after eight years in use.
Turf gained a bad reputation on both sides of the Atlantic with fans and especially with players. The first AstroTurfs were a far harder surface than grass, and soon became known as an unforgiving playing surface which was prone to cause more injuries, and in particular, more serious joint injuries, than would comparatively be suffered on a grass surface. This turf was also regarded as aesthetically unappealing to many fans.
In 1981, London football club Queens Park Rangers dug up its grass pitch and installed an artificial one. Others followed, and by the mid-1980s there were four artificial surfaces in operation in the English league. They soon became a national joke: the ball pinged round like it was made of rubber, the players kept losing their footing, and anyone who fell over risked carpet burns. Unsurprisingly, fans complained that the football was awful to watch and, one by one, the clubs returned to natural grass.[5]
In the 1990s many North American soccer clubs also removed their artificial surfaces and re-installed grass, while others moved to new stadiums with state-of-the-art grass surfaces that were designed to withstand cold temperatures where the climate demanded it. The use of artificial turf was later banned by FIFA, UEFA and by many domestic football associations, though, in recent years, both governing bodies have expressed resurrected interest in the use of artificial surfaces in competition, provided that they are FIFA Recommended. UEFA has now been heavily involved in programs to test artificial turf, with tests made in several grounds meeting with FIFA approval. A team of UEFA, FIFA and German company Polytan conducted tests in the Stadion Salzburg Wals-Siezenheim in Salzburg, Austria which had matches played on it in UEFA Euro 2008. It is the second FIFA 2 Star approved artificial turf in a European domestic top flight, after Dutch club Heracles Almelo received the FIFA certificate in August 2005.[6] The tests were approved.[7]
FIFA originally launched its FIFA Quality Concept in February 2001. UEFA announced that starting from the 2005–06 season, approved artificial surfaces were to be permitted in their competitions.
Regardless of the views of the governing bodies, criticism of artificial surfaces in soccer continues. Current and former players have recently criticised the surface, expressing concerns that, among other things, it may exacerbate injuries.
A full international fixture for the 2008 European Championships was played on 17 October 2007 between England and Russia on an artificial surface, which was installed to counteract adverse weather conditions, at the Luzhniki Stadium in Moscow.[8][9] It was one of the first full international games to be played on such a surface approved by both FIFA and UEFA. However UEFA ordered that the 2008 European Champions League final hosted in the same stadium in May 2008 must take place on grass, so a temporary natural grass field was installed just for the final.
UEFA stressed that artificial turf should only be considered an option where climatic conditions necessitate.[10] One Desso "hybrid grass" product incorporates both natural grass and artificial elements.[11]
In June 2009, following a match played at Estadio Ricardo Saprissa in Costa Rica, American national team manager Bob Bradley called on FIFA to "have some courage" and ban artificial surfaces.[citation needed]
FIFA designated a star system for artificial turf fields that have undergone a series of tests that examine quality and performance based on a two star system.[12] Recommended 2-Star fields may be used for FIFA Final Round Competitions as well as for UEFA Europa League and Champions League matches.[13] There are currently 130 FIFA Recommended 2-Star installations in the world.[14]
In 2009, FIFA launched the Preferred Producer Initiative to improve the quality of artificial football turf at each stage of the life cycle (manufacturing, installation and maintenance).[15] Currently, there are five manufacturers that were selected by FIFA: Act Global, Limonta, Desso, GreenFields and Edel Grass. These firms have made quality guarantees directly to FIFA and have agreed to increased research and development.
In 2010, Estadio Omnilife with an artificial turf opened in Guadalajara to be the new home of Chivas, one of the most popular teams in Mexico. The owner of Chivas, Jorge Vergara defended the reasoning behind using artificial turf because the stadium was designed to be 'environment friendly and as such, having grass would result on using too much water.[16] However players harshly criticized the field saying it caused many injuries as a result of the harder surface. When Johann Cryuff became the adviser of the team, he recommended the switch to natural grass, which the team did in 2012. [17]
In November 2011, it was reported that a number of English football clubs are interested in using artificial pitches again on economic grounds.[18]
In February 2015 Arsenal F.C. ordered 1,400 m2 of artificial grass from the Swiss company called Tisca Tiara for their training pitch at the Arsenal Training Centre.[19]
2015 Women's World Cup
The 2015 Women's World Cup took place entirely on artificial surfaces, as the event was played in Canada, where almost all of the country's stadiums use artificial turf due to climate issues. This plan garnered criticism from players and fans, some believing the artificial surfaces make players more susceptible to injuries. Over fifty of the female athletes protested against the use of artificial turf on the basis of gender discrimination.[20][21]
However Australia women's national soccer team winger Caitlin Foord said that after playing 90 minutes there was no difference to her post-match recovery – a view shared by the rest of the squad. The squad spent much time preparing on the surface and had no problems with its use in Winnipeg.
"We've been training on [artificial] turf pretty much all year so I think we're kind of used to it in that way ... I think grass or turf you can still pull up sore after a game so it's definitely about getting the recovery in and getting it right," Foord said.[22]
The 2012 Women's World Player of the Year, Abby Wambach noted "The men would strike, playing on artificial turf."[23]
The controversial issue of gender equality and an equal playing field for all has sparked debate in many countries around the world.[citation needed] A lawsuit was filed on 1 October 2014 in an Ontario tribunal court by a group of women's international soccer players against FIFA and the Canadian Soccer Association and specifically points out that in 1994 FIFA spent $2 million to plant natural grass over artificial turf in New Jersey and Detroit.[24]
Various celebrities showed their support for the women soccer players in defence of their lawsuit, including actor Tom Hanks, NBA player Kobe Bryant and U.S. men's soccer team keeper Tim Howard. Even with the possibility of boycotts, FIFA's head of women's competitions, Tatjana Haenni, made it clear that "we play on artificial turf and there's no Plan B."[25][26]
Tennis
Carpet has been used as a surface for indoor tennis courts for decades, though these originally was more similar to home carpets than a synthetic grass. After the introduction of artificial turf, it came to be used for tennis courts, both indoor and outdoor, though only a small minority of courts use the surface.[27][28] Both infill and non-infill versions are used, and are typically considered medium-fast to fast surfaces under the International Tennis Federation's classification scheme.[27] A distinct form found in tennis is an "artificial clay" surface,[27] which seeks to simulate a clay court by using a very short pile carpet with an infill of the same loose aggregate used for clay courts that rises above the carpet fibers.[27]
Golf
Synthetic turf can also be used in the golf industry, such as on golf ranges, putting greens and even in some circumstances tee boxes. Because of the vast areas of golf courses and the damage from clubs during shots, it is not feasible to surface fairways with artificial turf.
Landscaping
Since the early 1990s, the use of synthetic grass in the more arid western states of the United States has moved beyond athletic fields to residential and commercial landscaping.[29] Similar usage has increased in Australia, because of similar climatic conditions.
Airports
Artificial turf has been used at airports.[30] Some artificial turf systems allow for the integration of fiber-optic fibers into the turf. This would allow for lighting or advertisements to be directly embedded in a playing surface, or runway lighting to be embedded in artificial landing surfaces for aircraft.[31]
Health and safety
Injuries
A number of health and safety concerns have been raised about artificial turf.[2] Friction between skin and older generations of artificial turf can cause abrasions and/or burns to a much greater extent than natural grass.[32] Artificial turf tends to retain heat from the sun and can be much hotter than natural grass with prolonged exposure to the sun.[33] There is some evidence that periodic disinfection of artificial turf is required as pathogens are not broken down by natural processes in the same manner as natural grass. Despite this, a 2006 study suggests certain microbial life is less active in artificial turf.[32]
There is evidence showing higher rates of player injury on artificial turf. In a study performed by the National Football League Injury and Safety Panel, published in the October 2012 issue of the American Journal of Sports Medicine, Elliott B. Hershman et al. reviewed injury data from NFL games played between 2000 and 2009. "...the injury rate of knee sprains as a whole was 22% higher on FieldTurf than on natural grass. While MCL sprains did not occur at a rate significantly higher than on grass, rates of ACL sprains were 67% higher on FieldTurf."[34] Metatarsophalangeal joint sprain, known as "turf toe" when the big toe is involved, is named from the injury being associated with playing sports on rigid surfaces such as artificial turf and is a fairly common injury among professional American football players.[35] Artificial turf is a harder surface than grass and does not have much "give" when forces are placed on it.[36]
Cancer concern
There is also significant concern regarding a plausible link between artificial turf and cancer.[37] Some artificial turf uses infill such as silicon sand and/or granulated rubber, referred to as "crumb rubber". Some granulated rubber is made from recycled car tires and may carry heavy metals which can leach into the water table. As early as 2007, a moratorium on the use of ground-up rubber tires in fields and playgrounds was recommended based on health concerns.[38]
In women's soccer, concerns have been raised about cancer incidence in players, particularly goalkeepers, who are in more frequent direct contact with artificial turf. University of Washington goalkeeper coach Amy Griffin has collected data about athletes with cancer who have played on turf containing "crumb rubber".[2][39] As of 2015, her list of 200 athletes with cancer contained 150 soccer players, 95 of whom were goalkeepers.[40]
Concerns have also been raised about baseball players. The following Major League Baseball players and/or managers had prolonged tenure with teams that played on artificial turf, and subsequently were diagnosed with brain cancer: Darren Daulton, Ken Brett, Johnny Oates, Tug McGraw, John Vukovich, Gary Carter, Dan Quisenberry, and Dick Howser.[41][42]
As of 2013, the EPA called for further studies to monitor the impact of particulate matter from fields and playgrounds that use artificial turf.[2]
See also
- Poly-Turf
- Hybrid grass – grass reinforced with other material
- List of college football stadiums with non-traditional field colors
References
- ^ a b Dave Brady, "It's All So Artificial: The Uncommon Ground," Petersen's 12th Pro Football Annual, 1972. Los Angeles: Petersen Publishing Co., 1972; pp. 62-65.
- ^ a b c d e Weeks, Jennifer (2015). "Turf Wars". Distillations Magazine. 1 (3): 34–37. Retrieved 6 November 2015.
- ^ Gillette Stadium's grass field replaced with Field Turf.
- ^ http://www.turfgrasssod.org/files/file/51cac15a-90c9-4c9f-be03-6d398c916a05
- ^ Lawton, Graham (4 June 2005). "Field battle over artificial grass". New Scientist (2502): 35. Retrieved 11 January 2008.
- ^ Salzburg turf approval. UEFA.com (12 January 2006)
- ^ Mark Chaplin (10 November 2004) Approval for artificial fields. UEFA.com
- ^ "England to play on synthetic turf". BBC News. 11 July 2007. Retrieved 11 January 2008.
- ^ "Field 'No Excuse' For England". Sporting Life UK. Retrieved 11 January 2008.
- ^ Martyn Ziegler (10 October 2007). "England could slip up on plastic field, warns Ferguson". The Independent. London. Archived from the original on 12 January 2008. Retrieved 11 January 2008.
{{cite news}}: Unknown parameter|deadurl=ignored (|url-status=suggested) (help) - ^ "Desso GrassMaster hybrid grass > reinforced natural grass | Desso Sports Systems". Dessosports.com. Retrieved 24 December 2015.
- ^ "FIFA Quality Concept – Handbook of Test Methods for Football Turf" (PDF). FIFA. Retrieved May 2009.
{{cite web}}: Check date values in:|accessdate=(help) - ^ "Football Turf". Fifa.com. Archived from the original on 28 February 2008.
{{cite web}}: Unknown parameter|deadurl=ignored (|url-status=suggested) (help) - ^ "Football Fields". Fifa.com. Archived from the original on 28 February 2008.
{{cite web}}: Unknown parameter|deadurl=ignored (|url-status=suggested) (help) - ^ [1] Archived 2011-12-04 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ http://www.obrasweb.mx/construccion/2012/05/17/chivas-cambiara-el-pasto-sintetico-que-costo-1-mdd
- ^ Http://www.mediotiempo.com/futbol/mexico/noticias/2012/07/19/el-estadio-omnilife-listo-con-pasto-natural
- ^ "Clubs want artificial turf return". BBC News. 18 November 2011.
- ^ "Arsenal football club buys Swiss fake grass". SwissInfo.ch. 7 February 2015. Retrieved 12 February 2015.
- ^ Fox Sports. "USWNT stars not backing down on artificial playing surface stance". FOX Sports. Retrieved 9 October 2014.
- ^ "elite female players sue". espnW. Retrieved 9 October 2014.
- ^ Dominic Bossi (10 June 2015). "Matildas stay out of turf war at women's World Cup". Smh.com.au. Retrieved 24 December 2015.
- ^ "FIFA: The World Cup Should Be Played on Natural Grass". Retrieved 9 October 2014.
- ^ "Equalizer Soccer – Players officially file lawsuit against FIFA, CSA over artificial turf at 2015 Women's World Cup". Retrieved 9 October 2014.
- ^ "Players file lawsuit in Canada over artificial Women's World Cup turf". Global News. 1 October 2014. Retrieved 9 October 2014.
- ^ "FIFA officials to inspect BC Place turf in light of controversy". Global News. 7 October 2014. Retrieved 9 October 2014.
- ^ a b c d ITF surface descriptions
- ^ "Tennis". Dow.com. 3 August 2001. Retrieved 24 December 2015.
- ^ "BGTC - Artificial Lawns In Homes".
- ^ "Airside Applications for Artificial Turf" (PDF). Federal Aviation Administration. 2006.
- ^ Monte Burke (27 November 2006). "Field of Screens". Forbes. Retrieved 11 January 2008.
- ^ a b "New Penn State Study Debunks Staph Bacteria Scare In Synthetic Turf" (Press release). Penn State College of Agricultural Sciences. 30 August 2006. Retrieved 11 January 2008.
- ^ C. Frank Williams, Gilbert E. Pulley (2002). "Synthetic Surface Heat Studies" (PDF). Brigham Young University. Retrieved 19 February 2008.
{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=(help) - ^ "Ask Dr. Geier â€" Are ACL tears more common on grass or FieldTurf? | Dr. David Geier - Sports Medicine Simplified". Dr. David Geier. 18 January 2013. Retrieved 24 December 2015.
- ^ Metatarsophalangeal joint sprain
- ^ "Turf Toe-OrthoInfo - AAOS". Orthoinfo.aaos.org. 1 August 2012. Retrieved 24 December 2015.
- ^ Rappleye, Hannah (8 October 2014). "How Safe Is the Artificial Turf Your Child Plays On?". NBCNEWS.COM. Retrieved 8 October 2014.
- ^ David R. Brown, Sc.D. (2007). "Artificial Turf" (PDF). Environment & Human Health, Inc.
{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=(help) - ^ "Why Won't the Government Say Whether This Artificial Turf is Safe?". USA Today. 30 September 2015. Retrieved 6 November 2015.
- ^ Fernandez, Erick (3 November 2015). "ESPN Is Running A Segment On Turf That Should Worry Everyone". Huffington Post. Retrieved 6 November 2015.
- ^ Miller, Randy (22 July 2013). "Ex-Phillies wonder if stadium is to blame for players' brain cancer". USA Today. Retrieved 6 November 2015.
- ^ Dolan, Steve. "Artificial Turf Could Be Causing Cancer Among Former Phillies/MLB Players". Whiz Wit Sports. Retrieved 11 July 2013.